Fairy Tale Garden

by MissytheAngle

Rating: everyone
Tags: Twilight Sparkle, Slice of Life, Human, Sad, Original Character, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Second Person
Length: 3361

You are a human who's found a liking to gardening in Equestria. Nothing has happened to you here until Twilight Sparkle approaches you.

You're a human who settled into Ponyville with much ease - more so than you anticipated. Not like you're questioning it, though. Around a month later, you've adjusted well into the pony-filled society, made friends with a few of them, and even decided to create a garden; something you never even considered back home. You smile brightly as you water your flowers and wave at anyone who greets you.

It's really as perfect as you can imagine here.

Until Twilight Sparkle comes to your house to ask you a few questions. You don't really like any of them.

Story for the Most Dangerous Game Contest. Also an experiment for me because I've never done a story like this. (... does it show? Probably)

Published 2014-06-28 13:50:02 UTC
Last updated 2014-06-28 13:50:02 UTC

Words

Fairy Tale Garden

by MissyAngel

Your name is not known to many ponies in Equestria--as in, none of them know. They had multiple names like “Naked Creature,” “Half Centaur Thing,” and only recently “Human Girl.” You’ve been called far worse, so they don’t bother you in the least. You even smile and greet them when the ponies pass by, because they’re finally getting used to you now. It’s actually kind of funny, such strange ponies calling you odd.

You’re watering the flowers in the long stretching, colorful garden, taking in the spring air. Taking a whiff of a scent of grass and something wondrous with no name, you let loose your blond hair, fingering through it to get the knots out. As you tighten your visor around the sweaty locks, you continue on with tending to the garden, a delightful smile on your face.

After weeks in Equestria, you found home in this quaint town called Ponyville. And you found a gift you never expected - gardening. Every variety, every color adorn your front house. Ponies compliment you when they pass by. Of course, you suck in the praise like a vampire, and one day your ego will grow and explode.

Until then, you smile warmly at the positive attitudes.

Footsteps can be heard not too far away, and they slow upon getting closer.

Oops, hoofsteps. You’ll never quite get used to replacing those terms. You straighten up and look up to see a purple alicorn standing behind the bright white fence. Her big purple eyes are filled with something oh so common coming from Princess Twilight Sparkle:  curiosity.

But towards you? You chuckle under your breath. It is bound to happen, you suppose. You grin and wave at her. “Hey, Twilight!”

Smiling awkwardly - which you totally find adorable, but never say aloud for obvious reasons - Twilight waves back. “Hi, uh… you know, I don’t think you ever told me your name.”

“That’s not important. What’s up?” You lean against the fence, stretching out your lank, gawky legs after a long day of standing and walking around. They ache slightly, but it’s best to just ignore it for now.

“Can I come in? If you’re not busy, of course.”

“Just watering my plants, so I’m not doing much. Over here.” You point to a table underneath a parasol in the corner. Hurrying over to the fence, you unlock it and let Twilight inside.

She takes a seat with a nod of thanks, and you follow shortly after grabbing some cups and tea.

“So, what do ya want, exactly?” you ask, pouring some tea for two. Green tea--something you never even tried until waking up in Equestria. You add in a touch of lemon juice for an extra, soury taste.

“I just wanted to ask you a few questions.” Twilight bites her lips, and holy crap, she still looks adorably nerdy. You can’t stop the giggle bubbling in your throat.

“About what? What I am? Where I’m from?” Resting your cheek against your hand, you prepare for the onslaught of questions you bet she’s been dying to ask. In your head, you’re holding in the fact that you’d love to go on and on about home. If it made Twilight pique her interest in things like video games and musical devices, then you’d jump right in.

“Actually no. I’ll ask those another day," she says with a smirk that you give back. “I have… two big questions. It could take a while.”

You squint at her, sipping the tea to take time to respond. Her tone has grown serious, and you feel your palms grow sweat as her eyes bore right into yours. You try to smile to lessen the tension crawling up your spine, though now you decide to look around elsewhere. “I have time. How ‘bout the first one?”

“Are you planning on leaving anytime soon?”

Unable to hold it back, you chuckle, but it isn't as heartfelt as you wish. “Want me gone already? I thought we were getting along good, Twilight.”

Twilight’s eyes grow. “No, no, I didn’t mean it like that! I’m just wondering… you seem to like it here, but I imagine you’d want to go back home. You probably have family and friends who miss you,” she finally manages to get out, gaining back her composure.

Your eyes narrow, and a heavy breath escapes your breath. “I’m fine here. Really,” you answer, drawing your attention to a weed close by. Leaning over and with a single, harsh pull, you toss the little bugger in a nearby bin. "No need to worry about me."

Twilight taps her hoof on the table. “You seem to be. In fact, you’re getting along really well with everypony. I’m surprised. Usually strange new creatures take a while to, how do I put this… get accepted here in Ponyville? But it’s been three weeks. Wherever your home is, I’m certain that they’re getting worried--"

“I don’t have a way back home,” you cut her off. You push away any harshness back down your throat and stare down at the tea as it ripples in your grasp. “I don’t even know how I got here, so how the heck can I get back?”

“We found a way.”

An eyebrow shoots up, all attention brought back to Twilight, who smiles wide when both your eyes meet again. “How?”

Twilight’s magic sparks around her horn, and she levitates an object onto the table. Once the purple hue disappears, you shoot a look at the thing. And you frown, eyeing the princess again the second you realize what the thing is.

“Do you remember talking with Princess Celestia and Luna the first day you… came to Equestria?” she asks, quirking a brow.

"They're nice." You recall the day with an unpleasant feeling. Mostly due to the headaches - whether they were from the screaming ponies or whatever voodoo brought you to this world, you're still not quite sure. You shrug and decide to pick a tiger lily from a corner of the garden and twirl it between your fingers. They’re among your favorite here, and you don’t see many back home. “The guards gave me real mean looks, though.”

“You didn’t bow down to the princesses when you met them, so the guards probably didn’t like that.”

You snort noisily. “It might’ve been obvious they were royalty, but… okay, alright, fair enough. Anyway, the point?”

“Well, they talked to you about how you turned out to be a bearer of one of the Elements; how you were going to be the Element of Trust, to be exact, but you didn’t believe it. And you told me it was just a coincidence.” Once again, when she looks as you, as if urging you to speak, you turn anywhere else. “The Elements of Harmony were made to protect Equestra, but apparently, there was an extra made in another world.” She gestures to said ‘extra’ before continuing. “It was made in case of an emergency or if the rest needed to be found, and the bearer would be brought here to activate the Seventh element. Once it was activated and the Elements were used for whatever situation came along, the Seventh bearer could return to his - or her - own world.”

“It’s been pretty quiet here, though. Ever since I got here, too,” you point out, looking out onto the peaceful town. It was the epitome of quiet and serene, a cool wind kissing your face and no accidents to be had. A couple ponies that have passed by have greeted you like a friend. Rather than judge, they accepted the strange new creature without a name or origin.

You hate thinking of leaving.

“Well, I think there was a problem that caused you to arrive too late. You see, we had to deal with this monster called Tirek, and this was about a month ago. Without the Rainbow Powers, we might have needed to use the Elements, and that’s where you would’ve come in. But something must’ve happened, and… well, here you are.” Twilight nods.

Your jaw falls slack. “So me coming here was a mistake?”

“Yes and no,” Twilight answers. “You were just late.”

“I hate being late,” you joke, though you sulk in the comfortable chair knowing this information.

“I know the feeling.” She nods in agreement with a simper.

“So to go home, I have to, like, do something to earn someone’s trust. And there’s gotta be trouble happening, and when I help fix it, the necklaces will take me home?” you say, only wishing it sounded as easy as you said it. As you speak, your voice lowers, confidence drifting away.

“Exactly.”

You stare at the garden, all the colors that paint the front of your house. The smells that reach your nose when you step outside. The wonderful way it makes you feel just staring at an accomplishment. “... Can’t I stay?” Your voice cracks at the end.

“Huh?”

You know she heard that when her ears twitched. You ask again, slow and clear, “Can’t I just stay here? I like it here and all, so why not?”

Twilight tilts her head, staring and blinking as if comprehending that question. “You can, it’s just… I’d imagine you have a lot to go home to.”

“I did.” Your sip your tea with a huff, the slight heat rushing down your throat. You rub your fingers together and feel that comfortable conversation the two of you were having morph into something you never wanted to happen. “But not stuff I wanna come back to,” you murmur.

“Oh?” Of course she hears that. Her ears perk up high, and concern flashes in her eyes. “What’s that?”

“It’s nothing.” You wave her away and get up, catching her off guard. An unsettling feeling rumbles in your gut. Whether you’re uncomfortable or just hungry, it doesn’t matter. Your feet guide you to the front door, and for a second, you just think of shutting the door in front of the princess. For several reasons, this doesn’t happen.

“You can tell me," she says, walking up beside you. She flies up to meet you at face level, and staring into her eyes, you see more than a purple pony princess wanting to talk to the weird creature. That wasn’t the case before, but now you could see it clearly as she looks at you with big, concerned eyes. She asks with a sheepish smile, “We are friends, after all, aren’t we?”

You nod at her. “I just have a lot of problems with some friends back home, alright? Nothing you need to worry about.”

“Anything I can help with?” As if friends was the magic word, her wings flutter at just bit of a more rapid pace. Her expression doesn’t even change, but a gut feeling tells you enough about her enthusiasm here.

“Little too excited there, princess.” You pat her head, which causes her to shoot you a displeased look. “And unless you can do my college work for me, that’s probably a no.” Crossing your arms, you grin and catch sight of Twilight’s questioning gaze, which only deepens.

Then a shudder escapes, and you sigh. “Or if you know how to mend a broken friendship… even though it’s pretty much all your fault.” At first, you question just letting this all out, but if it means actually letting some hidden pain out, then all hesitance is out the window! Your throat tightens up, and oh boy, if those tears start coming...

“What happened?”

You do hesitate, boots digging into the dirt. “Okay, quiz time:  what happens when you aren’t there for your friends when they need you most? And it’s the first time you’ve ever done it, and I don’t know what to do because I’ve never wanted to hurt my friends.”

Your vision blurs as a heavy sigh slips under your breath. However Twilight’s reacts, you can’t see anymore and rub your eyes vigorously. “And it’s not even one thing, it’s-it’s a group of tiny, simple things I could’ve done to never let it happen. Missing birthdays, making last minute excuses to not hang out with them, all that.”

“You can’t always be there for your friends,” Twilight says at last. You feel her patting your shoulder, and the feeling makes you feel kinda sorta good, like the support will make everything better. If only. “Things get in the way, and I’m sure they’d understand that.”

You shake your head, tears now slipping out. “I say sorry, but I don’t know if they realize I mean it or not. One day I had to borrow eighty bucks to buy a book for school, and my closest bud lent the money to me. Just said I should return it when I could."

"I… well, I never did. When he needed the money a couple days later, I couldn’t give it back in return. He was so upset, and I still don’t know if it’s towards me or not. It’s probably me!” You laugh loudly, and frighteningly, too. It’s an awkward laugh around your tears and the burst of all this angst you've been holding back. “I would take in their friendship and all those good things they do for me, but I never gave anything in return. I’m the worst.”

Brushing away the drops, you feel an anger rise in your chest. It explodes outward as you say through your teeth, “That’s why it’s a mistake, Twilight. How can I be an Element of Trust if I can’t be there for my friends when they need me? Even if it’s something small like money? Your princesses were wrong, Twilight. I’m not the one you’re looking for.” You point right at her, chest heaving and all that anger projected to her, which makes her step back.

Suddenly, the tears burst out and drip endlessly down your cheeks, and you drop onto your knees, face buried between them. Twilight remains silent for a minute as you let all that anger and guilt fall out, that facade of a cheerful person breaking apart, that smiling mask cracking. This world you love suddenly shifted, reality settling in and smacking you right in the face. You can't run away from it anymore; time to face the music!

You don’t know where to go anymore.

“You’re still wrong, you know.”

Teardrops staining your face, you look up to her, sniffling. “What do you mean?”

Twilight’s smile and confident stance tells you she’s preparing for a long speech. Boy, you are not in the mood for this crap. “At first, we didn’t know what to expect from our new guest in town. You were some unknown creature that we all thought would harm us. It took a while, but when you started living with us and everything, we realized you weren’t out to hurt us.”

“Then why hasn’t it activated?” Your voice cracks again, sounding young and vulnerable. “You say I’ve gained trust of everyone, but what if that isn’t true? What if they’re just playing nice, and th-the-then… they talk about me behind my back?”

Twilight’s face grows serious again. She was observing you as you spoke - not just watched, observed something on you. And you can’t quite figure out what. She frowns in a bothersome way, like she’s figuring out a problem that was actually really easy to solve. “I think there’s one more person who needs their trust in you.”

You lean back against the wall, pondering the list of important ponies who might need your trust. “The princesses? They seem to like me. Luna bugs me in my dreams, though. It’s a little weird. Umm, is it Discord? Mmm, probably not. He’s not too bad. I could do without him turning the garden into a sea of flowers with teeth. I think I still got the bite mark, look!”

She grimaces. “I’m good. But I’m being serious!” You don’t answer her question - can’t. The longer she stares, the less comfortable you become. After a long, rather weird staring contest, she says, “You really don’t, do you?”

“Who?”

“You!” she exclaims as if it were obvious. It isn’t. You blink, and, catching your bemusement, she adds, “You’ve got the trust of plenty of ponies in Ponyville. You’ve made some friends, and you have plenty of potential - "

“Careful, princess. My head’s gonna grow three sizes too big if you keep at it,” you interrupt with a dead smirk. “Besides, I don’t even know how I got everyone’s trust. Well, not everyone, but you get the idea. Maybe it's just... maybe you ponies are just very easy to impress.”

“You’d be surprised, actually,” she deadpans. “But what you did is really the best thing to do to get someone’s trust:  be yourself.”

“How long have you known me?” you retort with a roll of the eyes.

“Long enough to know that you were entrusted with this Element for a reason. They aren’t just given out to anyone,” she points out with a spark in her eyes. “And about your friend… just talk to them. Be honest. Be yourself, and they’ll understand.”

You stare longer at the Element, a dark blue gem shaped like a tulip, and take Twilight’s words to heart. If she’s speaking anymore, you’ve zoned out and can no longer hear her. It matches the color of your cobalt blue eyes; this necklace, the only way to return home. To failing grades, to a friendship you have no idea how to mend, to a scary old world…

But also to a sister who calls three days a week just to make sure she’s not missing anything in your life, the friends you hung out with when you first drank, and glorious music that takes you away from stressful days. Hell, the last thing you recall before ending up here was a night with friends, video games, and theirs concerns whenever you became dizzy, and finally a sleepover that ended with you in the middle of Ponyville. Old memories settle in, and you smile.

Staring back to Ponyville, you watch several ponies out in the street. Two are chatting while one buys their food from the market, and a group of mares trotting while chattering endlessly about inaudible things. You like most of these ponies. Oh, there were rocky starts, especially when you woke up to screaming ponies and a splitting headache, as well as to distrust and judgement. But perhaps, after a month, they've grown to like you back. Perhaps...

You duck your head away, brushing the hair from your face and behind your ear. “Give me more time, Twilight. I can’t leave... yet. Soon, just not yet.”

She opens her mouth to retort, but the deep sadness on your face stops her. Instead, she nods and says, “Okay. I will say this, though:  facing your problems in real life will make them better. Running away only makes it worse when they catch up with you.”

“Do you get fortune cookies when you become princess? Ya know, to give out wise old advice?” you chuckle, though it’s rather forced, as you’re trying to wipe away a tear or two from your eyes.

Twilight giggles. “It’s just something you learn. And you’ll learn that trust isn’t just something you give to everyone, or someone gives you. You have to give it to yourself to really understand it. You’ll get there someday,” she reassures, using her wings to hug you. Only now do you realize how fluffy ponies are actually. Like the family dog; how cute!

“Thank you,” you tell her, breathing a sigh of relief. Placing your hands in the back pocket of your jeans, you notice the sun setting. You decide to go for a walk to think, exiting the brilliant garden.  Twilight catches up, and you can’t hold back a smirk. “Besides, from what I’ve been told, trouble comes here pretty often.”

Twilight laughs. “That’s usually the case.” Her eyes then travel to your neck, where the necklace with the tulip gem sits. Both of you smile at one another.