When a thief steals something, Vinyl is blamed for it and it drives a wedge between her and Octavia. However, the wedge isn't caused by the theft. Octavia's family has been hiding a dark secret for generations, and with the theft, the cellist is terrified that Vinyl will find out the truth.
But Octavia's secret, and her refusal to share it, may end up costing her and Vinyl everything, even each other. Thinking that everything is her fault, Vinyl sets off to reclaim the stolen goods, not knowing the danger she is walking into.

Some things are meant to stay so secret, so buried in shadows, that they can never see the light of day again...

Sequel story to Shopping Trip and A Hidden Secret