A Wish Fulfilled

by Chelis

Rating: mature
Tags: Romance, Self Insert, Equestria Girls, Sex, Sunset Shimmer
Length: 3394

When someone asked Sunset Shimmer for the last dance, it sparked the beginning of a friendship and relationship between the two.

I expected Sunset Shimmer to laugh me off when I asked her to dance with me. But, little did I know that that question would lead to the first of many great days between us to come.

Edited by DustyPwny!

Published 2014-10-15 11:20:03 UTC
Last updated 2017-07-05 14:57:43 UTC

Save the Last Dance for Me

There she is.

My mind was racing faster than a race car, and my heart was hurting from the multiple skipped beats it endured thought the evening. Palms were sweating, mom's spaghetti, nervous.

I admired her from afar, which described our entire relationship; look at her from a distance while she just stayed with her group of friends. Of course, the school unanimously hated her and rightly so; but there was something I really liked about her. Her bitchy attitude before she changed was attractive. To me, it meant she was an independent woman who needed no man, not even Flash Sentry when they dated. She was incredibly adorable reformed. Her hair was a mesmerizing mixture of red and yellow. Her natural curls were irresistible. She was ten-out-of-ten; would have sex with for the sole purpose of procreation.

She didn't dance much that particular night. Other than the six friends that accepted her, no one else wanted anything to do with her. I guess I kinda felt her pain, especially since my clique not much into the social scene. I ended up coming alone for the sole purpose of asking Sunset Shimmer to dance with me.

The DJ played another song, and announced it was to be the second to last song for the night.

Now or never.

I got up and slowly made my way to her table, which was on the other side of the gym. I struggled to move through the piles of dancing couples, the girl groups grinding on each other and other guys trying to dance with those groups of girls.

I made it out on the other side, barely. It was packed for the last two songs. The five friends were all tired from their dancing. Sunset Shimmer was not. Most of the night she looked at the dance floor she once owned in her bad-girl days.

It wasn't a look of jealousy either. It was a look of wanting to belong again.

I began to shake. The butterflies in my stomach were moving faster with the step towards her table. Her dress made her look like a goddess. The fact that the dress was slanted to one end to expose her upper thighs drove me into a lustful madness.

Here goes-.

She looked at me.

SHE’S LOOKING AT ME!

It was probably for less than a second. She gave me a small, uninterested 'oh hey' smile before she turned back to watch the dance floor. I froze up, unsure of what to do. That probably was the first time she’d ever had seen me. The protective bubble of her not knowing my existence had been busted, and I felt naked.

Get this over with, now!

I took a few more steps, and arrived at the edge of her table.

"H-Hey, Sunset Shimmer..."

She looked at me, prompting the rest of the table to look at me. Sunset and the girls were curious now.

"W-want to d-dance?"

Sunset was surprised. She looked to her friends for an answer. They all give her the look and motion that screamed 'Go! Go!'

She looked to me and gave me that precious smile that always made my heart melt. "Sure."

***

Good news was I managed to dance with her. Bad news was that I forgot that I didn't know how to dance. When she realized that, she taught me on the spot. If I had known how to dance, it would have been as less entertaining than having Sunset Shimmer teach me and then learning through trial and error at her expense. Sunset had a real smile and laughed for the first time that night. By the time I’d gotten the steps down and gotten into the rhythm of things, the last song was already over.

Principal Celestia thanked everyone for attending and told us to drive home safely.

Whelp, scratch that off the bucket list. At least she knows me now.

Everyone began to shuffle for the exits. The guys grabbed their coats and the girls picked up their purses. What’s done was done. The only thing left to do that night was to whack off to Sunset's yearbook photos.

"Well, I'll see you at school, Sunset," I said as I began my heartbreaking separation from her. It felt like a dagger through the heart as I walked away. But, it all stopped when I felt a grip on my wrist.

"The girls want to go out to dinner. Wanna to join us?" Sunset Shimmer asked.

My heart jumped. "Really?"

"Yeah, you seem cool," Sunset answered.

"Thanks. Want a ride?"

"Sure?" she answered. I guess she was expecting me to be driving some beat-up ninety's car.

***

"Whoa!" Rainbow Dash commented.

"Oh, my," Rarity added.

"I'll give it to ya, that's mighty impressive." Sunset replied.

My Camaro was thirty years old. When I inherited it from my uncle a few months ago, it looked like it was headed to the scrap heap. I spent every last dime of my eighteenth-birthday gift money reviving it to its former glory. What made the muscle car stand out was the black body and the gold stripes.

"Thanks girls. It was a present for my eighteenth birthday."

"Lucky you. My eighteenth birthday was the day I was given a job and bills to pay." Sunset Shimmer added.

"That sucks. Doors unlocked by the way."

"Shotgun!" Rainbow Dash called out.

Rarity and Sunset took the back seats as Rainbow enjoyed the passenger seat.

***

"So... You. What can you tell us about yourself?" Rarity asked on the way to Sugar Cube Corner.

"I don't know. I guess I just go to school because I have to?"

“I know that feel," Sunset added.

"So, what do you like about Sunset?" Rainbow Dash asked menacing smirk.

I saw Sunset blush with embarrassment through the rear view mirror. I wanted to say that I had my heart set for her the moment I saw her, even if she was cruel back then. I guess sometimes beauty can exist in ugly places. Sunset was a prime example. At the same time, I didn’t want to creep her out.

"She is cool, and cute," I answered.

Both 'How cute' and 'Awwww' came from Rarity and Dash. Sunset Shimmer tried to hide in embarrassment, but she did not have that studded leather jacket of hers.

***

Sugar Cube Corner was busy, and almost all the seats were filled. The rest of Sunset's friends had a table and enough seats for everyone. I helped Sunset to her chair. Everyone noticed and smiled at me. At that moment, I was 'the new guy'.

Learning more about Sunset Shimmer and her friends was a fun time. Her friends were friendly, sweet, and any positive word I could use. With every word Sunset spoke I felt more and more attracted to her. She had a way with her words and a way with my heart.

As we waited for our dinner, Pinkie and I had a milkshake drinking contest: I lost. Terribly. It was actually a blowout, but everyone always lost to Pinkie Pie in a milkshake-drinking contest.

Sunset and I had another chance to talk during my recovery from what had to be the worst brain freeze in my life. Eventually, I told her of my real hobby: tabletop gaming and tabletop gaming accessories.

"Sounds like fun," Sunset said with a small smile.

That answer made my mouth drop. I expected a laugh and to be called a 'nerd', but that didn’t happen at all. Sunset clearly had changed. It made my heart jump with joy.

"You don't mind?" I asked

"Why would I? You think I wouldn't be interested in fantasy?" She asked.

"Not really."

She smiled. "You have more to learn about me. And when you do, it'll all make sense."

Another group took a seat across from us. Sunset looked and recognized the boy with the blue hair.

"Ugh."

"What?" I asked as I turned around. Sunset grabbed the top of my head and directed my face to hers.

"Don't look. My ex."

"Oh."

"Yeah..."

"Flash Sentry. I guess after we broke up he became arrogant." Sunset lamented.

"Superiority complex?"

"I think so. I'm not a nerd like you," Sunset joked.

"So Flash! Who was that girl you dated!?" one of Flash Sentry's friends spoke up.

"WHO?! SUNSET SHIMMER?! COMPLETE BITCH! I MEAN, IF SHE WAS TRYING TO WIN, LIKE, 'BITCH OF THE YEAR' OR SOMETHING, SHE WOULD’VE WON TOP HONORS ON THE SPOT. HONESTLY, SHE JUST NEEDS TO GET LAID BY MY MASSIVE THICK COCK!"

The way he talked about her was disgusting. Sunset's eyes were seething with anger.

"Why don't you kick his ass or something?" I asked.

"If I was my old self I would’ve slap the taste out of his mouth by now." Sunset responded as she tried to use piles of napkins as a stress ball. The rest of the girls looked like they wanted to say something, but calling Flash out was something they couldn't do, for various reasons.

Fuck it.

"YOU KNOW HOW MANY TIMES SHE SUCKED MY DICK GUYS?!" Flash threw his arms in the arm with a bewildered expression.

"HOW MANY TIMES SHE SUCKED YO DICK!?" His friends bellowed.

"I don't know, but I bet your mom has sucked more."

That caught Flash's attention.

"WHO THE FUCK SAID THAT?!" He screamed. He looked in my direction and knew I was the guy. It was probably because I was the only one in the room standing. I took a quick side glance to Sunset Shimmer, and saw the fear in her. She looked more worried about my safety than anything else.

"It was you, huh? I know you. You're that one geek."

"And?"

"Why don't you play more Dungeons and Dragons, nerd. And leave real-talk to the cool people."

"Then what are you doing here?"

The entire place was drowned in a collective 'Ooooooooooo'.

He walked up to me and stopped when we were inches apart.

"You think you are funny, huh?"

"Funnier than you."

More 'oohs' were heard. Flash was frustrated and his short temper was evident. I was, without a doubt, scared shit less. But it was either that or let him act like an ass to Sunset.

"You know what, small fry? Fuck off." Flash said as he gave me a push.

My fist instinctively aimed for the head when I felt his hands. Had he not pushed me, my hand would have missed.  Instead, it landed on his temple. He went limp and fell to the ground.

The entirety of Sugar Cube Corner lost their mind in a howl laughter. The decompression of the adrenaline would have helped, but seeing Flash's friends make their way to me was not helping. I felt a tug to my hand. Sunset was holding my hand, and was trying to drag me out through the back door.

"Run!"

We found our way through the second exit and began a sprint to my car. She let go of my hand and went to the passenger side. I pulled out the keys as I arrived to the driver door and opened it.  I opened the passenger door as I turned on the car. As soon as she was sitting I took off. I looked back and saw Flash's friends’ race towards their cars, and we knew that the ordeal was not over yet.

"What the hell were you thinking?!" Sunset screamed at me. Luckily the streets were empty so I had no traffic to deal with.

"I don't know! It just happened!" I answered. Weak explanation, but I really was not thinking when I threw the punch.

Flash and his crew were catching up. They had the maneuverability advantage with their imports, but I had more power under the hood. So I floored it and killed the lights. It was stupid and risky, but as soon as it looked like I could have pulled it off, I turned into the nearest alley. Sunset and I looked back and waited to see if the plan worked.

It worked like a charm.

We watched as the 5 imports and one muscle car blaze past us. It felt like a great weight was lifted from us. We began to laugh and hug as the stress from the chase bled out. We laid in our seats for a good five minutes, searching for something to say.

"So, want to go get some food?" I asked.

"Didn't we just come from dinner?" Sunset asked.

"Yea, but how much did we actually eat?"

"Good point," Sunset said as she strapped on her seat belt. "So, where are we going?"

"I know this cool Chinese Food place in the city."

"Why would we go to the city for food?"

"You want to look for food while your crazy ex wants to commit double homicide on us?"

***

There is a small park on top of a hill called 'Lover’s Point' that overlooks the city. Although it was a very stereotypical place to go - we both even joked about that on the way there - it seemed like a nice place to cap off the night.

I had to teach her how to use chopsticks. It took her a while, but she managed to get the hang of it. As we looked on towards the beauty of the lights of the city, I wished that the night would never end.

"I have a question about your old ways."

"Sure?" Sunset answered. She looked uneasy.

"Why?"

"Honestly, it’s a long and complicated story. I don't think I'm ready to tell anyone the whole story."

"It's fine, but I knew you weren't pure evil, anyway."

"Really? How?"

"There's no way someone as beautiful as you can be that evil." I said with a warm smile.

"That's cute, but I know you are just trying to flatter me at this-"

"Sunset, I had a crush on you since freshman year. I had always admired you from afar because I saw how you were. I waited for years for this opportunity to know the real you. And, I'm glad I waited. "

Now's my chance.

I leaned closer to her, she did the same. My heart was beating as fast as it could. Then came the kiss.

Her lips were soft, the smell of her hair was invigorating, and I held her hand as we kissed. It was soft and silky.

She was perfect.

Her grin was one of mischief.

"You know, there is still some part of me that is bad."

"Oh?" I asked.

She did not answer. She violently shoved me on the hood of my car. The blow from my head to the hood dazed me a bit. She then jumped on top of me and shoved her tongue down my throat.

We were like that for a while, but I slowly moved my hands from her back to her lower back, and then to her bottom. She had no problem with it and went deeper in her kisses the farther down I reached.

Might as well go for it.

Her panties were as soft as her skin, but that was not what I wanted

Every second I spent with Sunset Shimmer that night drove me to what I wanted. I had it with our kiss. Sunset wanted more, so who was I to deny the woman that meant the world to me her desires.

I slipped my hands into her panties, and slowly made their way to her moist opening.

As soon as she realized what I was planning to do, she broke off the tongue action.

"Do you even know what you are doing? Being a nerd and all..." She asked.

"I passed health class with an A+?" I attempted to pass her test.

"Good enough for me," she said as continued to kiss me.

The second I slipped my finger inside her moist pussy, her skin had goose bumps. She moved her body in an attempt to get more of my fingers inside. Although the light fingerbanging was a fun appetizer, I wanted the full course.

"Want to head to the back seat?" I asked.

"No, it's on my bucket list to have sex on the hood of a Camaro."

While we were still locked tongue-in-tongue, Sunset pulled my fingers from her womanhood. She grabbed my hands, and moved them to my crotch; more importantly my zipper. As I zipped it down, she parted her panties to the side and waited for me to pull it out.

She knew it was out because the head was poking one of her thighs. She grasped it and moved it to where it needed to be, then slid herself onto my cock slowly. It felt wet and a bit slimy, but it was a feeling I’d never felt before.

Sunset moaned with every inch that went inside of her. As soon as I was all the way inside, she pulled her blouse down to reveal her C-cup breasts.

We locked eyes, and I felt confident about what I wanted to tell her since I first saw her.

"I love you."

She answered that with a deep kiss and her pelvic motions. Every move from her felt amazing on my penis. She went from moving her hips to bouncing her entire body off of me. She stopped kissing me and began to moan loudly into my ear. Every moment was bliss.

As she continued, I began to suck on her breasts. That made Sunset moan even louder, and her movements on my dick much more intense. I felt the pressure increasing, and I knew this magic moment was about to end real soon.

I stopped sucking and went back to kissing her. She buried her tongue deep, and did not want to let go.

I was seconds away from cumming, so I held on to her ass to make Sunset stop and I pulled out.

I came all over her ass, and some of the goo even landed on me. Sunset fell on my chest, and laid there. Every other second she gave me a quick peck on the lips. She wanted to keep going, but she knew the fun had to end sometime.

***

We were lucky that no one else was on the overlook because she was on my chest for a good half-hour. We exchange small kisses and enjoyed each other's loving embrace.

"I hate to do this, but can you take me home?" Sunset asked as she yawned.

"Alright."

It turned out she actually wanted to be dropped off at Pinkie Pie's. They planned a sleepover, but since I happened the plan went a bit wanky.

"Still worth it." Sunset said, as she rested on my shoulder on the way home. I wrapped my hands around her and enjoyed the silence between us. I felt like the luckiest man in the world. Because although Sunset was not perfect, she was as perfect to me as anyone else at school.

There was one light on at the Pie house at 3 AM. I assumed that was the room where the sleepover was happening.

Youtube Video

My suspicions were correct when I saw five figures peer out from the window. I parked the car, got out, and opened the door for Sunset. I walked her to the door, and felt my heart sink because I realized we were done for the night.

"I wish tonight was a whole lot longer," I lamented.

"Yeah, especially at Lover’s Point," she giggled as she gave me a kiss on the cheek. "Thank you, it was one of the greatest nights I've ever had. By the way, tonight counted as the first date."

My heartbeat began to increase again when she revealed that.

"Really? So how about a second date?"

PLEASE SAY YES. PLEASE SAY YES. PLEASE SAY YES!

Sunset Shimmer's answer was another deep kiss. The room overhead exploded in 'Awws' and general excitement.

"Sure. Goodnight," she said as Pinkie Pie opened the front door.

I began my lonely walk back to my car. Somehow, the realization of what happened that night sunk in fully and I involuntarily gave myself a fist pump. I straightened my coat, got back in my car, and drove off into the waning night.

First Date

Something has gone wrong. We don't seem to have an archived copy of that chapter.

Harvest Day

Something has gone wrong. We don't seem to have an archived copy of that chapter.

All I want for Christmas is You

Something has gone wrong. We don't seem to have an archived copy of that chapter.

Empire of the Sun

Something has gone wrong. We don't seem to have an archived copy of that chapter.

Motorstyle

Something has gone wrong. We don't seem to have an archived copy of that chapter.

Vanguard

Something has gone wrong. We don't seem to have an archived copy of that chapter.