It's Hearts and Hooves Day again! Celestia's sun is shining, the birds are singing, and everypony is getting for this happy holiday, especially Golden Flare, who has found love in the most unlikely of ponies: Pinkie Pie. Today is also their one year anniversary and Golden has planned a date night with her to celebrate their love, things couldn't be more perfect.

Except for a little, orange Pegasus filly, who doesn't agree with their relationship, believing that they should be with somepony of their own race. Apple Bloom and Sweetie Belle believe that she is going off the deep end and that all of her crazy talk is because of the incident last year. Ignoring their accusations, she pushes on to see her plan through.

Will Golden and Pinkie have the best Hearts and Hooves Day ever?
Or will Scootaloo ruin it all for them?