Sympathy for the Siren

by Anonymoose

Rating: teen
Tags: Dark, Sonata Dusk, Fluttershy, Equestria Girls
Length: 2931

Fluttershy seeks to help the fallen Sonata lift her life out of the gutters after her defeat.

Every day for the past few days, a mournful song has been coming out of the alleyway beside the rescue shelter Fluttershy works at. She finally braves the scary alleyway, concerned for the possibly injured creature, but is surprised by who she has found.

Maybe, if she can show Sonata Dusk just a little bit of kindness, she can turn the poor girl's life around.

Edited by Level Dasher.

Published 2014-12-15 06:50:03 UTC
Last updated 2014-12-15 06:50:03 UTC

Please allow me to introduce myself

Fluttershy crept quietly down the alleyway, being careful not to startle the frightened creature. She had heard the poor thing’s cries from inside the animal rescue center.

If there was one thing Fluttershy knew, it was how to be quiet— she was the world champion of “Shhh!” after all.

The creature’s awful caterwauling echoed through the alleyway; the closer Fluttershy got to the source, the more mournful its song sounded.

“Ummm, hello?” she called out softly as she approached. “Are you okay?”

Fluttershy looked down at the pitiful creature before her. Her hair was matted with dirt and mud; her clothes were ripped and torn; and she looked like she hadn’t eaten in days.

“Umm… Sonata Dusk, right?” Fluttershy asked, holding out her hand. Sonata pulled away from Fluttershy’s gesture. Fluttershy had seen this sort of reaction before, especially amongst mistreated animals.

“It’s okay. My name is Fluttershy,” she said as she squatted, looking Sonata in the eyes. “I won’t hurt you. Are you hungry?”

Sonata nodded silently.

“Well, come with me. I have some snacks inside…” Fluttershy paused, trying not to scrunch her nose at the smell. “…and maybe we can get you a little cleaned up, too.”

Sonata stood, using the wall to help herself up. Fluttershy tried to hide her frown, saddened that Sonata was wary of her.

If other-Fluttershy helped reform that Disco guy, then I can help Sonata!

Fluttershy led Sonata through to the staff area of the animal shelter. She sent Sonata to the restroom, where she could have a shower and clean up. The shower was a convenience she was extremely grateful for. Fluttershy did not mind the smell of the cute little creatures she looked after, but her friends certainly did, so she always made certain to keep a spare set of clothing around in case any of her friends decided to hang out after work.

She set about preparing a small salad for Sonata. There wasn’t a whole lot left in her snack box, as Fluttershy had been meaning to go and refill it. She couldn’t help it that poor Angel Bunny was more temperamental than the other shelter animals. He just needed some love and attention, and a few nicer vegetables than the scraps the others had.

She’d get through to him one day.

The door to the restroom opened, and steam poured out of the door. Fluttershy smiled as Sonata walked out; Fluttershy was a little taller than her friends, and definitely taller than Sonata. As such, the green miniskirt Fluttershy so often wore came nearly to Sonata’s knees, and the white tank top that fit Fluttershy so well hung loose over the smaller girl’s frame.

To Fluttershy, it looked adorable, like a little sister dressing up in her big sister’s clothes.

Sonata turned away from Fluttershy, her cheeks reddening and a slight scowl on her face.

“I’ve made you a little salad, if you’re still hungry,” Fluttershy said, directing Sonata to a chair at the breakroom table. “It’s not much, but we can get some more after my shift… if you’d like?”

Sonata dove into the salad, not even bothering with the plastic cutlery Fluttershy had provided for her. Fluttershy watched in silence as Sonata finished the salad.

“Thank you,” Sonata said, her voice croaky and dry. She scowled and turned away.

“Ummm, you’re welcome,” Fluttershy answered. “Would you like a drink of water?”

Sonata’s only reply was a shake of her head.

“Are you sure, you sound a little dry—”

A glare from Sonata cut Fluttershy off.

“Oh, is it because…?”

The miserable look on Sonata’s face was all the answer Fluttershy needed. Even if they were big meanies, Fluttershy felt a little guilty that she and her friends might have hurt the Dazzlings.

Fluttershy turned towards the door. “Well, I need to go back to tending to the animals—” A gasp from behind her caused Fluttershy to turn back around. Sonata was looking at Fluttershy with large, pleading eyes. “W-Would you like to help me?”

A large smile and a vigorous nodding of her head was all the answer Fluttershy needed.

Fluttershy pushed the trolley as she and Sonata walked through the isles of the local supermarket. From Sonata’s ragged look, Fluttershy suspected the poor girl didn’t have anywhere to live. From what she had seen, the other two sirens weren’t particularly nice to her, and had probably just thrown her out of the street when things had gone against them.

Sonata had helped without complaint all afternoon. She tended to the animals with a care and grace Fluttershy had rarely seen. The animals had taken to her as well, and Fluttershy smiled, thinking back at the adorable memory of Sonata surrounded by puppies and kittens, playing with them all.

Given how much she had helped, Fluttershy felt it fair to help Sonata out herself. She had picked up a few items of clothing in Sonata’s size at the thrift store… they weren’t the high fashion that Sonata seemed to be used to, but Sonata was grateful for them nonetheless.

Now, Fluttershy was shopping for supplies for the week, making sure to buy larger servings of everything.

She was going to have a guest in her home, after all.

“Did you want to watch a movie together, or something?” Fluttershy asked as she sat on her couch next to Sonata.

“Y-yeah, that’d be nice,” Sonata croaked out, before covering her mouth with her hand.

Fluttershy gently pulled the hand away from Sonata’s mouth and whispered, “It’s okay, you don’t have to be embarrassed.”

“B-but I sound horrible,” Sonata replied, her voice wavering.

“I’m sorry,” Fluttershy said, putting a hand on Sonata’s shoulder, “I didn’t know it’d hurt you—” Sonata turned away, unable to look her in the face. Fluttershy noticed Sonata’s hair was knotted and her pigtail was lopsided.

“D-do you want me to help with your hair?” Fluttershy asked, trying to change the subject.

Sonata turned back and nodded. “Adagio…” she croaked. “Adagio used to—”

“It’s okay,” Fluttershy cooed. She stood up and grabbed her hairbrush from her dresser. When she got back to the couch, she dropped a cushion on the floor and motioned for Sonata to sit on it. Fluttershy turned on the television, and gently brushed Sonata’s hair until it was silky smooth as they watched a movie.

When the movie had ended, Fluttershy smiled, finding Sonata asleep, leaning against her leg. Fluttershy helped her guest onto the couch and covered her with a blanket.

“Good night, Sonata.”

“No, stop!” Sonata squealed as the dog jumped all over her. She fell back, laughing as the playful animal crawled all over her, licking every inch of her face. “No, Buddy, stop that, it tickles!”

“Budweiser t. Dog,” Fluttershy said with a stern voice, “are you acting up for Sonata again?”

Sonata used Buddy’s momentary distraction to extricate herself from under the doberman, before tackling the creature back to the ground. “Now it’s your turn!” Sonata screamed, as she dove towards the dog with her tongue out.

Seconds later, she was off the dog, spitting fur out of her mouth.

“Blegck!”

“You know,” Fluttershy laughed, helping Sonata back to her feet, “you are only encouraging him.”

Both girls watched as Buddy crouched down, ready to play again. Sonata stepped one foot forward, slamming it down on the tiled floor. It was enough… Buddy ran out to the playpen, hopeful that Sonata would give chase.

“I was thinking, if it’s okay with you… that maybe you might like to meet my other friends tonight?” Fluttershy asked. “I’m sure they’ll like you, if they get to know you like I have.” The forlorn look on Sonata’s face was all the answer Fluttershy needed. “I mean, it’s okay, if you aren’t up to it. I know what it’s like to be shy, so maybe another time.”

Sonata gave Fluttershy a weak smile, and silently nodded.

It hurt Fluttershy when Sonata got like this. The animals were doing wonders for getting Sonata to open up, and she had grown closer to Fluttershy in the previous few days… but anytime Fluttershy mentioned meeting others, Sonata would crawl back into her shell.

“Maybe we could re-watch Milo and Otis tonight?” Fluttershy suggested. As predicted, Sonata perked up at the idea, but still remained silent, much to Fluttershy’s dismay.

Fluttershy leaned back, sitting on a cushion between Sonata’s legs. Sonata had asked if she could brush Fluttershy’s hair for her, and she happily obliged.

As Fluttershy had learned, Adagio was the one who used to brush Sonata’s hair for her, so Sonata was a little rough to start with. But through gentle instruction and patience, Sonata slowly improved her technique. Towards the end of the movie, Fluttershy had come to quite enjoy Sonata’s gentle ministrations.

Fluttershy drifted off peacefully to sleep.

For the gods they made

“Good morning,” Sonata said cheerfully as Fluttershy awoke. Sonata carried an overbed tray, with eggs, toast and a glass of juice, and placed them in front of Fluttershy.

“What’s this for?” Fluttershy asked.

“I… I just wanted to do something to say thanks,” Sonata replied, sitting gently on the side of Fluttershy’s bed. “You’ve been so nice to me, even after I was mean to you.”

“Well,” Fluttershy said, a small frown forming on her face, “when I first met you, you were a little scary. But I know you’ve changed now— I see the good in you.” She patted Sonata on the hand. “Now I see you were just someone who needed a friend.”

“A friend?” Sonata asked. “I’m… your friend?”

“Oh, ummm…” Fluttershy wrung her hands nervously. “Maybe? We don’t have to be, if you don’t want to. I just thought that—”

Sonata dove towards Fluttershy, pulling her into a strong hug. The breakfast Sonata had carefully prepared went flying off the bed and spilled across the floor. Sonata stared at the mess, before turning sheepishly to Fluttershy. “Umm, oops?”

Fluttershy giggled. “It’s okay, we can clean it up.”

“Friend!” Sonata said under her breath, before giggling herself. “Wow, I’ve never had a friend before!”

“Really?” Fluttershy asked. “I thought that Adagio and… oh, I’m sorry! I can’t even remember her name…”

“Aria,” Sonata answered, a frown crossing her face. “No, we’re not exactly… friends. We’re sisters, but I don’t think we’re friends.”

“Oh… that’s so sad,” Fluttershy said, hugging Sonata tighter. “Well, you have me, and you’ll have my friends, too, when—” Fluttershy stopped herself when she felt Sonata tense up. “—whenever you’re ready. Baby steps.”

Sonata relaxed into the hug, and the two sat there for several minutes, until Fluttershy’s mobile phone vibrated.

“Oh, I wonder who that could be?” Fluttershy picked up her phone and read the message. “Oh… oh dear.” Sonata sat in silence, pensively waiting for Fluttershy to say something. “Someone has come to the shelter, to adopt Buddy.”

Sonata gasped. “They can’t take Buddy!” Fluttershy held Sonata as she shook.

“I know it’s hard,” Fluttershy answered, “but Miss Goodall does a thorough check on anyone who wants to adopt a pet… he’ll be going to a loving home.”

“B-but… I need him!” Sonata wailed.

Fluttershy knew this pain— she had learned to live with it over the years. Many animals came through the shelter, some were able to find good homes. Others… others, well, she could only give them as much love as she could before… before they had to leave.

It was hard, and Fluttershy wished she could rescue them all, but she had come to learn the truth of the matter, that she just couldn’t. So she had vowed to show each and every animal that came through the shelter as much love and care as she could, so that wherever the went in the end, they left knowing someone cared.

“I know it’s hard,” Fluttershy said, gently stroking Sonata’s hair, “but this is a good thing. It hurts now, but Buddy will be going to a good home. He’ll be able to run and play, and he’ll have someone to keep him company at night.

“How about we go down there and see if we can catch Buddy before he leaves for his new home?”

Fluttershy watched Sonata through the rear window. Sonata was throwing a ball for one of the puppies, but Fluttershy could tell her heart was not in it.

Sonata had not said a word when Miss Goodall informed them that Buddy and his new owner had already left. Sonata had wordlessly walked out the back through to the play area.

Fluttershy had wanted to go and comfort her, but her boss had held her back, saying that Sonata might need some time alone.

Fluttershy volunteered to lock the premises so her boss could get home on time. When the sun had finally set, and all the animals were put back in their habitats, Fluttershy helped her silent friend to her feet and out of the building.

Fluttershy sat nervously on her couch next to Sonata. Sonata hadn’t said a word since they’d gotten home. She had just sat down and stared blankly at her feet.

Sonata had not responded to Fluttershy’s enquiries about dinner, and didn’t even stir when Fluttershy brought back her special vegetarian tacos.

Uncertain what to do, Fluttershy gave her friend a sidelong hug, and excused herself for bed.

Fluttershy was awoken with a start, as someone climbed into her bed. She stiffened, wary of the intruder, until the soft, croaky whisper of Sonata told her who it was.

“C-can I sleep with you?” she asked, ever so softly. “J-just for tonight?”

“Ummm, okay,” Fluttershy replied, a little nervous, but wanting to comfort her hurting friend.

Sonata crawled the rest of the way into the bed, sliding under the sheets. She clung to Fluttershy, who in turn pulled her towards her bosom and stroked her hair. She could feel Sonata’s tears soaking into her pyjama top, but it didn’t matter.

“Y-you won’t leave me?” Sonata whispered into Fluttershy’s chest.

“No, I won’t leave you,” Fluttershy replied.

And she meant it— she would never leave. She would always be there for her friend.

Sonata was gone when Fluttershy awoke the next morning.

Fluttershy searched her small apartment, but there was no sign of her; no note, no message on her phone, nothing.

A pang of worry filled her chest. Sonata was heartbroken yesterday, and now she had just up and disappeared.

Fluttershy desperately hoped her friend was okay.

“♫Aaaaah ahhh ahhh, ahhhhh ahhhhh.♫”

Three voices sang out in perfect harmony from the abandoned factory building.

“I can’t believe that actually worked!” Aria snorted.

“I know… I’m just as surprised as you are,” Adagio replied. “Who would have thought one of Sonata’s ideas would work?”

“I mean, it’s just so brilliant,” Aria added.

“A stroke of genius!” Adagio agreed.

Sonata gushed under the weight of their praise.

“I mean, it’s completely unexpected,” Aria said.

“I thought it was going to fall flat on its face, too.”

“Hey!” Sonata said with a scowl. She started to wonder if it was indeed praise her sisters were heaping on her.

“Well,” Adagio said, “you did find this spell on the internet.”

“On a webpage by someone who calls herself ‘High Priestess Chryssy of the Changeling Coven’,” Aria added.

“Seriously, who designed that website?” Adagio asked. “It looked like one of those goth kids threw up all over it.”

Aria snorted her approval.

“Well, it worked!” Sonata said, pouting. “I got our powers back, so you can thank me la— no, you can thank me now!”

“Very well,” Adagio replied, patting her youngest sister on the head. “You did very well. Sacrificing a hundred animals filled with love… it sounded so hokey, but I can’t complain that it didn’t work.”

Adagio looked around the room, where runes were painted across the floor with blood and viscera. Entrails draped over a pitch-black altar, with burnt candles made from animal fat. The place utterly stank.

“Ugh, it’s going to be so weird, feeding off of love instead of conflict now. Who does that? Who feeds on love?” Adagio complained. “Well, I need to have a shower and wash this off, at the very least.”

“I’m next!” Aria shouted.

“Awww!” Sonata pouted, annoyed at always being last. “Stupid older sisters.”

She looked around the room, to the gruesome display. It had been so much easier after she was able to steal the key to the shelter from Fluttershy’s dresser. It was a stroke of luck that Fluttershy had even brought the key home.

She’d had to move fast; Sonata didn’t even know that people could take animals away. Though looking at the scene, she was kind of glad Buddy was adopted early… it would have been hard plunging a knife through his heart.

“Okay, so after our shower, we burn this place down,” Adagio said. “And the human… she’s a loose end. Sonata, you’re going to have to—”

“No!” Sonata yelped. “No, please, I don’t want to hurt her!”

Adagio and Aria both stared at Sonata, dumbfounded.

“Why?”

“Well,” Sonata explained, “she’s my friend. Can’t… can’t I keep her?”

“Okay, fine!” Adagio rolled her eyes. “If you can train her, you can keep her. But you have to look after her, clean her, walk her, and make sure she is fed!”

“Thank you thank you thank you!” Sonata gushed, pulling her eldest sister into a bone-crushing hug.

Adagio hugged Sonata back. “How could I say no to those eyes?”