Cupcakes, The final party

by GodOfBBQ

Rating: teen
Tags: Tragedy, Dark
Length: 1916

Pinkamena captures another victim for her new cupcake ingredients

After arriving into Ponyville Silver Arrowhead is quickly introduced by a kind and energetic pink pony named Pinkie Pie who is acts quite strange and odd around him he then falls under the trap Rainbow Dash fell for only months ago.

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2014-07-08 22:20:05 UTC

Chapter #2 Learning the truth (End)

As he slept he dreamed about his friend Rainbow Dash being found dead, which at this point was his number one fear. He then saw himself in a fancy dark colored suit accompanied by other ponies possibly friends of the young pegasus. He then saw a birds eye view of a light brown coffin with Rainbow's cutie mark on the top slowly being lowered into the six foot deep hole.

"Gah!" Silver yelled quickly sitting up in the bed "Mother of Celestia that was terrible!" That dream kept him up for the rest of the night, he couldn't sleep because he feared he would go through the same dream. It was six in the morning and the sun was barley being risen, Silver stumbled out of the entrance of the hotel he stayed in. After a quick stroll he bumped into the pink pony from Sugar Cube Corner.

"Oh Hello Silver did you have a nightmare?" Asked Pinkie with a curios face

"How did you-" Silver was then interrupted

"Oh I just do! Anyways I was wondering if you could help me with something."

Silver looked at her with a questionable look. "What do you need help with, exactly?"

"Oh nothing to big just I need you to help me put a broken oven in the basement of Sugar Cube Corner, nothing you can't handle right?" The excited young mare answered. Silver agreed knowing it would take his mind off of the nightmare he had the other night. When he and Pinkie Pie got to the sweets shop he was offered a cupcake with rainbow frosting. He declined but Pinkie insisted, since he didn't want to hurt the mares feelings he took the treat and ate it. Soon after he started to feel dizzy he looked at Pinkie who had a devilish smile on her face, the last thing he saw before he passed out was the pink mare, with a meat clever in hoof.

When he woke he found himself in a dark room that smelt like rotting flesh, mold, and oddly enough frosting.

"Well sleepy head decide to join the party!?" said a high pitched voice in the darkness.

Where am I!? Who the hell are you!? Yelled Silver with an angry and displeased tone.

"Oh are you not happy? Anypony who attends my parties always have a smile on there faces!" Said the voice once more, after a minute Silver looked into the dark corner of the room, what he saw next was going to horrify him, he saw the same pink pony he met when he arrived into town, walking out into the light so he could see her better. She had a dress with other ponies cutie mark on it in fact it was made up of pony flanks, she had a neck less made of unicorn horns and the back of the dress had pegasus wings. It was to horrifying to look at.

"PINKIE PIE! GET ME THE HELL OUT OF HERE YOU SICK  TWISTED WHORE!" Yelled Silver with a raging expression.

"What a potty mouth, that's no way to treat your party host, looks like I'm going to have to fix that but first I want you to see something." As she said this she pulled out a obviously stuffed pony but this pony was very recognizable to Silver. It was his old friend the one hes been looking for this whole time, it was Rainbow Dash.

"Wha-what. WHAT DID YOU DO TO HER YOU SICK MONSTER!? WHY IS SHE LIKE THAT!?" Yelled Silver with tears and anguish in his face.

"Well since she was in such great condition I had no choice but to stuff her. Now how would you like to figure out my new recipe for Silver frosted lemon cakes?" When Silver heard this from the pink mare he new the impending doom that awaits for him, he quickly tried to figure out a way to get free but was distracted by his once living friend, he could just imagine what pain Rainbow went through. As Pinkie walked closer with a scalpel in hoof Silver stared her right in the eye just seeing the madness in the ponies eyes, as she came closer to his flank where his cutie mark was he hocked a thick and pasty hunk of spit and spat it right in her hair which made her cringe back away. "Eww! Why did you do that!?" Asked Pinkie Pie while rubbing her mane with a bloody rag trying to get the hunk of spit out of her mane. As this was happening Pinkie got a huge scowl on her face and swiftly dove into his flank area and cut out his right sided cutie mark.

"GAHHHHH!!!!!" Silver screamed, he never felt such pain in his life he struggled and kicked but didn't move, but noticed that his upper left hoof was able to move the metal binds he then noticed that the screws in said bind were loose. He quickly glanced at Pinkie looking through her chest full of torture devices and blood covered tools, possibly looking for a tool to punish Silver with. Taking the chance Silver yanked and struggled his left hoof to loosen the nails and hopefully get the bind off so he could escape. He successfully pulled out his hoof from the bind but he noticed Pinkie was starting to look up from where she was, so he positioned his hoof to where it looked like he was still stuck. When she came back she took her scalpel and cut out the other flank, Silver let out a blood curdling scream. When she went to the back to the room once more she returned with an ax in hoof, Silver quickly knew what she would do now so when she got closer he busted his hoof from it's position and struck Pinkie right in the jaw knocking her out. After some yanking and pulling he was finally free he was just about to rush out of the room when he then thought of the stuffed Rainbow Dash and imagined what that monster of a pony did to her.

"This is for you Dash." He whispered as he walked towards the pink pony still on the ground. He then lifted her onto the same table he was binned to and made sure she wasn't able to escape the same way he did. He woke her up by smacking her and shaking her head.

"Well hello sleepy head" said Silver with an expressionless face.

"Wha what the how did!?" Stuttered Pinkie still trying to figure out the position she was in.

"Why Pinkie, why did you take a life? An innocent life, for your sick little cupcake game? No don't you know what your doing!? Ponies still don't know where she is! Ponies are still looking for her! You took her away from this world you demon!" Said Silver with a serious yet angered face.

"I didn't do anything I-" Pinkie was interrupted.

"Don't pull that I didn't know what happened crap on me! You know what you did! And now your going to pay for the sins you've committed." Said Silver with a scalpel in hoof.

"No Please give me a chance! I'll change!" Yelled Pinkie Pie with a pleading expression.

"Kind of too late for that change don't ya think Pinkie? Replied Silver who was starting to cut out her cutie mark but then stopped half way. "No I'll prepare you for what you will encounter in the next life." As he said that he put the scalpel on the table and then grabbed an oil lantern with a small blaze in it. "ENJOY YOUR LAST PARTY PINKIE!... IN HELL! Silver then smashed the lantern on to the ground knowing that the blaze will spread onto Pinkie he then grabbed the stuffed Rainbow Dash and the scalpel and quickly fled out of the basement. The only thing he could hear was the painful sounding screams from Pinkie Pie as she burned alive. When he got outside he was encountered by a royal guard who saw him with the stuffed pony, "I found her" he said giving the guard what was left of the young pegasus. As he was pushing the stuffed Rainbow Dash towards the guard he whispered to it "See ya soon Dash." After that he walked off into the road leaving Ponyville. Once he was out of the town he took a somewhat large rock and used the scalpel he took from Pinkie's torture basement and carved out a grave for Rainbow on the rock, she would have wanted that. After he carved that and left he was never seen by anypony in Ponyville ever, they only referred to him as "The Final Party Guest"

Chapter #1 Gone Missing

After weeks of traveling and training a young strapping pegasus named Silver Arrowhead arrived in Ponyville to challenge an old friend by the name of Rainbow Dash to a grand race in Canterlot. When he got there he saw the usual things you would see in a small town shops here and there, restaurants, little homes, and some mansions but those were very rare. After a while he began to get a tad hungry so he decided to stop at a small shop called "Sugar Cube Corner" he was quickly greeted by an energetic and exciting pink pony named Pinkie Pie.

After he orders his sweets he then asks the pink pony "Excuse me miss but do you know where a pony named Rainbow Dash is? I'm an old friend of hers and I need to see her right away." As he asks this the pink ponies eyes widened and stared at the pegasus but then smiles widely and replies

"Oh you know Rainbow Dash? Well I don't know where she is shes been gone for a really really long time, I think shes been gone for a couple months now, oh but if she turns up I'll tell her you came by, whats your name stranger? Pinkie asks with a welcoming grin on her face.

"My name is Silver Arrowhead but you can call me Silver." Answered Silver with confidence and arrogance. After eating his small slice of lemon bread he walked out the door to look for a place to stay. As he walked he saw a poster on a wall near town square. He walked slowly towards it and starts to read it. It was a missing poster with a picture of Rainbow Dash on it, it said the usual things it would say on a missing or wanted poster but as he skimmed through it he found a sentence that was so terrifying it sent chills down Silver's back.

It said "If found deceased inform royal guards for criminal investigation." Silver hoped that it would come to that but then he remembered how strong and amazing Rainbow was then he thought to himself

"Nah shes too strong to be dead shes just lost or somethin she find a way back, I'm sure of it." As he said that he continued to look for an i to stay at for the night. Luck may have it that there was one and it had a room for a reasonable price, Silver took his keys for the room got to his room unpacked and slumped down on the bed and not even fifteen seconds of resting he falls fast asleep.