Can a Truth Tell a Lie?

"Why didn't you tell me?" I asked as I looked at her. Twilight raised her head up as she's still sobbing while she's looking at me.

"Huh?"

"Why didn't you tell me before, Twi?" I sat up from the bed as I'm now eye leveled with her. I didn't look at her angrily. No, I put my finger under her chin and I raised her head up for her to meet my gaze. Twilight sniffed when she tries to catch her words.

"I'm... I'm sorry. I know it's been almost four months since you came here. But, when I would hang out with you more. I thought you would be the one. You're very sweet, and you're always kind to my friends. But, you weren't there when Trixie tortured us." Twilight said as she turned away from me. Avoiding eye contact.

"Okay. Tell me."

"Huh?" She turned her head to look at me.

"Tell me what she did. So that way I'll understand what you're talking about." I sat criss cross after I finished my sentence. Twilight took a deep breath to calm her nerves and she turned around. She nods her head as I can see some tears still in her eyes.

"Okay." She mumbled. "It was before I became an alicorn. Trixie had this 'Alicorn Amulet' and she began to rule Ponyville with it. Her and I fought in a magic duel and she won because of that Alicorn Amulet she was wearing. We made a bet that if I won, she leave. But if I lost, I'll have to leave Ponyville forever. I went to Zecora's to see what I could do, and what I did was trick her. She did learn her lesson after that. But..." Twilight leaned her head down, ears folded back. "I just keep thinking that she's still a trouble maker after what she did to both me and my friends. And ever since you found her... I kept thinking that she'll use you for something like that. But, she didn't. I'm really sorry." She said as she broke out into tears. "I just wanted to be with you." She said the best she could.

"Hey, Twilight." I said as I reached an arm around her and I held her close. "You don't have to apologize. I should be the one that's apologizing."

Twilight looks up at me. "F-For what?"

"For me being an ass towards you and your friends. I really didn't know you really liked me that much. At least one of you could've told me. I'm really sorry for yelling at both you and your friends. I was just being a complete jerk for breaking your heart like that. I'm so sorry, Twilight." I said as I held her close to me. Twilight leans her head on me as I pet her fur while she's still in tears. We didn't say anything for a while as we just sat there in silence.

***

After a few hours of comforting Twilight. This time, I asked her if I could go to Trixie's to talk to her about what happened, and Twilight let me go over there so she could calm down. I couldn't stop thinking when I left, she was just sobbing on the bed. I felt very, very guilty that I completely ruined her heart.

I showed up at Trixie's travel wagon. Or, whatever you call it. I knocked on the door as I waited for a sec. Finally, she opens the door.

"Well hello there." She said in a sultry voice as she walks to me. "I've missed you so much. What happened?"

"Hey Trixie." I said in a quite voice. "Can we talk?"

"Of course. Trixie wouldn't mind talking about 'stuff.'" She said as she turned around and shook her plot to me as we both walked inside. I sat down on the chair as she sat down beside me. "So... What is it you wanna talk about?" She said as she looked up at me.

"Well... It's about Twilight. I just found out that... She has a crush on me." I said as I wrapped an arm around her.

"Twilight? Having a crush... On you?" Trixie said in shock. "That can't be. She was always mean to you when we're together."

"I know. But... She talked to me about the stuff you did before she turned into an alicorn." I said as I looked at her. But, not in an angry look. Trixie sighed as her head tilted down to avoid my gaze.

"Yes, it is true. I did do something like that with an Alicorn Amulet. I'm sure Twilight told you that already." She said as a tear drops from her eye. "I just didn't know what gotten into me. I thought she forgiven me for what I've done to her and her friends, especially Ponyville." She breaks into tears as she held onto me. I petted her mane to calm her down.

"Hey, it's okay, Trixie." I said as I pet her. "But, how come you did something like that? Did... Something bad happen between you and her back then?" I asked. Trixie sniffed.

"No. She showed me off after battling with her magic from an ursa minor. After she did, I became a laughing stock. E-Everywhere I w-went I was being laughed at. I even had to work on... A rock farm." She said as she finished with a squeal in her voice.

Trixie begins to cry on my shoulder to a point where she can hardly breath. I petted her mane some more to calm her down.

"Shh, shh, it's okay." I said to her.

"I know what I did was so stupid. I didn't know what came to me! Please, don't leave me! I was so happy when I first saw you, and now I don't wanna lose you! Just because of what Twilight told you! I'm so, so sorry! Please don't leave me!" She begged as she starts to cry on my shoulder.

"Hey. Trixie, look at me." I said as I tilted her head up to meet my gaze. I wiped a tear from her eye. "I'm not gonna leave you. That was in the past. Sure, I know mine still haunts me today, and I know what you did still haunts you. But... It doesn't mean that we can still move on, right?" I said as I look deep into her eyes. Trixie nods her head.

"That's good." I said as I kissed her forehead that's on the base of her horn. "But I promise. I won't leave you Trixie. I promise to stay by your side as much as I can. I don't wanna see you heart broken."

I heard Trixie sniff as she wraps her hooves around my torso. "Th-Thank you." She whispers with a smile forming on her face.

"Anytime Trixie." I said as I continue to hug her. "Anytime."

***
*1 Hour Later*

"How long has it been since you guys knew?" I asked in a soft tone to Applejack while I visited her as Sweet Apple Acres.

"It's been quite a while, sugarcube." She said as she bucked an apple tree. "I remember when you was taking a nap one time a few days after you came to Equestria. Golly, should've seen that blush on her face. She told us how much she liked you. She did tell us to keep it from you though."

"How come?" I asked as Aj picked up an apple and puts it in the basket.

"'Cause she was scared like a filly looking down from a high bridge."

"Oh." I said as I looked down. "I feel really bad for her though. I'm really sorry for being a jackass to you all, especially Twilight. I really didn't know. Can you tell me next time so I would know?" I asked Aj.

"Of course sugar. I promise, next time somethin' like that comes up. We'll tell you."

"Thanks Aj." I said as I turned around and went back to Twilight's castle. "I'll see ya around."

She waved goodbye to me as she goes back to her apple bucking.

***

"Hey Twilight? I'm back!" I yelled for her. But, no response. "Twilight?"

"She's up in her room." I hear Spike say as he's reading a comic book.

"Huh?" I asked.

"She's been in there ever since you left. She hasn't come out. I tried to get her to come out, but, she wont." Spike said. "I think you should talk to her about it."

"Alright, thanks Spike." I said as I went up stairs to go and see Twilight.

After I've been walking for a bit I reached Twilight's room. I knocked on the door silently. "Twilight? are you okay?" I asked through the door. But, no response. I opened the door slowly, and she's still laying in her bed with her whole body in the covers.

I came in and I closed the door and walked to her bed.

"Twilight?" I whispered as I looked to see if she's alright. She scoots the covers to make sure that I can't see her face. She remained silent as I sat down on the bed and I petted her mane.

"Look, Twilight. I don't know what's going through your head right now. But, I said I was sorry. The reason why I yelled at you like that for days was because you haven't told me how you felt about me. And I though you were trying to split us up." I whispered as I keep petting her. Which I get for a response was sniff.

I leaned down to give her a supporting friendly hug. Which I get no response from her as she's completely still. I can see her eyes tearing up as she closed them tightly so I wont see her cry. I begin to whisper again.

"Hey, Twilight. I know I was hard on you, and I'm really sorry." I can see her teeth clenching up as she's trying her best not to cry in front of me. "Is there anything I can do to make you feel better, Twi?" I asked as I wrapped my arm around her. I get no answer as I see her raise her hooves up a bit from inside the covers.

"Come on, Twi. Answer me. Please? What can I do to make you feel better?" I bring her in for a tighter hug as I was hoping for an answer. But, I still get nothing. "Look, Twi. Come on. There's gotta be something to make you feel better." I said as I think of what to do. Until...

"Cuddle?" She said in a quiet voice.

I heard her say that word as I took my shoes off. I petted her mane as I whispered "Sure Twi. If that makes you feel any better, I'll cuddle with you."

I get under the covers with her as she turned around and she buries her face in my chest as she wraps her arms around me. She stayed like this the whole time as I wrap my arms around her. I'm doing this so she would cheer up. but, it looks like it hasn't been working from how she's reacting.

***

At last, it's been thirty minutes since Twilight wanted me to cuddle with her. I saw her walk to the kitchen and asked Spike to fix her something to eat while I go out for a little walk. Twilight knew where I was going. Since that I'm going to Trixie's after all.

As I arrived there, I noticed that the sun's setting. I knocked on the door as I waited. Trixie opened the door.

"Oh hey. Didn't think you'd come by." She said as she let me in.

"Hey Trixie." I said as I sit down. "How've you been?"

"Alright." She said as she sat down beside me. "How's Twilight. She doing alright?"

"Well... I'm not sure." I said as I looked at her. "I saw her in her bed as she was crying so bad that she couldn't even breath hardly." I said to Trixie. "I wanted to make her feel better so she would get her mind off of what happened. But, apparently, it isn't working."

"Oh, I see." Trixie said as she looked down. "I can't blame her. I literally can't. I also feel guilty of what I did." She said as she doesn't make eye contact with me. "Unless..."

"Unless what?" I said as I looked at Trixie. Trixie looks at me with a smile on her face wider than ever. "I just got an idea! Hold up!" She said as she ran out her door.

"Wait, Trixie! Wait!" I said as I tried to catch up to her. She probably doesn't hear me. I can see her go in the direction to Twilight's castle. I ran out of breath as I tried to catch up with her.

'I guess it's walking' I think to myself as I start to walk to Twilight's castle.

***

Finally, I arrived at Twilight's castle. I came in as I was hoping to see Trixie anywhere around. But, I don't. I don't see Twilight either.

"Well, look who's here." I hear Spike's voice. I look to where his voice came from and there he is. On the couch eating sapphires. I still have no idea how he can stand eating all of those.

"Oh, uh, hey Spike." I said as I would clench from every time he takes a bit out of them rubies.

"Oh, Twilight and Trixie wanted me to tell you that they're upstairs in Twilight's bedroom." Spike said as he keeps eating the rubies until the bowl's completely empty.

"Uh... Okay. thanks Spike." I said as I walk upstairs to Twilight's room.

"I need more rubies." I hear Spike say after I disappeared from his view.

***

I finally reached Twilight's room as I put my hand on the door handle. I took a deep breath as I think to myself.

'Get a hold of it man. You probably think they're arguing about something. Just... Pull it together, and you'll be fine.' I think to myself when I don't hear anything from behind the door.

Until I opened it and... 'WHAT THE FUCK?!?!' I screamed in my mind as I saw both Twilight and Trixie making out on her bed.They noticed me as they break away and looked at me.

"Oh, it's good to see you here." Trixie said as she giggles.

"Um... What's all this about?" I asked as I was about to walk out. But, I get pulled in by Twilight's aura and the door shuts and locks.

"Well... Trixie came up with an amazing idea about us." Twilight said as she giggles too.

'Well, at least she's feeling better,' I think to myself.

"And what's that idea?" I asked.

"Well, Trixie told me how much you didn't want to leave her, and she told me how much you didn't wanna see me heart broken. So... She came up with an idea. What if... You dated both of us at the same time?" Twilight asked in a sultry voice.

"Me? Dating you two at once? I... I dunno guys. Isn't that... Cheating on one another?" I asked.

"Oh, it won't be for both of us." Trixie said as she circled a hoof on Twilight's chest. "Now, how 'bout you come over here, big boy." She said as her magic aura brung me to the bed. Twilight telleport me onto the bed as the both stripped me down until my soft cock is free from the prison.

"Hmm... What do we have here?" Trixie said as I see Twilight's eyes widen up. I see her blush as she stares at it.

"Twilight, since Trixie already had her turn with this. You wanna taste it?" Trixie asked her as Twilight nods her head slowly as her face darkens. "Well than." Trixie said as she whispers in her ear. "Make it hard for him."

Twilight leaned down, and she begins to lick my soft member. All of a sudden, it's now really hard.
]
"Oh my gosh." Twilight whispered. She looks at me as she's about to take it in her mouth. "C-Can I?"

"Uh..." I looked at Trixie as she nods her head to me. "Sure. It's all yours Twilight."

Twilight took the head into her mouth as she starts to suck on it a little bit. Until she finally took the whole thing in as I let out a scream of pleasure. I watch her move up and down on my hardness. Her blush deepen as she takes it in.

Trixie leans down as she kissed me on the lips for a bit, and whispered in my ear. "She told me how badly she's been wanting you. I thought I would give her the honors in doing so."

I see Twilight enjoying the feeling of my dick on her mouth. I couldn't believe that Trixie actually didn't mind one little bit of this. Twilight spits me out as she looks up at me.

"It taste so good. I want more." She said as she took it all in again and begins to suck faster.

"Hmm... She's very horny. For you." Trixie whispered in my ear. "Go on. Cum in her mouth. She's been dying for it so badly. haven't you Twilight?"

"Mhm." Twilight nods her head as she's still sucking on me. I could feel myself get closer and closer to climax. i tilted my head back as I eject into her mouth as I let out a moan. Twilight spits me out as she swallowed every last drop of my semen.

"Well? How was it, Twilight? Did his cum taste good?" Trixie asked.

"It's... It taste so amazing." Twilight whispered as she wiped her mouth with her hoof. I suddenly see her crawl up to me and she starts to kiss me passionately. I didn't know how to take it, but, I remember Trixie telling me that it's alright. I wrap my arms around Twilight as I kissed her back.

After a minute or so, we broke the kiss so we could catch our breath. Twilight looked down on me as a smile was on her face.

"So... Trixie told me that you and I could... Go out while you and her are still dating." Twilight said as she looked down on me. "So... Um... C-Can we?"

As I still remember what Trixie said. I looked at her again and she nods her head again.

"Well Twilight. I guess I could give you a chance. While I'm with Trixie." I said as I see Twilight's eyes go wide.

"Y-You would?" She asked excitedly. I nod my head to her and she hugged me tight as I'm getting a ton of thank yous from her. She was hugging me so tight, I could barely breathe. I feel like I just sewed her heart back up as I see tears of joy roll down her face.

"Hey, it's no problem Twilight." I said as I petted her mane.

"Anyways..." I hear Trixie as Twi and I looked at her. "Why don't we get down to a little fun time, shall we?"

"Oh, okay." Twilight said excitedly. "Um... You don't mind if I..."

"Of course not Twilight." Trixie said as she playfully scoffed her with her hoof. "I'll let you have this one."

Twilight's face turned to excitement as she excitedly lined herself up with my manhood. I watch her take it all the way in. After a little bit, she finally reached the base as we both moaned back in pleasure.

"YES!" Twilight screamed. "Finally! I've been waiting so long for you!"

"Y-Yeah." I said the best I could. Twilight begins to go up and down on me. I watch her for a little bit until Trixie brought in her ass on my face.

"You know what to do." Trixie said as she wiggled her ass in front of my face. I grabbed her plot as I sticked my tongue in her depths. The three of us grunting and thrusting as Twilight rides me with all her might and I'm eating out Trixie. I could hardly take in the pleasure that's driving me mad as I try my best to meet Twilight half way as she fucks me.

God her pussy is so tight. I have a feeling that I might release right then and there. I can feel Twilight's walls clamp down on me as her screams become louder and louder.

"Ngh! Ah! AH! AH! I-I'm gonna c-cum!" She screams. "It feels so good! Your cock is so.. Ah! AH! AH! AAAAHHHH!" She screams as she tilted her head back and a gush of fluids washed over me. I grunted as well as I feel my own semen eject into Twilight's hungry womb.

Trixie, however, was getting close too. Until she finally came as I swallowed every last drop of her fluids.

At last, we both collapse onto the bed as we held in each others brace. Twilight cuddled with me more. Knowing how happy she is that she's been wanting to be with me ever since I got here.

"So Twilight. How does it feel to have a sexy boyfriend by your side?" Trixie asked.

"It's... So nice." Twilight pants as a yawn escapes her mouth. I reached down as I kissed her on the lips. Twilight looked up at me as she blushed.

"I love you Twilight." I whispered.

"I.. I love you too." Twilight said as it feels like she's about to cry again. But this time, no tears.

"I love you too Trixie." I said so I won't forget about her. Trixie giggles.

"I know you do. That's why you got two sexy mares with you." She said.

"Heh, yeah." I chuckled as the three of us fell into a very cozy slumber.

Author's Note

Well everypony. That's it. I'm sorry for the very long wait. I've been getting writers blocks for a very long time. I can't believe it took me more than a year to complete this story. Wow. Anyways, I always hoped there would be a reading of this soon. So... That's it for this story everypony. Thanks for reading. ;)