Pinkie has sent off hundreds of cakes. Some for get-togethers, some for weddings, even some for just eating. But when Anonymous comes in for the same cake on the same day of every year, it's gonna raise some questions.

And Pinkie's curiosity might get the better of her.

This is an Anonymous in Equestria story, originally written for the Anonymous in Equestria threads on /mlp/. The main character's name is Anonymous to allow the reader to relate to the character without worry of details such as race, color, or minor details such as hair/eye color. If the name Anonymous does not suit your "needs", please find a different story.

Dramatic Reading: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-X8j0coj7mU