First Love's First Time

by Nightlock106

Rating: mature
Tags: Sex, Big Macintosh, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Romance, Original Character
Length: 2018

Nightlock and Big Mac have been going out for a few months now, and Nightlock feels that it's time to take things to the next level.

Nightlock has been dating Big Mac for a few months. They've spent a lot of time together and have really gotten to know each other. But, Nightlock is looking for more than a normal date for their anniversary. Tonight, Nightlock is looking to have his first time.
Warning: If you do not like homosexuality or gay sex, do not read any further!

Published 2014-08-31 22:50:03 UTC
Last updated 2014-08-31 22:50:03 UTC

First Love's First Time

Author's Note

If you are reading this, then you either ignored the first warning or don't mind the content that will be in the story. But for those who did ignore the warning, I will say it again.
WARNING: If you do not like homosexuality or gay sex, do not read any further and exit the story.

First Love's First Time

I popped the cork on my bottle of Applejack Danials and poured it into our glasses. I sat the bottle down in the center of the table next to the floral centerpiece. A bright smile came across my face and I stared at the table. The table was laid out with a purple silk table cloth, my finest cutlery, a few candles to provide a romantic mood, and to top it all off, my mother's famous vegetable casserole. It was perfect, and I just knew he was going to love it.

There was a knock at the door. I took a deep breath and walked over to the door. I pulled it open and there he was; his strong, sculpted body, soft red coat, and his straw colored hair that fell gently over his brow. He gave me a bright smile, "Hey baby, sorry I'm late."

I wrapped my hoof around him and gave him a deep kiss, "It's alright, I wasn't even paying attention to the time."

He walked in and put his hat on the door knob, "Something smells good. What are y'all making?"

"I made my mom's famous vegetable casserole."

"Well, your mom sure knew how to make somepony hungry."

I giggled and lead him into the kitchen, "Good thing its already done and set out."

His mouth began to water from the sight.

"Have a seat honey and I'll get everything all set."

He sat down on the left side of the table and took a look around candlelit dinning room, "What's with all the fancy stuff?"

I put a serving of casserole on his plate, "Well, today is our three month anniversary. I figured I'd do something special for us tonight. Oh, and be sure to save some room, I also have a pie baking in the oven right now."

He smiled at me as I finished serving the food. I sat down next to him, picking up my glass of cider, "Big Mac, I never thought that I a million years I'd find a stallion that could make me as happy as you have. I love you with all my heart, and I couldn't ever imagine being with anypony else."

"Nightlock, you're making me blush. But, I do feel the same way about ya. There's no other stallion in this world that I would be truly happy with."

He raised up his glass and clicked it against mine before we both took a drink. I let out a light sigh and set my glass back down before I began to dig into the casserole.

Though Big Mac and I have only gone out for a few months. We still haven't gone any further than second base. I wasn't really sure if it was the fact that both of us were too shy about it, or if it was that he was waiting for me to bring it up. Though, to be perfectly honest, I've never really had sex before. I mean, I've done some things before, but I've still never went all the way into it. I never really knew why. I didn't know if it was that I was waiting too long to bring it up, or if I was really saving myself for the right stallion. Whatever it was, I was willing to take the long awaited plunge.

I looked over at him as he cutely chewed on the bite of food in his mouth. I took a deep breath and another drink of cider before letting it out, "Honey, I think we should have sex tonight."

His eyes went wide and he began choking on his food for a second before finally washing it down with some cider.

"Are you okay honey?" I asked in shock and horror.

"I'm...I'm fine. Ya just caught me a little off guard with that."

"I'm sorry honey."

"I-It's alright. I'm fine."

"I guess I should've waited until later to ask."

"Don't worry about that. I just wasn't expecting it is all."

I looked away from him, worried that I made the wrong decision about asking him, "I'm sorry." I went back to eating my food in silence, a look of depression still plastered on my face.

Big Mac wrapped his hoof around me and pulled me in closer to him, "Baby, I'm not mad about it. To be honest, I was waiting on you to bring it up for a while now."

"Y-You were?"

"Eeyup."

"How come?"

"Mainly because, I'm a...a vergin."

"You're what?"

"I'm a virgin."

I looked up at him, his eyes filled with nervousness. I put my hoof behind his head and kissed his cheek, "Join the club."

His eyes lit up slightly, "Y-You mean..."

"Yeah. And to be honest, I was scared to bring it up because I didn't know if you wanted to do it this early in our relationship or not."

He smiled, moving a small lock of my hair from my eye. I looked into his deep eyes, lust quickly growing in my heart. I pulled his head closer to mine, bringing him into a deep, passionate kiss. We sat there for a long time, holding each other in our embrace. I finally broke the kiss and smiled at him, "How about we take this upstairs?"

We got up from the table and began to walk to my room. I was really nervous about this, and it was really obvious. My legs were shaking beneath me and I had to somewhat hold myself up against Big Mac. It didn't take long before we made it upstairs and into my room. I looked at Big Mac and I could tell he was just as nervous as I was. I walked over to my bed and sat down, my cock stiffening in anticipation.

Big Mac looked at my cock, a lustful look growing across his face. It didn't take long before his cock began to get hard.

Now I see why they call him Big Mac. I wrapped my hoof around my cock and began to stroke it, a drop of precum flowing down onto my hoof, "Are you ready?"

"Eeyup." He walked up to my bed and knelt down in front of me.

I let go of my cock and let it bob in front of his face. He licked his lips and brought wrapped his hoof around my dick. I leaned myself back on my bed and spread my legs a bit more, a soft moan escaping my lips. He continued to stroke my cock, gently caressing ever sensitive spot he could find. I let out another moan as I began to buck my hips against his hoof, precum continuing to roll down my stiff member.

Big Mac looked up at me, "You like this babe?"

"Mmm...Fuck...I love it."

He grinned and leaned his head closer, licking my precum off of his hoof and my cock. I laid myself completely back as he continued to lick my shaft. I put my hoof on top of his head and began to push my cock into his mouth. He let out a soft hum, the vibrations sending a wave of pleasure shooting through my body. I pushed his head further down my cock. He took my hoof off of his head and soon began to take my whole cock into his mouth.

"Ohhh fuck...I-I don't know if I can take much more."

He continued to suck my cock, moaning blissfully from the taste of my precum. I continued to buck my hips, wanting to get my cock deeper into his mouth. It didn't take too much longer before the pleasure became too much for me. I put my hoof back on his head and pushed my cock as deep as I could get it before shooting a load of cum into his mouth. He did his best to swallow it all, but eventually he pulled my cock out of his mouth and let the rest run down the corner of his mouth.

I sat back up and looked at Big Mac, my cum still running down his face. I giggle and wiped it off with my hoof, "That felt amazing Big Mac. Are you sure you've never done this before?"

"I've got no reason to lie to you baby."

I put my hoof around him and gave him a deep kiss, getting a good taste of my cum. I let out a soft moan as I pushed my tongue a little bit deeper into his mouth. I was really enjoying the taste of my cum, but sadly, I had to break the kiss. "So...Do you want me to return the favor, or do you want to move on to the main event?"

"I think we should move on to the main event."

Before I could say anything else, Big Mac laid me back onto the bed again. He put his hooves on my flanks, gently messaging them. He pulled them apart, exposing my virgin plot-hole. I began to get nervous again and I soon began to get second thoughts about this. But, before I could protest, Big Mac leaned in and began to lick my ass, his tongue gently running over my tight entrance. I shuddered from having my ass licked for the first time. Big Mac pushed his tongue into me, wiggling it around every spot it could reach.

He pulled his tongue out of my ass and looked up at me, "Are you ready babe?" I gave him a slight nod, quickly growing more nervous. He got up from the floor and stood himself over me. He put his hoof and my cheek, "Don't be worried." He lined up his cock with my ass and began to lightly press his tip against it. I closed my eyes and tried not to think about it. He continued to press his cock tip against my entrance before it finally slid inside. I gasped from the sudden penetration. It was painful I will admit, but in an odd way, it felt really good. Big Mac looked down at me, "Are you alright?"

"I-I'm fine...It just kind of...hurts."

"Do you want me to take it out?"

"N-No...just...don't move for a little bit."

He stayed there, his cock still wedged in my ass. After about five minutes, I finally got used to having his cock in me and I began to move my hips against him. Quickly taking my hint, he began to thrust his hips, his cock going deeper and deeper into me. My cock began to get hard again and I wrapped my hoof around it.

Big Mac leaned forward and gave me a deep kiss, "Your ass feels so good...This is the best date ever."

He started to fuck me harder and faster, continuing to push himself deeper into me. My eyes rolled back in my head as I continued to jerk myself off. I couldn't hold myself back for much longer and I began to cum hard onto Big Mac's stomach. My asshole began to tighten around his cock, eager to milk him of all of his cum. Big Mac leaned in again and gave me one final kiss before cumming deep into my ass.

I move his hair out of his eyes as I cuddled closer closer into his hold, "That felt really good honey. I'm glad I had my first time with you."

He kissed my head, "So am I. I really had a great time with you tonight."

I closed my eyes and laid my head on his shoulder. I began to smell something weird, "Honey, what's that smell?"

"It smells like something's burning."

"Burning...burning." My eyes quickly shot open and I jolted up, "I FORGOT ABOUT THE PIE!"