The Brohoof Bash

by Shakespearicles

Rating: mature
Tags: Romance, Comedy, Big Macintosh, Shining Armor, Sex, Twilight Sparkle, Applejack, Slice of Life, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic
Length: 9620

Though the law forbids it, this is kismet.

Twilight and Shining have always been aware of their romantic feelings for one another, but they've vowed to never physically act on them. But after a night of heavy cider drinking with her friend, she thinks that this Brother's Day, there might just be a way for them to experience their desire...

...Sort of.

AUDIO BOOK by LimeyPony

BONUS SONG

2068839

Published 2014-08-10 00:10:03 UTC
Last updated 2015-12-19 19:33:31 UTC

Though The Law Forbids It

"So what about you Twilight?" Applejack asked, sitting on the dirt floor of the barn. "Why haven't you found your very special somepony?" She poured another mug full of cider from the barrel beside her. Twilight finished off her own mug as she laid her head in her orange friend's lap.

"I dunno." Twilight started. "I guess I just never took a -hic- interest in other stallions."

"Other?"

"What?" Twilight asked back with half-lidded eyes.

"What do you mean other?" Applejack asked, taking another swig of her drink.

"Other what?"

"Stallions."

"Yeah. That's what I said." Twilight said. "I've never really taken an interest in them."

"Yeah but- but you said other stallions. Which means there is one that you do- uh, take an interest in." Applejack tried to reason through her inebriation.

"Nuh uh!" Twilight retorted wittily.

"Yeah huh!" Applejack countered. "I know it's true 'cuz yer blushing and it ain't just 'cuz yer hammered."

"I am not!" Twilight denied, turning a darker shade of red.

"Come on! You can't be dishonest with the element of honesty. That's like, a rule."

"No it's not!"

"Come on, tell me. Is it somepony I know?" AJ pressed.

"NooOOOooo" Twilight denied as her voice wavered in a sing-song tone.

"See! I can always tell when you're lying because you do that!"

"Do what?"

"Say 'no' like that."

"That's crazy!" Twilight said.

"Fine I'll prove it." AJ said confidently. "Did you build Canterlot Castle?"

"No."

"Are you the spirit of chaos?"

"No."

"Is there some stallion you have the hots for?"

"NooOOOooo!" Twilight denied. Applejack just stared at her. "Okay fine. There is!"

"Alright, now quit lying to me. Is it somepony I know?"

"Yeah." Twilight grumbled begrudgingly.

"Ooh." Applejack tapped her hoof to her chin. There weren't that many stallions in Ponyville that they both knew. She ran down the mental list. "Hmmm. Is it Braeburn?"

"No."

"Is it Caramel?"

"No."

"Is it Golden Delicious?"

"No! And stop trying to hook me up with your cousins!" She yelled, flailing her hooves. "-Nd gimmie a refill!" She levitated her mug to Applejack. AJ took the mug in her hoof and set it under the tap.

"Well I don't know now Miss Demandy-pants." AJ scoffed, "Maybe I won't until you tell me who he is."

"No- I just- I can't." Twilight gave up. "AJ, have you ever... felt something for somepony that you knew you shouldn't?"

"Oh no, it's me isn't it?" AJ asked.

"What? No. No!" Twilight scoffed.

"Oh well thanks!" Applejack huffed denying Twilight her now-full mug.

"No, AJ, it's not like that." Twilight pleaded, reaching out, upside-down with her hooves. "I do like you. I just never really thought of you like that." She said, trying to gloss over her crass remark.

"Well now you got me all excited." AJ said. "So you have to tell me or else no more cider."

"Really?"

"Really."

"Okay, but you have to Pinkie Promise that this just stays between you and me." Twilight said.

"I do."

"Say the words!"

Applejack sighed. "Cross my heart and hope to fly, stick a cupcake in my eye."

"Okay." Twilight took a deep breath "It's... it's Shining."

"Your brother?" Applejack asked, giving the purple pony her drink.

"Oh no. You think I'm weird, don't you? You think I'm weird. Promise you won't tell anypony!"

"I already promised I wouldn't. And no, I don't think you're weird." AJ assured her. "You know I'm the last one to pass any kind of judgement on somepony. I'm just surprised is all."

"Because it's weird."

"Would you stop it with that?!" AJ snapped. "I was just surprised because he's married. Isn't that cheating?"

"Wait, what? Oh, nono no, we haven't actually done anything." Twilight defended.

"Oh, sorry. I didn't mean to assume..."

"Well, to be honest, it's not like we haven't thought about it. We want to, but we promised that we'd never act on our feelings. And now he's married." Twilight said with a frown. "And even though he and Cadance do have an open marriage..."

"Wait, really?"

"Well sure. She is the Princess of Love. She's very open-minded about love in all of its forms."

"So they've... you know- with other ponies?"

"So he's told me." Twilight shrugged.

"But never..." Applejack motioned to Twilight with her hoof.

"No. And besides, there are laws about that sort of stuff too."

"Yeah. I know." AJ lamented as she finished her drink.

"Hmm?"

"Well, Twi, to be honest-"

"Duh." Twilight giggled.

"Shut up." She continued. "To be honest, I'm kinda in the same boat as you."

"Wait, your brother is married?" She asked. Applejack cocked her eyebrow at her.

"Okay, you know what? That's your last cider. I'm cutting you off."

"Aww!"

"No, I meant about being in the same boat about... the other thing." She said. Twilight's mind whirred for a moment.

"Oh. Oh? Oh!" She said. Applejack rolled her eyes as the last horse finally crossed the finish line in Twilight's mind. "Wait you- you and Big Mac? Have you two... you know?"

"No. We made the same decision not to." AJ said. " 'Sides, we didn't want to be contributin' to a country stereotype."

"Well I wasn't going to say anything but-" Twi smirked.

"You're one to talk." AJ snickered. But her levity faded quickly. "Look Twi, there's something I gotta ask ya." Twilight looked up at the orange pony. "How do y'all do it? Fight'n the urge I mean." Twilight frowned a bit. She understood immediately what AJ meant.

"I really don't know. It wasn't as bad when we were younger. By the time it started to get difficult, I was already in magic school, and then he went off to the academy. So the time apart helped. But it didn't make it any easier when I found out he was getting married."

"Yeah, I could tell."

"Was it that obvious?" She asked. AJ nodded. "Well, forget about me. What about you!? I mean, you see him all day, everyday! How do you do it?"

"Truthfully, I have no idea sometimes. Believe me, there have been days when I've wanted to so badly. Especially during the spring Heat." A single tear rolled down her cheek. "He's a lot stronger than me. His willpower, I mean. He has to be! Especially after things didn't work out with Miss Cheerilee. I guess she could tell he didn't feel the same way about her as he did about... somepony else." She sighed. "And I know he wants it just as bad. I could see it in his eyes last year. I could see how much it pained him when he had to tie me up in the apple cellar last spring. He knew I wouldn't be able to control myself when I was in season. He could have let me, you know? I knew he wanted to let me. But he was stronger than that."

Twilight sighed, feeling the drowsy effects of the alcohol. The clock on the wall chimed midnight.

"Oh dang!" Applejack sat up, looking at the calendar with a sudden realization.

"What is it?" Twilight asked.

"I forgot it's Brother's Day."

"Didn't get a gift for him?"

Applejack held up her cider mug. "Other plans got in the way. He'll be so disappointed."

"Damn I forgot it too. This could have been avoided. What the hell are we gonna do?"

"Hold up." Applejack said. "You thinking what I'm thinking?"

"I'm thinking I'm thinking it too." Twilight nodded as her smile grew.

"What time is it Twi?"

"It's time for a switcharoo! We both love our bros, stallions with grown stallion needs. I say we break em off. Show em how much they really mean. Because I'm a brother lover, you're a brother lover. We should fuck each others' brothers."

"Fuck each others bros!"

"Cause every Brothers Day needs a brothers night. If doing it is wrong, I don't wanna be right. I'm calling on you cause I can't do it myself. Because to me you're like no other, so be my brother lover."

I'm so sorry. I just couldn't resist.

"So what's this big surprise you have for me?" Shining Armor asked his sister as they walked along the dirt road. Whatever the surprise was, she seemed even more excited about it than he was. Even though Twilight didn't get to sleep until late after midnight, her excitement that morning still had her out of bed early, and at the Ponyville train station awaiting his arrival.

"Oh, you'll see." She said with a sly grin. She led him through the front gate of Sweet Apple Acres and across the field to the West Orchard, where she'd agreed to meet Applejack.

"Wait, this is AJ's place." He said.

"Yup!" She whinnied in excitement.

"Why are we here?"

"It's Brothers Day for Big Macintosh too silly. So I thought that we would join their picnic."

"Oh." Shining frowned. He was looking forward to spending some time with Twilight that day. And Just Twilight. Even if it was just holding hooves or sitting together on the sofa and watching a movie. He enjoyed the intimacy of their little dates, even without any sexual connotation. A group outing was not what he was hoping for. Twilight noticed the look of disappointment on his face. She turned back toward him, putting a hoof on his shoulder.

"Hey, It'll be fun. You'll enjoy it." She leaned in and nuzzled his cheek. "I promise." She held on to the last S, hissing a breath into his ear filled with hot desire. Pulling away, her sly wink sealed the promise of future delights. She continued forward, further from the farm house until it was out of their view. He followed obediently. Or rather, Little Shiny followed. The rest of him just happened to be attached to it, following it like a divining rod.

He watched her hips sway back and forth. Her tail swung from side to side in time with her steps, each time affording him the briefest of glances. No touching. Just looking. But then there was nothing wrong with looking. After all, it was Brothers Day. Twilight could feel his eyes on her flank. She exaggerated her tail's swing, feeding his hungry eyes. After a couple of agonizing minutes, they'd found the picnic site.

"There y'all are!" Applejack greeted them. "You're right on time. We just finished getting set up." The Sparkle siblings settled onto the red and white checkered blanket opposite the Apples. Twilight had barely sat down, already fidgeting with excitement.

"Applejack, can we just skip brunch? I'm too excited to wait." She said. She wasn't lying. The blanket under her was already moist.

"I know what you mean." AJ said, shuffling her hooves nervously. "Alright, let's tell 'em."

"Tell us what? What's going on? Do you know?" Shining asked Big Macintosh.

"Ennope."

"Shining," Twilight put her hoof on his. "I know we always said we would never act on our feelings. But I want today to be special."

Shining pulled his hoof away quickly. "Twi? What are you talking about. I have no idea what you're talking about." He emphasized.

"Shining. It's alright." Applejack said. "We ain't here t' judge. Mac and I feel the same way about eachother."

"AayJay!" Macintosh snapped.

"What? It's true!" Applejack said. "An' I'm tired of having to hide it an' bein' ashamed about it." She stamped her hoof.

"I'm sorry about breaking my promise to keep it a secret, Shiny." Twilight said, taking his hoof again. "But I didn't do it without a good reason."

"Me n' Twi came up with an idea last night for your Brothers Day presents." AJ said, nodding to Twi. On her signal, they each stood up and walked to the opposite sides of the blanket and sat down next to their friends' brothers.

"This way, we can satisfy our needs and-" She saw the hesitance in her brother's eyes across from her. "Shining, I really want it. I need it. But I want it to be with you. And this way... it sort of would be." She explained. Shining looked back and forth between the two scheming mares.

"So I would... with you?" He asked slowly, pointing at the orange mare. Applejack nodded. "And he would... with you." Twilight nodded in turn. "And we would, what? Watch eachother?"

"Precisely! We would be right here, experiencing it all together. You and I could watch eachother while they watch eachother." Twilight said matter-of-factly.

"You wouldn't get jealous?" He asked.

"I had thought about that, to be honest." Twilight said. "But after all, you're married. And I think I got all of that out of my system the day before your wedding."

"Same here when you were datin' Miss Cheerilee." Applejack said to Mac. "What about you fellas?"

"Uh, I dunno." Shining said. His mind was trying to scale several mental hurdles. Firstly, having sex with a mare he'd never even got on a date with. That was the easiest one. Next was doing so in such close proximity to another stallion. And lastly, the fact that he was married. Albeit an open marriage.

"Oh really? How about this? All stallions in favor of this idea, raise your dicks." Twilight said. It was then that each of the guys realized they were sporting a big 'yes' vote, and tried to cover themselves. Shining blushed. Mac somehow managed to turn an even darker shade of red himself. The girls each smirked, eyeing their brothers' erections.

"Okay okay!" Shining said as he and Mac avoided looking at eachother. "But just so you know, I am going to have to tell Cadance about this. Open marriage or not, we don't keep secrets from eachother." The others nodded in understanding.

"Wait, even about me being here? And why?" Twilight asked.

"Twi, she knows how we feel about eachother."

"But how? Did you-"

"I never told her. She figured it out on her own." He said. She still looked surprised. "She's the Princess of Love. Hello!" Twilight shrugged. That did make sense. It was Candace's special talent after all. "Although that time I asked her to dye her fur lavender may have tipped her off." He smirked. "So uh, how are we doing this?" He asked. Applejack moved his hoof aside, taking his shaft in her hoof.

"Ah was think'n somethin' like this." She said, slowly stroking it. Before he had a chance to react, she leaned in and started licking and sucking on his tip as her hoof ran up and down the white length, mottled with blue blotches.

"Oh-AH ohokay!" Shining's voice shuddered at the sudden contact. Twilight watched in awe as the farmpony stoked the familiar phallus she'd seen so many times with stolen glances in her youth. Big Mac was likewise mesmerized as he witnessed his sister taking the head of the stallionhood deeper into her warm, wet mouth.

Twilight took advantage of his distraction, running her hoof up and down his Little Mac. Though 'Little' was a bit of a misnomer. She could see why his name was Big Macintosh. The red stallion shuddered as she began sucking his dick as well, but he didn't pull away. He didn't even look down at her. He was still fixated on watching his sister. Twilight followed his gaze over toward Shining.

As big as Mac was, she realized that Shining's wasn't any smaller. She watched as Applejack took more of him, precum dripping from the corners of her lips. Her eyes wandered further up, catching her brother's gaze. He looked into her eyes as her head bobbed on the red shaft in her mouth. Shining realized that he and Mac were staring intently at each others dongs. He wanted to make sure he was clear about one last thing.

"Uh, Mac?" He asked as Applejack began to massage his balls in her hoof. "No homo right?" Big Mac could barely speak as Twilight started to take his shaft down her throat.

"E-E-Eeyup!"

"Here ya go." Applejack said, re-positioning herself. She shifted around pointing her rump in Mac's direction, pulling her tail aside. "This'll give ya something to feast yer eyes on." She moved her spare hoof between her legs and began rubbing herself. Twilight could feel Mac's cock twitching with excitement as Applejack spread her folds for his greedy stare.

Twilight, not to be outdone, took a mirrored stance, flagging her tail up. She watched as Shining's gaze shift from the sight of Twilight felating the other stallion, and back to her wet marehood as she played with herself for his viewing pleasure. She stopped for a moment, pulling Mac's dick from her mouth to speak.

"You like watching me suck this dick Shiny?" She asked, slowly stroking the red pony's pole. "You want me to keep going?" She asked, unsure of where this sultry side of her had been hiding all this time.

"Ah- uh huh!" He nodded, desperately wanting to watch her continue.

"You want me to keep sucking it? Say the words!" She commanded.

"S-s-SUCK THAT DICK!" He blurted out, blushing immediately.

"Well since you asked so nicely..." Twilight resumed taking Big Mac into her throat.

"Nngh!" Mac groaned. Now it was AJ's turn to tease.

"Whoa boy, looks like yer enjoy'n yourself there." She said in a sultry tone of her own. "That feel good?" Mac struggled to get out a response.

"Eh- uh- eeyup!" His leg started to twitch. Applejack could tell he was getting close.

"Um, ahem?" Shining asked impatiently of Applejack who was ignoring him at the moment.

"Don't you worry none, sugar cube. You'll get yer chance in just a sec. In the meantime..." She turned and pulled on his mane, pulling his snout to her hot marehood. "Why don't ya make yourself useful?" She said with a coy smile before leaning closer to where Twilight was working. He needed no further instruction as he set to work eating out the sweet apple juice of the farm pony, watching as Twilight continued to soak her hoof with her own juices mere feet away. Applejack looked up at Big Mac as he tried, and failed, to keep his stoic composure.

"Yer getting close aren't ya?" Applejack purred. "Are you gonna cum? Are you gonna cum with your sister Applejack right here?" His eyes shut as he felt his balls tighten. "Oh no you don't!" She barked. "I want you to look me in the eyes!" She ordered. "I want you to tell me when you're gonna cum!" He looked back at her.

"AhhaaY Jaay!" He moaned. Twilight felt him swell in her mouth and took a deep breath through her nose.

"Yeah? You gonna cum for me!?" She asked again. Twilight felt the first pulse shooting up his powerful shaft.

"EEEEEEEEYUUUUUUP!!!" He cried out as he let loose rope after rope of hot semen into Twilight's mouth. Mac's body spasmed and jerked, humping in tiny thrusts. Her mouth, already mostly occupied by his flesh, filled quickly. She swallowed what she could, but he was just producing it too fast. She pulled her mouth off him, and swallowed what she had. She kept her lips over his tip, letting her mouth refill halfway again before he finally finished. Applejack only pulled her gaze from his eyes when he collapsed backwards onto the blanket.

"Ah wish I could'a tasted tha-mmff" Before Applejack could finish, Twilight put her lips to hers, kissing her. Applejack tasted her brother's cum as Twilight opened her mouth gave her the rest of the load she'd saved. Applejack savored every bit of it. The taste, the texture, it was even better than she'd dreamed. Twilight pulled away from the kiss after the delivery.

"No homo?" She asked.

"Buck that! ALL of the homo!" Applejack said, pulling Twilight back in for another. At the other end, Shining was busy licking deep into the mare's honey hole. Tasting her brother's cum gave Applejack a sudden rush, coupled with Shining's assault on her love nub from her winking marehood. "NNNMMMMFFFF." Applejack moaned her orgasm into Twilight's mouth as their tongues danced with one another. Shining was treated to a fresh gush of her marecum as her legs trembled. "OOOOHH!" She continued to moan, stumbling to the ground after Twilight stopped kissing her.

Twilight prodded Applejack as she recovered on the blanket. "Hey AJ? Don't leave my poor brother hanging." She said pointing to Shining's still-rigid cock.

"Oh, believe me I won't!" She said, turning back around to Shining. He moaned softly as she resumed her work on him.

"Hey Applejack, do you have anything to drink?" Twilight asked.

"Mmfff." Applejack pulled Shining's cock from her mouth. "Yeah in the basket there." She said, before she got back to bobbing her head on his knob. Twilight dug through the basket.

"What the buck is this?" Twilight said in surprise. Applejack and the two stallions turned and looked at her. In her hooves was a plastic stallion dildo attached to a strap-on harness.

"Uh, plan B?" Applejack said. Twilight blushed. "What? I wasn't sure if they were going to say yes to all this!" Shining looked down at Applejack.

"Well... I mean, it's not like you can't still use it." He said.

"Eeyup!"

"You boys are something else I tell ya!" Applejack muttered before she got back to sucking. Beside Big Mac, Twilight opened a bottle of cider and took a small mouthful, swishing it around and spitting it onto the grass. She saw the hurt look on the red stallion's face.

"Oh, no, it's not like that Mac! It tasted really good!" She said taking another sip. "I just want a clean pallet for when Applejack finishes." He nodded in understanding.

"NNgghh!" Shining grunted.

"Ooh, speaking of which!" Twilight scurried over to Applejack's side. "Ooh Shining, are you getting close?"

"Uh huh!" He moaned.

"Yes! Can you feel the fluid accumulating in your Seminal Vesicle? The Spermatozoa traveling along your Vas Deferens? The building pressure in your Prostate Gland as you near ejaculation?" The other three cringed.

"Twi, shut up." Applejack advised.

"But I'm trying to talk sexy like you did. You know, to help get him turned on?"

"A valiant effort I'm sure." AJ said. "But I think I know something that might work a little bit better..."

"But I categorically covered every part of the male anatOOHH MYYY!" Applejack ceased Twilight's chatter as she mashed her free hoof into the unicorn's sopping wet marehood. That scene alone was enough to turn Shinning's crank. Applejack resumed sucking him off at the same time as she worked Twilight. Big Mac marveled at his sister's ability to multitask so well. "Ah I see, a visual st-t-t-timulation aid!" She stuttered as Applejack rubbed her. Applejack rolled her eyes. She'd something else in mind.

Applejack bobbed her head in a steady rhythm with Twilight watching. Her face no more than a foot away from the action. Once Applejack's hoof was thoroughly soaked, she pulled it away from Twilight's marehood and rubbed it across Shining's snout, soaking his lips with her still-warm juices. Shining's hooves moved on reflex, taking hold of AJ's as he licked his sister's marecum from it and sucked on it to an obscene degree.

"MMmmfff!" He moaned like a starving foal, trying to get every last bit from her hoof. Applejack paused for the briefest moment.

"Hey Twilie, I think he likes it!" AJ said. "Get ready too see your brother cum gallons now!" He shuddered as she kept pumping her head on his shaft. His senses were flooded with Twilight's scent and flavor. He felt his climax coming on like an unstoppable avalanche. Applejack could see Twilight's jaw hanging open in awe as she felt Shining's head flare in her mouth. At the last second she pulled him out of her mouth.

And pointed it at Twilight's face! Before she even knew what was happening, she saw the first glob burst from his swollen tip, rocketing into her gaping mouth. She gasped in surprise, and subsequently gagged for a second. But only for a second. The next spurt landed across her cheek while she recovered. She wouldn't waste another. She extended her tongue, catching the next couple of ropes of her brother's cum.

As she swallowed the first mouthful, his cock jerked free of Applejack's hoof, sending the next volley onto her horn, dripping down her forehead. Twilight craned her neck, careful to catch the rest in her mouth until his bursts slowed to a dribble. As much as she wanted to, she couldn't get any closer. Applejack gave him a final squeeze, licking the last bits off of his shaft.

"Applejack, what about the rule?" Twilight asked.

"I didn't see any touching." She said, licking her lips. "Hmm. They both taste good." AJ said, enjoying the last drop of Shining's cum.

"Yes they do." Twilight agreed, looking at her brother as he sat there panting. "But I suppose I am a little partial."

"I know what you mean." Applejack said, looking back at her brother behind her. Shining and Twilight looked at each others cum-dripping faces as his stallionhood began to retreat. It was a Kodak moment for sure.

"Who's ready for round two?" Applejack said.

This Is Kismet

"Seconds?" Shining asked Applejack. "Sheesh, gimme a second, would ya?" Applejack smirked at his messy face.

"Come on Big Mac," Applejack said, turning her attention to her brother, "you ready for some more action?"

"Eeyup!" he said. He nodded yes but it seemed that ole' Little Mac was still taking a break.

"Well let's see if we can't get you going again," she said, looking at the mess Shining was wearing behind her. "Y'all want some of what he's having?" She asked him. Mac nodded excitedly. "Hey Twi, do ya mind?"

"Oh, right." Twilight walked over and put her hoof into her pussy, getting it good and wet for Big Mac to lick.

"Uh, Twi, I think he'd prefer mine." AJ said.

"Oh, right." Twilight said, blushing. She wiped her hoof off and started over, rubbing Applejack's pussy. AJ noticed some of her juices dripping onto the blanket. It seemed like a darn waste.

"Actually I got an idea." Applejack said. "Mac, come over here and lay down where I'm dripping." She said, stepping aside. Once he was on his back, she stepped over him, straddling his body and facing in the opposite direction. Twilight stood alongside her, facing in the same direction as Mac, with his face between her hind legs. Applejack noticed that she could just as well return the favor for Twilight in this position. "Hey Shiny, why don't you come on over her and get under your sister too!" She said. Twilight moved out of the way as Shining laid beside Big Mac on the ground. Twilight likewise stepped over him, her hind hooves at either side of his head.

"You boys are sure in for a treat!" Applejack said. Twilight began to rub Applejack's pussy again. "But I 'spose we are too!" She said, lifting Twilight's tail. Twilight looked down at Big Mac's grinning face as she started to really get his sister wet. He closed his eyes and just let his mouth hang open. She could only imaging that Shining was making the same face. Applejack started really rubbing her hoof into Twilight's sopping wetness. Droplets of her juice fell with increasing regularity on the snout and tongue of the horny stallion under her.

Twilight looked under her. She could see Shining starting to become aroused again. Little Shiny began to poke out of his sheath. It was mere inches from her. She could just reach out and touch it. Just a quick touch. That'd be okay, she reasoned. She pulled her busy hoof from Applejack's pussy for just a moment. Applejack looked back for why Twilight had stopped. She saw the unicorn reaching out for the white stallion's penis.

"Twi, don't stop now! I'm so close! You don't want to leave me hanging!" Applejack called back. Twilight felt Mac's hoof stopping hers from getting any closer. Big Mac looked up at her.

"Yeah Twi." He said in his calm baritone. "You wouldn't want to do that." He said with a serious look in his eyes, putting a clear emphasis into his words. She realized that both of the stallions had their hooves free to touch at any time but they were abiding by the rule.

"Yeah Twi! Make her cum for her brother and you can do it for me!" Shining said, oblivious to what was happening. She bit her lip in frustration and nodded cooperatively. Mac let go of her hoof and she put it back to work on Applejack. Applejack faced her own throbbing red temptation underneath her. She closed her eyes and focused on Twilight's hoof. She was doing a good job after all. Twilight felt the orange mare winking into her hoof. Each time she gently grazed AJ's clit, it caused her legs to tremble.

"TwiaaahhhLaaaahhhhh!" Applejack cried out, treating Big Mac with a gush of her marecum. AJ's knees buckled, causing her to squat lower. With its next spurt of juice, her quivering pussy stopped perilously close to Mac's face. He needed to but crane his neck and he could lick her. This time Twilight took the initiative, putting her hoof under the earth pony's hips, lifting her back to her hooves.

Applejack recovered quickly, leaning over and licking Twilight's marehood. Twilight got goosebumps from the new sensation running up her spine. As the reaction ran back down her nerves it came to an explosive end. "Shhhhhinny!!!" She called out as her own orgasm rocked her body. Applejack held her steady as Twilight's nectar ran down her orange hoof into Shining's mouth under her.

The mares stumbled away from one another, giving the boys space to sit up. Shining and Mac both rose to their feet at the same time. Unfortunately, as they moved, their swords crossed for just the briefest of seconds. In that instant they both froze and locked eyes, which were the size of dinner plates. Big Mac could see the panic in Shining's eyes, as though he was asking, Did that just happen?

"Eenope!" Mac answered the question unasked.

"Dammit Shining!" Applejack called. "I need that dick of yours in me now! And if you don't get over her and give it to me, I'ma come over there and take it!" Shining broke from his catatonic homophobia and got moving.

Applejack and Twilight stood facing one another. Shining was the first to mount. He used his magic to guide himself into Applejack's waiting marehood. He shifted himself forward, knocking Applejack's hat off of her.

"Oops." He said.

"I'll get it." Twilight said, picking it up with her magic and placing it on Shining's head instead. "Oof!" Twilight grunted as Bic Mac reared up onto her. He tried a few times to penetrate her with failing attempts. "Here, let me." Twilight offered, taking hold of his shaft, guiding it into her. His feet shuffled impatiently. As soon as he felt himself start to hit his mark, he lurched forward, sinking deeply into her. "Ooohhh!" Twilight moaned. Shining had already begun to give Applejack a few slow thrusts, preoccupied with watching Twilight getting pegged by the red stallion.

"That feel good Twi?" He asked from on top of Applejack.

"Y-yeah." Twilight breathed, still getting used to the sudden fullness. Hearing her voice filled with such lust spurred Shining on, bucking Applejack harder.

"So how is she Mac?" He asked the stallion on top of his sister.

"I bet she's real tight!" AJ added.

"Eeyup!" Big Macintosh grunted as her pussy walls gripped him. Applejack clenched her own muscles against Shining's thrusts. Twilight nodded, telling Mac to go ahead. He began thrusting as well, eventually matching the other pair's rhythm. She and Applejack started to really get into it now. With each hump of their stallions, they met, thrusting right back. The slaps of thigh on thigh syncing up in stereo clapping.

Shining watched Twilight getting fucked. She looked up at him with her beautiful violet eyes. As they moved together he knew that with each thrust he gave Applejack, Twilight would be feeling the same thing. He glanced behind her, watching the red stallion pumping in and out of her. He felt himself growing painfully hard as he imagined that it was him fucking Twilight, deep in her tight purple flank. He gave Applejack's butt a firm squeeze with one hoof and a solid slap with the other, causing her pussy to tense up on him, her powerful muscles bearing down on his intruding shaft, attempting to milk him.

Twilight looked up at her big brother across from her, humping away into the orange farmpony. As she stared into his eyes, she lost herself. Yes, Big Macintosh was fucking her, but in that moment, it was just her and her BBBFF. She felt a strong, turgid penis thrusting into her each time Shining humped. She pretended that she was looking into a mirror. She was looking at Shining's reflection. He was actually on top of her! It felt like it must be his. How could it not be? It just felt so right. She indulged her fantasy.

"Oh, yes!" Twilight moaned. "Fuck me Shining!" She said. "I've wanted this for so long! I need it so bad!" Big Mac didn't take any offense. After all, this was what this was all about, indulging a fantasy. Shining didn't miss a beat in joining Twilight's fantasy.

"Yeah Twilight! You're so tight on my cock!" He said. "You like the feeling of me deep inside you like this?"

"Yes! Yes!" She cried out. "Rut me! Big Brother Best FUCK Forever! NNNggghhh!" Big Mac felt Twilight cumming again, squeezing him as he thrusted into her and soaking his scrotum as it slapped against her sensitive clit.

The Apple siblings were less vocal than the Sparkles. But it was every bit as cathartic for them. They looked deep into each other's eyes as they rutted. They rutted for all the nights they'd gone to bed in uncomfortable angst. They rutted for all the times they had to be strong. They rutted for all the times they were weak. They rutted, and they were doing it together. The passion they could see in eachother's faces said more than words possibly could.

"Love you." Big Macintosh mouthed silently to his sister.

"Uuh uHH AHH!" Applejack's orgasm rolled through her body, clenching and squeezing Shining's length as her muscles rippled while he continued to piston into her like a well-oiled machine.

Mac grunted and groaned, one of his hooves stamping the ground. Applejack could tell what it meant.

"Ngh, getting close!" Shining Armor said, almost as if on cue."

"Yes! Don't stop! I wanna feel it!" Twilight cried out. Big Mac gave a few more good heaves before slamming it home one final time. Twilight felt him flare inside her, filling her with a torrent of white with each powerful, throbbing burst.

Shining could hear her cry out at the feeling of Big Mac cumming inside her. Not two strokes later, he lurched forward as he felt himself cumming into Applejack. The force of the stallions' final push had caused the mares to close the distance between them. Twilight opened her eyes, her blurry vision was filled with orange. Without thinking in her emotional high, she leaned forward and kissed Applejack. AJ didn't object, kissing her back. Shining tapped Twilight on the shoulder.

"Hey Twi," He panted, "I'm up here kiddo." Twilight focused her eyes and blushed a little.

"But what about the rule?"

"Bah, it's just a kiss." He leaned down and kissed his sister.

Applejack could feel him still twitching inside her. Big Mac wore a dopey smile of his own, looking down at her. "Aw, what the hay. C'mere you!" She said, meeting his kiss. Despite penises being buried to the hilts inside of mares, their kisses were otherwise chaste. Each stallion dismounted, stumbling away from the mares who fell forward beside eachother. Neither could resist another chance to taste their respective brothers' seed, still leaking from the freshly creamed pies of the other. Without a word spoken, they began to quietly lick eachother clean.

Both stallions looked on as they themselves recovered. Twilight lifted her head from between Applejack's legs. "I wish this day would never end." She said. Applejack wore a sly grin as she rolled over. She reached into the basket and pulled out a strap-on.

"Who says it has to?"

It'll Be Okay

"Applejack! What is all this now?" Twilight asked. She looked on in awe as her friend retrieved the strap-on dildo from the picnic basket.

"Plan B," Applejack answered simply. "Just in case the boys didn't go for the idea today. I'd gotten so worked up looking forward to this, that I didn't want to leave unsatisfied. So if they didn't want to, I thought that as a back-up plan, you might."

"Well, I suppose I can't fault you for being prepared," Twilight said with a grin. Applejack struggled a bit with the straps. "Here, let me help you with that."

"Thanks. I actually just bought this for today. I haven't had a chance to try it on," Applejack said. Twilight reached around her friend's waist, attaching the straps to hold the member in an erect position. Before she tightened them, she reached her hoof around, slipping it inside the crotch of the harness, teasing her pussy. AJ purred at the contact.

As soon as the harness was secured, Applejack playfully bucked Twilight off of her hips, turning and grabbing her while she was still off-balance. She put her weight on Twilight's back, aggressively pinning her down and forcing her onto her elbows. Twilight smirked at AJ's rough play, particularly when she grabbed her purple tail with her hoof, yanking it upwards.

"Ooh-" Twilight moaned. Applejack brought the strap-on to Twilight's very wet nethers, pushing against them in an effort to penetrate her friend. A couple of thrust caused it to veer south, missing its mark. Shining Armor whom had been sitting idly for a while to recover along with Big Mac, decided to lend a hoof.

"Here, let me," he said, walking up beside AJ, and reaching under her. Grasping the dildo in his hoof, he guided it into his sister's pussy while Applejack pushed with her hips. He watched as inch after inch slipping inside her purple fold, mentally wishing that it could be him doing it. He tried to push the thought away as he let Applejack do her thing, thrusting in and out of her. As much as he liked watching her pussy take a pounding from another mare, the real show was at the other end. He shifted over, watching the look on Twilight's face as Applejack fucked her. The way her eyes rolled and her tongue lolled out was almost too cute to bear. He took a seat in front of her.

"Hey," he said. Twilight focused her eyes on his face. She looked in his eyes, thinking about him, all about him, while she felt herself getting fucked.

"Hey," she said back, her voice a little ragged from her heavy breathing. She watched as Shining brought his hoof to his dick and started stroking it in front of her. She licked her lips in wanton desire.

"You like this?" he asked. Twi nodded. "I bet you want to suck it, don't you?" She bit her lip and nodded again, harder. She wanted it. And he wanted to let her have it. He looked over her shoulder at Applejack on top of her, grinning as she fucked her. Her eyes darted up, behind Shining.

"Beggin' your pardon." Big Mac said from behind Shining. Shining stopped jerking off and noticed the other stallion entreating for his place on the picnic blanket. Shining begrudgingly moved aside for him as the red stallion put a hoof on Twilight's shoulder. She looked at Shining and winked.

"I'll pretend it's yours," she said, closing her eyes, and opening her mouth. Big Mac needed no further instruction as he fed her his cock. It felt wonderful as she sucked him off. He looked across at his sister, on other other end of Twilight. Applejack licked her lips and made a blowjob motion with her hoof toward Mac. He smiled back, enjoying both the sight and the feeling.

Shining felt like a bit of a fifth wheel, sitting aside while the Apple sibling enjoyed his sister without him. He felt a pang in his gut. Was it jealousy he felt? He tried to suppress it. He didn't want to be the one to call a halt to all the fun just because of his own insecurities. He'd been having a wonderful time with Applejack already. He would get another chance soon. And as luck would have it, Applejack broke from looking longingly into her brother's eyes and turned to Shining. She motioned with her head toward her hind end.

"Saddle up!" she said.

Shining was a bit unsure how this was supposed to work, but did as he was told. He moved around behind Applejack, who paused her rutting and flagged her tail. Beneath, Shining could plainly see that the straps of the dildo were specially designed to keep her marehood 'available'.

Saddle up indeed. He thought as he mounted the farm pony, sandwiching her between himself and Twilight under her. He did well keeping most of his weight on his hind legs. Guiding himself with his magic, he slipped inside her pussy with little difficulty.

"Hey Twi," Applejack said, "take a look." Big Mac eased off, letting himself fall from her mouth as she turned back to look. "I ain't the one fuck'n you now," she said. Indeed, Twilight could see Shining fucking AJ. And with each of his thrusts, he was pushing Applejack, and her strap-on in or out. In a way, Shining was fucking her, through Applejack. Twilight smiled, enjoying that knowledge, and turned back to her task at hoof. Shining did the work of the group now, his motion translating through the two mares, making Twilight bob her head on Big Mac's shaft with each thrust. Twilight felt her arousal skyrocketing knowing that it was her brother making that dildo fuck her now.

"MMff! Mfff! NNNNMMMM!" Twilight moaned onto Big Mac's dick, succumbing to her orgasm that Shining had given her... or that Applejack had given her. Either way, it was a team effort. The dildo made slick, wet noises as it continued to pummel Twilight. Applejack was hot on her hooves with Shining fucking her properly and the dildo's harness riding against her clit.

"Oh. My. Gosh!" Applejack cried in time with each buck of Shining's hips. He felt her pussy quiver and spasm as she came on him. Having cum so recently himself, and only just joining the fray now, he was nowhere near his own climax. He quickened his pace, fucking her faster and harder through her orgasm. "AH!Ah!AHH!" Applejack saw stars in her eyes as he pushed her to even greater heights. "I- Ah- I can't!" AJ cried. "It's too much!" Shining stopped, ever the considerate stallion, and pulled out, giving her a chance to recover.

Applejack's knees buckled, causing her to fall backwards, with the dildo slipping out of Twilight and flopping about. Shining caught her, easing her onto her butt on the blanket. Applejack slumped forward, inadvertently mushing her face into Twilight's freshly-fucked pussy. She pulled away, her face wet with a mixture of Twilight's wetness and some of Mac's residual cum from earlier. Twilight stopped what she was doing turned around to see to Applejack.

"Are you okay?" she asked. Applejack looked back at her with a goofy grin, punch drunk from the rutting she had been taking. Applejack nodded and Shining helped her to her hooves, while Twilight's magic took off the strap-on harness from AJ's hips. When Big Mac saw that AJ was just fine, he took the opportunity to mount Twilight again, catching her off guard. Even though they'd just had sex together not long ago, he still felt so big to her, pressing his wide tip against her entrance. Her nervousness from before was long gone now. She relaxed, letting him slip inside with relative ease.

Shining looked into Applejack's eyes to make sure she was okay. Looking back, she grabbed him by the scruff of his mane with her hooves, giving him a quick, hard kiss before tossing him onto his back. For all their size difference, Applejack was clearly the more physically strong of the two. Years of apple bucking, no doubt, he thought. He landed beside the strap-on that she'd been wearing. Without any shame, he turned and licked it, greedily sucking on it as he tasted his sister's juices. In a flash, Applejack was on top of him, holding his head with her hoof, taking his horn into her mouth.

Shining wasn't expecting that. His legs fell limp as she leaned down with him, sucking and licking his horn. Her tongue ran over every ridge of his horn's spiral, sending tingles of electricity through his nerves. He never really considered his horn as an erogenous zone before today. But in her mouth, it sure felt that way when she bobbed her head on it, sucking with gusto.

Twilight turned to look at what was happening, shuffling forward a few inches with each heave as the heavy stallion behind her rutted her. In no time, she was right behind Applejack. She considered for a moment, retrieving the strap-on to wear, and use in turn, on the Earth pony mare, letting Mac do the work of it as Shining had before. Her thoughts were cut short when she felt Mac's hoof on the back of her head, running through her mane, pushing her downwards. Another thrust forward and she understood what he was trying to do. Twilight lined up her horn with Applejack's entrance.

"HOO DOGGIE!" Applejack's mouth popped off Shining's horn in surprise at the penetration. She felt another thrust against her orange flank by the mare's head and looked back. Twilight had her horn buried to the hilt inside her. Behind her, Mac fucked her, sending her into Applejack with each hump. As with her and the strap-on before, now it was Mac's turn to fuck AJ through Twilight. Applejack smiled and went back to work on Shining's horn, enjoying the double penetration.

Twilight looked up from under her bangs, under Applejack's legs. She could see Shining getting his horn sucked. His eyes were closed, enjoying the sensation. Twilight timed her own rutting and tapped his hoof. He didn't notice the contact. Big Mac slid forward again, filling her completely with his cock with each advance, and shoving her horn into his sister. She tapped Shining's hoof again, harder. He opened his eyes, looking under Applejack at Twilight. He grinned. Twilight glanced down at Shining's cock, laying on his belly under her, hidden from both AJ's and Mac's line of sight. Twilight looked back at Shining and opened her mouth.

Shining gave her a puzzled look, unsure of what she was doing. Twilight cut another directed glance at his dick, instructing his to follow hers. He looked down at himself, fully erect and laying against his belly. He looked back up at Twilight. She opened her mouth again, lolling her tongue out, waggling it at him. He grinned at the funny faces she was making him. It was like she was a little filly again. Twilight rolled her eyes in frustration, sticking her tongue into her cheek repeatedly, simulating the appearance of fellatio. Shining's eyes went wide. Okay, that hint, he understood.

Shining glanced up at Applejack, out of sight, happily sucking away at his horn. And then he tried to look at Big Mac, his view equally obstructed by Twilight's body. Both oblivious to anything that would happen underneath. With each of their horns grounded out in a warm, wet place, neither could call to their magic to move him. Shining reached down with his hoof, trying to move subtly with AJ's hoof under his armpit. He could just barely get his hoof under it, lifting it up towards her. If he could just get it to her, just close enough for a suck, a lick, or even a quick kiss.

Try as he might, he couldn't lift it high enough from the angle he was in. He tried to flick it, tossing it up with the tip of his hoof. It got close, and closer still with each try. Twilight extended her tongue as far as she could, hoping for even the briefest contact. The thought of it, just the thought of tasting it, at long last, made her want to just, just... just-

"NGGGHHHhhhaaaaa!" Twilight moaned, as her orgasm rolled through her. Mac slowed down, enjoying the sensation of her pussy gripping his cock as her muscles spasmed around him. Twilight felt the jolts of pleasure running up her spine from her marehood all the way to the tip of her horn, still buried inside of Applejack's pussy. AJ stopped sucking Shining for a moment.

"Woah nelly! Her horn is making my insides all tingly when she cums!" With a fresh desire to feel the same thing in her mouth, she got back to sucking his horn with double speed. Twilight's eyes came back into focus, catching Shining's once more. He had almost gotten his shaft to her. Just a couple more tries and she would have it. Twilight tried to pull Applejack down with her head, getting her to bend her knees just a bit. After a moment, Applejack subconsciously followed her movements. Just one more try, Shining gave it one more throw.

Twilight head pulled away suddenly, missing the catch as she and her horn left Applejack's backside. Big Mac brought his hoof down under her chin, pulling her back toward him as he leaned over her, sucking on her horn himself, tasting his sister's juices on it. Twilight felt him swell yet larger inside her as he enjoyed the flavor. Applejack turned and looked at her, leaving Shining's horn in the lurch.

"Just as well, I suppose," AJ said. "I need something a fair bit bigger than your horn to get me off anyhow."

"Eeyup," Mac replied, releasing Twilight's horn from his mouth. Twilight used her hoof to wipe her horn dry with a picnic napkin, calling to her magic to levitate the strap-on over to her.

"Actually, I was thinking of something else," Applejack said, stepping off of Shining. She reached into the picnic basket, lifting out a big double-ended dong. "Mac, do ya mind?" Big Macintosh frowned briefly, but did as he was told, stepping back and letting his still-hard cock slip from Twilight's pussy with a wet 'plop'.

AJ made a turn-around motion with her hoof to Twilight. Twilight glanced at her brother again, getting to his hooves, before she turned around and presented herself to Applejack. She held the dildo in her hooves, lining it up with Twilight's pussy. Twilight looked back, under her legs as the long, plastic dildo got closer to her. AJ stopped at the last moment.

"Actually, why don't you?" she asked, turning to Shining. "I can't reach back there once I'm facing you and, I mean, technically it's not touching since you don't need to use your hooves." She held it out to him and he took it with his magic, levitating it. Applejack glanced back at Twilight's flank, lining hers up with it. Shining levitated the dildo over to Twilight's pussy, pressing it against her entrance. Twilight watched her brother from under her legs, the dildo glowed with the blue aura of his magic as he slid it up and down her slit, getting it very wet. She gasped as he applied more pressure, pushing the tip of it inside her. It didn't have the warm, pulsating flesh of a real penis. But she felt it moving inside her, filling her up. And she knew that it was her brother doing it to her now. There was no middle mare this time. And it made her all the hotter.

She could see the bulge in her belly as it filled her completely, bottoming out inside her with half of its length still remaining. He pulled it most of the way out before pushing it back inside again, eliciting a moan from her. Again he did it, making AJ turn to see what the holdup was, watching the glowing dildo fucking Twilight. The Sparkle siblings were edging into dangerous territory.

"Ya know, half of that's for me," she said, regaining his attention. Shining stopped moving the dildo.

"Uh, yeah. I know. I was just, uh, making sure that it in there all the way," he said, not entirely lying. He gave it one last push, pressing it solidly against Twilight's cervix.

"Ngggghhhh." Twilight felt her stomach do a flip at the weird sensation.

"Heh. Sure you were. Now, do you mind?" AJ asked as she raised her tail, shuffling backwards. Shining guided the other end into Applejack's impatient love tunnel, letting it go as she closed the distance, pressing her marehood against Twilight's as the dildo vanished between them. "Now come here with that other 'horn' of yours. I still owe you one," she said, motioning to Shining. He reared up and put his hooves on her shoulders as she began sucking him off again, rolling her hips against Twilight. Mac followed suit on other other end.

Applejack had enjoyed getting the unicorns' defining feature at both ends, but now both mares were enjoying being double-penetrated, sucking the stallions' cocks while they fucked backwards against eachother in rhythm. Above them Shining and Mac tried to look anywhere but at each others eyes. They both found a common view below. Shining pulled aside Applejack's tail, allowing Big Mac to watch the dildo moving in and out of her toned, orange flank. Mac did the same with Twilight's tail for Shining's viewing pleasure.

Shining leaned down a little closer, watching the dildo move in and out of his little sister in time with his cock, in and out of Applejack's mouth. It was so easy to just squint a little and imagine that it was his, moving in and out of Twilight's tight little purple-

Shining felt lips on his horn. He looked up in surprise. Mac stopped and raised his eyebrows, suggestively. Shining felt his heart jump a little with the adrenaline.

"Um, I uh, I appreciate the sentiment, but uh, no thank you," Shining said politely. Mac shrugged, his expression neutral, and looked back down at the show between them. Shining held Applejack's waist still for a moment, creating a few inches of space between the girls. He grasped the middle of the dildo with his magic, jerking it back and forth between them both rapidly.

"Mff MFF MMMHHH!!!!" Twilight moaned with her mouth full, the vibration, at last, pushing Mac over the edge. He threw his head back as his cock flared in her mouth. Twilight braced herself for what was next, holding her breath as he unloaded a torrent of cum, most of it spilling from her mouth as she pulled off of his cock. But Shining didn't stop there. He kept going just as hard, pushing Twilight even higher in her climax, and bringing Applejack to hers shortly after, hearing her friend's orgasm behind her.

"NMM AGMM MMMFFF!!" Applejack's cries of ecstasy were likewise muffled by male meat. Shining's hips spasmed and bucked as he went past the point of no return, losing his ability to hold the dildo. Twilight stumbled away, pulling the double-ender from Applejack with her, causing AJ's pussy to spurt her orgasm. AJ felt her mouth fill with Shining's flare, but regained enough composure in the stimulating dildo's absence to ready herself for his impending load. His shaft swelled and throbbed as the first rope of cum rocketed out. She gulped the first bout almost immediately. And then the second, but struggling by the third of a seemingly endless volley of semen. To her credit, she swallowed most of it like a champ. What little that escaped her, dribbled down her chin as she too, fell onto her back, gasping beside Twilight.

Mac and Shining barely had the strength left to walk, as they each shuffled around the outside of the two mares laying on the blanket together. Thoroughly spent, their satisfied stallionhoods retreated for good into their sheaths. Mac fell onto the blanket beside Applejack. Shining stood beside Twilight, using his magic to grasp the dildo still lodged in her. He pulled at it gently. Twilight whimpered.

"Ooh oooh!" she cried like a little foal with a skinned knee, feeling overstimulated. Shining winced.

"Sorry," he said, pulling it completely out of her and returning it to the basket along with the strap-on. He laid down beside Twilight, holding her in his hooves as he used to whenever she'd had a bad dream. They laid there, opposite the other siblings.

"Best. Brothers Day. Ever," Applejack said. She leaned over a little and licked a bit of Mac's cum off of Twilight's snout. Twilight giggled and licked Shining's cum off of AJ's chin before kissing her. Lightly at first, and then with more passion as their tongues ran over one another's. Twilight pulled away after a moment.

"Same time next year?" she asked.

"Eeyup!"