Tired of dealing with all the stuck up mares, and their ‘BS games’ just to get some decent action, you decide you would rather try your luck with a gentler mare, like the sweet Fluttershy. Yeah, a mare like her isn’t likely to toy with me and make me her "little errand boy," you think to yourself. As you walk along the flowery path towards her cottage, you can’t help but notice the lack of the usual animals surrounding the area. Well, not like watching them is my job, so, oh well just makes it easier to talk to Fluttershy, I guess. You knock on the door to get her attention and she opens the door in response.

“H-h-hello? C-c-c-c-can, I h-h-h-help y-y-you?” She, shyly and weakly stutters, as she stares at your athletic, muscular, earth-pony body.

“Fluttershy, I thought with you being all alone in such a big old cottage, you might like some friendly company.” You sweetly say to her.

“T-t-t-thank y-y-y-you, f-f-f-f-for the kind offer, but I am a bit too b-b-b-busy dealing with so many injured animals at the moment. Perhaps another time?” She says, with the sweetest smile on her face. “I hope...you are not too...mad at me, are you? I just don’t have any time for you.”

It would seem Fluttershy is having a bit an issue at the moment, and might be a bit reluctant for a night of wild sex.

You could try to just force yourself on her, after all, Fluttershy is hardly a strong mare, and as long as you are able to avoid her using that little ‘stare’ of her’s, you seriously doubt she could stop you from straight raping her ‘till she bleeds out her ass.

On the other hand, perhaps if you offer to help her with the some of the animals, you may be able to win her heart, and persuade her into sex. Then again, this whole thing might be more trouble than it’s worth. Perhaps you would have better luck if you tried at the bar for some hot mare action.

(Brutality rape Fluttershy)

(Attempt to win Fluttershy’s heart through kindness to her animals)

(Try your luck at the bar)

Author's Note

Guest Chapter by LightningDash13