Double Birthday Surpirse

by Seanzilla115

Rating: mature
Tags: Comedy, Fluttershy, Pinkie Pie, Sex, Anthro, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Alternate Universe, Romance, Original Character
Length: 3569

It's Silver Hawk's Birthday, and Pinkie Pie has something 'interesting' planned involving Silver's Marefriend, Fluttershy.

It's Silver hawk's birthday, and Pinkie has something 'interesting' planned for it. She just needs one more thing to complete it..Silver Hawk's Marefriend, Fluttershy.

(Image is done by SS2sonic of DA and FA)

(Pairings: Fluttershy X OC with bits of Pinkie joining in, and hints of TwiDash)

*Characters are over 18 years of age, and are anthro(specifically based on SS2Sonic's anthro designs)*

=WARNING: if you're under 18, or don't care for lemon fics or anthro ponies..turn away now!=

(Co-written with KKD Silver)

Published 2015-03-07 23:10:02 UTC
Last updated 2015-03-07 23:10:02 UTC

Double Birthday Surprise

Author's Note

Even though I promised the remake of my first lemon story, here's a new one to hopefully tie you over...again, and I cannot stress this enough, if you're under 18, or not into lemons or anthro ponies, turn away now...also, here are the ages for each character.

Silver Hawk; 21-22

Fluttershy: 21

Pinkie Pie; 20

Oh, and one last thing i should mention that in this Au, both Fluttershy and Silver Hawk(my Oc) are from Neighpon

Double Birthday Surprise

“Hmm...let’s see…” Pinkie hummed as she looked through a calendar. Since she was pretty much the town’s party planner, she had info one whose birthday it would be, as well as the overall schedule for big events, and she checked to see that today was…, “‘Silver Hawk’s Birthday’? Well well, This is quite the surprise...kinda, “she then tapped her chin in thought, “I wonder what Fluttershy is going to get him? I mean, they have been going out for a few months.”

This kinda gave her a little bit of an idea for the two lovebirds, a small grin growing on her face. She just needed two things, and she happens to know where one of them was.

“So ya need..uh..”

“Sexy bunny costumes. Do I need to repeat myself?” Pinkie asked, “And it’s not just for me, but for a friend as well. I have something BIG planned involving her.”

“Well… okay. I hope you know what you’re planning, Pinkie,” the mare with light cobalt colored hair sighed before going into the back room, “What color would you like them to be?!”

“Hmm… I’m thinking either a nice shade of magenta or a nice goldish yellow.”

“..We’re all out of the latter, but we have some magenta ones left,” the mare replied off-screen.

“In that case, I’ll need two of them,” Pinkie answered, ‘Ohh~ this is going to be good! I just need one more thing..or rather..one shy mare.’

Meanwhile, Fluttershy was tending to her animal friends as usual, feeding a few of the chickens some seeds before she sat up, dusting off herself quickly before she saw a familiar pinkette bouncing over towards her.

“..P..Pinkie P-,” Fluttershy began before Pinkie glomped right, knocking the two into her home as the door closed.

“Hiya Flutters!” Pinkie smiled, bouncing off Fluttershy as she moved back a bit, “How're ya?”

“Um..o-okay I guess,” Fluttershy replied as she stood up, adjusting her forest green sweater, “W..was there something you need, Pinkie?”

“Actually, yea. You see, Silver Hawk’s birthday is today,” Pinkie informed.

“T..today?!” Fluttershy squeaked before Pinkie appeared from under her, using her..ahem, rather large bust as a hat.

“Yeppers! It may be last minute, but I thought of a different kind of party I could help throw him, but I need your help,” Pinkie added, adgustign her ‘hat a bit’.

“..O-Ok but..wh-what kind of party?” Fluttershy couldn’t help but ask.

“..Well…” Pinkie paused as she leapt up and whispered something into Fluttershy’s ear, making the shy mare blush heavily.

“Th-th… that kind of party?” she gulped.

“As Applejack’s brother would say, Eeeyup,” Pinkie nodded as she reached for something behind her, “I even got the costumes picked out for the two of us.”

“Oh… my…” Fluttershy blushed so deeply that her pale yellow fur looked reddish-orange.

“Yup. Pretty great huh?” Pinkie asked with a playful smirk, holding a pair of soft magenta colored bunnygirl outfits with black leggings, and a pair of magenta colored bunny ears, “Got these two for a great price.”

Fluttershy just flushed more until her entire body was red before fainting.

“..Fluttershy?” pinkie blinked as she crouched down to the shy mare’s face, “Fluttershy? wake up~...hmm...how can I..oh! I know!”

With that, Pinkie rushed towards the kitchen before rushing back in, carrying a bucket of cold water before splashing it onto Fluttershy.

“Kya!” the shy mare yelped as she shot up.

“Sorry. Had to..wake..you..” Pinkie paused before seeing how Fluttershy’s sweater clinged to her body..mainly around her breast, “..Are you not wearing a bra?”

“Eep! Uh… w-well… I-I couldn’t find one that could fit me, so I..I’ve been..g...going braless,” Fluttershy admitted with a blush, holding her arms over her chest.

“Oh my sweet Celestia…I’m surprised Silver Hawk hasn’t jumped you yet with those boobie bombs out!” Pinkie exclaimed, making Fluttershy blush heavier.

“S...Silver’s not like that, Pinkie,” Fluttershy stated.

“He’s not? I would’ve figured you two would’ve gone..onto..wait. Are you a virgin?”

Her response was Fluttershy blushing heavily once more, the shy mare giving a small, very shy nod.

“...Oh my… then this should make Silver’s Birthday even more special! Think about it, not only are you two spending it together, but it’ll be your first time doing the dirty!” Pinkie giggled, “oh this is going to be great!”

Fluttershy just flushed red again, on the verge of fainting, before Pinkie wrapped her arm around her.

“So..are you in..or out, Flutters?” Pinkie asked before whispering, “You may never get this chance again.”

“....o….o…..o-o...okay,” Fluttershy nodded.

“Okay!”

Later, Silver Hawk was busy getting some food for tonight’s dinner. He was a bit excited that it was his Birthday today, but he was a bit saddened that no one seemed to acknowledge it.

“..Maybe if she’s not doing anything tonight, I can visit Fluttershy and we can have a small dinner together,” Silver said to himself, not aware of what Pinkie has planned, “...Maybe i’ll go visit her after I…” he paused before he spotted a note on a nearby wall, “Eh?”

He walked over to the walk and plucked off the note to read it.

“‘Silver Hawk, meet me tonight at my place for a special gift. Fluttershy,’” Silver read before blinking, ‘Special gift?’

That night, Silver arrived outside Fluttershy’s cottage, the snow-white stallion wearing a black jacket on top of a grey shirt, and a pair of blue shorts.

“Uh..Shy-chan? I’m here,” Silver called out as he knocked on teh door...before it opened on it’s own, “Eh?”

Confused, he stepped inside to see the room was dark, the snow-white pegasus stallion making sure he wouldn’t bump into anything.

“Uh...Shy-chan? your front door was opened an…” Silver began before a bright light blinded him a bit, “WHOA! What the…?!”

When his eyes adjusted to the brightness, he raised an eyebrow slightly when he saw a pair of rose-red curtains in front of him, a pair of spotlights soon shining down on it. Who were shining them was a mystery to him.

“What’s going on?” he asked before a familiar pink furred hand poked out of the curtains.

“Oh nothing,” Pinkie’s voice spoke as the hand gripped the curtains, “Just a special surprise for you.”

“Pinkie Pie? What’re you doing here? And wh-? Silver began before the curtains were flung open, causing him to blush a bright red when he saw what was behind it.

“Surprise~! Happy Birthday, Silver!” Pinkie cheered, the bubbly pinkette wearing one of the bunny costumes she bought earlier, the top showing a good amount of her DD-E cup cleavage, “And if you like what you see, you’re definitely going to love your birthday present!”

“..M..my birthday present?”

“Yup,” Pinkie nodded before calling out, “Oh Fluttershy~!”

From behind the curtain, a familiar head of pink hair poked out, the owner blushing a bright red before she took a deep breath. She then walked from behind the curtain, revealing she was wearing the same outfit, the top barely holding her mid F-low G cup breasts, and the lower half strained a bit by her rear.

“H...holy…!” Silver gawked, his entire head brighter and redder than a tomato.

“H..H..Happy Birthday, S..Silver-kun,” Fluttershy replied, a bit of Neighponese slipping into her dialogue.

“Sh-Shy-chan? Wh..what’re you wearing?” Silver managed to choke out.

“Oh this?” Pinkie spoke up as she stood next to Fluttershy, “It’s something I helped convince her to wear,” she then got into a small pose with her, causing their breast to mush against each other, “You like~?”

“W-W-Well… I…” Silver stuttered a bit, scratching the side of his head a bit as he turned towards the window, “I..It’s r-really cute on you, Sh-shy-chan.”

“..th..thank y..o..oh my,” Fluttershy blushed when she saw something.

“What? What is it?” Pinkie asked, but all Fluttershy could do was point at what she saw, a small ‘tent’ in Silver’s pants, “..Wow..That was fast. We haven’t started, and he’s already halfway there.”

“H...halfway there?” Silver blinked as he overheard this.

“You know,” Pinkie smiled as she pointed to his ‘tent’, making him look down before he blushed heavily, “...I believe you need some relief. Flutters?”

“Um… y-y-yes?” Fluttershy asked.

“Mind helping him out?” Pinkie asked as she pointed to Silver’s ‘tent’ once more, causing the shy mare to blush once more.

“Uh… w-well… o-okay,” she nodded rather shyly as she approached silver Hawk before sitting on his lap, “S..Silver…”

“Y..yes, Sh-” Silver Hawk began before Fluttershy pressed her lips against his, surprising him a bit before he returned it, the two kissing passionately before wrapping their arms around each other. He felt her tongue press against his lips before he opened them, allowing her entrance into his mouth as their tongues began to ‘dance’ around each other.

Unknowingly, Fluttershy reached down to Silver’s pants, slowly undoing the zipper and belt before she let out a small gasp when Silver’s still covered member popped up and pressed against her covered marehood, making her almost gasp before resuming the kiss.

“Wow...those two are going at it,” Pinkie noted as she watched the two kiss passionately.

Fluttershy soon separated the kiss with silver, a small trail of saliva trailing from their lips as they looked into each other’s eyes.

“I love you, Silver-kun,” Fluttershy smiled softly.

“I love you too, Shy-tenshi(angel),’ Silver replied back with his own soft smile.

After a bit, the two looked down to their crotches, and while they blushed, they felt like wanting something more.

Taking the first step, Fluttershy lowered herself down to Silver’s covered member before she pulled his underpants down, letting his half-awakened member out, making her blush a bit, but she seemed to drool a bit, the sight of the member making her eyes turning a rose-red for a moment before she gave it a small lick, causing Silver to gasp before she softly grasped his member and began to stroke it. As she did this, his member stiffened more and more until it reached its full length. Giving a small gulp, Fluttershy soon began to lick it, causing Silver to gasp once more. She was still hesitant, but as she licked his member, Silver moaning in the process, Fluttershy’s normally greenish-blue eyes turned rose-red again. This time, the shy mare started to suck on Silver’s member, her tongue dancing around it as Silver gripped the couch cushions.

“Wow..I guess it’s true..the shy ones are always the most wild,” Pinkie blinked, getting a bit hot herself as she watched this, teasing herself in the process.

“G..Gah~ Sh-shy-chan~” Silver grunted as Fluttershy continued to suck on his cock.

Fluttershy just moaned, giving Silver a blowjob at this point as she used her free hand to rub her covered marehood, the lower part of her outfit starting to get wet by her juices. As this went on, Silver moaned louder and louder, getting closer to his breaking point.

“Sh..shy-chan..i..I think I’m gonna..Unf!” Silver grunted as he climaxed, shooting a load into Fluttershy’s mouth, making her eyes widen as she moved off his cock and began to cough a bit, Silver’s remaining seed spilling onto the top of her breast, “G..g..gomen, Shy-chan.”

“It’s okay, Silver-kun,” Fluttershy smiled, swallowing what seed ended up in her mouth before looking him into the eyes once more, “Now..it’s your turn~”

“M..my turn?” Silver repeated before in a instant, Fluttershy pulled the top of her outfit down, letting her ample bust bounce free, “0//0”

“Oooh~ now you’re getting into the spirit of things,” Pinkie giggled as Fluttershy began to lick off what cum landed on her breast before she hefted one of them up to Silver.

“Thirsty?” Fluttershy asked in a near seductive tone.

“M-Maybe?” he answered nervously before she put her left nipple up to his mouth.

“Drink, my love~”

Silver froze for a moment before he began to suckle off her, causing the shy mare to gasp a bit as she began to feel his tongue against the nipple every few seconds.

“Oh~ yes~” Fluttershy moaned, loving the sensations as she began to grope her right breast.

“..Mmm~” Pinkie whined a bit, ‘Dang..now i want to join~!’

With that, Fluttershy moaned louder before Silver stopped, looking up at his marefriend before she cupped his face.

“You deserve something special~” the normally shy mare purred as she soon moved off him and laid down on the couch, spreading her legs while moving the blockade to her marehood, “It’s all yours, Silver-kun.”

Silver blushed intensely before he kneeled down to look at his marefriend’s marehood. He then gave it a lick, causing her to gasp loudly as Silver began to lick her ‘flower’. She moaned louder as Silver’s tongue tasted her inner walls, dancing around inside her as he did so.

“...Mmm~ that’s it!” Pinkie shouted, causing the two to stop for a moment, “I’m joining now!”

“Eh?” Silver blinked before Pinkie Pie leapt right towards him and Flutters, the excitable pinkette discarding her outfit in the process, going completely naked before getting up and shoved her marehood in Fluttershy’s face.

“Mmm~?!” Fluttershy muffledly gasped in surprise a bit, but she was feeling too good to care at the moment before she began to lick her friend’s pussy.

“Oh~ yes~ Don’t stop~” Pinkie moaned, waves of pleasure going up her spine as Fluttershy began to eat her out, the normally shy pinkette moaning as well as Silver resumed licking her marehood.

This didn’t take very long as the mares screamed with pleasure, the two spraying their femjuices in their friends’ faces.

“S..sweet,” Silver panted as he lapped up a bit of Fluttershy’s femjuices, “Just like you, Shy-chan.”

“Thank you, Silver-kun,” Fluttershy smiled after she moved Pinkie out of the way, smacking her fellow pinkette on the flank as the normally shy mare got on all fours, presenting her marehood and rear to him, “Now..come get me, my love~”

“Of course, my little shy angel,” Silver smiled as he approached her, rubbing his once more hardened cock against her flower, “This may hurt.”

“I’m ready,” Fluttershy insisted before Silver slowly inserted himself into Fluttershy, causing her to gasp before Silver hit a ‘wall.’ Within a second, Silver pushed further in before Fluttershy let out a loud moan of pleasure and pain, a bit of blood dripping from her pussy.

“Are you okay?”

“Y-Yea… I’m fine,” Fluttershy panted, her tongue sticking out a bit with each pant, ”P..please..continue.”

Silver nodded before he began thrusting in and out of Fluttershy, starting a bit slow.

Fluttershy began to give out small moans as the pain slowly began to fade away, pleasure replacing it as her breast began to swing with each thrust Silver gave her. They both began to moan as Silver began to thrust faster and faster. Soon,he moved Fluttershy onto her side before lifting her leg over his shoulder, the snow-white stallion still thrusting into her as he grasped one of her breast, causing her to give out a loud moan.

“Oh~ Silver~” she moaned loudly before Silver used his free hand to move her face towards his before the two began to kiss once more, “Mmm~!”

“Wow..this got steamy really fast,” pinkie noted as she watched the two, teasing herself again, desperate to join in once again.

After a few moments, the two switched positions as Fluttershy began to ride Silver in a reverse Cowgirl position, bouncing up and down on his stallion dick as her breast began to bounce around like mad.

Seeing this as an opportunity, Pinkie shot up before moving towards Fluttershy and began to suckle off her shy friend’s breast, starting with the right nipple. This made Fluttershy moan louder before Silver grabbed her waist and began to thrust in unison with her.

‘S-so amazing~! A..at this rate, I..I think i’m going to lose it~!’ Fluttershy thought, moaning loudly as she and Silver were on the verge of their second release.

“F..Fluttershy~! i..i’m about to climax again~!” Silver panted.

“M-Me too, Silver…” Fluttershy panted, “P..please..inside~”

“B..but what if..?” Silver began.

“Don’t worry. Just…please..R..rela..ahh~..ahn~!”

“G..Gah/Ahn~!” Silver and Fluttershy gasped as they climaxed, the latter spraying her juices on Silver's Member as Silver shot a load up in the normally shy mare.

“Th...tha...that was…” Silver panted before Shy put her finger against his lip.

“We’re not done yet~” she purred as she got off of him before kneeling down, Pinkie moving back in the process. She then wrapped her breast around Silver’s member, causing him to gasp once more before she executed a paizuri on him.

“G..gah~!” Silver grunted as he felt felt Shy’s massive mounds rub against his cock.

“Feels good, doesn’t it?” she asked with a small, near lust filled smirk.

“Y..yes it do-ahh~!” Silver gasped a bit.

“good~” Fluttershy purred as she felt something press against her back entrance, “?!”

“Sorry shy, but you left yourself open,” Pinkie’s voice grinned, making the normally shy mare turn her head a bit to see the excitable pinkette wearing a..strap-on, “Oh, and as for this? I borrowed it from twi and dashie.”

“What the..where is it?” Dash blinked as she searched through the drawers.

“What’s wrong, Dash?” Twilight asked.

“I can’t find it!” the pegasus responded.

“Oh that? Well, I think we can work around it,” Twilight smiled, casting a spell, which caused Dash’s short’s to strain as a large ‘tent’ began to form in it, “how’s that?”

“...I am so gonna tear that ass of yours up,” Dash grinned as she discarded her remaining clothing and leapt at Twilight.

“I was hoping you’d do that,” Twilight smiled, kissing Dash.

“So yeah..if this goes well..possible DP,” Pinkie shrugged before smirking a little, “But enough talk..time to tap dat ass~!” she declared as she slammed her ‘cock’ into Shy’s soaked marehood.

This made the shy mare gasp and moan before she took Silver’s member into her mouth, sucking on it like mad as her tongue rolled around the tip while Pinkie thrusted in and out of her like mad. This lasted for a few minutes before Silver released his third load, Filling Shy’s mouth up before she managed to swallow his seed.

“Mmmm~ So tasty~” she moaned before she pushed Pinkie back a bit, causing her strap-on to slide out of the normally shy mare before she positioned herself over Silver’s member once more before slid down on it, “Ahhn~!”

“G-gah~!” Silver grunted as Fluttershy began to ride him.

Taking this as an opportunity once more, Pinkie immediately positioned herself over Fluttershy, pressing the tip of her ‘cock’ against Fluttershy’s anal entrance.

“P..Pinkie wait~! n..not th-!” Shy began, but Pinkie didn’t listen as she plunged in anyway, “A-AHN~!”

“Sorry, but again, left yourself open Shy,” Pinkie panted as she began to thrust into her shy friend’s ass, smacking her rear every so often.

“A..ahh~” Silver gasped before he began to thrust as well, gripping his marefriend’s waist.

“Ahn~!” Fluttershy gasped/moaned loudly as she was double teamed, “This… this is…is..A-ahn~!” she moaned as she climaxed for a third time. She’d thought it would be over, but Silver and Pinkie continued to plow into her entrances, causign the shy pinkette to moan/gasp with each thrust, her breast bouncing around.

“You like getting DP’d..don’t ya Shy~?” Pinkie smirked as she smacked Shy’s flank once more, causing her to moan loudly.

“Y-Y-Yes…”

“I’m sorry, what?” Pinkie asked as she smacked Shy’s butt once more.

“Y-YES~!” Fluttershy gasped, her eyes nearly rolling into the back of her head.

“I thought so. Even though you were a virgin not too long ago, you are one naughty little pegasus, Shy~” Pinkie smirked as she soon grabbed her friend’s arms and began to hammer into her, making the shy pegasus moan louder.

“S..Shy-chan~!” Silver gasped as he was on the verge on his fourth climax.

“Ahh~! Ahh~! ahh~! Ahh~!” Fluttershy moaned with each hard thrust the two gave her, “S..Silver~~~! P..Pinkie~~!”

Silver climaxed in Fluttershy once again, the mares moaning loudly as they climaxed as well, Shy spraying her femjuices all ovr Silver’s member once more as Silver’s seed bursted into her womb. Exhausted, the three collapsed onto the floor, Pinkie falling backwards while Shy fell on top of Silver.

“Th...th...that..was...amazing…” Silver panted, completely spent at this point.

“I hope that made your special day even more special,” Fluttershy whispered to him as she planted a small kiss on his lips, “My love.”

“I..it has..” Silver smiled softly as he wrapped his arms around her, “My shy angel.”

The two smiled before falling asleep, Pinkie smiling at the sight.

“Looks like my work here is done. Now..” she paused before she pulled out a schedule, ‘time to prepare to their eventual wedding..hmm..should I have it set alongside Twi and Dashie’s wedding, or keep them separate if silver proposes early?...eh. I got all the time I need. Nothing to worry about.’ she then picked up her costume before slowly walking upstairs to get her clothes, ‘I’ll just leave once i get my clothes..don’t want to disturb those two love birds while they sleep.’