Dirty Sexy Pony

Convulsing from orgasm, Pinkie Pie was shocked awake.

She coughed, her bruised lungs irritated from her sudden gasp of air, like thousands of red hot needles prickling her insides all the way up her esophagus. Pinkie clenched her jaw, feeling another wave of searing heat roll through her. The ongoing spasms terrified and confused her, unaware of what was happening at all. Looking up, Pinkie recognized the wooden ceiling of the Ponyville library above her. At some point while she was unconcious, she was carried inside.

Her body twitched from a jolt of fiery ice rushing up her spine. Pinkie cringed from the strength of yet another peak. She became aware of the ministrations at her loins.

Pinkie gasped in a perplexing combination of surprise and pleasure when she looked down to find Rarity between her legs. Eyes closed and hungrily lapping up her gushing fluids, Rarity was prolonging the torturous pleasure by using the flat of her tongue running the entire length of the earth pony's slit.

Her unicorn friend's teeth brushed against her swollen clit. Wrapping her lips around the hard knub Rarity sucked and suckled and scraped her rough tongue against Pinkie's sensitive and exposed flesh, causing another torrent of juices flow and widen the pool of liquid on the wooden bedroom floor that had been mixing with their sweat and drenching their coats.

A slim, muscular form came into Pinkie's focus.

His hips moved at an arduously slow pace, into and away from Rarity's body. The speed of his movement dictated the speed of Rarity's tongue, becoming interrupted more frequently as the sound of slapping became faster in Pinkie's ears. She looked at the scaled beast as it continued to pound his hips into the unicorn, his scaled waist slapping against the mare's fleshy ass. His chuckle carried her gaze further up toward his face, a sneering smile and eyes full of wanting carved in a way that made Pinkie shiver upon seeing it.

“How does it feel, Pinkie? Her apology?” His voice was deep and sinister, asking without concern for her answer. He gave a quick succession of thrusts making Rarity squeal and dip her tongue into Pinkie's snatch, writhing about between the wet folds and eliciting a happy sigh from the earth pony. He let out another soft chuckle under his breath. “I was the one that saved you, you know? After she threw you out the window...” In an instant, he grabbed a clawful of Rarity's mane and pulled, causing her to whinny and moan.

Pinkie let out the quietest of whimpers as her body fought against her mind in wanting the pleasurable feelings again. She bit her tongue to keep from making a sound.

“It was Rarity's idea when she realized how much we're in love.” He turned said pony's face toward him and regarded Rarity's dumb smile and unfocused eyes. He pouted at the sight. “Did you pass out? Hmm...”

Loosening his grip, the white pony flopped to the floor. The force of the fall seemed to wake her up, as Rarity squirmed so her face pointed to the side.“M-more...” she groaned. Shrugging his shoulders, he placed his claws on her hips and began his assault once more, much to her moaning pleasure.

“So, like I was saying...” Reaching forward, the dragon once again grabbed a clawful of Rarity's purple mane and with a slight lift, aimed the tip of her horn between Pinkie's legs. “She admitted that she acted without thinking. That she was jealous that our love was mutual, not like what happened in those dreams. When I forced myself on Rarity against her will.”

“No! Stop it! You're wrong, I-” Pinkie choked out a whimpering cry. The cuts all over her body made it too painful to try to crawl away. Her muscles were sore and numb from the pleasure that threatened to bubble over. Her lip quivered and fresh tears rolled down her face.

Her eyes widened and pupils dilated at the sight of the horn pressing against her sphincter and she weakly tightened her muscles as much as she could. “N-no, no please...” she panted desperately. “Please, p-please...d-AAGHHHHHHHH!” Pinkie whipped her head back, letting out a bloodcurdling scream as she felt her skin tear. Her eyes clenched tight. She sobbed and trembled and gasped for air.

The horn pushed further in. She screamed and cried and tears fell anew.

He let out a snarling laugh. “Rarity~!” His happy tone of voice carried despite Pinkie's screams. “Do you like your new hat?” His claw pinched the unicorn's cheek, causing her eyelids to flutter. After plunging his dick into Rarity's hot folds a few times, her lips curled up and her dumb smile returned to her face as she moaned out,

“I...” Thrust. “...love...” Thrust. “...it!”

He laughed again at the uproarious sight, continuing his heavy thrusts to keep skewering Pinkie's widening ass with his pony-sized dildo.

“See, Pinkie? She was just jealous! You wanted Rarity to smile too, right?” His head rolled from shoulder to shoulder as his thrusts continued. “You wanted all of us to smile...right?”

Her response was more screams and cries of pain, sending his heart aflutter.

“We can all be happy now!” He howled up toward the ceiling, moving quicker and quicker.

Pinkie shook her head, drowning in the agonizing pain. “Make it stop! Aaaa-aaa-agh! MAKE IT STOP!”

“Yeah...yeah, I will...I'm...I'm...coming!”

He pulled out of Rarity and in a single motion doused the two ponies in his cum, growling and howling as he sprayed all over their faces and wherever else he could before running out.

Their manes, their tails, their bodies.

He walked closer and knelt down, rubbing his still-hard dick against Rarity's lips that she eagerly took into her mouth to draw on it succulently. Pinkie writhed in pain, the horn still lodged in her ass. She yelped as he dipped three claws between into her puffy lower-lips.

Pinkie shuddered and teared at the sight of her friend Rarity.

She sobbed and trembled at the sight of the monster that had destroyed Spike.

She cried at the thought that she had failed.

Failed to save her friends.

Failed to stop this nightmare from turning real.

Failed to change the ending.