The Mysteries Of Murdershy

by magic_of_friendship

Rating: teen
Tags: Tragedy, Adventure, Dark, Sad
Length: 1079

Another year of the Summer Sun Celebration has gotten off to a bad start. A pony that Fluttershy knows best, her own twin sister, is having murder sprees in Ponyville. She and her friends have to survive somehow, but can they do it?

Fluttershy has a feeling, a really bad feeling. That this year's Summer Sun Celebration, won't turn out to be a blast. She was right, the worst of all villians, appeared at her house the day before. Her twin sister. Fluttershy thought she could get away, but her sister found her again. She has to find a way to tell her friends about the fact that her sister wants them dead. And she better do it quickly, before everypony in Equestria is running away from a deadly murderer.

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2014-06-07 16:14:26 UTC

Introduction

  It was a glorious day on Ponyville, probably one of the best. Because tomorrow is going to be the Summer Sun Celebration, everypony was excited and super busy as well. It seemed as if nothing could possibly go wrong. But there is always something going on in Equestria, something evil and lurking out; waiting to bite out into the safety of everyday ponies. But nopony was worried, because this summer sun celebration will be the celebration of Luna's return. And to a few picky ponies, a celebration of a new friendship. To these special ponies, they believe this year, the summer sun celebration will be a full success.

  "Twilight." somepony said.

  "Uh yes Fluttershy?" the purple pony replied back.

  The purple pony herself was known as Twilight Sparkle. Leader of the elements of harmony, decent princess, used to be Celestia's faithful student, a known sister in law to the princess of love, recognized as Princess Cadence, and her husband, the captain of the royal guards; Shining Armor, just happened to be her brother. She was known for royalty, but she treated herself, and everypony else, fairly. She had wise thoughts, and was best for plans. Twilight was always planning for the summer sun celebration, last year she was a major part of the holiday. But this year she was dedicated to helping out the Ponyville community.

  "Maybe we shouldn't be so..carefree about this.." Fluttershy answered.

  "Well why not?" said Twilight.

  "Um well." she muttered quietly.

  She could not think a reason good enough to support Twilight's questioning. And she knew Twilight would not want to waste her time waiting for her to come up with an answer. She hid behind her mane as she walked back slowly.

  "Nothing to say huh?"

  "Maybe you're right. I will get back to the decorations now.."

  "See you later then!"

  Fluttershy flew back towards the decoration area of the park, watching Rarity and Pinkie Pie put up streamers around the trees.

  "Hey Fluttershy!! Can you help me out with these streamers?" Pinkie asked.

  "Sure thing." she smiled back.

  Fluttershy honestly thought that sometimes, she wasn't in any use for her friends. The only reason why she decided to help them out was because of Princess Celestia. Her friends didn't really seem to care about the fact that she didn't hang out with them. She spent most of her time with Discord, the only friend that can make a pretty mean hurricane and still understand her the most. Discord was once a villain, but Fluttershy always believed in second chances, and her predictions were right. He was a good friend, a really, truly good friend. Her friends may not had taken Discord into consideration one hundred percent, but she did.

  As she hung up the festivities around, she had this feeling that she was going to be in danger. She didn't exactly have "Pinkie Sense" like Pinkie, but she still felt a little nervous, if only she knew what was going to happen.

  "I'm going home..just in case" Fluttershy thought to herself.

  "Rarity, tell Twilight that I'm going home early..I don't feel too well." Fluttershy said sternly.

  "Feel better dear." Rarity whispered.

  And off Fluttershy went, through the trees and into her cottage.

One Strange Visit

As soon as Fluttershy found her cottage, she slammed the door shut and hid in the living room.

"My animals will keep me safe. From whatever is roaming around." she muttered to herself.

"But they are just animals..they can't do anything."

She noticed that most of her animals were eating their lunch, and the fact that they think nothing bad is about to happen.

Something will happen. She just knows it.

"Angel. Come over here please?" she whispered.

The shiny white bunny hopped over as quick as a cheetah.

"Angel probably knows that something is wrong," she thought to herself.

Only Fluttershy understood animals, so she knew exactly what Angel was saying.

"You sent me all the way here for a reason, are you alright?" Angel asked in his bunny talk.

"I have a feeling, a really bad feeling. I don't know what, but something will happen."

"I think that 'bad feeling' is about to happen right now..look over there." Angel muttered.

Somepony was at the door. They couldn't tell who, though.

"Angel, I'm sure it's Twilight trying to see if I'm feeling better." Fluttershy replied.

But she didn't feel confident. Her nerves went crazy, her heartbeat got louder and louder, and sweat started to come down her face. She started gritting her teeth to cover her scream. This pony was definitely not Twilight. Whoever it was, she did not want to find out.

She heard a strange sound. It sounded like a heavy bag falling onto the floor. Then she noticed a letter going through the door.

"That's weird..the mailmare puts mail in my mailbox, not through my door," Fluttershy mumbled.

She slowly walked towards the letter, opened the envelope, and started reading it.

"Dear Fluttershy,

I wonder if you still remember me? Most likely not, but I decided to send you this letter anyways. Don't believe that I am here for revenge, sister. I love you, with all of my heart. But if you ever ditch me for your so called 'friends,' there will be consequences.

With love, your twin sister, Magnolia"

"No," she mumbled.

This was even worse than what she had expected. Worse than some villain taking over Equestria. Pretty much, this was the worst thing that could possibly happen around here.

She obviously did not want to open the door, but she knew if she had to keep her sister Magnolia waiting, sooner or later, she would get trapped.

She skedaddled over to the door, and slowly pushed it open.

"What are you doing here.." Fluttershy mumbled.

"Gee Fluttershy, I'm a guest. And I thought you were more kind than this." Magnolia sneered.

"Why would I be kind if you were to kill Posey?!" she yelled.

"You mean the worst mother ever? It was for the best, you know." said Magnolia.

"Go away. I don't want you in my cottage anymore." Fluttershy replied.

"Oh come on!! Fine, but sooner or later, you and I will have some quality time." Magnolia replied.

Magnolia slammed the door shut, picked up her bag, and simply walked away like she was leaving. But she isn't leaving. She's staying in Ponyville until Fluttershy breaks up with her friends, or worse, everypony in Equestria gets killed.