The Seduction of Colgate

The following morning arrived and the snow had once again picked up and the winds were blowing stronger than they were during the night. When Colgate and Twilight woke up, they gave one another seductive smiles. Twilight gave her a quick kiss and commented, "Just what I was hoping for, the storm being worse!"

Colgate rolled on top of her and replied, "Oh I know Twily, I know. You know what that means don't you?"

Twilight gave her a smile, "More bonding time?" Both mares' stomachs began to growl and she added, "After breakfast?"

Colgate replied, "Yes but I think we should have something simple. After all the less time we spend on breakfast, the more time we can spend bonding!"

This was something that shocked Twilight. She knew how Colgate tended to operate and was shocked that she would want to rush breakfast for more bonding. She wasn't about to pass this up though. "Oh I'd love that Colgate, we can eat and then you can lay on top of me, we can kiss passionately and you can dominate me all day long!"

Colgate's experience the previous night dominating Twilight was something that had woke up a part of her that she didn't knew existed before, a side of her that desired sex and lots of physical contact. If Twilight wanted her to dominate her, she was going to damn well do it, "Oh yeah Twily, I'm open for that! Dominating you is exactly what I want to do!"

The two got out of bed, joined hooves and headed downstairs to have some breakfast. Twilight began to think of something that would be simple and quick. She asked, "Is a bowl of oats ok?"

Colgate gave her a seductive smile, "Oh it is Twily, we can have a bowl of oats for breakfast and then I have other plans, plans that will give both of us more pleasure than either one of us has likely ever had."

Twilight giggled, "Oh?"

Colgate pointed to her horn and suggested, "You know what I want!"

Twilight gave her a smile and a nod. While she was fixing her breakfast, her shock was only growing bigger. Not only was Colgate wanting to dominate her and obviously grind her marehood up against hers but she was wanting horn sex. She wasn't fully sure about her but she had never had anything up in her and it was making her a bit nervous. Once she finished fixing their oats, she motioned for Colgate to join her at the table. Colgate joined her but could sense something was off with the lavender Alicorn and was going to find out what it was.

"Twilight," Colgate questioned "what's wrong? All of a sudden you seem a bit off."

Twilight replied, "I'm just nervous. It is just that I've never had anything up in me before."

Colgate gave her a smile, "I've never had anything up in me before either and your horn is longer than mine but I'm not worried."

Twilight knew that it took a lot more to rattle Colgate than it did other ponies but still couldn't help but be concerned, "I know how you are Colgate but still, I'm nervous you might hurt me."

Colgate sighed, "Tell you what Twilight, if I get to hurting you too much I'll stop, alright?"

Twilight gave her a nervous smile, "Alright, after breakfast let's share our horns."

The two ate their breakfast before heading upstairs to bond in what is the most intimate way for unicorn mares. Once they arrived the two looked at one another before Colgate asked, "So do you want to share yours first or do you want me to share mine first."

Twilight, while she did want this very badly, was still nervous. She knew though that if she didn't receive first that she may wind up chickening out and denying Colgate the pleasure she wants. She plopped down on the bed and said, "Colgate, you can give me your horn first." She became more nervous and requested, "But please be gentle, like I said this is my first time."

Colgate gave her a smile and replied, "Don't worry Twilight, I will be gentle."

Colgate got on her knees and began to insert her horn into Twilight's marehood. Both mares let out a gasp of delight as her tip first went in and as Colgate continued to push her horn in, both mares moaned in delight but once Colgate had most of her horn in Twilight, she felt a barrier that quickly gave way and Twilight screamed in pain. Colgate quickly pulled out and said, "I'm so sorry Twilight, I didn't mean to hurt you."

Twilight screamed, "It's ok Colgate, this is normal for virgins when they get penetrated like this. Just wait a minute and you can put your horn back in me, your whole horn!"

Colgate gave her a smile and it wasn't long until Twilight gave her the go ahead to give her her horn again. Since Twilight had been penetrated, Colgate knew that she could put her whole horn in her without any problems so she shoved her whole horn into her to the point where Twilight's lips were making contact with her forehead. She began to thrust the Alicorn and quickly both were moaning in ecstasy.

The feeling of Colgate's horn in her was something she had never felt before and it felt like a slice of heaven to her. Once Colgate began to thrust her, the pleasure Twilight was feeling was even greater. She began to call out her name, "Oh Colgate baby, yes baby yes. Harder, faster, deeper!"

Colgate complied with her request and she too was feeling pleasure beyond imagination. Twilight was hot, wet and like it was with all virgins, incredibly tight. The feeling was more than she could imagine and she began to call out her name, "Oh Twily baby, Oh Twily baby, yes, yes, yes!"

The breathing of both of them became heavier and their moans became louder as both of them were nearing a climax. When they finally climaxed, both let out a loud moan and Twilight soaked Colgate's forehead in girlcum while Colgate left a big stain on the floor. After their experience, both were pretty tired. Colgate gave her a smile and said, "Wow Twilight, that was amazing!"

Twilight returned the smile, "It was more than anything I could have ever imagined!" She then yawned, "I don't know about you but I am really tired. I was thinking that we could get some rest before I give you my horn."

Colgate too yawned, "That sounds good Twilight although before we decide to get some sleep, I have something I want to ask you."

Twilight's eyes grew wide in anticipation wondering what Colgate was going to ask her, hoping that it would be something special. She replied, "Yes?"

Colgate didn't want to just flat out ask her, she wanted to do something more romantic. She began, "Twilight, I'm going to admit something. When we were up in Celestia's school, despite you not spending much time with me and the girls, I had always wished you would. Once we began to come of age, I would fantasize about us sharing our horns a lot more often than I should have. I know this may sound creepy but the reason I ultimately chose Ponyville to open my practice was so I could be closer to you."

Twilight gasped, "Really, you opened it here because of me?"

Colgate continued, "I did. When I heard that Princess Celestia was sending you here, I scrapped my plans to open my practice up in Canterlot. Luckily I came from a fairly well off family so they gave me a loan to open my practice up down here instead. Ultimately I got them paid off and was able to afford a place of my own. Yes I went through a lot of hard times but it was worth it to be in the same town as you."

Twilight then became curious, "If that was the case, then why didn't you come and tell me you wanted to spend time with me, that you wanted something special?"

Colgate continued, "Well you got your new friends and I figured you wouldn't have time for me or want to spend time with me and I ultimately thought you'd wind up hooking up with one of your friends."

Twilight then decided to make an admission, "Colgate, I will admit, I had a crush on Fluttershy but I never pursued her because I was always hoping somepony else would want me." Twilight gave her a seductive look and continued, "Somepony such as....."

Colgate couldn't take it any more as she interrupted, "Twilight, would you be my marefriend?"

Twilight leapt into her hooves and exclaimed, "Yes Colgate yes, yes I'll be your marefriend!"

The two then began to kiss passionately. As they were kissing, both of them felt something they had never felt before. They felt that they were loved, they felt truly happy. When they broke the kiss Twilight looked at her new marefriend lovingly, "So Colgate, are you ready to receive my horn?"

Colgate exclaimed, "You bet I am Twily!"

Twilight then took to Colgate, knocking her down and readying herself to give her the horn sex she wanted so badly. One thing Twilight noticed though was that Colgate wasn't the slightest bit nervous. Twilight gave her a curious look and asked, "Colgate, aren't you going to ask me to be gentle?" She then became more stern, "Or are you lying to everypony about never thinking about anything sexual, have you done this before?"

Colgate turned beet red and replied, "Uh, maybe!" She saw an angry look on Twilight's face and knew she better fess up, "Ok, I'll admit, other mares have given me their horn. I had five marefriends at the dental academy in Manehattan."

Twilight grunted in frustration, "Well then, just because of that I'm going to be extra rough with you!"

Twilight then shoved her horn into Colgate's pussy and thrusted her hard. Much to Twilight's dismay, Colgate seemed to be enjoying Twilight being rough with her. She continued to thrust her until she soaked her forehead with her cum. Once they were finished Twilight gave her a smirk and laughed, "Also, we're going to go and you are going to admit everything to Amethyst and Sea Swirl AND then you are staying with me until Spike gets home." She then began to snicker, "And I can see to it that he won't be coming home anytime soon!"

Colgate gave her a nervous look, "Hey, that sounds great sweetie!"

Twilight laughed, "Well it better and I'm going to be rough with you every single time, got that sexy girl?"

Colgate nervously laughed, "Uh-huh!"