Lyra's secret.

by kainofthesand

Three is not a crowd.

Previous ChapterNext Chapter

"So then he scaled the tower using just her hair! Isn't that the coolest thing? When I was reading it I just thought that he sounded so brave and heroic."

"Lyra-"

"Then, in this other story I read, the hero charged in head first, his sword raised at the dragon."

"Lyra-"

"And he did it all to save one girl. Don't you think that that's so hot? I mean to do all tha-"

"Lyra!"

Bon Bon slammed a hoof down on the bar, causing the glasses to rattle from the force. Having been broken from her human gushing, Lyra looked to her friend a bit shaken from Bonnie's outburst. Everypony in the bar looked on at the two mares who had caused the disturbance.

"Enough, Lyra. I'm tired of hearing about this every day. All you ever talk about are humans. You read those stories like they're sacred text."

Lyra felt a mix of embarrassment and anger as her best friend explained her frustrations.

"I get that you like those stories, but they're not real, Lyra."

"W-well, maybe not today, but I read that they once lived here in Equestria," Lyra said as she looked down at the glass in her hooves.

"But not now, Lyra. You're not a filly anymore, don't you think it's time that you stopped believing in those stupid stories?"

Lyra shot Bon Bon a defiant look, she knew that Bonnie didn't care much for her hobby, but to call her human stories "stupid" was going too far.

"Well I'm sooooo sorry that my hobbies and interests annoy you so much. At least I'm not boring like you!"

Bonnie looked shocked at her friend's defiance. In all the time that she had known Lyra (which was ever since they were fillies) she had never seen her get angry or snap back at her.

"Maybe I should be boring and-and, make candy! Then I can collect recipes for candy, and go to candy conventions, Oh, and I could even start a collection of different candies from around the world. Would that make you happy, Bon Bon? Then would I be boring enough to be your friend!?"

Lyra didn't stop to take in the sight of her friend as she began to cry silently, she didn't even stop to pick up the glass she had flung across the bar during her outburst. She galloped as fast as she could out the door of the bar and down the dimly lit street that lead to her house. She didn't want to see Bon Bon, or anypony for that matter. She just wanted to get home so she could be alone for a while.

She found herself sitting in her bath tub with no water, she curled herself into a ball as she bawled out her hurt feelings. Ever since she was a little pony she had loved to read and hear stories about humans and their adventures. Her first day of pre-school, when the teacher went around and asked what everypony wanted to do when they grew up, Lyra said that she wanted to meet a real human and go on an adventure with him.

To this, everypony, including the teacher, began laughing at her like she was a joke, everypony except Bon Bon. It didn't get better after she got older, she got laughed at and picked on so much she dropped out of the school for gifted unicorns. Now her best friend had made her feel like a fool for her interest.

Lyra bawled loudly in the tub as snot dripped from her nose. It wasn't so much that Bonnie had been mean, but she was realizing that her obsession with humans was starting to have a negative affect on her life. All her money that didn't go to either food or home was spent on more books, or human toys. She had never even gone out with a stallion because in her mind they didn't compare to what a human male would be like.

Her hobby was becoming a problem, but the thought of giving up her beloved collection broke her heart and made her want to cry more. Until that night, she had never felt so alone before.

She thought to herself as she wiped the snot from her nose with a tissue, "Maybe it is time to make a change……."

Lyra got out of the tub and slumped over to her bathroom mirror, the pony who looked back at her looked like Tartarus warmed over. Her eyes were red, the fur under them was matted from the tears. She looked miserable.

Maybe she was right. Her hobby had brought her nothing but heartache and humiliation. The thought of giving up her love of humans was heartbreaking, but Lyra was (for the most part) a girl who was able to see things in the long run.

Lowering her head, she could see that if she continued on this road that she would continue to be a social outcast, and even worse, she may wind up loosing her best and only friend.

It would hurt, but she had to give up on humans.

A few weeks passed. Lyra had given up almost all her books and toys, and had reconciled with Bon Bon. On the surface, she seemed to now be a normal and well adjusted pony, but on the inside she felt like a part of herself was missing.

These feelings weren't lost on Bon Bon. She noticed that while Lyra was smiling and carrying on, she carried a look of sadness behind her smile.

"You just need to get out there and find yourself a nice stallion to take you out."

Lyra half heartily agreed, yet she wasn't sure at all about that. She had harbored a fantasy of meeting a human through some crazy magical situation and been saving herself for that. But now she realized that she had to give up on that notion.

"What stallion would want me?" She asked herself, looking at her reflection in a mirror.

"I'm not really cute at all, and I'm not girly like Bon Bon."

She sighed in self doubt. She had tried make up and dresses and getting her mane styled, but all that accomplished was a lot of snickers from everypony.

She looked around her room. She thought that maybe a bow in her hair or a ribbon around her neck would bring out whatever feminine charms she had buried deep down. She found a bunny ear head band in a drawer. Lyra had never been into cosplay stuff like that, but maybe it would look cute on her.

Placing the ears on her head she stood in front of her mirror, striking poses and making kissey faces at herself. She sighed, thinking to herself that you can't make a stone cute.

A subtle tremble under her hooves caused her to look around her room. She wondered if an earth quake was happening, but the trembling was too subtle.
She heard a magical sound coming from her wall, when suddenly something big and dressed in clothes came tumbling elbows over ass through her wall and landed on its back on her floor.

She meeped, startled at the sudden intruder.

The creature moaned as it looked around her room, its eyes finally falling on Lyra.

They didn't say anything for what felt like ages. Lyra was a pony caught in the headlights. Her brain knew what she was looking at, but the shock of the moment kept her from realizing it.

She took on a defensive stance, readying an attack spell just in case.

"Beautiful," the creature said, looking transfixed by the sight of her.

Lyra felt her cheeks glow, oblivious of future her and the creature would have together.

Fast forward to the present.

"So…let me try and get this straight. Lyra has some bondage thing, and you, trying to be supportive, have been "playing along" with it?"

You sat next to an unconscious Lyra, who had fainted from embarrassment after Bon Bon walked in on you two.

Bon Bon had insisted that you two sit down while you explain exactly what had been going on when she interrupted.
You were…embarrassed, to say the least.

"Yeup, that pretty much sums it up," you replied.

Bon Bon sighed, looking very uncomfortable.

"I'm uh, sorry you had to see that, Bon Bon."

"No, it's ok. It's my fault for not knocking."

An awkward silence enveloped the room, neither of you knowing what to say to the other.

"So, um…I wanted to…apologize to you too."

You lifted your head up to the pretty earth pony. She was looking away from you as she shifted a bit in her chair.

"Apologize, for what?"

"Well, you know. For the mean way that I've treated you. Yes, I have my own feelings where you and Lyra are concerned, but that's no excuse for how I've acted."

"So, you do love Lyra, don't you?" You asked.

She nodded sheepishly.

"I-I know that you love Lyra, and I know that she loves you, but I….I can't help feeling this way. I've watched her grow. I've helped pick her up when she was down. Life without her just…scares me. She's a grown mare though, and she can make her own choices. But when I see her with you I can't help but feel like…she doesn't need me anymore."

You sat and listened to Bon Bon. You could see where she was coming from. Until now you thought that she was just a mean spirited bitch, but now you could see her for what she really was.

A protective mother.

"Bon Bon, Lyra loves you. I'm sure she wouldn't be the pony she is today without you, and for that I have to thank you."

Bon Bon blushed, looking up at you as if to ask 'really?'.

You reached out to her, placing your hand on her hoof.

"Like you said, you practically raised her from a filly. There will always be a place for you in her life, even if I am in the picture."

She smiled wide, tears nearly forming around her eyes.

"Well, I…I guess that I can, you know, like you…for Lyra."

"Well well well, aren't you two getting friendly?" Came the sweet voice of a familiar unicorn.

Bothe you and Bon Bon quickly looked at the source of the voice, seeing Lyra's face. She was laying sideways and smiling like she knew something juicy.

"Lye Bunny, you're awake. Are you feeling ok?"

Lyra brought a hoof o her mouth as she giggled.

"Oh, I'm feeling fine, not as *fine* as you and Bonnie seem to be."

You and Bon Bon raised a brow at the same time.

"Lyra, I'm uh, sorry….for walking in on your….personal time."

Lyra blushed, but kept her sinister smirk.

"I-it's fine-but don't let me stop your moment."

Lyra was acting a little strange, and you just had to ask.

"Bunny, are you sure you're feeling ok? You're acting a little odd."

"'Sigh!' Honey, you can be so naive. It's obvious that Bonnie is trying to tell you that she like-likes you."

If you and Bon Bon had been drinking something, you both would have spewed it out.

"Lyra, that's ridiculous!" Bon Bon blurted out.

"Yeah, Bunny, I think you have the wrong idea," you added.

Lyra used a hoof to turn your head to look her in the eye.

"Sweetie, you don't have to lie to me. I'm not mad. In fact I'm happy."

"HAPPY!?" You and Bon Bon said in unison.

"Yes. I mean, my best friend and the person I love coming together? Why wouldn't I be happy?"

There were no words for what was going on. You looked to Bon Bon for an idea of what to say, but she looked just as shocked.

"Bunny, I'm confused. You want me to cheat on you?"

To this, Lyra looked confused.

"Cheat? No sweetie, cheating would be if you fooled around behind my back with some stranger. Bonnie is a friend. Not to mention that you're a stal-I mean, a male. It's your right to start a herd."

This was getting out of hand. Obviously Lyra had heard part of your conversation with Bon Bon and assumed that it was some heart felt confession. But the fact remained that Bon Bon was a lesbian. There was no way that she would be down with this.

Ooooor…

"That's right, Bunny. Bon Bon was just asking to join you and me in the bonds of heard…..hood."

"What!?" Bon Bon exclaimed.

Lyra clapped her hooves together happily, her smile like one of a filly who had just gotten a love letter from her crush.

"Oh Sweetie, that's wonderful! Shall I, uh, leave you two to get better acquainted?"

You turned to Bon Bon, who looked like she was ready to kill you five times over. You winked at the sour faced girl.

"Actually, seeing as you two are my mares now, I think that you two should get to "know" each other. With my supervision, of course."

Bon Bon's face shifted. Something dawned on her, and she slowly realized that you had given her the gift of a lifetime. Lyra's cheeks turned a delicate shade of pink. Her eyes darted from you to a very enraptured looking Bon Bon.

"M-me, and Bonnie?"

You stood up from the bed.

"Yes of course. I want you two to bond while I watch. Bon Bon, you get over on the bed and face each other."

"Uh, um….ok then,"

Bon Bon got up from her chair and climbed onto the bed. Lyra and Bon Bon sat facing each other, both looking a little unsure about the whole thing.

"Now, before we begin, I think it's a good idea if you both say something nice about the other."

"W-why do we have to do that?" Bon Bon asked.

"Because, you two just had a fight. It wouldn't be good for you two to enter into a relationship with that still in the air. So we're going to squash that here and now. Bon Bon, why don't you go first?"

Bon Bon did her best to keep her eyes from making contact with Lyra's while she thought of what to say.

"Uh-uh, Lyra…I-"

"Look at Lyra, Bon Bon," you instructed.

Slowly, Bon Bon looked her friend eye to eye.

"Lyra, you're my best friend, but lately its felt like we've been drifting apart, and…you're more than just my friend. You're the other half of myself. I'm sorry for being mean and over bearing at times, but it's only because I worry about you, and…I love you."

Lyra looked positively touched. Her eyes were glossy, and she held her hooves over her chest as if to hold her heart in.

"Good-good, that was very nice. Bunny, it's your turn."

Lyra sniffed back her tears of joy, placing her hooves on Bon Bon's.

"Bonnie, ever since we first met, you've been a friend, a mentor, a rock, and someponey that I can depend on. Nothing makes me happier than the idea of us being more than friends. There isn't any tif, fight or quarrel that would keep me from loving you."

Now both girls looked like they were about to burst into tears, and now they were ready.

"Kiss each other," you instructed.

Bon Bon looked like she was about to question your instruction, but Lyra stopped her by swooping in and planting her lips on Bon Bon's. Your eye brows rose in glee. This was going to work out for Bon Bon and you.

The cream colored mare closed her eyes and leaned into her new girlfriend's kiss. From where you were watching, you could see Bon Bon's tongue hesitantly poking at Lyra's lips, as if to ask permission to enter.

Lyra opened her mouth wide, welcoming Bon Bon's advances and even one upping her by mashing her own tongue into Bon Bon's.

The two mare's tongues collided and swirled together as both girls made little whimpers and coos. They pushed their bodies together, hooves running up and down the others body. Lyra squirmed one of her hind legs between Bon Bon's legs and under her rump, eliciting a sharp gasp from her friend. Bon Bon retaliated by running her hooves down Lyra's body, curving over her shapely hips and gripping her cheeks tightly, causing Lyra to gyrate her rump from the welcomed touching.

This was getting to be a pretty good show. You had always had a feeling that Bon Bon was a girl who would submit if you gave her a little push, and you looked forward to seeing more of that side in the future.

But now, there was business to attend to.

"Ok, ladies, that's enough of that," you said cooly.

Lyra broke away from Bon Bon like a good girl, but Bon Bon looked more than a little disappointed.

"H-hey! What's the deal?" Bon Bon asked.

"Well, Bon Bon, now that you and your fellow herd member are on good terms, it's time to initiate you."

The earth pony looked confused, but you could see that she didn't want to say anything that would end her future with Lyra.

"Initiante?" Bon bon asked.

Lyra placed her hoof on Bon Bon's shoulder, drawing her attention.

"Bonnie, you're now a part of this herd, and that means that master has to initiate you by dominating you."

Bon Bon hid it, but you could see the terror behind her eyes.

"It'll be alright, Bonnie. Master may be a bit harsh, but after a while you'll really start to love it."

"Actually, Bunny, I had a better idea for Bon Bon's initiation."

Ten minutes latter and a lot of rope and tying knots, you were finished with the setup.

Lyra and Bon Bon were lashed together facing each other. Their hind legs were tied together at the hooves, bringing their pussies within an inch of each other. They were both gaged, and their fore hooves were secured behind their backs.

To make things a little more interesting, you put blindfolds over their eyes to keep them in suspense.

"Ok, my sweet little slaves. The name of the game is 'don't cum first'. The one who climaxes first has to eat the pussy of the one who comes last."

This worked out great. No matter who comes first, Bon Bon will win. Either she gets eaten out by Lyra, or she gets to eat out Lyra.

You pulled out a double ended dildo, unable to help grinning at the fun to come (no pun intended).

You were about to pull out some lube, but stopped at the sight of the two pink, glistening sexes between the two girls legs.

"Well-well, looks like you little sluts are ready to begin. Well then I wont keep you both waiting."

You started with Lyra, who moaned with great delight at the feeling of the dildo sliding into her moist sex.

Once she had enough inside her, you turned to insert the other end in Bon Bon, who was trembling with anticipation. You touched the flat tip to her lips, and she jumped a bit from the contact. You pushed the tip inside, finding the insertion to be easier than you were expecting.

"Wow, Bon Bon, you're much looser than I was expecting. You must be pretty popular with the stallions around town huh?"

"Mm-mmm! Mm-mmm!" She protested, shaking her head.

"No?….Oh! That must mean that you masturbate regularly."

Like you had flipped a switch, her face lit up red like a christmas light. She sighed as loud as she could around the gag in her mouth, wiggling a little as if to try and get a little more inside herself. You slid the length of phallus inside of her slowly till there was an even amount in both girls.

You stood and watched them. They squirmed and twitched, both eager to begin.

"Alrighty then, girls. You may begin…..now."

Like a horse out of the shoot, Lyra began wiggling and bucking her hips as best she could. Bon Bon moaned sharply when she felt her counterpart begin assaulting her, forcing the end inside her to wiggle and move. It was clear to you that Bon Bon had never experienced this kind of pleasure, and you could only imagine the swarm of joy and ecstasy that was swirling around in her head.

Bon Bon began pushing back into Lyra, which only helped in pushing the end inside Bon Bon to sink deeper, since Bonnie didn't know to clench down on her end. Lyra heard her muffled sound, seeing an opening for her to push her friend further. Lyra clenched her teeth around her ball gag, you could see that while she was happy that you three were together, she was bound and determined to prove that she was still number one.

You were surprised at how much she was able to move despite the expert job you did in tying her up. She started bucking herself against Bon Bon like she was a stallion, sweat forming on her minty coat and around her forehead.

Bon Bon wasn't out of the fight yet though. She was moving her own hips, gradually building momentum. It was like watching two ponies trying to become one, almost similar to watching snakes mate, but way more hot.

The two continued grunting and gyrating, both with a look of determination and fervor. Their pussies were squishing and sloshing, the dong nearly disappearing it was so deep inside both of them. Their speed was getting faster and faster, one little tick would send one or the other into orgasm.

The both bottomed slammed their sexes into each other, both girls throwing her head back and groaning as they came hard together. A fountain of crystal clear mare come erupted from where they were both connected. It flew everywhere. On the bed, on both girls, you even felt droplets on your face.

It was beautiful, two friends symbolically combining their lust and 'coming' together.

The liquid stopped flying, and both mares were panting and covered in sweat and cum. You took their gags off so that they could breath easier. You removed their blind folds, both looking to you with sparkling eyes. You petted both of them, Lyra swooning into your hand while Bon Bon looked tiered yet skeptical.

"Well well well, bitches. It looks like we have a tie. You two know what that means."

Once both of your slaves were untied, they looked at each other shyly. They had to sixty nine now, and you could see the excitement mixed with hesitation.

Bon Bon laid on her back as Lyra mounted her. Bon Bon's eyes widened as she looked at the plot she loved to think about on those dark nights. She lifted her head slightly, catching a whig of Lyra's sweet, musky bunny scent.

"I-I've never done anything like this before, Ly Ly. I'm sorry if I'm no good."

"It's ok…Bonnie. I'm so sensitive right now. Not to mention….I've never done anything like this…with a girl either."

The two fillies fidgeted as they settled into position. Lyra started things by giving Bon Bon a kiss on the place just above her pussy, causing a shiver to creep up Bonnie's body.

"Don't worry so much about how you're doing. What's important is thinking about your partner and how they feel. That's the basis of coming together as a herd," you explained to the girls. Though you said it like an expert, in truth you had no idea what you were saying. Sounded good though.

Lyra wiggled her ass, trying to entice Bon Bon. Enticements were not needed though, Bon Bon's mouth was watering just from the smell of Lyra's sweat and the view of her bountiful rear.

Lyra threw you a pouty face that honestly had you briefly short of breath. Her eyes were glazed with lust, her lips were moist and glistening as she gently panted, and her mane hung slightly from the humidity in the room.

She didn't say anything. She didn't have to. The gaze of love and passion said it all.

You couldn't help but smile.

You and Lyra had always shared a connection that didn't need to be spoken.

It wasn't that you had never believed in 'true love' before her, it was that you never believed that it would happen to you.

Funny, Lyra always did have a way of surprising you.

The minty unicorn dropped her rear gently down on her friends face while burying her own muzzle into her wet, steaming marehood. A muffled moan of ecstasy escaped both girls as their mouths opened and their tongues made contact with the others soft, pink centers. Bon Bon's tongue began feverishly wriggling and pushing its way inside of Lyra, who was taking her time gently licking and tasting Bonnie's outer folds.

Bon Bon was quickly being swept away by the unbelievably sweet taste her friend was leaking into her open mouth. The cream earth pony greedily drank down the clear liquid like it was ambrosia. Lyra found Bonnie's clit, using the flat of her tongue to swipe and coat the little bump in her saliva, while her opening leaked her candy flavored juices with a steady drip.

"MMMMMPH!" Bon Bon moaned with her tongue still snugly wedged inside Lyra. The notion that her tongue was inside the place that her friend's boyfriend had used numerous times did cross her, but she was too happy to care.

Lyra (who was well acquainted with having her marehood licked like a lolly pop) was more composed, allowing her to focus on pleasuring Bon Bon. Not to say that she wasn't enjoying the hard work that Bonnie was doing under her rump.

You watched the two girls writhing together, trying to ignore the nagging down south.

Bon Bon started thrusting her hips up to meet Lyra's tongue as she lashed and swabbed the earth pony's pussy. Lyra's brow furrowed as she felt Bon Bon find her G-spot. Bonnie noticed the change in Lyra's demeanor, and started concentrating her efforts on the wavy place inside her.

Lyra responded to the attention by closing her lips, taking Bonnie's swollen clit and sucking it hard. She started to spray her cum on Bonnie's face, soaking her mane as it splattered on her. She pushed her rump down on Bonnie's face, gyrating her hips to force Bonnie to eat her deeper. Bon Bon held on tightly to Lyra's flanks as the unicorn maintained her hard sucking.

Bon Bon began to shake, and her grip got tighter. She screamed from under Lyra's butt as she squirted. Lyra held her tongue out, catching the liquid like Bonnie was a drinking fountain. Lyra quickly joined her friend. Her floodgates opened as a wave of her own liquid girl cum exploded from the place where Bonnie's tongue was still stuck.

The earth pony's mouth was quickly filled to the brim, and you could see that she was eager to swallow.

"Don't swallow it, Bon Bon," you ordered.

Bon Bon closed her lips, her cheeks bulging like a chipmunk transporting nuts. She looked at you with urgency, saying that she needed to swallow her mouthful soon.

"Do it, Bunny."

Lyra turned Bonnie's head toward her, opening her mouth and pressing her lips against Bon Bon's. Bonnie released her mouthful, swapping the cum.
It dripped from where they were connected as they held each other and kissed passionately.

Once they had finished drinking Lyra's nectar, the two oversexed pony girls continued holding each other as they turned their heads to look at you.

You smiled at your two slaves. The day was still young, and there was so much more fun to be had.

"M-master, we need more. Please help your pathetic fuck slaves," Lyra begged as Bon Bon licked girl cum off of her friend's cheek.

"Be right there, Bunny."


Author's Note

Sorry for the delay, all. What with new season and trying to keep up on other stuff.
Stay tuned for when Bon Bon and you consummate your union ;)

Next Chapter