The Cupcakes Sequel; 1+1=2 Psychos

by Music within us

Rating: mature
Tags: Slice of Life, Dark, Romance
Length: 1912

It's time to get baking!

This story takes place after the events of Cupcakes. There is a new pony in Ponyville, and she is fast friends with Pinkie Pie. However, when her number comes up, what will happen? Well, enough explaining…It's time to get baking!

I'm probably going to get spammed with so much hate mail, but this is to the people that love our grim dark story Cupcakes and want more. So, I spoke with the Sergeant Sprinkles himself about writing this story, and he said that he would not mind at all! Tell me what you think of this story, and if you want more, I will give you more! Then again, I'll be adding more anyways, even if you don't ask because I'll have to end the story.
PS: Just a warning but this is originally meant to be for Nightmare Night. However, I feel as though I should post this as soon as possible.

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2014-04-13 17:45:35 UTC

Chapter 1 to the story that will give you NIGHTMARES!!! *Laughs crazily.*

Chapter 1 to the story that will give you NIGHTMARES!!! *Laughs crazily.*

It's that time of the month again! the time for Pinkie Pie (or Pinkamena) to pick out the number at random. There's a new pony in town, so she added it just the day before. She gets to Sugar-cube Corner, where Apple Bloom is smiling at the Silver Spoon that's been taxidermied. She then looks over at Pinkie and squees as Pinkie goes to the spot where she picks the number out. She draws the number at random, and would you look at that? It's the number she recently added. She perks up and starts bouncing up and down as she squeals. Time to get baking!

There, in the rotting old warehouse, was a silent mare holding a chainsaw in her hooves. Her name was Silent Death. She had a smoky gray coat of fur, silver eyes, and a dark blue mane and tail. She also never found her talent, therefore, she has no cutie mark. She had enough of her husband's abusive lifestyle, and decided it was time to end his life. So, as he pleaded that she not kill him, she revved up the chainsaw, and slowly inched closer. He started to cry, but she felt no remorse as she got so close, he could feel her breath brush along his soft chest fur. She raised the chainsaw, and jerked it down a bit to cause a flinch to erupt from the stallion tied down to a table. She laughed and stopped the chainsaw, putting it down. She cackled with delight, her eyes (irises and all) shrunken down to the size of a pebble as she said, "Oh, please!"

She had a richly seductive voice when she spoke, so it was hard to not see her as sexy for some stallions. She then continued to speak, asking "After all the shit you've put me through, you think I'm going to kill you off quickly?" She shook her head and said, "Oh, no no no...I want to make your death the same as the abuse you've done to me; long, slow, and PAINFUL!!!" And with that, she hit him hard in the muzzle, blood spurting onto her left hoof. She then hit him in the gut, blood shooting onto her face. She hit him there a few times, and blood went all over. Finally, she took a scalpel, and put it next to his leg. She started to rub his crotch, and his member started popping out of his sheath. He immediately knew what she was going to do, and tried to hold back his cock from reaching full length, but it had a mind of its own. When it reached full length, she took the scalpel and got to work, cutting small incisions here and there.

She then stabbed the hole at the top. He shrieked from pain, but she continued to use the scalpel. She took it out of the hole and cut the medial ring, earning a loud cry of pain from the stallion. She sliced away at his tip, and the pain was so much he started to cry tears of blood. She saw this, and put the scalpel away. She took out a hacksaw, and carefully placed it at the base. She then started moving the blade back and forth, blood shooting out from the new cut. The stallion bit his lip so hard, blood came out. His blood tears continued. She didn't care.

She finally cut the stallion's member off, and seeing it hang by a sliver of skin, she wrapped her hooves around it. She looked at the stallion, her eyes showing how over the edge she now is. She looked back at the bloody shaft, and ripped it off. Blood and other bodily fluids splattered onto her face, and she licked it off her lips. She smiled, licking the fangs that were showing. She then tossed the limp, bleeding cock aside and picked up her chainsaw, revving it up more. She then said "I think I hear the church bells. Just because you had a dick, doesn't mean you are a stallion, 'deary.' I think I've gotten my taste of revenge. Now, you die." And with that, she put the buzzing chainsaw down the middle, and pressed down. Blood spattered everywhere. Finally, the chainsaw stopped, and she took it off the table, putting it to the side.

She was getting ready to skin him when she heard a knock on the door. She cursed under her breath and got a wet rag to wipe the blood off. However, she forgot to wipe it off her muzzle. But she didn't notice. She trotted to the door and opened it. There was Pinkie Pie, her closest friend, just bouncing up and down as she giggled like a school-filly. She suddenly stopped and looked at me with those bright blue eyes. She opened her mouth and said, "I've got GREAT NEWS!!!"

"What is it, Pinkie?" I asked.

She grinned unbelievably wide and said, "This weekend, the Cakes are putting me in charge of running the bakery! I might need some help running the place. I asked some of my friends to help, but they all said they were busy, so I--" she stopped, and made a confused face. She then asked in confusion, "What's that red stuff on your muzzle?" I wiped my hoof on my muzzle and felt the almost dried and flaky blood come off onto my hoof. I gasped and came up with a lie. I feigned surprise and said, "Oh, I was eating my breakfast which was toast with strawberry jam. I guess I didn't remember it was there. Don't worry about it..." At first, Pinkie grew skeptical, but then giggled and said, "That is such a coincidence, because this morning, I had the same thing! Except, I added some extra sugar to it..." She trailed off into her train of thought, until I clapped my hooves and said, "Yes well, I'd be happy to lend a hoof! When do you want me to come by?"

She grinned again and said, "They're leaving tomorrow, so if you could come by around 12:00, I'd really appreciate it!" I told her I'd come, and with that, she left. I locked the door and immediately thought as I galloped up the stairs, "Gotta clean this stuff off my muzzle to lower any suspicion...oh, and dispose of the body..."

Time to Get Baking!

"You know, Silent?" Asked Pinkamena as Silent came back from around the counter. Silent was still high, so she could easily take advantage of the moment. Silent grinned and said, "Yes?" Pinkamena said, "I need some help downstairs in the basement." Silent stumbled and tripped, then said she'd help, and went downstairs. Pinkamena grinned wide and held up a baseball bat. When they reached the bottom of the stairs, Silent turned on a light to see Pinkamena whack her with a baseball bat. Silent didn't even budge, the bat just broke over her head. Blood came pouring from her mane-line as she opened her eyes wide and smiled creepily. She walked towards Pinkamena and half-lidded her eyes. She leaned forward and kissed Pinkamena, parting her lips with her tongue. Pinkamena was shocked, because first of all; Silent was still conscious. Two; Silent was kissing her...and she was enjoying it. Silent broke the kiss, and looked at Pinkamena's undercarriage. She grinned and said, "Looks like I still got it." Pinkamena looked down, and saw a bit of fluid dripping from her sex.

Silent then tackled her and stated all out making out with Pinkamena. Pinkamena accepted the kiss, and brought Silent even closer. They ended up grinding on each other, fluids escaping them and burying itself into their fur around the area. Finally, they couldn't take it anymore, and they both released. Making a mess all over. Silent took the opportunity, and went down to lap up the soaked wetness that was Pinkie's marehood. Pinkie moaned, grinding up against Silent's muzzle. Silent chuckled, and started to suckle on the nub of Pinkie's soft lips.

2 painstakingly annoying hours of moaning, groaning and mare on mare sex later...

Pinkamena looked over at Silent, and realized; she didn't want to kill her. They'd been best friends since Silent first came to Ponyville. So, she got out of bed and ripped up Silent's number. Silent saw this the entire time, and some xplaining later, Silent became Pinkamena's assistant.

Chapter Two

Silent woke up and smelled an odd stench. At first, she didn't know what it was, but then she smiled as she remembered the asshole of a husband she murdered. She took a shower and washed her mane. She then dried off, went to her mirror, and brushed her hair. It curled under the feel of the brush going against it. She giggled lightheartedly as she thought of ways to dispose of the body. Finally, she came up with a brilliant one; she'd make acid, and dump the parts in it. She put on her lab coat, goggles and gloves and got to work. After making the acid, she slumped the body on an old gurney she found. She brought it to the pot of acid and shoved the body in headfirst. The body melted on contact, so she needed only fed the body into the pot. When all was done, she took off her science clothes, and got rid of the acid, dumping it into a lake behind the warehouse. She lived in this ugly place only because it was all she could afford.

As she ate her breakfast, she thought of the possibilities for what Pinkie needed help with exactly. All she said was that she needed help with running the place. After eating breakfast, she put the plates in her makeshift sink and washed it, then left for Sugar-cube Corner. Silent suddenly went into a train of thought, thinking of what might happen. Suddenly, she bumped into a door, falling on her rump. She rubbed her muzzle and looked up. She was at Sugar-cube Corner. She got back to her hooves and was about to knock. But Pinkie answered the door, causing Silent to accidentally hit her in the face. She fell backwards and her mane and tail deflated. She started to cry, turning away from the door. Silent felt sorry, and tried to comfort Pinkie. Pinkie quickly cheered up when Silent mentioned Cupcakes.

Pinkie told Silent, "Wait right here! I've got a snack for you before we get started on the day!" and she trotted behind the counter. Se started shuffling stuff around, her rump hanging in the air. Silent looked and her face turned from it's original color to a deep crimson. Suddenly, Pinkie got back up, trotted back to her, and handed her a cupcake with purple frosting. Silent took the cupcake and looked at Pinkie with confusion in her eyes. Pinkie told her it was for her. Silent shrugged and took a bite. She chewed for a bit, and felt a familiar feeling she hadn't felt in a long time.

Fuck, she was high.

Silent looked at Pinkie and giggled before stumbling around for a bit. Pinkie looked baffled as Silent asked, "Is it just me or did the roof suddenly turn orange?" Pinkie just realized what happened, and started to snort from the laughter. This was going to be an interesting day...