Murdering a Caterpillar

by GN-icorn

Rating: teen
Tags: Discord, Pinkie Pie, Slice of Life, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Rainbow Dash, Sad, Fluttershy
Length: 1621

On a visit to Fluttery, Pinkie Pie learns of a dark secret of her.

All seems like a bright sunny day for Pinkie Pie. It was a free day for Pinkie, so she decided to go see Fluttershy. But what awaits her is a dark secret.

Published 2014-07-20 07:50:02 UTC
Last updated 2014-07-31 19:27:16 UTC

Chapter 1

Author's Note

This takes place before "Flight to the Finish".

Chapter 1

Pinkie Pie dashed throughout Ponyville and rushed to the bridge to the Everfree Forest. Pinkie Pie hoped for Fluttershy to be able to bake with her.
Right when Pinkie Pie arrived, she knocked on Fluttershy's door. But there was no repsonse. Pinkie Pie tried again, but still no response. Pinkie Pie continuously knocked on Fluttershy's door. But she still received no response.
Pinkie Pie entered Fluttershy's cottage and saw Fluttershy in plain sight. But only Fluttershy didn't look like herself. Fluttershy, looked rather somber. She was sitting down on the floor staring down at Angel Bunny.

"Fluttershy?" Pinkie Pie asked, "Are you feeling alright? What's the matter?"

"Nothing," Fluttershy said, "It's noth...ing."

"Aw, but can't you trust your Aunt Pinkie Pie?"

"Uh, I-I don't know."

"Come on, couldn't you?"

"Maybe."

"Well, remember when I told you and Rarity that nopony cares about your lives?"

"Yes?"

"Ah-hah-hah-ahahahaha!" cried out Score and Dumbbell.

"Hey Cluttershy! Your life is worthless!" cried out Score, "You want to know why? Because you can't fly!"

Almost all the other foals replied with snickering.

But Fluttershy replied, "Say all you want, but I don't care anymore. I know I can just take care of animals!"

She lightly trotted away from the crowd until suddenly, yelled out,

"But what's the point in that! There are already Earth Ponies to do that!" cried out Dumbell.
Everypony else, including Fluttershy, became shocked at what had just been said. Even Hoops was shocked. Flutteshy stopped and turned around.

"EA-Earth PONies!" she cried out.

"Yeah! They've done it longer than you have! And I haven't see any pest problems lately! So why should you, a pegasus, have to leave the clouds to take care of animals!" Dumbbell said.

" I bet anything that there's an Earth Pony that could do your job better than you!" Score cried out.
Both Score and Dumbbell burst out laughing. Fluttershy whimpered and cried as she heard their mocking.

"But you might as well make the best of your talent," Score suggested, "by feeding yourself to an Ursa Major!"

"Wait, I got a better idea," Dumbbell replied, "Let's turn you into a Earth Pony...BY TEARING YOUR WINGS OFF!"

"Wait, what!" Fluttershy cried out.
Fluttershy backed away from the two bullies as they slowly hovered towards her. She tried to run away only for Score and Dumbell to crash into her.
Score sat on Fluttershy's back and tugged on her wings very hard. She cringed heavily as her wings were going through the stress of getting torn off. Everypony watched in horror as the two bullies were humiliating and physically abusing the poor filly. Now Score was on one side of Fluttershy holding her wing and Dumbbell was on the other, holding her other wing. The two tugged even harder then before. Fluttershy was on the verge of breaking into tears. All seemed lost. Fluttershy would give anything for this intense humiliation and abuse to be over.
Just then, Rainbow Dash flew out and darted to Score and Dumbbell. Upon this surprise, they let go of Fluttershy. Fluttershy ran off in tears to the edge of the clouds. Life for her was over. She leaped off, hoping to plummet to her death.
But Fluttershy felt something odd. She felt as if she were going up instead of down. Fluttershy looked up and saw Rainbow Dash carrying her. They landed back on the cloud.

"Fluttershy!" yelled out Rainbow Dash, "What were you thinking! You have a whole life ahead of you!"

"But what they said was true!" Fluttershy replied, "I am worthless! Look at me! I can't fly and my only talent is something that I don't need to do!"

"Well get over it!"

"But-"

"GET OVER IT! I told you to just forget about stuff like that!"

"Yeah, if it makes you feel any better, move to Ponyville," replied a young Thunderlane, "which is something you should've done a long time ago!"
And everypony snickered once again.

Fluttershy concluded, "And I did. After what happened, my parents moved me to Ponyville. But everyday of my life, I thought to myself, why me? Why couldn't it have been an Earth Pony, like Applebloom, taking care of these animals? Why me, a pegasus, who should be up in the Clouds, doing things pegasi should do? Even after I made that tornado for Cloudsdale, even after I became the Element of Kindness, I still feel worthless. And I even began to question other ponies's lives too. That's why I told you no pony gives a "flying feather" about your lives"

"Those-those meanies!" Pinkie cried, "They shouldn't have-"
But just then, a familiar figure popped into the room. He was 3 times the height of Princess Celestia, had a slim body, a deer antler, a fang, a lion paw, a eagle leg, a dragon tail, a bat wing, a bird wing, and a lizard leg.

Chapter 2

Something has gone wrong. We don't seem to have an archived copy of that chapter.

Chapter 3

Pinkie Pie, Fluttershy, and Discord were in the kitchen of SugarCube Corner.

"Let's get to baking some cupcakes!" exclaimed Pinkie Pie.
While Pinkie Pie and Fluttershy got out some ingredients, Discord teleported to Sweet Apple Acres.

"Let's see," he said, "which one of you has milk?"
He lifted up a cow and shook it, but heard nothing but its bell and a moo. He put the cow back and lifted up and shook another cow, but got nothing again aside from its bell and moo. Again, he put it back and lifted a third cow up and shook it. This time, he heard something. Discord shook the cow and heard a liquid splashing around. Satisfied, he teleported back.

"Where could he be?" asked Fluttershy.

Pinkie Pie replied "I hope that Discord's at least not going around making trou-"
But Discord popped up right in front of them with a cow. He milked out some milk into the bowl as Fluttershy and Pinkie Pie stared at him oddly. He teleported out again, but Pinkie Pie and Fluttershy decided take turns mixing the batter anyway.
Even if the experience starting to get unusual for her, Fluttershy felt far better baking with Pinkie Pie than she did somberly thinking at her house.

"Even if this isn't the funnest thing I've done," Fluttershy said, "At least it's far better than getting your wings torn off and told your life's worthless. In fact, I think that almost anything has to be better than that."

"See," Pinkie Pie replied, "It's pretty fun. And at least you have your Auntie Pinkie Pie.
Discord popped right back into the kitchen.

"And your dear friend, Discord," he said.
Pinkie Pie took out a pan and Fluttershy poured the batter in. Fluttershy popped it into the oven and set the timer for fifteen minutes.
After sometime, Pinkie Pie and Fluttershy got to making the frosting.

"Powdered sugar, check! Cream cheese, check! Butter, check!" Pinkie Pie said.
Pinkie Pie took out a bowl, and mixed in the cream cheese and butter. Fluttershy poured in the powdered sugar and mixed the ingredients together. But Discord had something up his sleeve.
Discord got out a plate and levitated the frosting. He stretched out his arm to the oven, took out the finished cupcakes and threw them at the floating blob of frosting. The cupcakes landed onto the plate, topped with frosting. The plate was put down one to the table.

"Thank you?" Pinkie Pie said.
Mr. Cake went in, only to be surprised by Discord's prescience.

"Gah!" Mr. Cake cried.

"Don't worry," Fluttershy replied, "I reformed him."

"And he even helped us make cupcakes," said Pinkie Pie, "even in his own weird way."

"Alright, then," Mr. Cake chuckled sheepishly, "Pinkie Pie, Rainbow Dash wants to see you."

"Oh boy!"
She ran off with the plate of cupcakes to Rainbow Dash at the counter.

"Hi Pinkie," she greeted, "I finished with the clearing the skies of those stray clouds. Didn't expect them."

"You want a cupcake?"

"Sure."

"Guess who helped me bake these cupcakes!"

"Who?"

"Fluttershy and Discord!"
Rainbow Dash spat out her cupcake.

"WHAT?!" she cried out, "What's he even doing here anyway?"

"Calm down," Pinkie Pie said, "I went to Fluttershy's house and asked for her to bake with me. But she was sad about getting told her life was worthless-"
Pinkie Pie put her hooves over her mouth. Rainbow Dash hoof palmed.

"Oh come on! Fluttershy should'v been over that a long time ago. Let me go in to the kitchen."

"But-"

"JUST LET ME IN!"

"Let me in!"

"But Discord helped Fluttershy get better!"
Suddenly, Rainbow Dash thought to herself, "Did I fail to help Fluttershy, the pony who's been my friend since my foal hood?"

"Can you go get out Discord?" she asked.
But the draconequess popped out right in front of her.

"Did somepony call for me?" he said.

"Yeah, I want to ask you, just how right was I when I tried to help Fluttershy with her, you know what?"

"What are you ta-oh that! That! You where well-intended but it seems you haven't been of much help."
Rainbow Dash bowed her head in shame.

"On the other hand, you're still just a young pony who has a lot to learn. Don't feel bad about yourself."

"Can I see Fluttershy as well?"

Discord teleported and came back holding Fluttershy.

Rainbow Dash sighed.

"I'm sorry if I fail to help you get over what Score and Dumbell said to you," Rainbow Dash said.

"That's alright!" Fluttershy replied, "I feel all better now. So are we going to finish these cupcakes?"
Everypony laughed together and proceeded to finished their cupcakes. But Rainbow Dash gave Discord a stare of distrust.