A TR Soldier's Adventures in Magical Horsey Land

So, many of you (If you actually thought about thinking about this Sleep-deprivation-made crackfic) may have noticed that I have not updated this fic in some time. (Mostly from the amount of school and other IRL stuff) And among other reasons, it's because I could get over the amount of inconsistencies in this. I.E.: Matt not freaking out when surrounded by talking multi-colored horses. So here is my question to you guys:

Should I:
A: Rewrite this fic entirely as a new start.
or
B: Continue with this fic and fix the plot holes as I go along.

I'll let you guys and gals decide on this, it's a democracy here, so no opinion will be judged by me. (Though I can't guarantee for other users.