Sunset Shimmer's Place to Stay
"Sunset Shimmer, please report to the Vice Principle's office. Sunset Shimmer, please report to the Vice Principle's office."
Sunset froze. Had she been discovered? If she doesn't go, that would just make her more suspicious, and it would mean the humans are certain to find out about her if they don't already know. The only thing to do is go there and hope for the best. At least she'll find out quickly and still have a chance to run. There is still one problem.
"Can someone show me the way to the office?"
A purple-haired girl stood up and walked over to her. "You're new here, aren't you? I'm Rarity. I'm the class president, so I can show you the way. Follow me."
A blue-haired adult welcomed them in. "Thank you for coming, Sunset. Rarity, you may head back to class. I have something private to discuss with Ms. Shimmer."
"Of course. See you soon, Sunset." She left. Luna locked the door after her. This was not helping with Shimmer's nerves.
"I'm Vice Principle Luna," she introduced herself. "I understand you're new here. Very new."
"Yeah," said Sunset. "My family just moved here and ..."
"It's okay," said Luna. "I already know. You don't have to keep it a secret from me."
"What are you talking about?" asked Sunset.
Luna turned a box on her desk around. It had an image of the statue. Then the image moved. It showed Sunset leaving it.
"But there was nobody there!" said Sunset. "How could you have seen that?"
"Do they have cameras where you're from?", asked Luna.
"Yeah, but you need someone to take the picture, and they don't move."
"You obviously are new to this world," said Luna. "How about you stay with me. I'll try to explain everything you need to know, and you'll have a place to stay."
Sunset couldn't help but wonder if it was a trap. But Luna was right. She needed someone to explain this world to her. And there's no way that someone would believe she was a native.
"All right. Walk me to your place when school is over."
Shimmer was relieved when the finally arrived. She was by all accounts a powerful mage, but she'd never seen anything like Luna's "car". Luckily, Luna didn't seem to mind her holding on to her for dear life. Sunset probably wouldn't let go even now if it wasn't so inconvenient to get out that way. Once they went inside, Luna took off all of her clothes. Sunset followed suit.
"So, clothes," said Sunset. "Where I come from, they're mostly just for formal occasions. Everyone seems to where them here. I haven't seen one human naked until now. What's the deal?"
"Being naked outside is taboo. In fact, you shouldn't mention being naked here. While I'm at it, you shouldn't talk about even being here. Don't even tell my sister."
"You have a sister?" asked Sunset. "What's her name?"
"I guess you wouldn't know yet. Principle Celestia is my sister."
Sunset froze. Celestia's sister. Banished to the moon by the Elements of Harmony for a thousand years. Vice Principle Luna must be this world's version of ...
"Is something wrong?" asked Nightmare Moon.
Sunset ran out the door back into the garage. There was still the huge metal door the car went through. She tried to lift it, to no avail. There must be some way to get this open. Too late. Nightmare Moon grabbed her and pulled her back.
"What are you so scared about? Like I said, you really shouldn't be going outside naked."
"Please don't eat me!" shouted Sunset.
"I'm not going to eat you," Nightmare Moon chuckled. "You can leave whenever you want. I'll just send that video to the police so they know to take care of you. Do you want me to do that?"
"No", Sunset whispered.
"Well then," Nightmare Moon smiled, "just do what I ask you and you can stay. I'm sure we'll have lots of fun together."
"You said this is your first time? You still want to do this? I'm not going to force you."
Consensual sex was supposed to be fun. Non-consensual was ... less so. This is her last chance. She could still try to run. But then the humans would find out about her for sure, and things would get a lot more complicated.
Hopefully rape isn't as bad as they say.
Sunset nodded.
"In that case, wear this." Nightmare put a gag in her mouth. "We don't want your moaning to alert the neighbors. And we'd better tie you in place as well. Can't have you banging loudly on anything."
After Sunset was securely in place, she started having second thoughts. Being tied down wasn't comfortable. Especially if she tried to move. Doesn't sex involve a lot of movement?
Nightmare left, and returned with a metal helmet, gauntlets, and a pair of metal low-fetlock boots, or whatever humans called them. She also brought an assortment of toys.
She crawled on top of Shimmer and kissed her face. Then she slowly made her way down to Shimmers breasts, and sucked on one of her nipples, which seemed to be erogenous. Shimmer struggled. The sex was barely starting, and she already changed her mind.
"Do you want to stop?" asked Nightmare.
Shimmer nodded.
"But we just started. Don't worry, it will get better after you're used to it."
Shimmer knew Nightmare was lying about not forcing her, but finally seeing it made her feel even more hopeless.
Luna fondled Shimmers breast with one hand, and made her way down to Shimmer's lower lips. She started licking her there. Then she stopped. Shimmer relaxed for a second, until she saw Nightmare reach for a dildo. Nightmare flipped a switch on it, and it started vibrating.
Shimmer felt her hymen break, and something huge and vibrating get shoved inside of her.
Sunset had studied a lot on her quest for power. Magic, of course, but there are other ways to gain power. She had only recently gained her cutie mark, but she nonetheless had achieved a strong understanding of psychology. For example, she knew the two-factor theory of emotion. There is physiological arousal, which controls how strongly you feel emotion, and a cognitive label, which controls which emotion you feel. If there are two things that cause emotion, for example: walking across a rickety bridge (fear) and then talking to a pretty mare (sexual arousal) then you get the physiological arousal from both, so whatever cognitive label you're using gets stronger. The stallions that where given a survey after walking across the rickety bridge were more likely to ask the mare out when they returned them than the stallions that walked across the sturdy control bridge.
If she chose to get tied down and have a dildo shoved up her cunt, the arousal from the bondage and pain would most likely make the sex that much more enjoyable. That is not what happened.
The feeling on the walls of her vagina was unbelievably intense. She came immediately. And it made her pain and fear feel that much worse. She tried to scream, but the gag muffled her. She tried to struggle, but she was bound too strongly. She couldn't do anything but struggle, as the Mare of the Moon raped her.
Nightmare Moon soon got tired of that, and pulled the dildo out. She was about to toss it away, but thought better of it, and forced it up Sunset's ass. She licked up Sunset's juices, the she sat up, put one leg under Sunset and one leg over so their vigina's touched, and rubbed vigorously as she groped Sunset's breasts. As she was about to come, she backed off. Then she grabbed a double dildo and stuck it between them. She shoved it in as she moved back into position, and felt Sunset struggle as she came again. Nightmare moved back and forth, moaning in pleasure, until she reached her climax. She got off the bed. Then she turned Sunset's head to face her and asked: "So, are you going to stay here?"
Sunset nodded.
Nightmare moon slapped her. "You're lying. You don't think your secret is worth this. It's okay. You'll stop worrying about it so much after a few more rounds."
Luna grabbed a few more toys and got back to work. It's a shame she had to do this. She liked the sort of girl that would fight back. But she couldn't afford it. Still, getting students in bed with her had been risky. It will be good to have a single, permanent sex toy.