A Hearth's Warming Gift

Fluttershy trudged through the slush on the roads. She had been unenthusiastic when Angel asked her to make him a special Hearth's Warming Eve dinner. Naturally, it was virtually impossible for her to find any store open that day. She was headed home, very sorry to disappoint her pet. As she passed a dark alleyway, a hoof clamped over her mouth and pulled her into the alley. She tried to scream, and soon after found the hoof replaced by a magical grip not allowing her to open her mouth at all.

"You're mine for the taking, now." The voice sounded strangely like that of a mare's, but Fluttershy couldn't see through the shadow their hood cast on their face. The unicorn slammed Fluttershy down on her back and stood above her, pinning her legs down. The pegasus whimpered. The hooded figure moved their face downwards, and connected their lips with Fluttershy's, but she couldn't pull away. The other pony's grip was far too strong. The pink-maned mare whimpered, but the unicorn was merciless. She pulled away and shoved Fluttershy's tail out of the way, her magic now gripping all of the pegasus' upper body, holding her in place. She, unexpectedly, first gave Fluttershy's breasts a lick. This elicited a gasp from the mare below her.

The hooded mare just chuckled.

She continued to lick, causing Fluttershy to tremble. "Please...s-stop..." She tried. It didn't work.

The unicorn moved down a little further, and saw Fluttershy's virgin pussy. She lifted a hoof, and traced the pegasus' outer lips. Fluttershy squealed. Please, no, no! Not this!

The figure gave her a soft lick, and the yellow mare began to reek of arousal.  Fluttershy couldn't help it, but she felt ashamed. She liked this? This was rape, this was sick!

The voice spoke again. "You naughty little mare..." The figure had the plunged her tongue into Fluttershy's honeypot, and found it tasted a little sweet. Fluttershy bit her lip to prevent any moans from escaping, but failed. She didn't like this emotionally, but physically was a whole other story. It felt so good.

After getting Fluttershy ready, the made took her by surprise. She stopped licking, and slid the tip of her lavender horn in. The butter yellow pegasus shrieked at the foreign object's entrance, and once again tried to wiggle away. The magic still surrounded her upper body, but the horn was also tingly with magic. The further she slid in, the more vibrations Fluttershy could feel against her tight walls.

And it drove her crazy.

The unicorn pumped slowly at first, but the louder Fluttershy's whimpers got, she went faster.

But then she stopped. Once the unicorn had stopped, Fluttershy looked up to see why. She knew why she had pain, now, when she first began. Because her hymn had been broken. She saw some blood coming from her pussy and leaking onto the ground. The unicorn's magical aura prevented her horn from getting stained.

She suddenly lifted Fluttershy up with her magic, and pinned her against the wall. Her lips met the other mare's and, this time, she fought less.

The unicorn's hoof rubbed against one of Fluttershy's yellow teats. The pegasus moaned into her mouth, and she allowed access. Their tongues wrestled as Fluttershy thought, Why do I like this so much? She let out a whimper against the other mare's mouth.

As Fluttershy squirmed slightly under her mouth, the unicorn pushed her hoof against the pegasus' pink nipples. Her hoof wandered downwards, and stroked her lips, eliciting a gasp from the yellow mare. The tip of her hoof poked in and kept pushing as far as she could go. Fluttershy's neck craned upward, and their lips disconnected. She yelled in pleasure, tears slipping free finally.

"Ah! P-ple..." She tried, but she couldn't force the words out.

As the unicorn pleasured the mare, her own hoof had found its way to her wet slit. She pushed her own hoof inside herself and moaned with Fluttershy. She bit her lip in anticipation, and when she heard Fluttershy's breath hitch, which was followed by an ear-piercing scream, she felt a warm liquid gush over her hoof. She let Fluttershy's body relax, dropping her to the ground, but her magic still gripped her torso.

She focused on her own pleasure, now. She pumped in and out, moaning openly. She wasn't worried at all about if somepony heard them--this was an enclosed area. Even those out shopping weren't in earshot. She knew she shouldn't do this. She knew that something could go wrong, but she just wanted this so bad. She knew she couldn't.

But she did.

A strand of her dark blue mane fell out of place, but she ignored it. She gasped for air, feeling herself slipping over the edge. She knew that what she had just done was totally overboard. Even fantasizing was a little too much, but performing her fantasies...she knew that she should not have just done this. No pony would forgive her if they found out. She would try her best to make sure nopony did.

She yelled out with impressive volume as she fell over the edge. Fluttershy had been watching this entire time after she recovered from her afterglow. She had to admit that this had been the best experience she had so far. Even though she had only masturbated a few times in her life, but none were as intense as this.

As the pony recovered from the afterglow, she got up shakily. In the process, her hood fell down. Fluttershy didn't notice the motion at first, for she had been avoiding looking at the pony. When she stood, she struggled to raise her hood again, but Fluttershy had already seen.

"T-Twilight...why?"