Tail Plug

by Bysen

Rating: mature
Tags: Rainbow Dash, Rarity, Sex, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Human, Romance
Length: 2514

After sharing their furry... I mean Wonderbolt tails with the school during Helping Twilight Win the Crown song, Rarity discovers Rainbow Dash's secret.

So the whole school's going around wearing furry... I mean Wonderbolt tails now after their little song and dance number in the cafeteria. Of course the mane 6 have been wearing them all day.
However there's something odd about the way Rainbow Dash is wearing hers. Everyone else has it wrapped around their waist but hers appears to be coming out of her pants and Rarity can't help but wonder why.

Story inspired by two strippers... I mean cosplayers I met at a con I went to over the weekend that me and my friend came to the conclusion was wearing a tail plug as part of her 'costume'. I then got drunk at 1am on the bus ride home and found this story in my googledoc two days later.
If by some coincidence that was you and you find this story, sorry... but you knew what you were getting into wearing those pants...

Published 2014-08-25 04:10:02 UTC
Last updated 2014-08-25 04:10:02 UTC

I Said What What

“Get on the bed dear.” Rarity told Rainbow Dash as she finished removing her last article of clothing. Well, aside from her socks. The spectrum haired girl nervously sat down on the edge, keeping her legs modestly closed and her somewhat flat chest half covered by her arms. “No, not like that. How am I supposed to do this if you cute little butt is down on the bed. Up, up.” she ordered motioning her friend to stand back up. “Now, turn around, lean over the bed and crawl on. And make sure to keep that wonderful toosh of your nice and high now.”

Rainbow Dash did as she was told and had only just pulled her second knee up onto the mattress because she felt a pair of hand pantly firmly on her cheeks. That whole openly lesbian thing was fine in theory, but in practice… honestly, this was her first time with anyone male or female. She couldn’t help but think back to how she’d wound up in this situation with one of her best friends.

~ ~

They’d just finished singing in the cafeteria, letting everyone know they should vote for Twilight for Princess of the Fall Formal and having passed out all of their Wonderbolts ears and tails. She’d never admit it, but seeing nearly the entire school wearing tails like this was a massive turn on for Rainbow Dash. She had to blame Fluttershy for that one when she’d introduced her to that furry fetish stuff a few years ago.

The six of them has been wearing the things all day in solidarity and even went as far as to tie them into their clothing rather than just wrapping the band around their waist. Rainbow Dash however had gone a little further. “Rainbow Dash. I must ask you something.” Rarity call Rainbow Dash off to the side, her eyes locked downwards as she did. “It’s great to see you wearing that tail and all, but it’s attached rather oddly, wouldn’t you say?”

“What are you on about?” Dash replied incredulously.

“Well, it’s just that most of us are wearing skirts or dresses and the tails are coming out of them yes but… you in those tight sports pants of yours, well… I can see the tail coming out of them but I can’t quite see where it’s attached.”

“O-oh, it’s just wrapped around my waist inside is all.”

“Yes, well I thought as much. Until, that was, you bent down earlier and the top of your underwear was showing ever so slightly above your waistband. And the thing is… the tail was coming from under that too. I don’t mean to sound accusive but I simply have to ask: are you wearing a tail plug Rainbow Dash?” Rarity said with complete sincerity and genuine curiosity.

“What?! N-no, of course not!” Dash replied in astonishment.

“Right, right I’m sorry I even brought it up.” Rarity said before and awkward silence fell over them.

“Well…” Dash said as she raised a hand and gently scratched the back of her head. “I gotta get going. I’ll see you around.” she added before walking past her friend only to… “Ohhh!!!...” she moaned.

“I knew it!” Rarity declared as she let go of Dash’s tail. She’d grabbed it and pulled on it gently as Dash had walked past and given a reaction exactly like she had expected of a tight pull followed by a sudden popping release. That, and she’d pulled Dash’s pants and underwear back a bit and clearly saw it inserted between her cheeks. “Oh my goodness, that’s so pervert, that’s so naughty, that’ so… hot!”

“I know, I know, just please don’t te-what?” Dash asked as she realised what Rarity had actually said. Rarity looked around before pulling Dash in close, wrapping her arms around the girl placing their faces practically touching and their breasts pressed hard against one another’s. One hand squeezing Dash’s left cheek, the other gently tugging over and over on the tail making Dash let out the cutest little whimpers of enjoyment.

“I’ve always wanted to wear one of these out and about but never worked up the courage. Even the smaller, unseen plugs I haven’t been able to bring myself to wear out in public. But you… such audacity… to wear a tail plug so openly… I’ve been practically dripping since the thought crossed my mind!”

“Geez Rarity. I never pegged you for a-” Dash was cut off as Rarity forcefully kissed her friend. Dash didn’t object. Hell, she’d have done this sooner if she’d thought Rarity wasn’t straight as the soccer team’s dick that girl was always jumping on.

Soon enough though Rarity caught herself and pulled away. Blushing she told Dash “Sorry about that. I just sort of lost control when you said ‘pegged you’. If, if it wouldn’t be too much to ask... would you… care to come over to my house after school today? I’d very much appri-” and this time Rarity was the one interrupted by Dash forcefully kissing her.

~ ~

Dash had thought this would be amazing. Rarity’s slender body with the perfectly matching breasts quivering at just the thought of the naughty things she’d been doing with her toys all day. But instead she was just nervous. This was one of her best friends and once the initial excitement of not being the only one of her friends to like V instead of D had passed, it just left her with a pit in her stomach. Of course that could’ve just been an empty feeling from letting Rarity pull out her tail.

On all fours on Rarity’s overly frilly bed, Rarity had one hand on her cheek and slowly spread her rear. now, while Rarity had been on the brink of orgasm all day, Rainbow Dash wasn’t exactly dry herself. Quite the opposite as she strippign in front of her friend had gotten her quite hot as well. Embarrassing, but hot. Rarity however, was still in her cloths. Minus her underwear which had been thoroughly soaked through before they’d even left the cafeteria earlier. A publicly given treasure Dash would keep for years to come.

Her cheeks spread, her tail hole, as she had once heard Fluttershy refer to it as, was not what you would call gapping but not fulling closed yet from pulling her last toy out. “Now Dash, don’t be afraid to tell me if i’m being a bit too forceful. I’ve only ever done this to myself and I know it can be a bit uncomfortable if pushed too hard too fast.” and with that Dash felt the tip of a finger being pressed against her ring and slightly pushed inside of her before it began to wiggle a little.

“That’s fine Rarity. Just make sure you wet it all up first before you put much more in alright?” It had a small [ish] bulb shaped metal head before it thinned out and led to a bigger circle end. And on the end of that end led 6 colourful lengths of threads designed to look like rainbow hair. Rarity had spent her final home-ec class of the day changing the standard wonderbolts tail before attaching it to the plug Dash had been using once they arrived somewhere more private. Luckily, thanks to their show in the cafeteria that day no one raised an eyebrow about it.

Dash said, looking to the said at Rarity’s own personal arrange of toy. There weren’t that many, honestly less than Dash had, all but the tail plug she was holding now where very penis-centric whereas Dash’s collection where more butt oriented. Not that you couldn’t put any of these up her arse, she didn’t didn’t exactly like penises over specifically designed for anal comfort.

“Right, don’t want them going in dry of course.” Rarity said with a hint of hesitation in her voice just like Dash. Of course that was likely for a different reason than Dash however as she felt her cheeks being pulled apart slightly more before a wet object touched down on her anus. Then it moved and circled with a fluid motion that couldn’t have been some wettened toy.

Rainbow Dash moaned as Rarity began to rim her tail hole and and bury her face in between her cheeks. Tongue moving up, down and all around with the occasional dip into her slightly open ring. The most intense moment was when Rarity’s tongue exactly circled around the muscle ring a few times before finally pushing it’s way into her arse. It riggled and wiggled and jiggled inside her, covering every inch Rarity could reach in her saliva.

Her tongue still extended, she withdrew from her friends butt leaving it wider than it was before but slowly closing again. “Uh, Rarity. Totally not complaining about that at all but… I meant you should get it wet by dipping it in my vag first.” Rainbow Dash told her friend who get gotten her even wetter now with that little bit of surprise butt sex.

“Oh, yes of course. How silly of me.” Rarity said with a blush that perfectly matched the red part of the rainbow plug she was holding. “Anywho. Let’s begin, shall we?”

And with that Rarity pressed the metal tip against Rainbow Dash’s tail hole, about half of the cone part easily going inside of her as she was still opened up from the previous tongue lashing she’d received. “Cold!” Dash blurted and instantly clenched. She moaned as the object didn’t move at first, just leaving something hard half inside of her to constrict her anus around before the pressure became too much and she forced it out of her.

“Oops, my apologies once more Rainbow. I uh... perhaps I’ll try what you said first.” Raid suggested and with the cold metal still pressed against her friend’s hole, ran it down her skin across the small valley of her gooch before sliding it in between Dash’s wet lips. She slid the toy up and down along Dash’s slit a few times, eliciting a moan from the kneeling girl before pushing it inside.

“STOP!!!” Dash shouted as just the tip entered her pussy. “Rarity, I’m a virgin so…” Dash trailed off. The tip was still inside of her and warming fast. “I think it’s been warmed up now. You can put it in my butt. Just, uh, don’t do too much up front is all.” Dash continued. As much as she liked Rarity and was essentially losing her virginity to her anyway, she knew this was just a fling and didn’t want to take it too far.

“Of course dear.” Rarity said with a smile as she retracted the toy. She could understand Dash’s hesitance. This was first first time too after all. Well, first time with another girl. well… first time with only another girl. But she was going to make the most of it and experiment with it to the fullest. So before she placed the plug back in between Dash’s cheek, she moved it up to her mouth. ‘Mmm skittles.’ she thought as she licked the plug ever so slightly. Very different to her own marshmallowy taste.

Rarity placed the toy back at Dash’s rear entrance, this time her hole was sealed shut. Dash wasn’t tensed up, her anus has just returned to it’s natural closed state now was all. Rarity pressed the toy and once again, the first half sunk in almost instantly before she had to start applying pressure. It slowly sank in, making Dash moan and groan in equal pleasure and minor discomfort. Then, all at once as it sunk up to the very end of the bulb, the plug popped inside her of, swallowed and sucked in faster than it was being pushed.

And there it was, right in front of Rarity’s eyes. Rainbow Dash completely naked, crawling on her knees with her arse cheek spread open, dripping profusely with a tail sticking out of her slender arse. Rarity just stared at the sight before her, wide-eyed. Such a naughty act, such a depraving position, such a massive turn on! She dove in and slowly rang her tongue from the bottom of the plug at her entrance all the way to Rainbow Dash’s clit before sucked in it into her lips.

She came. both of them. Rarity had only just slid her hand up under her dress before it overwhelmed her. The thought that her friend had worn this around school all day, publicly showing her lewd act with noone but her any the wiser. She wished she could do the same. She could do the same… she just didn’t. Not yet at least. She continued to suck and lick as Dash’s love as she continued her delicately finger herself throughout both of their orgasms.

Eventually, the two came down from their ecstasy. Rarity down on her knees, one hand on Dash’s thigh and the other half buried insider herself. Dash up on her knees as her arse was still held high in the air for Rarity to access but her chest had fallen against the bed. they both stayed silent, aside from their heavy breathing, in the afterglow of the moment. Chests heaving as they did.

The silence was finally broken. “That. Was. AWSUM!!!”

Author's Note

This is by no means my OTP and Rarity is worst pone. This is just the ship that happened to be sailed by the two cosplayers whose 3 inch pants inspired this story.
Also aside from my personal theory that Fluttershy is a furry, she was mentioned in this because there was a [much less sexualized] cosplayer of her there too.
I went to a convention on Saturday and met two ridiculously smexy poni cosplayers who me and my friend came to the conclusion RD was wearing a tail plug. While this may or may not actually be true I tend to believe my gay friend when it comes to butt toys. That, and I want to believe it anyway!
So anyway, on the 8 hour party bus ride home overnight all of us got hammered and at some point I must've started writing this because this morning I found this story almost completed in my google.docs. After probably 3 times as long as it took me to write it, I managed to correct all the drunken ipad on a bus grammar and bad wording.
So behold! My first non-troll clopfic!

Bonus scene

Dash stood facing away from Rarity, still naked, tail still in her tail hole and blushing heavily. “Rarity… I…” she muttered, deeply regretting her decision. She looked over her shoulder at her friend and just received a smile. It didn’t make it any easier. “Fine…” Dash sighed as she started to shake her hips back and forth, letting the tail swish behind her before singing “Shake your tail ‘cause we’re here to have a party tonight.”

Author's Note

Wiggle wiggle wiggle wiggle wiggle wiggle wiggle wiggle.