Your heart thumps heavily in your chest as you hear her words. You wonder if Fluttershy can hear it through the thick silence of the bedroom.
"Y-you really want to?" You ask her nervously, still letting her question sink in.
She replies to you with a small nod, her mane covering most of her face, leaving a teal eye peeping through the soft pink curtains that you have caressed countless times, and reach a hand out to do it again. The soft hair flows through your fingers as you pet her, her head leaning into your hand. Her eyes are now closed as she... purrs? Shes never done that before.
Your heart melts as the yellow pony continues to act cat-like, drawing an "Awe" from you, as if she forces them out of other ponies.
She opens her eye halfway to look up at you with both eyes now that you have stroked her mane out of her face so you can see her. "Only if you want to," She said to you quietly, glancing away several times.
You stand up, and give her a light kiss on her forehead. "I'll be back later tonight. That okay?"
She nods again, and you both walk to the door to say your goodbyes for now.
You kiss her on the forehead, and close the door behind you as you walk out into the fresh air of the everfree and take a deep breath. Fluttershy had asked you for the first time in your relationship if you wanted to have sex, and you said yes. She also agreed to do anything you wanted to do with her, Almost as a slave. Thinking about a shy girl like her getting kinky in the bedroom was hard to vision, but enjoyable to try. You are also nervous, because she may not accept your... 'problem'. You never told her, in fear of scaring her. You have no idea how it happened because nobody seems to have any idea how you got to Equestria.
All you remember is waking up on the floor of the Everfree right next to Fluttershy's cottage, which is where she found you. No memories of any past life were present in your mind.
After breaking free of the foliage wall that blocked off the forest, you made your way to Sugarcube Corner to buy some cupcakes from the pink pony that would always try to seduce you even though you tell her you're with Flutters. You take the cupcakes and drop the bits in front of her. Once you turn, she says she wanted to show you something, but you quickly walk out of the bake shop and roll your eyes.
I'm gonna have to be completely honest with her tonight. Making her feel sad is like stealing things from foals
Your next destination is the library where Fluttershy's friend Twilight lives and works. You arrive and greet Twilight, her doing the same to you.
"Let me set those somewhere for you." She offers, her horn creating a purple aura around the box of cupcakes you have, setting them gently onto the table.
You thank her and kneel down, and place a necklace over her ears, and slide it down her neck. "You left this at Fluttershy's last time you came over."
"Thanks! How is she doing?" She smiles up at you, curious as to what her friend was up to.
"She's fine. But she asked me something I'm not really sure I can do." Twilight was the only pony who you told your secret to, in hope of her having a spell that can fix it. Unfortunately, her magic wasn't strong enough for those spells.
"And what would this favor be?" She asks, looking a little confused.
"Well, we've been together for a while now, and... she finally wants to have sex." You say, biting your lip in the agony of betraying Fluttershy's trust that you wouldn't tell anypony.
Twilight gives you a soft look. "Telling her the truth is your best option. If you don't, you know it could ruin your guys' relationship."
She's right. Lying to Fluttershy wouldn't be the greatest idea. First of all, she doesn't deserve it. She's by far the kindest being you've ever met. Second, she would just use... The Stare on you. You shiver at the thought.
"You're right. I'll tell her as soon as I see her tonight. Oh, and uh, can we just keep this between us? She'd probably die of embarrassment if she found out I told you about this."
"Of course. I understand that we all need privacy. Your secret is safe with me."
You pick up the cupcakes and thank Twilight before heading out the door.
When you arrive back at the cottage, you stop at the front door and breathe deeply. This is probably the hardest thing you've ever had to do since you've arrived in Equestria. The thing that worries you the most is the possibility of her leaving you. She wouldn't do that after all this time... Would she?
You put slowly twist the doorknob, and push the door in, stepping into the house, and walking into the kitchen to put the cakes down somewhere. Once you do, you turn to see Fluttershy smiling sweetly at you.
Forcing a smile on your face, you walk to her and kneel so you're both eye level with each other and you pet her left ear gently, stroking the fur on the outside as the other one twitches. Her eyes close, and she purrs quietly.
Her eyes slowly open, and look up at you. "I don't want to wait any longer."
Her words are like a dagger pushed through one side of your body and out the other. "Well... there's something I have to tell you."
She nods slightly, letting you know you could tell her.
Your palms sweat as you sigh noticeably, and unbutton your jeans. "I'm not really..."
She smirks a little and pulls the zipper down with her teeth, and continues to lower her head, sliding your pants down.
What happens next, you will never forget. Her shock was showing on her face as she raised a hoof to her mouth. "Y-you... You're a doll?"
Between your legs was a hard shell of skin colored plastic. The reason for this was because Fluttershy found you near Zecora's hut. A failed experiment that she thought was dead, so she threw out. All these memories flood back to you as Fluttershy looks down in disappointment.
"I was hoping you wouldn't freak out over this." You say, holding your hand under her chin. "Just because we can't have sex doesn't mean we cant be together, right?"
(notice the day this was published)
Wrong
Fluttershy forces her hoof across your face in disgust and kicks you out of the house, breaking up with you and throwing the cupcakes at you, covering you in frosting.
Happy april fools day!!!!!
The End.
Author's Note
I apologize to those of you who read all the way through this poorly written fic, but I also applaud you for having the stomach for this low level writing. I hope you understand this was all fun and games, and I will be sure to make it up to you in the future. Happy April fools day and yes, I'm sorry not really bye
