Luna woke an indeterminate period of time later, groggily creaking her eyes open. A headache assaulted her head, felling like it had been hit by the Friendship Express. She pressed her hooves to her temples in an attempt to relieve the pressure. While it provided some manner of relief, it is only short lived. It did clear her head to the point where she turned over in the bed, but she felt that all too familiar feeling in her bowels. She ran a hoof down her back, lifting up her tail and feeling around.

I don't know what happened, but that monster left this... thing, inside me when he put me in the bed. Luna tried using her magic, but the inhibitor is still around her horn. She tries using her hooves to push it off, but they keep slipping over the metal, and what grip she could muster didn't seem to be doing any good in terms of getting it off. Oh well, looks like she'll have to do this by hoof.

Luna reached behind to get a good purchase on the base of the dildo in the crook of her hooves, and began to pull. A sharp sting of pain and pleasure assaulted her sensitive plot, her eyes widening from the sensation causing her muscles to cease working. She dropped to the bed with a thump with a gasp at the sting.

Now knowing what to expect, she braces herself and begins pulling again. Clenching her teeth, pulling steadily, the construct begins its exit from her plot hole. Heaving pained breaths through clenched teeth, she got surprised when she encountered ridges and raised bumps on the phallus. 'Those weren't there before! Did... Did he replace it while I was sleeping!?' A disturbed blush found its way across her face as the bumps and ridges on the replaced plastic cock stimulated her evermore.

Luna estimated she had half out, but just as she decided to pull the rest of it out in one go, the first tug brought with it a crescendo of endorphins as she felt a change in the raised patterns. Grumbling to herself, bracing once more, she pulled harder and began lightly squealing to her self as she pulled it out more. The change in ridges of this construct seems to be more pronounced, raised higher than the rest of what she pulled out.

She is forced to change her grip on the toy, putting her hooves directly on the phallus itself and pulling it out that way. Her grip slipped, causing the dildo to twist within her as the higher ridges and bumps on the toy pressed against her tightening hole. Unintentionally, she let out a high pitched squeal and fell off the side of the bed, landing awkwardly on the floor on her stomach from the unintentional stimulation. Luna tries getting to her hooves, but every time she makes an attempt to get up, a sudden head rush has her hoof slip out from under her. After the fifth or sixth attempt, she just elects to lay on the floor with the dildo half out her ass much to her disgrace.

Moments later, she hears fumbling and clicking at the door. It swings open, revealing Crimson standing there. She just smirks at Luna as he casually walks up to her.

"Awake I see. Sleep well, your highness?"

"What do you want this time?" Luna unhappily deadpanned.

"You woke earlier than you should have. It's a little before midnight, you weren't supposed to wake until morning." Crimson then went up to Luna and put a hoof on her upper back between her shoulder blades to hold the princess against the floor. "You weren't even supposed to move this too." With hoof pressed against the base of the toy, Luna felt the reversal of what she wanted to happen.

"Stop, ple—" Before she could finish her sentence, the ribbed toy got pushed back up her ass with considerably less lube than last time, all the while Luna clenched her teeth as a painful moan threatened to escape her mouth.

With a firm tap to ensure it's back in, Crimson went back over to one of the chests and pulled out the O-ring gag again. "Open up!" He joyfully said." Luna just shook her head in protest, still on the floor. Reaching back into the trunk, he got out the crop he used to spank Luna earlier.

Upon seeing that again, part of her told her to open her mouth, yet another part told her to not do so because the rush of being spanked wasn't entirely unwelcome. With regret, she decided to open her mouth and get it over with more quickly.

Crimson slip the item into her mouth, and did the strap up behind her head. He left the room momentarily and came back with a glass of water and a capsule. "You may wander why you're so uncoordinated, my dear." He lifted her head up off the floor and put the capsule in her mouth. "That is a strong sleeping pill. I put one in the bowl of water I gave you before you konked out before. They also take a while to get over if you wake up earlier than expected. I don't need you awake right now, so have another." He then pour the water into her muzzle carelessly, and Luna had a bit of difficulty swallowing it aside the choking on the water.

The only way to breathe again is to make an effort to swallow the water, which would allow her to breathe again. The only problem is she swallowed the pill too.

"Now, since you can't get back on the bed, I'm going to have to help you back up." Crimson had enough of a time getting Luna onto the bed begin with. Much to his surprise, it didn't take as long nor near as much effort as he thought. He went to pull the covers back over her, but stopped half way with his hoof and blanket mid-air. "You know, I'm in the mood for a midnight snack." Crimson stated plainly.

Tossing the blanket aside for now, he repositioned Luna on her back and held her legs open with his hooves. With gusto, he dove in and began vigorously licking at the princess' delicate folds. Crimson enjoyed himself as he had before; greedily slurping up Luna's nectar while making satisfactory moans for her to hear, and mockingly intended to tease at the same time. Luna only gave unhappy groans throughout the five-minute long process. At the end, Crimson had to take a long, tantalizing lick from top to bottom of her pussy, ending with his tongue hanging out his mouth.

Licking his lips and deciding he's finished, Crimson put the covers back over Luna and removed the gag from her mouth, putting it back in the chest.

"Why?" Luna simply asked.

"I like to have a bit of fun from time to time. After which I erase the mare's memories of the last 24 hours and put them back on the streets, freeing me to continue."

"How many..." She sleeplessly asked. Then, thinking to herself she said; 'He must be punished for his crimes.'

"I don't keep count. Anything else?"

'I need to think of something, fast.' A idea bulb went off inside Luna's head. "All those years before I became Nightmare Moon..." Luna trailed off, yawning heavily. "...with Celestia looking down on and ignoring me. It instilled a mild subservient state in my mind."

Crimson shot an unexpected glance at Luna. "What are you trying to say?"

"After 1000 years on the moon, what would be the first thing on one's mind when they return?" Her figure involuntarily relaxed greatly at this stage, struggling to get out the next few words. "All you had to do... Was ask....", she yawned. And with that, Luna finally dropped off to sleep, leaving a dumbstruck Crimson Skies standing at the foot of the bed.

~~~***~~~

The same sensations from waking up during the night, and waking up blindfolded flooded Luna's senses for the third time. Her surroundings are vastly different this time, resembling the alley, or thereof anyway, that she landed in the night before last. Refuse, trash, garbage, litter, and all synonyms for peppered the dirty alleyway from her place on the ground.

Unlike last time, waking up didn't come with the 'full' sensation from having a dildo shoved up her plothole. Luna slowly got to het hooves, shaking and swaying lightly as she did. 'How did I... Get here?' She wondered. That stallion did say he would put me back after he... Wait, he also said he'd erase my memory somehow! So why do I remember? No matter, I shall exact punishment on him later. She bought a hoof up to steady her swimming head, trying to think of how she's going to inform Celestia of her whereabouts.

I can't tell her specifically what happened, Sister would rip apart the fabric of space-time to find that monster. An idea buld went off in her head. I'll just say I stumbled upon him taking a mare home and followed. With the plan semi-sorted, she ran a hoof along her horn. The magical inhibitor ring was removed when Crimson dumped Luna in the alley. Looking over herself, Luna saw her Moon Shine disguise still in place. She used the advantage of not having the spell worn off from not having cast the canceller, to walk out of the alley to the assault of the hustle and bustle and morning sunlight assaulting her every sense.

Her eyes forcibly shut of their own accord from the sunlight. She creaked them back open, and could hazily make out the various shapes of the ponies going about their morning business.

"Are you alright there, miss?" Asked a voice.

Luna's gaze found the source of the voice; a tan brown stallion and a darker brown mane. "What time is it?" She asked.

"Oh, it's just gone ten in the morning, a few minutes after," he said, although rather redundantly. "Are you alright? You look like you had a bit of a rough night!" He said jovially.

"That is... One way to put it..." Luna said, cringing. "I must be going, I am late getting back home."

"Well, glad to see you're alright. I suggest drinking some water first, that will help with the headache!"

With a thankful nod and a weakly mustered grin, the two parted ways. Luna went into a store first and got a couple bottles of water, which she drank rather quickly, depositing the bottles in receptacle not twenty metres up the street.

Up ahead lay Canterlot Castle. From her position, it loomed overhead, although some ways in the distance. Picturing the throne room in her minds eye, she concentrated her magic on the image and stepped into it, effectively teleporting herself right into the throne room with a loud pop.

All eyes shot to Luna upon her arrival.

"SEIZE HER!" Cried Celestia. "This mare intruded on the royal throne room without requesting an audience prior!"

Three guards made their moves in her direction "WAIT!!!" Boomed Luna's Royal Canterlot Voice. Her horn lit up and the illusory spell dissipated.

"Luna!!!" Cried Celestia, although more happily this time. She quickly got up off the throne and ran down to Luna's position, pulling her into a hug. "Guards, please leave us for the time being," Celestia commanded. They all nodded at Celestia and promptly left the room, closing the massive throne room door with a resounding thud.

Celestia turned back to Luna and hugged her more tenderly, squeezing her out of sheer affection. "I am sincerely sorry for what I said. I am glad you're OK, however. What were you doing? I had to make up excuses for the officials!"

"Forgive me sister, I was... Indisposed."

"Excuse me?"

"Tied up?" Clarified Luna.

"Doing what, exactly?"

'Now's my idea to put my plan into action.' "I went to one of the Canterlot City's bars to cool off, and I ran into a stallion called Crimson Skies."

"I gather that was the disguise you teleported back into here, in?"

Luna gave a nod and continued. "We were playing drinking games and one of the mares had enough. He offered to take her home, and I went with them just to make sure she got back home safely."

"And did she?" Inquired Celestia.

"He... had less than desirable intentions in mind for her."

Celestia audibly gasped. "What did you do!?"

"I stopped him before he could do anything, and up until now I spent trying to track him through the streets. I couldn't find him, but, I know of a way to find him."

"And what way is that? Is it dangerous?"

"By no means. We simply go to the clubs tonight and wait for him."

~~~***~~~

Luna and Celestia made their plans, but much to Celestia's chagrin Lune kept several of the details to herself, namely the punishment she had in store for him. Luna kept her disguise from before, and taught Celestia the illusory spell so she could create her own disguise; a slightly taller than normal unicorn mare with an azure coat and a flowing deep purple mane. Luna gave Celestia one of the bands she used when they got to the same boulevard that Luna was at the other day.

The Night Princess had Celestia wait outside the club that she initially went to when she met Crimson, giving Celestia his description and told her to use 'the signal' when he showed up.

Two hours later, it's Luna instead of Celestia that caught sight of the stallion walking with purpose through the street. Luna closed her eyes and concentrated her magic on a telepathy spell. 'Tia, he comes your way!'

'I shall talk to him until you get here.'

Luna walked back up to the club she stationed her sister at, trailing behind him enough to keep tabs on him. It didn't matter if she lost sight of him, her sister would catch him.

When Luna got to the bar's entrance, the two were already talking so Luna decided to make an appearance. "Hello!" She bellowed. "I see you've met my sister!"

Crimson Skies nearly fell down from the fright and shock of having Luna basically yell in his ear. His legs gave way, but not enough so that he'd actually fall over. His head snapped around to look into Luna's eyes with a look of pure terror. He only looked at her aghast, unable to muster any other expression. "I, I, I... Uhm..."

"What's the matter, Crimson? I was to meet my sister, Moon Shine here for some drinks to make amends for a quarrel we had on the night you met her. She said how much of a good time was had, and decided to see if we could find you, so you could tag along!"

"Uhhmm..."

"Please, let us go inside!" Exclaimed Celestia.

"I've got to meet somepony else, sorry..."

Celestia's expression deadpanned. "That is not an option, you vile creature." With an intense light surrounding her horn, Celestia teleported the three of them back to the throne room.

Celestia exited from the teleport sitting on the throne, and Luna at her side.

"We know what you did. My sister informed me of your despicable deeds" The alabaster mare began, talking down to a disorientated pegasus whom had clearly never been teleported.

"Ugh, my head... What are you talking about, 'deeds'?" He said rather groggily.

"You know full well what you did, Crimson Skies." Berated Luna. "GUARDS!" She bellowed, and several night guards of the bat pony variety came rushing in, looking incredulously at the stallion on the floor. "Take this individual to the dungeons. He is being held on several accounts of accused rape."

The looks on the guards faces turned to those of disgust. "Yes, your majesty."

An involuntary twinge ran through Luna at being called 'your majesty'; reminding her of the scenarios she was put through, but she shrugged it off.

"One moment, if you please guards." Celestia said, turning to Luna. "What do you wish for his punishment to be?"

"I will say to you, and to him at a later time. The guards need not know." Luna leant in and whispered into Celestia's ear.

A wide grin spread across Celestia's face, and she began chuckling non-audibly. "Take him away." She said between giggles. "Now what? She asked Luna.

"Dinner first, then I will deal to him."

Luna prompty made her way to the kitchens and placed an order which she had the servants bring to her private dining area, where she ate with Celestia. Getting up after finishing eating, she left for the dungeons to deal with her rapist.

Luna stood before the cell of Crimson Skies, whom is laying on a bed of straw with a tray containing a half eaten bowl of rice, some bread,and a small assortment of fruit.

"What do you want with me now?" Crimson spat. "You've already got me locked up, is that not enough?" Luna curtly shook her head. "Well, what is then!?"

"Tomorrow you shall be trialed for your crimes. We have spells that can track down the mares you had your way with. As for your punishment..." Luna got closer to the cage. "For this, I grant thee immortality, life eternal and without end." Luna adopted a more authoritative, archaic tone and manner of speaking while she delivered her sentence.

"WHAT!?" Gasped a shocked Crimson. "Why would you gift me immortality!?"

" I grant this, that thou might suffer every night the torments thou hast inflicted 'pon me and doubtless others, that they torment thy dreams 'til thou hast made amends and repaid thy debts! Only then, when all thou hast harmed sing thy praises, shalt thou knowest the peace of death, rapist of mine. And I shall personally see to it that thou DOTH suffer as I demand!"

Crimson only stared, dumbfounded. "Clear to clarify? I didn't quite catch that."

Luna's voice returned to normal. "You will simply exist for four hundred years on the moon, conscious the whole time."

"Something like that will make a guy go insane." He replied.

"This much is true, but you won't be alone. You will have company. There are some twenty odd other mares—whom also have sentences to carry out—that will be accompanying you. I will be casting a spell to make them perpetually aroused as penance for their crimes too."

"Four hundred years on the moon with twenty horny and immortal mares as company, as punishment? I can live with that."

Luna just smirked, a sly grin crossing her face. "Are you sure? I never said the mares would be immortal, that much was assumed by yourself. Guess what happens in one hundred years?"

Pure panic filled Crimson's eyes as he looked back at Luna, knowing all too well what that meant.

"One more thing." Luna turned her back towards Crimson, giving him a nice view of her plot, lifting her tail out of the way for him to view her delicious flower."Ask yourself this. What's better: Having sex with me and living to talk about it, or performing a despicable act and being punished for it? I would have removed my disguise for our little encounter, letting you do as you please to a royal princess. Now you've gone and soured the experience." He only stared in utter disbelief. Luna lowered her tail and walked off. "Goodbye, Crimson Skies. You only needed to ask."

Author's Note

Keeping the poll in mind, it wasn't totally wasted. I did get some good ideas from it, but I completely forgot to get the names of the people whom ideas I used before deleting the post, so please forgive me for that.

The conclusion was largely decided upon between me and another friend of mine after we kept tossing ideas back and forward, but there are still some of the ideas in there what were suggested. So yeah, I hope you enjoy and understand the punishment!

Yes, this chapter was rather rushed. I had a constant headache for three days and nothing I did could alleviate it. I will go back and rewrite this chapter when I can be arsed.