2 - Fluttershy's Accidental Orgasm
"Oh, are you sure he stole it? Because if he didn't, it wouldn't be right to be mad at him," Fluttershy told Angel, who claimed Pinkie Pie's toothless alligator had stolen his carrots. Angel shook his head yes, wearing a grumpy face and with crossed arms, as if to say, "Well, what are you going to do about this?"
Neither Fluttershy nor any of the pets at her house dared mess with Angel's carrots. He helped to maintain the carrot section of the garden, and the only living creature he dared to permit entrance to that section was Fluttershy. The last thing to try and get at Angel's carrots was a red-breasted robin, for whom Fluttershy held a heartbreaking funeral, and Flutters grounded Angel for two weeks, saying he could not leave the house; but she still brought him carrots during that time.
Therefore, the news that a quarter of the carrots had been uprooted and snuck off someplace else was taken very seriously for two reasons: the theif that could steal that many of Angel's carrots right out from under his whiskerednose could be good at stealing other things, and none of them wanted to be the subject of the next heartwrenching funeral by not caring about some stolen carrots.
"Okay. I guess I'll go ask Pinkie about it, then." Fluttershy said goodbye to all of her pets, who waved back. She closed the door behind her and walked into town.
Ponyville was very busy that day. Flutters had to squeeze through a lot of crowded spaces, which she didn't like one bit. She shrank as much as she could and wished she could just disappear. By the time she had made it to Pinkie Pie's house, she was on the verge of either screaming or fainting. She grabbed the doorknob and almost yanked it open, but then she thought of how inconsiderate that would be, so she knocked lightly on the wood, her sweaty palm still gripping the doorknob.
"Ooh, visitors! I love visitors, don't you, Gummy? Come in!" The moment Pinkie yelled those words, Flutershy yanked open the door with all her might and slammed it shut behind her. Pinkie looked at her, worried for a moment. Fluttershy's face was flushed,she was sweating, and her wings were flapping lightly against the door.
"Oh, you don't like crowds, do you, Fluttershy?" Pinkie Pie asked. Fluttershy shook her head, walking forward a little bit.
"N-no. Why are there s-so many ponies out there anyways?" Fluttershy asked in a shaky voice.
Pinkie Pie walked next to Flutterhsy and wrapped her arm around Flutters, then with the other arm she made an arching motion as she said, "It's called, 'Black Friday.'" She walked off to the kitchen, saying, "It's a buyer's dream!" Pinkie came back with a glass of water, which Fluttershy drank down thankfully.
"Why'd you come here anyways, Flutters?" Pinkie asked.
"Oh, um, Angel told me that, uh, well, she thought Gummy might have taken his carrots," Fluttershy's voice got quieter and quieter until her voice was a small whisper.
Pinkie looked surprised for a moment, then called, "Gummy! Can you come here for a second, cutie?" In wobbled Gummy, Pinkie's toothless pet baby alligator. Fluttershy couldn't help but smile at the sight of him, he was just so cute.
"Um, hi, Gummy." Fluttershy said. Gummy stopped and looked at her blankly. "Did you, by any chance, happen to get any, um, carrots recently?" Gummy blinked once and continued to stare at Fluttershy.
Fluttershy looked at Pinkie and said, "I don't think he understands me at all."
"Well, then. I guess we'll have to look for carrots ourselves! It's like a game of hide and seek! Come on, start looking!" Pinkie ran off into another room in pursuit of carrots.
"Okay, I guess," Fluttershy said too quietly for Pinkie to have heard, and she started looking around her, checking for any place Gummy might have been able to hide some carrots. She walked over to the furntiure, where there were two two-seat couches and a recliner. She looked under one couch, finding nothing but dust and dead bugs, then got up tomove over to the next couch, when she saw him.
Outside, Big Macintosh was arguing with another Black Friday shopper over a ball of wool outside a window. Big Mac always turned Fluttershy on. She had dated him once before, and they didn't have much in common, he wasn't the kind of stallion she could relate to, but his body was so attractive to her for some reason. And she had a good view of his flank, and he was sweating from running around all day. It was so much for Fluttershy, and she immediately felt her pussy get wet. She blushed as she reached down and rubbed her clit lightly, but then she stopped. No. You will not do that. You never have, and you never will. She still looked at Big Mac, though, and her vagina produced juice against her will.
A single drop fell to the floor, and Gummy saw it. What little thought he had was innocent enough, Tall thing leaks. Plug leak with orange stick under bendy chair. So, while Fluttershy took in the view, Gummy stuck his head under the recliner, grabbed a carrot from his stash, walked over to underneath Fluttershy, took a deep breath, and, "plugged the leak."
The carrot shot up from Gummy's mouth into Fluttershy's already aroused vagina. And with that, her golden cherry was popped. She didn't have enough time to wonder what had just stuck in her vagina before she orgasmed. She stiffened, her eyelids fluttered, and she fell over onto the floor, spasming as her juices spilled over onto the carpet. "O-o-oh m-m-m-mmmmy!" Was all she could say. Soon, the orgasm passed, and she was left on the floor, wondering what had just happened.
Pinkie Pie rushed in. "Did you say something, Fluttershy? I heard-" Pinkie Pie stopped and looked at Fluttershy on the floor, a carrot sticking out of her vagina, cum in a puddle below her. She put her arms on her hips. "Silly old Gummy!"
