"What's wrong, AJ?" asked Rainbow Blitz. The stallions were sitting in Applejack's barn and they had been making out for a while. But then when Rainbow Blitz had tried to push it farther, Applejack had stopped him, placing his hooves on his chest.
"I, uh..." Applejack swallowed. "I-I don't think this is such a good idea."
"What are you talking about? You said you wanted to before."
"I know, but... I don't know if I want to now." Blitz leaned away, breaking from Applejack's embrace and sitting on his rump.
"Come on, don't be a tease. You should at least figure out whether you want it or not so I don't have to keep wondering!"
"I'm sorry!" Applejack shouted. He hung his head in his front hooves and began sobbing. "I just don't know!" Rainbow Blitz scooted up close to him, wrapping his hooves around him.
"Hey," he said apologetically, "it's okay. I'm sorry I called you that. But we can't do anything if you don't know what you want." He leaned away and looked at the orange stallion. "Tell ya what. We'll call this off today, and I'll give you two days to make a decision. If you want to do it, fine; if you don't, fine." He got up and walked to the barn door, pushing it open, and looked back at AJ with a warning expression.
"But listen; if you can't make a decision, I don't think this is gonna work." He turned and took flight, leaving Applejack to his thoughts.
Rainbow Blitz was flying over Ponyville the next day, looking down on the town and thinking how peaceful it looked in the mid-morning light. Then it was all ruined when he thought of Applejack. Rainbow shook his head to clear it of thoughts of the orange stallion, but it did little to help.
As Rainbow Blitz was flying near Sweet Apple Acres he moved to change course, but he saw Applejack waving to him from the ground. He banked and drifted downward, his hooves planting themselves on the grass a few feet away.
"Hey, AJ," he said, stretching and relaxing his wings before folding them up. "What's up?" The earth stallion looked down, fidgeting with his hooves.
"Well, uh... I thought about whatcha said. And I'm sorry I put ya through all that. It's just that I've always been told bein' a... coltcuddler—" He had to struggle to even say the word. "—was gross and immoral. I guess maybe my family's opinions kinda got through to me."
"Hey, it's alright," said Rainbow Blitz, laying a wing over Applejack's back. The farm pony stiffened at first, then forced himself to relax. They started walking together toward the house in the distance. "My family didn't really accept my bisexuality at first either. They thought I was just going through a phase and I should see a shrink or something. You can probably guess how that would have gone."
"They could too, I'm guessin'."
"Right. But after a while, they pretty much laid off the drama. And actually, when I brought home my first coltfriend about a year later, they even joked around with him about my tendency to sleep!" Applejack chuckled at that, Blitz having managed to temporarily break him out of his funk.
"It's alright to be a coltcuddler," continued the pegasus. "It doesn't mean you're a bad pony; it just means you like colts. It's like if your favorite food is hayburgers instead of pizza. Doesn't make any difference; it's just what you're into." Applejack smiled at him.
"I'm kinda... into you," he said, blushing.
"I know," replied Rainbow without missing a beat. "I'm awesome like that."
"Rainbow, I... I want to do it." Rainbow looked at him uncertainly.
"You sure?"
"Yeah. I've thought a lot about it, and... I think I'm ready." Rainbow nodded.
"Alright. Where do you wanna go?" Applejack's face was blank at first, and then he frowned.
"Ya had to go and ask me that, now didn'tcha?"
"What about the house?" Applejack stopped and sat down, counting off the members of his family one by one.
"Well, let's see. Macarena's workin' the fields, Apple Buck's at school, and Grampy Smith is away visitin'—"
"Awesome!" said Rainbow Blitz, jumping into the air and cutting him off. "So we got the whole house to ourselves!"
"Well, so long as Macarena don't come in to get a drink or nothin'. Yeah, I guess we do." He smiled and continued walking to the house, a hovering and already horny Rainbow Blitz in tow.
They entered the house after a few minutes of walking, and Rainbow immediately grabbed Applejack and kissed him, mashing their lips together hard. Applejack pushed Rainbow gently away, his face an odd combination of amusement, shock, and horror.
"Rainbow, we're not even to my room yet!"
"You mean you didn't wanna fuck out here?" asked Rainbow Blitz innocently. "But that couch in the living room is so comfortable."
"Rainbow!" The pegasus fell to land on his back, writhing on the floor laughing. Eventually, he managed to compose himself enough to speak.
"I'm sorry, man, I'm just joshin' ya." He nudged his coltfriend on the shoulder playfully. "Let's go, Candy Rump."
"I told ya not to call me that," Applejack mumbled. Rainbow Blitz, of course, overheard.
"That was only because I said it within earshot of one of your relatives, and I already apologized. Thank Solaris the old geezer had cloud for brains."
"I'll have you know that cousin Golden Delicious is smart enough to keep records of the entire family tree. Can't rightly find it underneath all his cats, but the point still stands."
"Hey," said Blitz, interrupting him. "Are you gonna talk about your family, or are you gonna come upstairs so I can fuck your brains out?" He waggled his eyebrows, swaying his rump and flicking his tail seductively, which gave a fleeting glance of his balls and his slowly hardening shaft. Applejack could feel the fire lighting inside him, and from that point on he walked after the pegasus and his alluring genitals as if in a trance.
They reached the top of the stairs and turned toward the bedroom. Rainbow Blitz led Applejack through the door and Applejack hung his Stetson on the hat rack. The earth pony stopped by the bed, then Rainbow went back to the door and closed it, eliciting a quiet click. He then sauntered back over to Applejack.
Rainbow Blitz wrapped his forelegs around Applejack and pulled him close, and they gazed into each other's eyes for a moment before Blitz slowly leaned down to kiss Applejack with a surprisingly gentle and tender touch. His lips felt silky smooth against Applejack's own, and the stallion melted like ice on a hot day, gradually falling backward onto the bed and sinking into the soft, velvety sheets.
All the while, Rainbow Blitz, now on top of him, continued to kiss Applejack like he never had before. Their chests rubbed together and Applejack writhed in pleasure, caressing Rainbow's back and massaging the bases of his wings.
Suddenly, Applejack felt Rainbow's mouth open wider, and then he felt a foreign mass of writhing flesh that he quickly identified as a tongue. Startled at first, he soon warmed to the sensation, opening his own jaws and embracing the strange feeling. Rainbow's tongue licked the insides of his cheeks, then the top of his mouth, and repeated the cycle.
After a slight hesitation, he gingerly pushed out his own tongue, and he was instantly greeted with a myriad of strange tastes. He had never tasted another pony's mouth before. His first kiss was from a filly and had just been a peck on the lips, and he had only kissed Rainbow Blitz maybe a half-dozen times. But now, he was unable to understand how he ever lived without the strange and wonderful feeling. He could taste what Blitz had had for lunch that day. And he could never explain it, but he could have sworn that he could taste his coltfriend's desire.
Rainbow Blitz broke the kiss by gently placing a hoof on Applejack's chest. After a few seconds of heavy breathing, he spoke.
"So what do ya think of my Prench kiss?" he asked with a smirk. Applejack gazed at him with a blank look of delirious pleasure.
"Can ya do it again?" he asked breathily. The pegasus chuckled.
"Hey, easy, tiger. We haven't even gotten to the good stuff yet." Rainbow kissed him again, but more gently, allowing him to focus on other sensations—namely the hoof inching toward his retreating sheath and hardening penis.
Blitz's tool was already hard, but because of the way they had laid down it was held back by the bed, the downward-facing head smearing translucent pre-ejaculate on the fabric. As they moved slightly on the bed, the sheets gently rubbed his shaft, drawing out clear fluid drop by drop.
As they continued their make out session, Applejack wrapped one hind leg around Rainbow's frame, then the other, embracing him fully. The pegasus moaned into his mouth and instinctively bucked, rubbing his dick hard against the mattress. After a few seconds he broke the kiss and looked at his partner.
"You ready?" he asked. Applejack nodded.
"Yeah." Rainbow Blitz got up off of Applejack and sat on the bed next to him.
"You wanna be top or bottom?" he asked.
"Uh... pardon?" replied Applejack.
"You know," said Blitz, "top or bottom? Giving or receiving? Pitching or catching?"
"Oh," said the farm pony in realization. "Um... I wanna be the, uh... receiver."
"Cool," said Rainbow Blitz. "So, have you ever, ya know, used it? Put stuff up there?"
"Um..." said Applejack, his face flushing a bright red. "I used a, uh... flashlight once."
"Applejack, misusing household appliances. Tsk, tsk, tsk."
"What the hay does 'tisk' mean?" asked Applejack, his embarrassment having been replaced with confusion.
"I dunno, something I read in a book. So!" He clapped his hooves and rubbed them together in anticipation. "You ready fo' dis?"
"Sure. Just... be gentle." For once, Rainbow was serious.
"Of course," he said sincerely. Then he got to work.
Rainbow Blitz placed his hooves on either side of Applejack's body, guiding him into a kneeling position. Applejack lowered his face to the mattress and his tail lifted of its own volition, giving Blitz a first-class view of his hard, trembling stallionhood. It twitched and a drop of precum dripped on the sheet. In addition, his balls jiggled ever so slightly, and Rainbow looked at them with hunger in his eyes.
"Hey, RB," said Applejack, "don't ya need to, like, spit on it or somethin'?"
"What do you think I'm getting ready to do?" replied the pegasus in a smarmy voice. He used a hoof to lift Applejack's blond tail and brought his muzzle up to the stallion's puckered tailhole. He inhaled deeply, and the musky, masculine aroma made his mouth water. He opened his mouth and moved down, touching his tongue to Applejack's balls. He then slowly moved up, causing Applejack to give a throaty moan, and gave his taint a long, thorough lick. He finished by swirling his tongue around the circumference of his hole, then moved back to speak.
"You like that?"
"Y-Yeah, that felt pretty good." Rainbow grinned.
"Well, there's more where that came from." He grabbed one of Applejack's balls in his mouth and sucked on it. He moved his tongue around it, wetting the entire slightly-wrinkled surface, then shifted his mouth to move to the other.
Meanwhile, Applejack was in heaven. He had never felt anything like this before, and if it was anything like what was coming, he was sure he would not be disappointed. As the waves of pleasure moved through him, he ground his hooves into the bed, biting his lip so as not to moan some more and embarrass himself. But when Rainbow Blitz wrapped his lips around his protruding tailhole, there was no quieting his groan of lust.
Blitz wetly kissed Applejack's asshole, lathering it in lubricating saliva. He suckled on it like a teat, and Applejack's tail twitched, accompanied by another stifled moan. Finally, he pushed his tongue up against the barrier and it slowly wiggled inside, filling his mouth with Applejack's taste as it touched the inner surface of his rectum.
Applejack gasped at the feeling, and it became more and more difficult to hold back his noises. Blitz finally noticed and removed his mouth.
"Hey, you alright?"
"Uh," panted Applejack, "y-y-yeah, I'm fine. I just didn't wanna, uh, make too much noise." Rainbow Blitz looked at him as if he had just insulted the Wonderbolts.
"Too much noise? Trust me, you can never make too much noise!" He shifted closer to Applejack's ear. "I think you're lubed up enough. Let's get down to business. And feel free to make as much noise as you want."
Applejack shivered with anticipation as Rainbow Blitz mounted him, placing his hooves on the bed on either side of Applejack's barrel. He felt the pegasus' hard cock hit his balls as it swung between his hind legs, and his own member throbbed with need. Rainbow Blitz's head rested on his shoulder, and the stallion whispered in his ear.
"You ready, AJ?"
"Yeah, RB. Put it in me."
"Can do, farm colt," said Blitz with a grin. He sat back on his haunches and spit on a hoof, then rubbed the saliva on his member. Then he guided the tip with a hoof, lining it up for penetration.
"If it hurts, let me know, okay?" he said. Applejack nodded in response. Then Blitz pressed the slightly flared head of his member against the ring of muscle and after a few seconds of prodding, it relaxed enough for him to pop inside.
Applejack immediately winced, but then the initial sharp stab of pain quickly became a dull throb that he felt he could manage. Once he got over the discomfort, he felt amazing. This was a thousand times better than anything he had ever experienced.
As the firm flesh of the organ spread his soft anal walls, he could feel every inch of it sinking deep into him. What was formerly pain became a pleasant tingling in his loins as he grew familiar with the sensations. As the medial ring passed the threshold, Applejack's eyes rolled back in his head and he pushed backward into Rainbow Blitz, driving him deeper. The medial ring passed the entrance and still the shaft continued to enter him.
Finally, Rainbow Blitz bottomed out, the small tuft of fur above his crotch brushing against the underside of Applejack's tail and his balls slapping quietly against his taint. Rainbow kissed Applejack on the back of his neck. Then he gently pulled back out, leaving Applejack feeling empty. Then Rainbow thrust into him again, relieving the feeling and causing Applejack to let out an especially loud moan.
"Ya like that, AJ?" whispered Blitz into his ear.
"Yeah," replied the earth stallion breathily. As Applejack grew used to the feeling of penetration, Rainbow's gradually thrusts increased in frequency and force. Soon he settled into a rhythm, pumping in and out at a steady rate. Each time he thrust it drove an effeminate whimper out of Applejack, which Blitz took to mean that he was doing a good job.
Applejack, of course, was in heaven. With every thrust he felt he was going to crack in two, and each movement sent a bolt of pleasure up his spine. His tail quivered with his excitement, lifting occasionally as his body tried to signal his partner to keep going.
After a few minutes of this, Blitz decided slowed down and stopped his thrusting, and Applejack looked back at him curiously. The pegasus pulled out with a slurp, and a tiny bit of soreness in Applejack's rear accompanied the motion.
"Let's switch it up a bit," said Blitz. He nudged Applejack to turn around and guided him into a position where he was lying on his back. The farm pony's hard, 9-inch cock throbbed right in Rainbow's face, and Applejack looked at him with the most adorable expression that he had ever seen.
He sat back on his haunches, then spit into his right hoof, rubbing it over his dick and lubing it up once more. Applejack lay there, his own genitalia quivering as Rainbow Blitz inched the flared tip of his stallionhood toward the puckered entrance.
Rainbow pushed the head of his cock inside Applejack, spreading his cheeks apart. The earth pony groaned as he was penetrated, moaning loudly into Rainbow's prismatic mane. He grabbed Rainbow's shoulders and hung on for dear life, falling into a state of bliss.
"Ya like that, Applejack?" said Blitz as he began working his hips.
"Oh, yeah," replied Applejack unsteadily. "It feels so good." As he was rutted, Applejack could feel a pressure forming in his balls. Though he had been a virgin up to that point, he knew what that pressure was, as well as how it would feel when it was released. With every thrust of Rainbow's hips, Applejack moved his own pelvis to slap against Rainbow Blitz, producing a loud, rhythmic smacking sound.
By this point, Applejack was fully into the experience and never wanted to give it up for anything. Each thrust smacking against his cheeks and pounding his inner walls sent him into a whirlwind of ecstasy as he felt waves of pure pleasure rocking his body like an insubstantial leaf at the mercy of a hurricane's mighty winds.
"Oh, Blitz!" he moaned, abandoning all notion of shyness or shame. "Fuck me harder! Oh, Solaris, yeah!"
"You like this big cock, AJ?"
"Oh, I love it, Blitz!" Rainbow Blitz grinned at having discovered this other side to his coltfriend. He wrapped one fetlock around Applejack's throbbing, rock-hard, precum-leaking member and started stroking it, milking it for that sticky, white prize that signified a job well done.
"Are you a dirty colt, AJ?" ventured Blitz, and he was quite satisfied with the answer.
"Yeah, Blitz! Fuck me like a little dirty colt!" Applejack's cheeks clenched, and Rainbow knew his partner was close. He worked Applejack's cock slightly more vigorously and thrust even harder than he had been in an attempt to drive the other stallion over the edge.
Soon, the head of Applejack's cock flared, signaling the imminent orgasm. His moans increased in frequency and volume, eventually reaching a crescendo. Finally, his anus contracted and his balls twitched, and a liberal jet of semen exited the flared head and sprayed in between the two lovers, coating them both with viscous, milky-white seed. He released a few more jets of semen that had less power behind them, and after a couple of spurts they petered out, and while his noises also lowered in volume, they did not completely disappear.
As Applejack's orgasm subsided, he discovered that he did not feel the onset of the usual post-orgasmic aversion to further sexual activity. Rather, against all odds, he seemed to be even more sensitive than before, and in response he tightened his hold and latched onto Rainbow's back with an iron grip in order to weather the intense ecstasy radiating from his sensitive asshole.
Rainbow Blitz, meanwhile, was nearing his own orgasm. The pressure was building and he was getting closer and closer to letting it go. He thought that he should let Applejack know, and promptly did as such.
"AJ," he said through gritted teeth, "I'm ready to cum. Where do you want it?"
"In me, RB! Cum inside me!" After only a couple more thrusts, Rainbow reached the point of no return, the head of his cock flaring outward. With one last push and a loud grunt, he shoved himself into his coltfriend and shot a huge, creamy load deep into Applejack's colon.
The flared cock head kept all of his seed deep inside, blocking Applejack's passage like a plug as he was slowly filled like a balloon with thick, creamy cum. A small amount of the gooey liquid made it past the plug formed by Rainbow's flare, however, and seeped out of Applejack's asshole and dribbled down his tail. Applejack's tender hole could feel every drop shooting off inside him and he wanted more and more.
Eventually Rainbow's cum trickled out and stopped, leaving them frozen in a passionate, cum-covered embrace. Rainbow Blitz turned his head slightly and gave Applejack a kiss, cradling the spent stallion in his forelegs. His cock gradually softened and shrank, finally pulling out of Applejack's ass with a quiet pop. Rainbow's cum leaked out and coated the sheets, but neither stallion paid attention. Rainbow Blitz flopped down and laid on his back next to Applejack. He then turned and draped a foreleg over his partner's chest.
"You have a good time, AJ?" Applejack simply laid back and stared at the ceiling. After a moment he replied.
"That was amazin', RB." Blitz grinned.
"I thought so. You weren't too bad yourself." Applejack turned to look at Rainbow Blitz.
"Now ya don't go tellin' ponies 'bout this, ya hear? I know how much ya like to brag."
"Cross my heart and hope to fly, stick a cupcake in my eye," said Rainbow Blitz, reciting Bubble Berry's classic promise and making the associated motions.
"Alright," said Applejack. "I'm just not ready to tell ponies yet. Maybe someday, but not yet."
"Don't worry, AJ. You can count on me."
Unknown to them, Macarena had been watching through the window for the last minute or so of the ordeal. She had been carrying some baskets of apples inside when she had heard some... questionable noises coming from the house.
So her brother was gay. Well, it's not like it was a surprise. After all, the quiet mare saw a lot more than anypony gave her credit for. Perhaps she would blackmail her brother with the information. She could hold that over him for however long she wanted to get whatever she wanted.
Or she could forget about it and not say anything. Yeah, that was easier.
