Pinkie Pie's Key Party

Applejack barely cleared the door when it suddenly slammed shut. Spinning around, she saw Rainbow Dash hovering, locking the door with its key.

“What the hay?” she called out in surprise, but then Rainbow was on her in a flash. She pushed the cowpony backward and they tumbled to the ground. The sky blue pony thrust her lips to Applejack’s, pressing her head against the ground and causing her signature ten gallon hat to tip up and off her head. Applejack flailed.

When Rainbow finally let up, she grinned gleefully. Applejack frowned as she stood up again. “What was that all about?” she asked, replacing her hat.

“I’m just super excited that we’re partners!” Rainbow Dash was absolutely beaming. She was so excited she took to the air again, but she managed to compose herself and returned to the ground. “But I, of course, knew that we’d be partners,” she said matter of factly.

Applejack looked up at her, arching an eyebrow. “And just how did you know that?”

“Because I challenged you,” she proudly explained. “And I knew you couldn’t resist a challenge.” She darted right up to Applejack so they were nose to nose, both with serious faces. “Am I right?”

“I can too resist a challenge!” Applejack shot back.

“Got you again!” Rainbow Dash started giggling.

“Wait, did you just challenge me to resist a challenge?”

“Yep.”

“And I took it, didn’t I?”

“Yep!” Rainbow doubled over laughing. “You’re so predictable, AJ!”

Applejack put her hoof to her forehead and shook her head. “You were practically begging to be my partner! What if one of them noticed?”

“I’m sure they didn’t. Besides, they’re our friends. They’d understand.”

“I’ll bet Twilight will come a knockin’ any minute now and tell us to draw straws like we’re supposed to.” The earth pony walked up to the door and pressed her ear against it.

Rainbow fidgeted as she waited and glanced around the room. Twilight’s bedroom area was divided into two floors with a wooden staircase on the side built into the trunk of the Golden Oak Library.

At the top of the stairs was a small wooden bird post for Twilight’s pet owl, Owliscious, who was absent. Behind the post was a small open window to the outside, indicating that the owl had left to hunt for the night. Next to that were Twilight’s and Spike’s wooden beds as well as a large guest bed that Applejack and Rarity had once slept in. All three beds were framed nicely by a large bay window.

On the first floor, the movable wall was barren except for two magical candle holders that dimly lit the room. The other three walls were covered with books, stuck into every kind of crevasse the architect could create. Rainbow casually looked over the decidedly boring book titles, such as “A Thousand Years of Peace: The Golden Age of Celestia” and “The Mechanics of an Egalitarian Society.” Twilight could be such an egghead.

“I don’t hear anything,” Applejack said, pulling herself away from the door. “I think we’re in the clear.”

The pegasus wiped a bead of sweat from her brow. “I’m glad that’s over with. Now we can be together.”

“Yes we can, Dashie.”

Suddenly, Applejack charged. Dash didn’t have time to react and she was bowled over. The next thing she knew, she was looking up at the face of the most dependable, most beautiful pony in Equestria, framed perfectly by her brown hat.

“It’s been too long, hasn’t it?” Rainbow asked rhetorically.

“Yes it has.”

Applejack kissed Rainbow with the intense passion that had become the hallmark of Apple family lovers. Her feathered partner returned the gesture, opening her mouth to take in as much as she could. The two wrestled with their tongues for several minutes. It was wet and beautiful and both emerged victorious.

Applejack rolled onto her side, panting, still holding Rainbow Dash. Looking deep into her fuschia eyes she spoke. “I love you.”

“I love you too, AJ.” Rainbow leaned in and gave her another peck on the lips. She then sat up, leaning her head on her forehoof. “You know what this means, right?”

“What?” the cowpony replied, sitting up herself in the same way, smiling casually.

“We won’t have to keep our relationship a secret anymore!” She shook her front hooves in excitement. “‘Cause after this party, everypony will know what we did together.”

The joyous expression on Applejack melted into one of terror. “No, no, no, that can’t happen!”

She jumped up and stepped towards the door but Rainbow jumped up and flew in front, causing Applejack to stop short.

“Wait!”

“No, we have to tell the others that… that this means nothing.”

“Woah there.” Rainbow was hurt, but tried her best to hide it. She placed her hooves on her partner’s shoulders. “They’re not going to be onto us after just one night, especially if we don’t tell them what happened in here.”

The earth pony shook her head, putting her hooves on Rainbow’s chest. “But they might...”

“So what if they do? They’re our friends!” Rainbow thought of how best to calm her. “Do you really think Twilight wants other ponies to know what kind of party this is?”

This idea seemed to calm Applejack. “I guess not,” she said, putting down her hooves. “It’s just that, if Granny Smith found out...” her face became distant.

The pegasus pulled her lover close and pressed her head against her chest. This wasn’t the first time she’d heard these fears. The apple bucking pony was constantly worried about how her family would take learning that she was into other mares.

Rainbow Dash was pretty certain that Granny Smith valued family more than tradition, Big Mac would probably take it in stride, and Apple Bloom wouldn’t care as long as her sister was happy, but Applejack got it stuck in her head that they would disown her and kick her off the farm. Even if she didn’t agree, it wasn’t something she could argue out of her.

“It’s alright, they’re not gonna know,” Rainbow soothed. “We don’t have to tell anypony.”

“Yeah, but hiding the truth is still lying.” Applejack clung to the foreleg that embraced her and closed her eyes, squeezing out tears. “I… I don’t know how much longer I can keep this up.”

“I know.” Rainbow consoled, holding her tight. “I’m sorry I brought it up. I just thought…”

Applejack shook her head, brushing her cheek against Rainbow’s velvety fur. “No, it’s my fault. I know this is hard for you too.”

“It’s okay. I’ll stand by you no matter what.”

They both stood still, listening to each other’s breaths. Rainbow wondered how they could show their devotion to each other. When the Apple family saw that, then surely they would understand. But the idea seemed a long ways off.

Applejack thought of ways of telling everypony the truth about their relationship. She shuddered to think how all of Ponyville would react to knowing. Could they start out small and work their way up?

“Maybe…” Applejack started, “maybe we can tell somepony about it. After tonight, I’m sure one of our friends will understand and be able to keep it a secret.”

Rainbow perked up at this idea. Keeping the secret to herself had been weighing on her heavily. She didn’t want to admit it, but since the start of their relationship, she had begun to resent the rest of the Apple family. It was their fault they had to meet discreetly in the back roads of Ponyville and had never been out on a proper date. She couldn’t complain about it to Applejack of course, so the idea of having another friend to go to was very appealing.

“Which one?”

“Hm…” Applejack contemplated.

Trusting a friend would be risky. It only took one rumor to escape and spread all across Ponyville, and Applejack wasn’t ready for that just yet. Their friend would have to be able to keep it a secret from everypony else.

Rarity was a total gossip and though she would certainly keep the secret, she might accidentally let it slip while she was chatting with one of her clients.

Fluttershy wasn’t exactly a social butterfly, so she’d be a good candidate to keep a secret, but if Rarity pressed her for any juicy gossip during one of their weekly trips to the spa, she’d surely give it up.

Twilight Sparkle might hold on to the secret, but she would tell if she thought it would do more good than harm. That left only one of their friends.

“We can talk to Pinkie Pie.”

Rainbow was shocked and stared at Applejack with mouth agape. “Pinkie Pie? Are you kidding?”

Applejack shook her head. “Nope. We can talk to her, but she has to Pinkie Promise that she won’t tell anypony else about it.”

Rainbow was reluctant to agree, but then she walked through each of their friends in her mind too.

Ever since Gilda left, Rainbow and Pinkie shared a special bond in their pranks and love of grandstanding. She worked better with an audience and could always rely on Pinkie Pie to cheer her on, whether it was a local iron pony competition, or even a race in Cloudsdale. If Pinkie Pie could be trusted, then she was sure to stand by their side no matter what.

“I guess she does make the most sense,” she admitted. “But only because Pinkie would never break a Pinkie Promise.”

Applejack smiled at the decision, but said nothing. All this serious talk was beginning to get to her and she wanted to move on to something a little more fun. She glanced around the room for what they should do next.

“I don’t suppose you want to move to the bed, do you?”

Rainbow nodded her head. “Sure, we can do that.”

The farmer walked up the stairs to the guest bed and sat on it, looking towards the window. Rainbow Dash soon landed next to her. She sat close, extending a wing across Applejack’s back, and rested her head on her special somepony’s shoulder.

Through the window they could see the white and pink plaster house next door and the white cobblestone streets. There wasn’t a pony in sight, being so late, but Luna’s moon and stars shone bright in the midnight sky. The couple sat in silent contentment, taking in the beauty provided by their princess of the night.

Rainbow’s mind wandered to what she’d tell Pinkie Pie. She’d finally be able to talk about how frustrating it was to always avoid Granny Smith, or try to act casual every time Big Mac appeared in the apple orchards. She had no idea what Pinkie would say, but anypony would be better than no pony to talk to.

Rainbow Dash furled her eyebrows. “How is it that Pinkie Pie is always first in line for the apple cider at the start of apple cider season?”

Applejack threw her hoof up. “You know her when she’s excited! She sets up a tent the night before and practically lives there every day until the end of it. That’s one pony who sure loves her cider.”

“I just wish it wasn’t first-come first-served. If it weren’t for Pinkie, I wouldn’t have gotten any cider last time!”

“I swear I saved some for you from the very beginnin’,” Applejack defended, “but then Apple Bloom was all like ‘Look! I found another barrel in your room, sis!’”

Rainbow rolled her eyes. “Of course she did!”

On the occasions that Rainbow romantically snuck into Applejack’s room late at night, Apple Bloom would inevitably walk in at exactly the wrong time. Fortunately, Rainbow was always fast enough to escape out the window before she noticed.

“Apple Bloom really needs to learn how to knock.”

“Who?” came a voice from beside them.

Rainbow Dash jumped and turned to look at who said it.

On the other side of the second floor, Owlicious had returned from his night on the town and settled onto his perch. Rainbow Dash discreetly retracted her wing from Applejack. “Owlicious, I didn’t see you there!” she said frantically, trying to hide her embarrassment.

“Whoo.” Owlicious called.

“Me,” the pegasus replied, with a hint of guilt in her voice.

“Whoo.” He repeated.

Rainbow began to get irritated but before she could respond again, an orange hoof closed her mouth. “Calm down, sugarcube.”

Applejack walked over to the owl post. It was short enough so that Applejack could look Owlicious in the eye. “Can you keep a secret?” she asked him.

The owl nodded.

“Me and Rainbow, we’re kinda together, like dating.” She smiled at her partner, who smiled back. “And we’d really appreciate it if you kept this on the down-low, ya know?”

He cocked his head to one side in contemplation, almost like he was asking “why?”

“See, not everypony in Ponyville is okay with filly foolers, and… well, now’s just not the right time to go telling everypony about it.”

Twilight’s pet nodded, agreeing to keep the secret, though Rainbow Dash wondered if anypony would think to question an owl, besides Fluttershy maybe.

“Good. And one last thing,” Applejack added. “Would you give us some alone time? We don’t often get to be together like this.”

Owlicious nodded again. He then spread his wings and flew out the window.

Rainbow Dash stared wide-eyed. “I didn’t know you were so good with animals!” she exclaimed, running up to Applejack.

“Owlicious isn’t just an animal, silly!” Applejack chuckled. “She’s Twilight’s pet. I see him every week at our Pony Pet Playdate. You would too if you ever came out.”

“Hey, it’s not my fault it’s in the middle of my naptime!” Rainbow exclaimed. “Besides, Tank gets tired too; we like our afternoon naps.”

Applejack laughed.

“So what’s in that box Pinkie gave us?”

“Oh, right! I completely forgot!” Rainbow dashed to the shelf where she had put the box down and presented it to Applejack while hovering. She lifted off the top and showed its contents. Inside was a thick black double-ended dildo and about 4 feet of a thin black rope.

"We'll ain't that quaint?" Applejack laughed.

"That looks huge!" Rainbow exclaimed with wide eyes and a grimace. "We're... we're not planning on using that, are we?"

Applejack smiled mischievously. "Oh? Why not?" She looked at her partner. "Is it too much for you to handle?"

"No! I mean," Dash took the toy out of the box, feeling it's weight and getting a better view of its size. "It's just that I've never had something that big." She wasn't even sure if she could fit it into her mouth.

"I'm sure you'll be fine, " Applejack jibed, waving a hoof. "You’re supposed to be a bit pliable. How else is a foal supposed to come through there?"

Rainbow shuttered at the thought. “Eww! There’s no way a foal’s gonna come through here! If we’re gonna do that, you can do it.”

“You bet I would!” Applejack winked. “So how ‘bout it? Want to give that thing a try?”

Rainbow floated in the air and stared at the toy. “I don’t know…”

“Here, I’ll help ya out.”

Applejack took a step forward and pressed her face between Rainbow’s hind legs. Surprised, Rainbow dropped both the box and the dildo and found herself pushed backwards and laid out on the bed.

“Ya,” the pegasus said blissfully as she felt kisses along the inside of her sky blue thigh, “why don’t you help out.” She closed her eyes, letting the gentle caresses wash over her body in blissful waves.

Applejack absolutely loved making Rainbow feel this way. A gentle kiss, a subtle lick, a bit of suction, and a tiny nibble each elicited a different reaction. She could feel Rainbow’s legs tense and relax, hear her heavy breathing, smell her wispy pegasus scent, and taste her sexual flavor. It was hard to tell sometimes who enjoyed this more.

Still reveling in the pleasure, Rainbow sat up, flapping her wings with growing excitement. Between her legs she saw the familiar sight of her favorite mare’s brown hat. Rainbow set it aside, revealing Applejack’s face, her green eyes closed in concentration.

It was an amazing sight, like always. Her lowered position, her determined expression, the sensation she offered, all culminated in Rainbow’s euphoric passion for her. Applejack seemed to glow with love.

Rainbow ran a hoof through her partner's golden mane, casually removing the red band that held it together. Her long hair fell loosely to either side of her strong, feminine form, neatly framing her freckled cheeks. Rainbow Dash couldn’t resist giving her some form of compliment.

“You’re really pretty, you know.”

Applejack leaned back and look up into her fuchsia eyes. “Awe, shucks, Dashie. It’s not like you to be sentimental.”

“Hey!” Rainbow objected, embarrassed. “I didn’t say stop!”

She pushing her lover’s face back between her legs. Applejack tried to continue, but couldn’t stop herself from giggling. Rainbow folded her arms and pouted, but started snickering with her partner’s infectious laughter. Soon they both were overcome by the absurdity and began laughing together.

“Come here, you silly pony!” Applejack jumped up onto Rainbow and started tickling her sides.

“H-hey!” She cried, falling backward onto the bed, trying to push her off. "Ooh, haha, I’ll get you for this!" She laughed.

"Try me!" Applejack said firmly, continuing.

"Alright, you asked for it!" through fits of laughter, Rainbow managed to push Applejack aside and immediately pounced on her. Despite flailing, she was able to secure each leg with her own.

“What’re you gonna do now?” Applejack taunted, squirming beneath the pegasus.

“This!” Rainbow craned her neck to the side and bit a feather off her wing.

“You wouldn’t dare!”

Dash smiled coyly and, using her dexterous lips, brought the feather quickly but gently up and down the pit of her captive’s forelegs.

Applejack screamed in laughter and shook involuntarily. She threw her hooves at Rainbow, trying to get her off, but the quick pegasus, with the help of her feathered wings, dodged into the air and returned, keeping the tickler firmly above the ticklee.

Rainbow Dash grinned widely and switched to tickling under her other leg, causing her to jump and giggle more. It was wonderful to watch Applejack smile and laugh so much. The weight of responsibility of her farm and family seemed to evaporate, and everything felt right.

"Uncle! Uncle!" Applejack cried at last.

Rainbow stopped tickling and lay down next to her on the bed, dropping the feather. “You let me win!” She smiled and wrapped her forelegs around Applejack, drawing her into a hug.

“I might have.” Applejack responded, still catching her breath. “Sometimes it’s fun to lose.” She pressed her face into Rainbow Dash’s chest.

The pegasus laughed. “I always like to win!”

Applejack loosened her embrace and looked up at Rainbow. “Oh really? Are you sure about that?”

That got her a curious glance in return. “You’re being sneaky. What are you talking about?”

“Well, when we first came in here, you said the pony with the most endurance wins.” Applejack made a goofy grin. “Isn’t that a challenge you’d rather lose?”

Rainbow smiled and shook her head. “Making you happy is always a win in my book.” She smiled and added, “but I wouldn’t mind taking that challenge now, if you’d like.”

“You’re on!” Applejack jumped off the bed, threw her hat back on, and returned with the black double-ended dildo in her mouth.

“Wait, what are you doing with that?”

Applejack dropped the toy on the bed. “We’re seeing who has more endurance. Let’s both use it and see who lasts the longest.”

Excitement and fear filled Rainbow Dash. She couldn’t deny that she wanted the space between her legs to be filled since Applejack had kissed her down there, but this thing was so big. She knew it would feel wonderful if she could get past the initial discomfort. She grit her teeth. “Alright, let’s do it!” She rolled onto her back and spread her hind legs wide.

Applejack took hold of the toy once more and moved it towards the mare’s already moist pussy. Rainbow shook nervously with anticipation. The moment it touched, The pegasus jumped into the air and flapped her wings, hovering above the bed.

“Whaa wah thah?” Applejack asked, mouth still full.

“I…” Rainbow hesitated, embarrassed. “I just needed to stretch my legs first!” Still floating, she started reaching opposite legs out in the manner she’d do before a race.

Suddenly a brown lasso wrapped around Rainbow’s body and wings, pulling them tight together, dropping her to the bed. The other end of the lasso rope lead to Applejack’s smug face. “Now you hold still, alright?”

Rainbow feigned a pout. “Okay, fine.” She didn’t really have a choice anyway.

Applejack took the double-ended dildo once again and slowly inserted it into her lover’s special place. Rainbow’s eyes opened wide and her pupils shrunk to a pinpoint as she took a big gasp of air. It was certainly larger than anything she’d taken before, and it felt extremely uncomfortable.

“Oh-my-gosh-oh-my-gosh-oh-my-gosh!”

Applejack waited patiently for her to get accustomed to the new sensation. She recalled her own experiences of penetration and working with larger toys. She loved the vague discomfort and remote sense of pain that can only be described as intense. She found herself getting very excited.

Once Rainbow calmed down, her partner pushed it in another inch. Another bolt of intensity shot through her and she began to flail, but didn’t say a word.

“Too much?” her partner asked, casually and without judgement.

Rainbow looked at her, teeth gritted and beads of sweat on her forehead.

“No, I can take more,” she strained.

Applejack nodded and smiled. Then she flipped onto her own back and slid herself down the bed until she could put the other end of the dildo into her own wet pussy. It was her turn to feel it press her open. Though it was bigger than what she normally used, her excited body accepted it without complaint. The wonderful sensation of fullness washed over her.

She smiled at Rainbow Dash, who was still sweating bullets and scarcely aware of what was going on. Applejack reached over and gently massaged her partner’s clitorus.

“Hey!” Rainbow jumped at the intense sensation, and then stopped suddenly when she felt the thick cock inside her. “N-no fair!”

“All’s fair in love!” Applejack taunted. She turned sideways, locking her hind legs onto her partner’s, and squeezed the gap between them closed.

Rainbow took a deep breath. She’d never felt this aroused with Applejack before. Maybe it was the size of the dildo, or maybe because they were in their friend’s house, but something about it felt risky and grand. It was the exact kind of rush she enjoyed from racing, and that ignited her spirit of competition, despite the overwhelming euphoria she was experiencing.

“Well, two can play that game!” Rainbow smirked and returned the pleasure with her own hoof. Even though Applejack had a head start, she knew how to manipulate her lover’s body.

Applejack grinned delightfully. Through excited from their earlier activities, she was ready for more direct stimulation, and Rainbow made no mistake about making up for lost time. Her touch embodied the sexual pleasure that Applejack sought, and she let her body absorb as much as she could.

“Yee-haw!” Applejack cried out, moving back and forth on the bed. She threw her head back, holding onto her hat with her off-hoof. This was way more fun than herding a flock of sheep!

Rainbow Dash started gyrating too, her hoof moving faster. She closed her eyes tightly and turned her head away. Her body felt like it was on fire with passion and it took her whole mind to hold on and let it happen. It felt so intense, she wondered if it would produce a sonic rainboom when she came.

On the other side of the bed, her partner watched the changing expressions on Rainbow’s face. She could feel her every shake and twitch. She lost track of who was giving whom the feeling as they became one.

For a moment that seemed like an eternity, their minds and bodies merged. Their thoughts were blank save for the ecstasy they experienced. Sensation travelled between them like electricity, burning them both with love until at last they exploded together.

“Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh!” Rainbow’s yell echoed through the room, overshadowing the grunted breaths that came from Applejack. When the moment was over, they both fell backwards onto the bed. They could still feel each other’s spasms and continued to take turns squeezing the shaft between them.

“You won,” Rainbow panted.

“Only by a hair,” Applejack admitted, breathing hard.

A moment went by.

“That was amazing.”

“Eeyup.”

Applejack pulled herself away from the grapple and gently pulled the toy out of her lover. Rainbow gasped and shook as her vagina closed around the new vacancy. The dildo was tossed aside and Applejack maneuvered next to Rainbow Dash in the bed.

The exhaustion of the act hit them and they both became very tired.

“We have to have a rematch,” Rainbow said sleepily, rolling over and holding her lover to her tight.

Applejack placed her brown hat onto a table next to the bed. “You bet we will,” she replied.

“I love you.”

“I love you too, sugarcube.”