NightMare Night

by MissMarvelousMare

Rating: mature
Tags: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Angel, Nightmare Moon, Fluttershy
Length: 1220

Nightmare Moon has been on the moon for 1,000 years. Every year on Nightmare night, a victim gets chosen to be killed by Nightmare Night. The victim this year: Fluttershy.

Fluttershy rarely does anything every Nightmare Night. So Nightmare Moon decides to pay Fluttershy a visit.

Published 2014-08-04 19:30:02 UTC
Last updated 2014-08-04 19:30:02 UTC

Nightmare Night

Author's Note

WARNING: This FanFic should stay away from Fluttershy, to prevent nightmares.

Nightmare Night

Fluttershy yawned. The morning was bright and sunny, the way Fluttershy hoped it would be. Fluttershy took a view of the clock, it read 2:37. She gasped.

"Oh! It's Nightmare Night tonight! I have to get the food to the chickens, feed Bob, Tim, Tina, and Harry! Oh gosh!"

Fluttershy muttered to herself. She flew out of bed, and started combing her mane. She brushed her teeth, and rushed outside with the chicken food. "Come little ones!" She called out to the chickens. She sprinkled the food and watched them eat. She smiled, knowing everything would be under control as long as she was here. She looked to her right to see busy ponies getting food and buying costumes for tonight. Fluttershy rushed to give honey to Harry. She patted is head, to calm him as he roared. She continued with her daily routines.

"Whew! That was exhausting!"

Fluttershy sighed. She took a glance at the clock and froze. It was 6:00. She looked out the window and saw the sky growing dark. She yelped, and quickly took a shower, going as fast as Rainbow Dash herself! She just wanted to sleep through this. She fell on her bed of exhaustion. She smiled as she closed her eyes. After 3 minutes, she was asleep.

Fluttershy awoke with a loud bang at her front door. She sighed. She looked at the clock. It was only 9:15. She rubbed her eyelids with her hooves. She flew downstairs and looked out the window. There was nopony there.

"That's strange."

she muttered. She unlocked the door, opened, and scanned the outside. No Scare-or-treaters. Strange. She yawned and closed the door, once again locking it. She was too tired to use her wings, so she just climbed the stairs. She fell in her bed in defeat, again. She tried to drift asleep, but kept hearing hoofsteps down below. She groaned.

"Angel Bunny! If that's you, you're in trouble!"

Fluttershy yelled. Agitated, she stomped downstairs. She looked around. There was nothing! "Angel, stop messing with me!" She went to the kitchen and searched for Angel, so she could lecture him.

"Angel?"

she sounded worried now. She heard Angel screech right then. Her eyes widened. As she stepped into the living room, she finally noticed something she forgot to check. The door was wide open, the lock unturned!

"B-But.. how?"

Fluttershy whispered in fear. She was bloody prints of Angel. She gasped in horror.

"Angel! Did you hurt yourself?!"

she asked, deperate to reunite with her best friend. She noticed the screeches coming from the bathroom upstairs. She flew upstairs and kicked down the door. She gasped in horror, tears filling her eyes.

"ANGEL!"

she yelled, on the verge of tears. There was Angel's skin, blood dripping. His skin hung from a rope. It was clear somepony had come in, and murdered Angel. Fluttershy took a moment to sob her eyes out.

"Don't...be...afraid,"

She heard a voice behind her. She trembled.

"W-Who.. are-"

Before she could finish the voice added,

"Fluttershy."

with a sudden pain in her back, Fluttershy fell back, passing out.

"AH!"

Fluttershy awoke, screaming. She looked around at her surroundings. She snickered. She had been dreaming! She was in her room! She felt a pain in her back again. She groaned of the pain, and went to look in the mirror. She gasped. There was a hole in her back! One connecting to her spine, and organs! She gasped in horror, the pain bringing her to tears. The loud hoofsteps banged downstairs, and the TV turned on. Fluttershy realized she hadn't been sleeping. She had been laid back in her bed. She ran to the bathroom again. Angel was still there. One of his eyes had fallen on the ground. She began to cry. She went downstairs to go through the door, to leave. She saw the door, in it's place. She began to hit the door with all her might.

"I want to go! I want to go! I want to go!"

She repeated with every new hit. Every hit brought the pain down her spine, along with a chill that somepony else was there with her. She heard laughter echo through the cottage. The door didn't budge. Her only option was the windows. She tried to open them, but realized they had been boarded from the outside, along with something heavier holding the boards in place. She tried every window, each one the same. It was like it was a unicorn sealing a spell... she froze at her though and gasped. She ran to the kitchen, to retrieve the knife she had used today. She searched the cupboards, the fridge, and the sink. The knives were no where. No silverware was found that would affect the pony who had broke in. She went to call the emergency services. She lit a candle, so that she could see something.

"Hello?" "There's a burglar-"

all of a sudden, the lights around the whole cottage shut off. Fluttershy yelled. She quickly grabbed the candle, trying to escape, but was kicked in the back. She fell frontwards. She felt somepony eating her. Her hind hoof was bitten off, and Fluttershy yelled, crying.

"Please stop, please!"

she pleaded. The pony didn't stop. She turned and gasped at the sight. The mare standing there, had then ripped out her eyes. Fluttershy cried out in pain. She then, rested her head on the floor, bleeding to her death. As the mare finished up pieces of Fluttershy's hooves and her kidney, she smiled. The last noise heard on that night was the menacing laugh of Nightmare Moon, finishing her victim for that year.

(EXTRA: READ AT YOUR OWN RISK HERE)

I know now what you're thinking.

"Why Fluttershy?! THE SWEET KIND FLUTTERSHY BITC-"

Let me stop you. It was Fluttershy because there was hardly any horror stories about Fluttershy in the FanFic community. I thought it would be good to show a pony that was defenseless. So it could be interesting. Sorry if that's not what you wanted... Comment below the next kind of story you want.

(EXTRA 2: ABOUT THE STORY)

So in the story, every year on Nightmare Night, Nightmare Moon decides on a victim to kill. This year, instead of her normal filly picks, she chose Fluttershy. About 7 minutes later, the po-po ponies found Fluttershy's dead body, unable to identify the hoofprints. They knew it was Nightmare Moon's, but they couldn't say that to the Princess. Basically because every time they mentioned that it was her sister, she got teary and remembered the night she was banished and just emotionally broke down. That really wasn't their fault that that b*tch was unstable but whatever. Until the next Nightmare Night, Nightmare Moon chooses a victim and confirms. She then practices how she'll kill the filly (Well, if it is a filly next year.) Twilight and friends also went to visit Flutetrshy's house, but the po-po ponies forbid them to come on the crime scene. After all her friends heard the news, they celebrated. The end.

JUST KIDDING.

Now you might be wondering why I'm still typing. Well.. I need 1,000 words. I don't want to be a criminal scum..