Setting Her Heart Afire

Around a year had passed since that wonderful night in the moonlight, Jake and Applejack were still together, spending their days off with one another and walking around town.

Many ponies had noticed the two getting closer and closer. After around the six month mark, Ponyville had figured out that the human and the country mare had gotten together. They were undeniably cute together and there was no denying that the love they shared was quite strong but they had not ventured into the realm of sexual desire yet. The farthest they had gone were heavy make-out sessions on Applejack’s bed, yet, when Applejack asked to go a step further, Jake would turn her offer down. Sure his erection screamed otherwise, but his mind told him that he wanted to be with Applejack for a little while longer before venturing there. Jake saw his opportunity when their one year anniversary approached. Applejack had been asking for sex for at least a few months now and Jake was happy to finally feel confident enough to give it to her. But he wanted to do it right, like he would back on Earth. He would treat Applejack to some love and attention, order dinner, and make his move after. He was all set, a twinge of nervousness ripped through his body but quickly subsided as he made up his mind.

He left work that Friday with the intention to take the weekend off. He was granted this request due to his ability to plot-kiss and be damn good at his job. Jake made his way to his new home. It was modified to fit his large body and towered over the nearby neighborhood homes. His neighbors were quite nice, Taylor, Bon Bon and their foal Sweet Seas, and 2 mares by the name of Lily and Roseluck. Jake opened his door and entered his home, his mind racing with preparation ideas. Applejack was no Rarity in the sense that she hated pink lovey dovey stuff. Of course, that didn’t mean she didn’t like the love poems Jake wrote her and left hanging in the trees of the orchard so when she did her work, she was rewarded with a sweet love poem about her. It never ceased to amaze her how silver his tongue was. Jake knew what dinner was going to be that night, pasta and sauce. Applejack had said on numerous occasions that this simple meal was her absolute favorite. Jake cracked his knuckles and began to work.

When Applejack arrived at Jake’s house like she did every Friday night, she immediately sensed something different. She entered to the glorious smell of tomato sauce and garlic bread. She found Jake in the dining room, waiting for her.

As soon as he saw her, his face lit up in a smile.

“Well hello there my hard working mare. Have a seat, dinner is ready.” Jake beamed.

“Well yer awfully chipper today ain’t cha?” Applejack returned his smile.

“I got the weekend off so yeah, I’m in a pretty good mood. Getting to spend it with you makes it even better.” He said, pulling her chair out for her.

They ate their dinner making small talk about their days and their boring work, it all came to an end as Jake cleared the dishes and packed away his leftovers.

“Hey AJ, I haven’t showered yet so before you curl up with me, just let me clean myself up alright?” Jake asked.

“Sure thing sugarcube. Don’t take too long.” Applejack winked at him.

He pecked her on the lips before climbing the stairs to his bathroom.

This part of the plan was crucial, since it all depended on Applejack doing her part. Jake was no idiot and he knew that Applejack would sit and listen to him in the shower when she came over. Sure enough, as he turned the hot water on, her heard hoofbeats approach and stop outside the bathroom door.

Jake stripped down to his boxers and counted to three before flinging the door open and grabbing Applejack in one motion. She let out an alarmed yelp as he shut and locked the door before setting her down.

“What are ya-oh.” Applejack looked at Jake, a blush making its way across her face.

“Happy one year anniversary Applejack.” Jake said before picking her up yet again and bringing her lips to his own in a sloppy kiss. When they pulled apart, it finally clicked in her mind. He was going to give her what she desired for so long now. Her eyes hooded themselves and she looked down to Jake’s crotch to see the tent he was pitching. It was quite evident now as it stuck out like a silo underneath her.

“Am I that good hun?” Applejack purred.

“You have no idea how long I’ve been holding this back. Let me tell you AJ, you might not walk straight for a while I’m so pent up.” He growled in a husky voice as he mashed lips with her. His tongue snaked into her mouth and her own followed. She tasted like apples, nothing new there, he was more interested as to what her leaky faucet tasted like, feeling her arousal drip onto his boxers.

Jake opened the shower door and stepped inside, making sure to discard Applejack’s hat and mane and tail ties along with his own boxers before entering. They continued to make-out with renewed vigor as Applejack grinded her dripping slit against his shaft.

“Jake! Touch me! Please! I’ve waited too long!” Applejack cried in desperation

Jake brought one hand from her flank to her hot nethers and slid his finger inside. Applejack let out a scream of relief as Jake began to pump her slowly with his fingers.

“Oh Jake yes! Sweet Celestia!” Applejack cried out.

Suddenly he pulled out and set her down on the floor of the stall. Jake spread her legs and dove into her cunt head first. Applejack threw her head back and let out a silent scream of ecstasy as her back arched.

“Holy buck Jake!” She cried.

Jake snaked his tongue into her snatch, tasting and feeling every part of her insides, brushing her clit with his teeth.

Applejack came with a scream and another arching of her back. Jake lapped up every drop of fem-cum that came his way to the point that his chin glistened with her and the water cascading down upon them.

“I want to continue this in the bedroom. Is that ok?” Applejack asked seductively, already knowing the answer.

“Yes ma’m” Jake said with a smile.

As they dried themselves off, modesty was cast to the wind as Applejack leaped up into his arms and began kissing him again as they made their way to the bed.

Jake set the farmer mare down on the soft sheets and she looked up pleadingly at him.

“Jake, please. Rut me, love me, make me your mare!” Applejack nearly begged.

Her answer came in the form of his throbbing erection parting her lower lips.

Applejack tensed up at the feeling of excitement that washed over her.

“It’s my first time so be gentle.” Applejack said to the human.

“Applejack, my lovely Applejack. I will do anything for you.” Jake said.

He suddenly pulled himself out.

“JAKE? Wha-” Applejack shouted in shock at the feeling of being left hanging.

“Applejack, I want you to move over so I can lie down.” Jake instructed.

Applejack did as she was told and Jake set himself down on the bed and patted his chest.

Applejack crawled onto his defined torso and kissed him deeply.

Jake broke off for a moment, as Applejack felt his head at her entrance again.

“This is gonna hurt a little, so just kiss me and let me do the work, ok?” Jake asked.

“Yeah, I gotcha Jakey” Applejack whimpered.

With one quick motion, he entered her. His shaft sliding up through her love tunnel and breaking her hymen easily.

Applejack let out a muffled cry as she felt the excruciating pain of her virginity being taken. The pain was intense but within a minute was giving way to pleasure Applejack had never felt the likes of before in her life.

“Oh Celestia Jake!” Applejack murmured.

“Ready to move?” Jake asked her tentatively.

“Yes” She whispered.

Jake pulled out until just his tip remained in and thrust softly back into her tight snatch.

The light smack of her flank against his made a sound quite satisfying to the both of them.

Applejack let out a loud cry of ecstasy as she felt Jake’s cock fill her to her limit and remove itself, making her shudder uncontrollably with pleasure. She would reach her peak soon, there was no question about that.

“Jake! I’m about ta cum!” Applejack said.

“Go for it then.” Jake grunted.

Applejack increased her pace and rode him until she felt a solid brick wall of pleasure hit her square in the chest. Applejack screamed as she dumped her fluids all over Jake’s still embedded cock.

Applejack slowed her pace and lowered her muzzle to his face and kissed him.

“Have you even hit your peak yet sugarcube?” Applejack asked.

“Nope.” Jake smiled.

“Wow, so it is true. You humans do last longer in the hay.” Applejack chuckled.

“Wanna go again?” Jake asked.

“Hay yeah I do.” She smirked,

Jake suddenly thrust himself as deep as he could, getting a cry out of the startled mare. Applejack ground her hips into his as they made out with fervor and passion.

“Applejack, I’m about to peak!” Jake warned.

“Inside! Give it to me! Make me your mare!” Applejack cried as Jake thrust deep within her depths on final time and released his seed into her waiting snatch. The feeling of his love enter her sent Applejack over the edge and into another world of bliss.

Their chests heaved and they kissed deeply as they reveled in the glow of each other’s orgasms.

“That was amazing.” Applejack panted.

“I figured we would like it.” Jake smiled.

“We are going to do this again sometime, but right now, I think we just need some rest after we clean up sugarcube.” Applejack cooed as she brushed a lock of his dark brown hair out of his eyes.

“I can live with that.” Jake chuckled.

They rose and walked to the bathroom for another shower, this time for cleaning and not foreplay.

As they washed and scrubbed each other clean of their romp, Applejack got on to her hind legs and laid her head on Jake’s muscular torso.

“Jake, promise you’ll never leave me for another mare. Stay with me forever.” Applejack cooed.

“After tonight, it’s gonna take some convincing to get me to leave your bright and beautiful face.” Jake said, looking down into the mare’s sparkling green eyes with his own.

That night was the first night Jake and Applejack shared together as lovers and as soul-mates. For Applejack, he had truly set her heart afire with affection.