At first, Diamond Tiara and Rumble payed no attention to the lights, doing things like they normally had done. Rumble stuck his crotch in between Diamond's breasts, feeling the wiggly sensation of it. He couldn't help but stare at her nipples, soon being dauntless enough to take a sharp, quick, bite. When Rumble once again came, Diamond Tiara moved her breasts around, trying to get them covered in semen. Rumble laughed, and then bit the nipple he had not bitten yet. But soon, they began to notice the lights.

"Er- um..." Diamond Tiara stammered as she began to notice that the lights were on.

Rumble rushed over to the lights and turned them back off.
Then they magically turned back on.
Off.
On.
Off.
On.
Off.
On.
*CLICK*
The light burned out.

Rumble sighed, finally in the darkness, and ran over to Diamond who was staring behind herself, unsure of what she'd seen.

"You okay?" asked Rumble, slowly opening her legs.

"Yeah, I just thought I saw... somepony in here. They turned the lights on," said Diamond, opening them herself. Rumble slowly put his head right in Diamond Tiara's opening, and with tentative, slow, licks, began to taste the juices sprouting out of her. After, he sat on Diamond and rubbed her breasts against his crotch. When he came, he instantly licked her breasts clean of the substance, and then began sticking his dick into her mouth. By then, Diamond Tiara wrapped her tongue around it, waiting for him to come, clutching his dick with her tongue ferociously.

Then, a light turned on.

This time, Diamond Tiara was sure of it.

"Button Mash, I see ya!" she tried to say, but it was difficult with Rumble's penis in her mouth.

Whispers came from that direction.

"Who else is there?" asked Rumble.

"Uh, nopony! We are just-"

"GHOSTS! Fear us!"

"OOOOOH! BOOO!!!"

"Seriously? We knew you're not ghosts. Button, come out!" said Rumble, popping it out of Diamond's mouth. Diamond tried to plop it back in, but Rumble retreated.

"Yes, we ARE ghosts!" said a squeaky voice.

"Wait, we really are?" asked Button.

"No! I'm just-" the squeaky voice replied.

Then, the light fully turned on. But the light was not it's usual shade of yellow/golden. It was green. And it wasn't real light. It was unicorn magic.

"BUTTON! Who is that with you?" asked Diamond Tiara, standing back up. But the light was too high, and you couldn't see who was making it.

"Nopony! Just my... um... JoyBoy," he said nervously.

"Right. Okay what are you even doing in here?" Diamond started. Then she realized. "Did you see us?"

Button nodded, looking at Rumble with a look of disgust. How could his friend do that? And with Diamond Tiara of all ponies available! It was unthinkable. But Button Mash kept a calm face and said,

"We were hiding, like you would probably guess. We wanted to be alone,"

"WHO IS THAT OTHER PONY?" roared Diamond, her blue eyes bulging.

"Sweetie Belle," she said herself.

"What? What are you two doing up here? We were actually worried! WAIT A SECOND! Were you two having sex?"

"NO!" They said in union.

"Oh, because I thought you guys actually had something going on here for a second. But why are you up here?" asked Rumble.

"Because we needed to talk," answered Sweetie Belle.

"About what?"

"Scootaloo,"

Then Diamond Tiara remembered. A few dares ago, it had actually been her own dare, Scootaloo had said something that made everypony angry, annoyed, and made Sweetie Belle curl up into a tiny ball. Diamond Tiara remembered that the only reason Scootaloo had not gone was because she had chosen Discord to go next. Because she had recently found out Discord had a crush on Scootaloo. But as she thought about it, Button Mash had been scooting over to Sweetie Belle, and Scootaloo had said,

"That should have been Button Mash and Sweetie Belle up there!" or something along those lines. She had said it when Snails had pinned her down and was rubbing her breasts.

"So, what else were you guys doing up here? Making some chemistry?"

"Unless you count the chemistry game on my new JoyBoy, nope."

"No, I mean kissing!"

Sweetie Belle nervously looked over at Button Mash.

"Uh, nope,"

"Now you're sounding like Big Mac! Just, were you?" asked Diamond, eagerly looking into the eyes of Sweetie Belle.

"No, except Button kissing me on the cheek,"

The filly screamed.

"You know NOTHING about relationships! Now, we have to get going and tell everypony we found you!"

Sweetie Belle gave Button Mash a nervous look. This would not be good. Everypony would be asking them what they had been doing up there if they chose truth. But if they chose dare, they would ask them to demonstrate. Even though they were not doing anything, they would have to make something up because then the audience wouldn't believe that they were bored, doing nothing. But telling the truth also meant saying what they had said about Scootaloo. And demonstrating it would mean Button Mash wasting half the battery in his JoyBoy to demonstrate what they had been up to, and the fifty or so ponies would not believe that was all that they had been doing anyways.

******

A few minutes later, there was a vast circle of ponies again, ready to begin the game. Silver Spoon, ready to go, eagerly said to her pink, lavender-maned friend,

"Diamond Tiara, truth or dare?"

"Truth," she answered.

"What were Button Mash and Sweetie Belle doing when you found them in the closet?"

The room went quiet.

Author's Note

COMMENT-DRIVEN SECTION! What would you guys like for Diamond Tiara to say for her question? Do you want her to lie? Tell the truth? Pick either one and leave a comment about what you would like to say! I will mention your name in my next chapter in the story and in the author's notes if you give the best answer.

Blue_Valentine

******CLOSED, SORRY******

Vote for next chapter ------->