You look at the small Fluttershy, and immediately decide that you wouldn’t dare attempt to rape such a nice mare. You also know that you do want to go at it with her, and conclude that a mare like Fluttershy, should be won over. You’ll do it by helping her out with her poor animals. Yes, that will surely get you some hot mare ass.

What kind of evil Stallion would I be, if I stole the innocence away from a pony like you Fluttershy? Not somepony my parents would be proud of, that’s for sure. She looks at you worried, as you think to yourself.

“Um, if you...don’t…m-m-m-mind, I would really like to get b-b-b-ack to helping my animals.”

“Fluttershy.”

“Y-y-yes?”

“I would love to lend a hoof to help you take care all of those sick animals.” You say, trying to give her your warmest smile.

“YOU WOULD?! OH THANK YOU, THANK YOU.” Fluttershy says, with a gleam of tears in her eyes. “You have no idea how hard this has been trying to save them all by myself, and I would be ever so grateful for some help.”

“Not a problem, now where can I help first?”

“Well…”

Three hours of bandaging and cleaning up after all of her animals later...

“I can’t believe you are that good with animals, and went through all that trouble for them.” Fluttershy says, as she eyes you with a very high look of affection.

“What more can I say? When I heard you say you had animals in pain, I couldn’t help, but not act, to help the poor critters feel better.”

She kisses you on the lips. “And how can I not help, but love such a kind, giving stallion like yourself?”

Yes, it would seem your plan to win over her heart is working. Now all you need, is a little sweet talk, and like the master casapony you are, Fluttershy will be all over you.
“Fluttershy, has any pony ever told you, that you have the cutest little smile and mane of all the mares in Ponyville?”

“R-r-r-really, no pony has ever told me such a w-w-w-wonderfully nice thing before.” She says, as she begins to blush.

“Oh yeah, in fact, I am surprised that no pony has ever asked such a good looking mare like yourself out before.” You lean over, and grab hold of her head as you pull her into a sweet kissing embrace. “You really are a special kind of mare, and I think it’s about time a stallion like myself showed you just how perfect of a mare, I think you really are.”

Fluttershy kisses you back, and begins to rub against you in loving motion. “Thank you, I am happy to have met a special somepony like you.” She says while pushing her tongue into your mouth.

You play a game with your tongues in each other’s mouths, mixing and tasting each others fluids as they flow between you. Once the foreplay is done, Fluttershy whips the two of you up a nice little meal for dinner. You chat back and forth as you enjoy the well prepared meal, Fluttershy made. Fluttershy leads you up to her bedroom.

Yeah, finally the moment I desired to happen, has arrived and in just the way I planned. Leading the way in front of you, Fluttershy wiggles her ass seductively as she walks. You can’t tell if it’s being done on purpose, or if just a coincidence, but either way you find it, oh so sexy.

“You ready for me to rock your world, Stud?”

“Does Celestia control the sun?”

“Well then, let’s get to it, but before that, I have a question for you.”

“What is it?”

“Would you like me to use the stare on you, for an extra kinky experience?”

“Wait...what?”

“Yeah, If I use the stare on you, I can control your entire body, and your mind. I can make you experience the ultimate in sexual pleasures for a very long time. I promise you will love every single second under my control. So, what do you say, stud?”

Well, “stud,” Which choice will you make? Allow Fluttershy to use the stare on you, for a higher sexual pleasure? Or, refuse the offer, and just stick with straight sex?

(Allow Fluttershy to use the stare on you)

(Refuse)

Author's Note

Guest Chapter by LightningDash13