A little Surprise.

by Sugarcube66

Rating: everyone
Tags: Romance, Slice of Life, Alternate Universe
Length: 2112

Pinkie Pie and Cheese Sandwich have their fifth foal only to have a shock. A pegasus with a white coat, blonde mane and purple eyes.

Little Surprise is the daughter of two crazy party ponies but isn't much of one herself. As she grows, she becomes confused about a certain thing. Her wings. Even her best friends, Firefly and Posey are the same as their parents. She's the only one out of her family of 5 to be a pegasus. She was also the youngest. Posey is the earth pony filly of Fluttershy and Big Mac and Firelfy is the pegasus daughter of Rainbow Dash and Soarin.

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2014-06-01 17:41:04 UTC

The strange birth.

Pinkie rushed home after being at the hospital, her four foals were still at school so things weren't a problem.

''Cheesy, Cheesy!''

''Pinkie, what's wrong?'' he said, looking at the out of breath pink party pony mare.

''I.(Pant)..went to the doctors...(Pant) cause I have been sick lately...(Pant) and they told me.....(Pant) that I'm having another (Pant),'' Cheese looked at her in confusion.

''Another what?''

''Foal!'' panted Pinkie.

''Really?!''

''Yep, another little rascal,''

''Interesting. I wonder if our 5th child will be different,''

''If she is then Rainbow's soon to be second daughter will help her,'' she was referring to her best friend's pregnancy. She was 5 mouths along and knew that it was a filly now. She already had a little colt by the name of Thunder Drum.She had picked the name Firefly though ready.

Fluttershy was also pregnant but was only 2 months along so didn't know if was a filly or colt yet. She already had a pair of twins that were both pegasi. She knew the names she wanted though. If it was a filly, she wanted Posey and for a colt, Flower Hurricane.

Her twins were a colt and filly. The colt was called Apple Bucks while his twin sister was called Paw Shy. Both were the first pegasi in the Apple Family. Paw Shy had been the pegasus member of the former CMC group but when she earned her cutie mark, three black paws. It was parted.

Applejack had newborn twins on her hooves with a young filly on the side. The filly was five and called Caramel Apple. The twin colts were called Johnny and Apple Cream in age older. Johnny was perfectly the older one of the twins. Caramel had been the earth pony member of the former CMC group which had parted when she earned her cutie mark, a green apple dripping with caramel.

Rarity had a young filly on her hooves at the age of 5. The fillies name was Spiked Jewel and boy was she very vain. She would spend hours at a mirror to prefect herself. She had her cutie mark already and had been the unicorn member of the new CMC which departed a little while ago. Spiked Jewel was truly half dragon meaning she had dragon like eyes which meant she had shining eyes with pointed pupils. She had a unborn sibling that she hadn't been told about yet by either of her parents.

Lastly, Twilight had a young colt who wanted to be in the royal guards despite being a alicorn prince. His name was Flash Shield and he had a cutie mark of a shield with lighting behind it. He also had a baby sister called Twinkle who was also an alicorn. He was very overly protective of his little sister and didn't want anything happening to her.

Cheese paced around the outside of a room. On a nearby seat was a group of 4 foals. Two colts and two fillies. The oldest filly and the oldest of the group had a orange coat with a dark brown hair similar to her father.

Her eyes were closed as she tried to think and she was 8 years old. The second oldest and oldest colt had a bright pink coat and a brown mane similar to his mom but shorter and he had his mother's blue eyes. He was 5.

The third one and youngest colt was a clone of his father but with his mother's hair style but a lot shorter. He was two. While the youngest was about two and was just like her mom but with a mane like her father's. She and the youngest colt were twins.

Cheese stared at his youngest at the moment when suddenly a cry was heard from the room making some tears come into his eyes. He had a newborn.

''You can come in now, Mr sandwich,'' said a nurse as she left the room. He burst through the door and there in his wife's hoof was a beautiful filly. She had a angelic white coat and sun kissed golden mane that shimmered in the light of Luna's moon. She was truly a filly of the night. Her golden mane was short but still had curls in it.

''Hi, Cheesy,'' uttered Pinkie. He smiled.

''Hi, sweetheart. How's the little one?''

''She's fine. Just finished her first feed on the bottle,'' to make it better believable, there was a half full milk bottle on the counter next to her. He noticed something faintly on the side of his newborn filly.

''She's an earth pony, right?''

'No....She's a pegasus like Rainbow's little Firefly,''

''But how?''

''I don't know. There has been pegasus blood in me though since birth. My Grandma Pie was a pegasus that was identical to this little one,'' said Pinkie. ''Our genetics were never passed though but she's just like Pound and Pumpkin,'' she referred to the twin colt and filly who lived with her in Sugar Cube Corner. Pound grow to love his wings and even gained a cutie mark in being rough and tough.

It was a block being pounded by hooves so it wasn't all rough and tough, more like pounding things. Pumpkin, however did love her young magic but didn't use it to learn proper magic even though she was the student of Princess Twilight. She preferred to use it to cook developing a cutie mark of a chef's hat and two books.

''I see,'' the filly in Pinkie's hooves yawned and opened her eye lids revealing a cute surprise. Instead of blue or green, they were purple orbs instead of blue orbs or green orbs like her older siblings.

''Surprise.....,'' uttered Pinkie confusion her husband.

''Huh?''

''That should be her name, Surprise short for Surprise-amena Diane Pie,''

''It's cute, very cute,'' he said, kissing his wife and then smiling lovingly at his newborn pegasus daughter.

Starting school

Surprise walked along the dirt path to school next to her mom and dad, her older siblings were all in the afternoon class which was set for 8 to 12 years. Then they went to middle school. Her mom was carrying, in a baby carrier, a light blue baby earth pony filly with pink mane. She had green eyes and was staring at her older sister.

''Mommy, why am I a pegasus?''

''Well...Your great Grandma Pie was a pegasus..,'' said Pinkie. At that moment a group that would normally look like a family but not. Fluttershy and her husband, Big mac walked in front of Discord. With them was a group of two filly, Screwball and Posey.

Screwball smiled when she spotted her friend and ran over, jumping on her.

''Morning, Surprise!''

''Oh morning, Screwy,'' Posey walked over a bit concerned.

''You okay, Surprise?'' she asked in a soft voice that she had inherited from her mother.

''I'm fine. Screwy, get off!''

''Oh...,'' blushed Screwball then rolled off Surprise. A family of pegasi flow in too. It was Rainbow Dash, Soarin and Firefly. Firefly flapped her wings to join her friends.

''Morning!''

''Oh morning, Firefly,'' said the group.

''Are ya'll as excited as Apple Cream and Johnny here?'' asked Applejack walking over with the twins who walked over to their friends.

''We are,'' said the group to Applejack. The last group walked over, it was Rarity, Spike, Twilight and Flash with their youngest, Spiky Book and Twinkle.

''Hi, everypony,'' said Twinkle in a polite way. She was a pure princess despite hating flying. Johnny turned his head towards Twinkle then blushed. Twinkle slightly blushed herself but it was least notable.

''H-Hi T-Twinkle,''

''Hi.....Johnny,'' Applejack looked at Twilight with a knowing expression. The group walked towards the house as a periwinkle mare with a blonde mane and golden eyes came out.

''Morning, everypony. Can you all come in?''

''Yes!'' called the foals as they entered. There was 16 seats so there was 4 columns and rows. Surprise got the seat next to Firefly on the front row on column numbers (Which is from right to left) 3 and 4. Johnny and Apple Cream were at the back on column numbers 1 and 2.

Twinkle was sat on the first row on column number 1. Posey was sat behind Firefly and Spiky Book was sat at row number 3 on column number 1 so behind Twinkle on the back row. Screwball was sat on row 3 at column number 2.

''Hello, everypony. My name is Dinky Hooves. But call me Mrs Dinky,'' said Dinky at the front. Her cutie mark was 4 golden stars glittering.

''Hello, Mrs Dinky!'' said the class in unison.

''Now. I need you to introduce yourselves starting with the little princess on the front row,'' Twinkle smiled, standing up.

''My name is Twinkle Sparkle but I go by Twinkle. I may be a princess but don't treat me any different. I love reading and using my magic but I hate flying, that's all,''

''Hello, my name is Sea Song. I'm a sea pony but I don't love the water much. I do need to be in water to keep my tail,'' said a sea blue pegasus filly with soft seaweed green hair and jade eyes. She had a cutie mark of a water like note.

''My name is Surprise. I'm not much of a party pony like my mom and dad but I love surprising others. I also love my new baby sister, Baby Cuddles,''

''Huh? Why is she called 'Baby' Cuddles?'' said a pink colt with golden mane with a small streak of white. He also had golden eyes.

''Um..I don't know but she's very baby like,''

''Okay, okay. Next please!'' said Dinky.

''My name is Firefly. I wanna be a wonderbolt like my mom and dad!''

''Hi, everypony,'' started the colt from before, ''My name is Golden Spade. I'm a heir to the filthy rich money!''

''My name is Sliver Shell,'' said a grey colt with white mane with a single grey streak. And he had glasses over his blue eyes.

''My name is Screwball, never ever call me Discord Junior even though my daddy Discord is the best thing in the world to me!'' she was making a death glare at half of the class with her swirly eyes. After that Surprise only listened to her friends.

''My name is Spiky Book. I love books but I don't like clothes,''

''Howdy!'' yelled the twins before parting.

''Ah'm Apple Cream, ah'm the younger of the twins. Ah like helping my older sister make Caramel Apples!''

''Ah'm Johnny. Ah'm the older of the twins. Ah like bucking trees and being outside!''

Play dates.

Needless to say, Surprise was a hard filly had rear. The moment,she learned to fly, it just made things hard. Confetti, the youngest was the closest to her baby sister while Confetti's twin brother Cheese Pie didn't like how she got all the attention and that she had wings.

But things turned out well and in the end, Fluttershy and Rainbow's newborn daughters, Posey and Firefly along with Princess Twinkie the apple twins, and the princess of chaos, Screwball would have play dates with Surprise. Firefly was a pink pegasus with a messy coltish blue mane and the same colored eyes as her mom.

Posey was a earth pony that was identical to her mom but seemed to love flowers more then animals. Twinkie was identical to her mother but she had blue eyes, she was even an alicorn making her the hardest foal to handle apart from the random newborn daughter of Discord who didn't have a mom.

The apple twins had the same coat color as there mom Applejack. Apple Cream, the younger one had a short two colored mane and tail that was blonde and brown, his eyes were green. His twin also had blonde hair but in a different style and he had blue eyes.

Screwball was a earth pony but could be known as a alicorn without wings or a horn. She had a pink coat with a curly purple and white mane. She also had purple eyes that was just a swirl with no pupil.

Later on, Rarity's newly born son joined them making the group now 8. He had a purple coat with green hair. His hair was spiky making his name Spiky Book. He also had blue dragon like eyes and a scaly green tail that just left room for a cutie mark to appear. He did have a horn yes but couldn't use it very well and pure dragon wings.

Little did they know that they were gonna be friends for quite some time.