First to Whinny Rematch

by Nocturnal Derp

Rating: mature
Tags: Romance
Length: 2807

Twilight may or may not be a little sore about losing last time... So she decides tonight is a good night to poke the mare until she takes the bait and falls into her trap.

Due to popular demand, and my own fun writing this I have chosen to finish the rematch.

Twilight lures Trixie into a rematch of their fun little sexy game.
However is poking fun at Trixie really a good idea before participating in such activities?
Well Twilight is about to find out.

VIEWERS WARNING:If you have not figured it out… Clop. F/F Pretty descriptive. Just thought I should let you know.

Twixie is best ship.

Sequel to First to Whinny
Though can be read alone.

Cover Art By the-smiling-pony On Deviant Art

[size=0.75em]I'm aware cover art for Twilight has wings. She has no wings in the story. Sorry…[/size]

[size=0.5em]There will be a tie breaker if I can get enough people on board for it.[/size]

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2014-10-04 14:20:05 UTC

Here We Go Again

       Two unicorns sat on the couch in their living room. One was watching a movie that filled the room with flashing light and noise while the other read a book paying no interest to the movie at all. Trixie suddenly burst out laughing, pointing a forehoof at the screen before looking over at Twilight. When she got no response from the book worm she crossed her forelegs, pouting. What she didn't see was the corner of Twilight's mouth turn up in amusement.

Trixie threw Twilight a sideways glance when she heard the audible turn of a page. “Did you see that?” Trixie asked, pointing her hoof back to the screen.

“Huh? Oh, no sorry.” Twilight replied without so much as an eye turned her way.

With an exaggerated sigh Trixie turned her attention back to the movie which she could no longer enjoy. She hated being ignored. Even if Twilight were to at least ask her to just let her read she would be alright but the purple mare had barely even acknowledged her presence in the last hour.

Trixie brushed her tail across the side of Twilight's leg and got nothing but a flick of her ear as a reaction. For the next ten minutes the magician made no move to get her attention, hoping she would pull her muzzle out of the book on her own accord. However with each turn of the page Trixie became more and more impatient. At last she tried a more direct approach.

“Twilight... Hey... Damnit Sparkle!” Trixie growled.

Twilight turned her and gave the blue mare a look of ignorant innocence. “Yes Trixie?” She asked.

Trixie was dumbfounded for a moment until the realization hit her. She was doing this on purpose. “Nothing, enjoy your book.”

“Okay.” Twilight replied simply, returning to her story as if nothing had happened.

For a few minutes Trixie pretended to forget the whole thing and pay Twilight no mind. Without warning she tackled Twilight from where she was sitting. Unfortunately the pair fell off the couch when Twilight had recoiled from shock. Trixie was able to maintain her position on top when they landed however and she took Twilight's forehooves with her own pinning her to the floor.. Twilight no longer held the act and grinned up at her attacker. “Took you long enough.”

“Shut up Sparkle.” Trixie sneered, having been played for a filly.

“Oh? What are you going to do if I don't?” Twilight asked mockingly.

If it had been any other pony that had challenged her so, she probably would have tried to blast them into oblivion.

What worried Twilight was the wicked grin that grew upon her muzzle. She did not have long to contemplate the gesture. Trixie dropped her head down to Twilight's shoulder and bit down, enticing something between a scream and a squeal from the purple mare. She probably bit her a little harder than she should have but Twilight deserved it.

Twilight struggled beneath Trixie and cried out. “Trixie please, that hurts!” Twilight exclaimed.

Maybe a little too hard. Trixie released her and looked down at Twilight with concern. “I'm sorry.” She backed away as Twilight held her injury with her right forehoof. “Are you alright?” She felt even more ashamed when Twilight got up to her hooves with a pained look instead of answering her.

Trixie closed her eyes and let her head hang low in shame having let her anger go like that. Not a second later she felt something crash against her and knock her off her hooves. When she opened her eyes Twilight was standing over her smiling.

“Aww, your so sweet Twixie, worried about your little book worm?” Twilight asked, bopping Trixie on the nose with her right forehoof.

Her face lit up with color. “Twilight... You shouldn't play like that... I thought I hurt you.” Trixie replied, guilt ridden.

It was Twilight's turn to feel bad. She knelt down over her and nuzzled the side of her neck. “You're right, I'm sorry... It did kinda hurt but...” She brought her muzzle to the Magicians ear. “But I kinda liked it.” She whispered, nipping the side of her ear to reinforce her meaning before pulling her head back up.

It was then that Trixie realized her own arousal, often a side effect from getting angry... Then it dawned on her. Twilight must have been exploiting that to get what she wanted. (I'll give it to her alright, but she isn't going to enjoy it.) Trixie brought one of her hind legs up between Twilight's legs.

Twilight squeaked, then narrowed her eyes down at Trixie. “Geez, now you get it. As smart as you are you can be pretty dense som-mmph.” Her sentence cut short by Trixie's lips brought abruptly to her own.

Trixie broke the rough kiss a moment later. “Shut up Sparkle, you're gonna get what you want, but you're not gonna like it.”

“Feisty, I like it.”

“Careful what you wish for.” Trixie warned as she drug her hind leg across Twilight's marehood.

Twilight shuddered, then just as she was moving to retaliate she was bewildered to  find she couldn't move her hooves. Upon examination she found blue rings of aura around each of her legs, then looked to see that in fact, Trixie's horn was glowing. “Hey! That's not fair Trixie! You're cheating.”

“Cheating?” The magician almost effortlessly rolled Twilight over with the help of her magic. Their positions reversed Trixie spread Twilight's forelegs out to her sides and her hind ones spread out as Twilight struggled against the magic. “No, I'm just spicing up our game a little bit.”

Twilight gave up her struggle and smiled up at her. “You sure you want to do this?” When Trixie did not answer her own horn began to glow.

Trixie flinched as her spell broke and Twilight's forehooves wrapped themselves around her neck, pulling her into another aggressive kiss, though this time Twilight forced her tongue inside of the magician's mouth, seeking an early dominance.

Instead of struggling to keep her hooves planted to the floor Trixie collapsed atop of her, hoping to keep her pinned with her weight before Twilight tried anything. An unusual warm tingling coursed through her limbs and body as their tongues wrestled inside their muzzles.

The feeling left her struggling to concentrate on the task at hoof, a struggle she was losing. Little moans and whimpers escaped her muzzle through their embrace until Trixie finally pulled away panting. Twilight's horn was glowing and her own body was shrouded in her aura.

Trixie's struggled to concentrate as she neutralized Twilight's magic with her own in an attempt to subdue her arousal from taking control. Twilight did nothing to stop her and giggled up at her assailant. Even after she released the spell she found the mare's face still ripe with color from the intense heat and pressure that had already built itself inside her.

“Is Twixie feewing okay?” She asked innocently, bringing a forehoof to her muzzle and nibbling at it cutely.

Her response was a low growl from the mare who glared down at her.

Twilight wasn't going to wait for her opponent to recover, and resumed her spell.

The tingling resumed in her body despite her efforts to break the spell. She closed her eyes, concentrating on maintaining control.

Twilight brought her forehooves up and gently pushed Trixie away so she could get back on her hooves. Despite the simplicity of the spell, fighting to maintain it against the magician started to drain her. So as soon as she recovered to her hooves she put an end to the magic.

Again Trixie was left panting from her efforts. She was both relieved and disappointed the enchantment had ended. Maybe this wasn't such a good idea. Trixie suddenly had doubts about breaking the magic rule to their usual game. Her doubt was somewhat extinguished when she saw Twilight's own exhaustion and figured that was the reason she hadn't pounced the moment she was up.

Trixie wasn't going to wait. She drove her shoulder into Twilight's chest in an attempt to overpower her but the purple mare kept to her hooves. Twilight wrapped a forehoof around Trixie's neck and dropped her weight down to bring Trixie to the ground. Both mare's grunted and growled with the effort however slowly but surely Trixie's legs gave way and she soon found herself pinned to her belly by the book worm.

Twilight made sure to keep her forehooves on Trixie to keep her pinned while she rotated around her, straddling her back and hooking the heels of her hind legs into Trixie's hind hooves so she would have trouble bracing herself to get up. That did not stop Trixie's struggles though it did much to make it easier on Twilight. Twilight leaned forward and took Trixie's left ear in her muzzle and nibbled at it while pulling gently on her blue mane.

Trixie tried to pull her ear away gently but whenever she did Twilight bit down enough to discourage any further attempts. She was just toying with her, probably trying to calm down herself while playing with the magician just enough to keep her hot. While Trixie knew this there wasn't much she could do about it.

“You know Trixie.” Twilight breathed into Trixie's ear, her voice just above a whisper with a hint of mischief. “You're being really bad tonight, I think maybe.” She stopped and nipped at the end of her ear. “I think maybe you're gonna have to pay for it.”

Trixie could feel Twilight's hoof making its way up to her horn. In a desperate act of defiance she went to use a spell but Twilight took hold just as she was about to cast it. The jolt from the contact stole her concentration and Trixie let out an audible gasp. “S-Sparkle, i-i-if you d-don't le-ah, ahh.” Trixie gritted her teeth when she felt the slick wet tongue of Twilight drag it's way slowly up her horn. She wasn't given a second to breath before the process repeated itself, again and again.

All of the nerves in her horn were going haywire, making magic improbable at this point. Her horn was growing warm and thanks to Twilight;s tongue, moist. Maybe Twilight wasn't just playing with her. Either Trixie got away now, or she was done. Just as she was about to attempt to dislodge Twilight however, the entirety of her horn was taken into Twilight's mouth.

Trixie was done. She whimpered like a filly and shut her eyes as Twilight suckled on the sensitive tip before going down on it again, just to pull slowly up, keeping her lips firmly sealed around her horn. All the while using her free hoof to massage Trixie's chest and grinding gently on her back. Trixie's heat was nearly unbearable and she could feel the juices of her slick arousal begin to run down her leg.

“Twilight I-I give up, just please. Neeigh Neeeigh.” Trixie would have felt shame if pleasure and suffering were not already in control of her mind.

Twilight couldn't help but grin, even though her own heat was taking its toll on her body. “I'm sorry Trixie, we never actually said we were playing. I'm afraid you're cute little pleas and whinnies won't get you out of this one.” She gave the end of Trixie's ear a gentle flick with her tongue.

“Twilight! Please that's not fair. Please!” She whimpered a bit more, shifting underneath her assailant to relieve some of the heat radiating from her marehood.

“I don't know. Is Trixie sorry for being bad?” Twilight asked with play full malice as she traced the end of Trixie's horn with the tip of her hoof. Though Twilight could not debate the eagerness in her own voice. Whether Trixie begged or not she would end this soon.

“Yes, T-Trixie is very sorry. How long w-will you let her suffer?” Trixie moaned.

Twilight basked in the desperation in Trixie's voice. “This would been over a lot sooner if you would not have been so rough with Twilight.” She giggled having mocked Trixie's third person speech.

She pulled her self away from Trixie to give her space. “Roll over.”

Trixie wasted no time in obeying the command. When she was on her back she looked down at Twilight, giving her the cutest most begging look she could muster, all remnants of her ego gone from her eyes.

Twilight wasn't wasting any more time with her dominance game and crawled back over top the magician. Though she did take the time to give the end of Trixie's muzzle an affectionate lick. Without further delay Twilight spread Trixie's hind legs with her own, thrust her pussy onto Trixie's and began to grind. Trixie gasped and bit down on Twilight's shoulder when she doubled over.

The pace of the grind escalated quickly with no real rhythm. The juices from each of their pussies made the contact slick and virtually non abrasive. Twilight could feel her climax building but it just wasn't coming fast enough for her.

Trixie released her bite on Twilight's shoulder and gave Twilight a half pleading, half questioning look when Twilight lifted herself away. Before she could reject however Twilight took her forehoof in her own and pulled it down to her own pussy. Trixie understood and with no further assistance began to rub vigorously at her marehood. In turn Twilight returned the favor, using her free forehoof to uphold the bulk of her weight.

The rougher and more abrasive texture of their hooves added the much needed friction to speed up the process. Not to mention the narrower and more concentrated contact.

Both mares were grunting and whimpering with the effort to please one another and the effects their efforts were having on each other. Trixie's hoof stopped moving as she tensed up, holding on as long as she could. She gritted her teeth, arched her back and with a loud unintentional whinny she exploded in  blissful release.

Twilight did not want to short change Trixie and kept up the pressure until the final shudder racked Trixie's body. With a sigh of relief Twilight brought her other hoof up and to the floor by Trixie to help support herself. Her other foreleg had grown tired of the full bearing.

Twilight looked down at Trixie expectantly who blushed as she remembered. “Sorry.” She smiled and began her assault on Twilight's pussy once more. With the support of both her forehooves she was able to lean over and now it was her turn . She stifled her own moans by biting down on Trixie's shoulder until at last the end drew near. She tried not to bite down too hard when her climax hit but she heard Trixie squeal a bit though she made no move to stop Twilight.

After Twilight recovered from her orgasm she released Trixie, pulled her head up and looked down at the mare under her. Trixie had a big stupid grin on her face even though she had been belittled beyond measure. “Well?” Trixie asked.

“Celestia's sun Trixie. That, that was more fun, wow. I don't know.” Twilight blushed.

“Told you playing rough made it better.” Trixie smirked.

“Yeah.” Twilight agreed, rolling one of her shoulders. “Kinda sore though.”

“You bit Trixie too!” Trixie whined.

“I know.” Twilight sat and straddled Trixie's waist to keep her pinned. With a devilish grin she raised the hoof that was still covered in Trixie's love juice. The lowered it to a confused looking Trixie's muzzle. “Lick it.”

“What! No!” Trixie struggled but was too tired to get away. “Twilight why?” She whined, giving up the vain effort.

Twilight shrugged. “You lost. Lick it.”

“Trixie will not.” She crossed her forelegs over her chest and looked away with a pout.

“Then we will stay here until you do.” Twilight smirked.

“Twiiiiiilight! Come on.” Trixie uncrossed her forelegs and looked back up at the purple mare. “I did it last time.”

“No I kissed you last time.”

“Sparkle, let me up this instant.” She huffed.

All Twilight did was push her hoof ever closer to Trixie's muzzle.

Trixie growled then sighed in defeat. “Fine.” With much reluctance she brought her muzzle to Twilight's hoof, slick with her own arousal. She closed her eyes so she wouldn't have to witness the act so much as taste it. Just so Twilight couldn't complain she drug her tongue up Twilight's hoof slowly and deliberately, shuddering upon completion of the act.

Before Trixie could whine anymore Twilight wrapped her in her forelegs and kissed her. When she let her go and saw Trixie's whole face was red she giggled.

“Only for you Twilight.” Trixie gave Twilight another quick peck on the lips. “Only for you.”