Only You

by Pinkyshy101

Rating: mature
Tags: Pinkie Pie, Gore, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Fluttershy
Length: 1386

Fluttershy takes an unassuming Pinkie Pie into her home. Pinkie thinks that they are just going to hang out, but Fluttershy has other plans in mind.

This is a creepypasta story about Fluttershy and Pinkie Pie. If the title doesn't make any sense at all, its because it was for a story for school. We had read a story in which the final words were "only you" and we had to make a story with that title. Me being the crazy brony that I am made it MLP.
The webstite that I originally posted this on was a website called Figment. I'm just saying this so that if you see this and think I'm copying it, I'm not. Where I originally posted this story
The cover was a request I made on deviantArt. Here's the link: http://pallet-pride.deviantart.com/art/Only-You-493557582
I'm not really good at descriptions...

Published 2014-10-19 15:40:03 UTC
Last updated 2014-10-19 15:40:03 UTC

Chapter 2

Pinkie Pie sat her cup down on the table.

"Thanks Fluttershy, but I promised Mrs. Cake I'd help her today. She's got a huge order to fill today and she needs help!"

Fluttershy was worried. "Pinkie, its ok. You can do that later. For now I have something... special... planned, just for the two of us." Fluttershy wore an evil grin on her face. Pinkie looked scared and confused.

"Sorry Fluttershy I really have to —" Pinkie collapsed. Fluttershy grinned. All was going according to plan.

Chapter 3

Pinkie Pie jumped up. Or rather, she tried to. She was strapped down to a table in a dark room. She was terrified. She looked around. She couldn't see anything. She tried again to break free, but her efforts were in vain. Suddenly a blind light switched on above her head. She looked around. She saw some shadows, shadows that looked like other ponies! She also smaller other, smaller shadows. Like... animals...

"...Fluttershy?"

"About time you woke up," a gentle voice said. "I've been waiting for ages."

Chapter 5

Fluttershy went upstairs into her cottage. She called for her animals.

"Can you come to me, please? Its time." They quickly scattered over to her.

"Are you guys all ready?" The animals nodded. "Good. Now lets go."

Fluttershy walked downstairs with her animal friends. Pinkie was still unconscious on the table. She walked around the table waiting for Pinkie to wake up.

"Any minute now..." She quietly said. As if on cue, Pinkie's eyes opened.

"Fluttershy..." her eyes filled up with tears. "Please... just let me go. Please." Fluttershy laughed.

"Oh Pinkie Pie. I wish I could. but the animals need something to eat."

"Wha...what?"

"You heard me."

"Fluttershy! No! You don't know what you're-"

"But I do. You remember when Twilight went missing?"

Pinkie nodded, nervous.

Fluttershy nodded towards her animals. On cue, Angel bunny flicked on the lights. The room lit up and Pinkie looked around. She could clearly see that she was in Fluttershy's basement. She could also see numerous piles of bones and hair scattered on the floor. In one corner of the room, near the door, there was a small pile of bones with purple hair and some flesh scattered near it. She squinted her eyes. Looking closer, she saw that it... was Twilight...

"WHAT DID YOU DO TO TWILIGHT?!??!" Pinkie Pie yelled in rage. Her normally poofy hair went flat. She mane and coat darkened. "I said, where is Twilight?!?!?!" Fluttershy laughed.

"You're staring at her, silly."

"But..." Pinkie looked close at the pile of flesh and bones. She noticed teeth marks in them. She gasped.

"ARE YOU TRYING TO TELL ME YOU FED TWILIGHT TO YOUR ANIMALS?!?!?!"

"Ah, you got me. Yes, that is what happened." Pinkie's coat started becoming paler.

"Are... Are you going to do that... to... me?" Pinkie started to cry. "Are you going... to... chop me up... and feed me to your animals?!" At this, Fluttershy laughed again.

"No, of course not!" Pinkie sighed in relief. "I don't have the tools I need to cut you up." Pinkie looked at Fluttershy, terrified.

"You... you mean... They're..." She started to cry.

"Yes. Hope you enjoy it!"

"FLUTTERSHY!!! NO!!!" Pinkie was crying. "HOW LONG HAVE YOU BEEN DOING THIS?!?!?!"

"Hmm... since I was a filly, up in Cloudsdale, with mother and father. I do miss them though... It's a shame that I had to do it to them, they were so nice! They taught me how to do this. But one day they were mean to me, they abused me, and I had to give them what they deserved."

"YOU KILLED YOUR OWN PARENTS!?!?!?" Pinkie was truly terrified now.

"I guess you could say that. Now enough chitchat. Its lunchtime." Pinkie screamed as animals jumped onto her, eating her alive.

"Good night Pinkie Pie."

Chapter 6

Fluttershy walked upstairs and shut the door. She sighed.

"I wonder who's next? I do hope that its Rarity, she was always such a pain." She reached into a jar and pulled a slip of paper out.

"Oh, its only Big Mcintosh... Oh well, I can work with that."

Chapter 1

“What are we doing today, Fluttershy?” A bright pink pony asked a pale yellow pony as they were walking along the trail to Fluttershy's cottage. Well, Pinkie Pie, the pink one, wasn't hopping. It was more like skipping. Or hopping. Whatever it is, its just Pinkie Pie being Pinkie Pie.

"You'll see," said the pale one in her soft voice. "I think you'll enjoy it."

"Okie dokie lokie!" Pinkie smiled. She was sure she'd have fun, there was always fun with Fluttershy. Well, with all her friends! She was guessing they were going to be doing something related to nature or animals, since Fluttershy loved both. A moment later, they arrived at Fluttershy's cottage.

"Come in Pinkie. And watch your step. There's little animals everywhere. Try to make sure you don't step on any. When Twilight was here last week, she almost stepped on so many of them!" She giggled. "I'm surprised she didn't."

"Speaking of Twilight, I haven't seen here since she stopped by here last week. Have you seen her? The rest of us have been getting worried about her."

"Oh yes. She's been helping me with the animals."

"Really? I would've thought they'd be scared by her! I mean, she almost stepped on them! How does she help?"

"Well, she's been helping me feed them. Usually it takes forever to feed them all, but the animals just seem to come to her to eat. They ignore me when they eat though... but that's alright."

"Oh. Hey lookie, we're here!" They were at the door of Fluttershy's cottage. Fluttershy gestured for Pinkie to come in. Pinkie hopped inside, being careful not to hop onto one of the adorable little animals. "So how am I gonna help Fluttershy? Do I get to feed them to? Or maybe help bathe them? Maybe sing them a lullaby?!"

"We'll get to that later. For now, why don't you sit down. I made some punch earlier, before you came. Want some?"

"Sure! Thanks!"

"No problem. I'll go get them now."

Fluttershy walked into the other room to get some punch for the ponies. Pinkie Pie was sitting on the couch playing with the animals. She looked around. All around her were animals,big and small, running around and having fun. Pinkie Pie started humming while waiting for Fluttershy to come back with the punch.

"I got it Pinkie!" Fluttershy yelled. she was balancing a plate on her head that held two teacups with punch in them.

"Gee, thanks Fluttershy!"

"No problem. Do you like it?"

Pinkie Pie took a sip. "Mmm! Delicious!" Pinkie then gulped it all down. "Can I have some more?"

"Certainly. I'll bring the whole pitcher out."

"Thanks Fluttershy!!!" Pinkie yelled to Fluttershy as she was leaving the room. Not a minute later Fluttershy came back with a pitcher of punch. It looked delicious! Pinkie poured herself a cup and drank it.

"No problem, Pinkie." Fluttershy smiled.

Chapter 4

The gentle voice moved closer into the light. Pinkie Pie could clearly see that is was Fluttershy now.

"Fluttershy, what do you want?! Just say it and I'll do it! Just let me go!!!" Pinkie started crying, fearing what her best friend was going to do.

"My, you've given up fast. Even Twilight lasted longer than you. I would have expected this from her. She's such a weak pony. But you? I would have expected you to last for at least half an hour, maybe more."

"Wh-what are you going t-to do with m-me?" Pinkie Pie was crying. She didn't want the end to be like this. She couldn't imagine this ever happening. Fluttershy was so sweet! Fluttershy couldn't be doing this! It had to be a dream! Pinkie Pie pinched herself. Nope, definitely not dreaming. This was reality.

"Oh, you'll see." Fluttershy replied. "For now, relax."

Pinkie nodded, but she couldn't relax. She was terrified. This wasn't the Fluttershy she knew! This was scaring Pinkie... a lot.

"Now Pinkie, it's time to take a nap."

"But Fluttershy I-" She passed out as Fluttershy pulled the needle out of Pinkie's arm.

"Have a nice rest Pinkie Pie.