Pinkamena and Cheese Sandwich

Fluttershy walked downstairs from her room to find the Scootaloo playing with her animals. She sighed and walked over to her.

“Scootaloo, sweetie-”

“Yes?” Both Scootaloo and Sweetie Belle asked in unison.

“N-no, Sweetie Belle, I just want to talk to Scootaloo.”

“Oh, right.” Sweetie Belle said, feeling dumb and leaving the room.

“Scootaloo,” Fluttershy said.

“Yes Fluttershy?”

“How many times have I told you not to play with my animal friends without supervision from me or Discord?”’

Scootaloo began counting. “One… Two, three… Four, five? No, just four.” She said.

Fluttershy stared at her blankly for a moment and then nodded, “Yeah, sure, four times. Anyway, that means you can’t play with them. Do you understand? They need to rest and eat their food.”

Scootaloo nodded sadly, “Yes, I understand Fluttershy.”

“If this happens again, I’ll be forced to punish you.” Fluttershy said as regretfully as she could manage.

Scootaloo gulped nervously, “Yes, Fluttershy.”

Discord walked down the stairs, looking tired and annoyed.

“Fluttershy, remind me again why we agreed to take care of all these little…” He paused, seeing Scootaloo standing in front of her, and the other two girls peeking over the corner. “Fillies?” He finished.

“Because we’re the only ones that can support them.”

“As I recall, Rainbow Dash was taking care of this one,” Discord patted Scootaloo on the head, “For quite some time.”

“Well, yes, but Scootaloo would have preferred to be able to see her friends.”

“She could come down here and visit them whenever she wanted, couldn’t she?” Discord asked.

Scootaloo looked down at her hooves sadly. Fluttershy looked at her and then back at Discord. “Actually, no she can’t.”

“You mean she still can’t fly?”

Fluttershy and Scootaloo both shook their heads.

“But,” Discord said, now directing his words at Scootaloo. “You have your cutie mark and you’ve grown so much.”

“But I still can’t fly.” She said sadly. She demonstrated by flapping her tiny wings as hard as she could. She only lifted a few inches off the ground and then fell back to the floor.

Discord rolled his eyes. “Whatever, I’m done complaining about this. I should be used to it by now, but I guess I’m just not.” Discord snapped and disappeared.

Fluttershy sighed and looked back at Scootaloo. Her exhaustion was apparent, she had dark circles under her eyes and her eyes were half lidded. Her coat, mane and tail were filthy, like she was so busy taking care of the girls that she didn’t have enough time to wash herself.

She gave Scootaloo a weak smile, “Remember what we just talked about, and don’t let me catch you playing with them again, ok?”

Scootaloo nodded, “Yes Fluttershy.”

“Do you girls mind watching Gala? I really need to take a nap.”

Apple Bloom and Sweetie Belle emerged from the wall they were hiding behind and Sweetie Belle said, “I would love to watch her.”

“Me too.” Apple Bloom chimed in.

“I wouldn’t mind either, go enjoy your nap. You need it.”

Fluttershy gave them a weak smile and left to go up to her bedroom. The girls went up the stairs as well to the room where Gala was sleeping. They sat in the room quietly, waiting for her to wake up on her own so they could either nurse her back to sleep or feed her or change her diaper.

About an hour later, Fluttershy was asleep and the girls were still watching Gala Amour, who was still asleep. Suddenly Discord popped into the room. The girls all jumped back and forced themselves not to scream or make any loud noises so they didn’t wake up Gala.

“What are you girls doing?” He asked in what sounded like an angry voice.

“Umm… F-Fluttershy asked us to look after Gala while she took a nap.” Sweetie Belle whispered.

“Oh…” Discord said, no longer mad. “Well then, carry on.” He started to leave, but then turned back. “Scootaloo, would you mind coming with me?”

“Wha-huh? Oh, sure.” She said. She got up and followed Discord back down to the living room. “What exactly did you want Discord?”

“Oh, nothing really, I just wanted to show you something.” Discord hugged Scootaloo and snapped his fingers. Suddenly, they found themselves outside a small cabin covered with trees. Discord led her inside, the whole time keeping his paw on her back.

Once they were inside, they saw nearly ten other creatures. Scootaloo saw a mantacore, a cockatrise, a chimera, a griffin, a diamond dog, a dragon, a minotaur, a draconequus similar to Discord, a timberwolf, and a bat pony. She noticed that they were all males.

She tried to take a step back but Discord stopped her. “D-discord, wh-why did you bring me here?” She asked, her voice shaking.

“Because you deserve some type of punishment.”

“But… Wh-what kind of punishment involves all these creatures, and why are they all males?” She asked.

“Do you think I always looked like this? Do you?”

“Well… Yes?” Scootaloo said nervously.

“Well, you’re right, because I did. But, what you don’t know is that my mother was a pony. When I was old enough she told me the story of how my siblings and I became to look like this.” He gestured to himself. “And she told me that she was kidnapped, and raped by all these creatures you see here.” He gestured around the room.

“B-but…” Scootaloo stuttered nervously.

“But nothing. I’m leaving you here to take your punishment.” Discord said. He pushed her forward into the group of strange, hungry looking creatures. “I’ll be back in two hours.” She looked back at him as he was leaving, her face full of fear and sadness, tears running down her face. Discord felt regret for a single second, but dismissed it and left the small cabin.

He heard a loud, shrill scream before he closed the door behind him and snapped his fingers. He arrived back in Fluttershy’s house. He walked up to where the other girls were still watching Gala Amour.

“Discord, you’re back.” Sweetie Belle said.

“But where’s Scootaloo?” Apple Bloom asked.

“Oh, she’ll be back in a few hours.” Discord said, trying to be discreet.

The girls shrugged off where she might be and nodded.

“Fluttershy is still sleeping, I presume?”

The girls nodded again.

Discord left and went into his and Fluttershy’s room. He set himself an alarm for two hours and then climbed into the bed with Fluttershy. He fell asleep quickly, and slept peacefully until his alarm woke him up. He opened his eyes to see Fluttershy still asleep.

He quickly snapped his fingers to turn off the alarm so it wouldn’t wake her. He got up and walked down the living room, past Gala’s room, seeing the girls still sitting in it watching the little filly.

Discord remembered the promise he had made to Pinkie Pie. That he would tell Gala one day what had happened to her parents. He knew that it would be easy because now he and Fluttershy were together and they basically raised her as their own.

He made his way down to the living room and snapped his fingers. He appeared outside the cabin in the woods where he had left Scootaloo. He walked up to it and opened the door to find a scene he hadn’t really desired to see.

He stared for a moment with his mouth wide open. He closed the door and put his claw over his mouth. He took a few deep breaths and then opened the door.

“I promised you fellows two hours, and it has been….” Discord snapped and a clock appeared out of thin air. “Two hours and five minutes.”

The creatures continued violating the poor little Scootaloo who had tears pouring down her face, along with something else that will not be mentioned.

Discord growled angrily and forced the monsters to stop. He gently took Scootaloo by the hoof and snapped before the creatures could get a hold on her again.

“Come now, we’ll need to wash you up.” Discord said once they had finished teleporting. They had arrived near a small pond. Discord cast a small spell on it and the water sparkled slightly. He snapped and a bucket appeared.

He scooped water up in the bucket and poured it over her head. Slowly, her body stopped shaking. He scooped up some more and poured it over her. She had stopped crying and was all cleaned up.

“I knew it would be a good idea to learn this spell that made normal water healing water and give normal water the power to erase memory.” Discord thought.

“Discord, is this where you wanted to take me?” Scootaloo asked, looking out at the water, having already forgotten about the traumatic experience.

“Yes, that’s right.” Discord snapped and the bucket disappeared. He snapped again and the water went back to normal. “It’s just something that I stumbled on and I thought you might like it.” He said.

“Ehh… Not really.” She said. “I could have sworn that just a minute ago, the water was all sparkly and magical looking, but now it just looks like ordinary water.”

“Oh, I see.” Discord said. “Come on then, we’re going back home now.” He grabbed her hoof and snapped. Not soon after they arrived back in Fluttershy’s cottage.

Scootaloo looked at the clock. “Why is it so late?” She asked Discord. “Didn’t you just take me to that pond and back?”

“Time goes by faster during teleportation.” Discord lied.

“Oh, ok.” Scootaloo nodded and walked up the stairs to where Sweetie Belle and Apple Bloom were watching Gala. Discord walked up as well, but instead he went to his and Fluttershy’s bedroom.

“Soon, Scootaloo will realize she’s pregnant with a deformed child, or multiple children. She’ll have no idea how it happened or who the fathers are, and that will be her real trauma.” Discord thought as he lie in bed with the sleeping Fluttershy. “She’ll either chose to have an abortion, or give birth to it/them. Either way, it won’t be pleasant for her.” Discord soon fell asleep knowing his evil plan had been a success.