CYOC: Miss Nightmare Bikini Contest

by Twifan

Rating: mature
Tags: Human, Anthro, Comedy, Random
Length: 9509

'You' are forced to choose a winner for a bikini contest to determine who rules the moon: Nightmare Moon or Nightmare Rarity.

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2015-05-19 21:35:01 UTC

Start story here.

You have arrived back at your home, the work day and trip back leaving you exhausted. Another day ended the same as the last. Deep down you were wishing for something to happen to you that would change your life, or even simply change your day. Of course, you were too exhausted to actually do anything about it. So it was back to what you always do: browse the internet for the rest of the day. You quickly turn on your computer, pull your chair out, and sat back into it.

Or at least you would have, if your chair was still there.

You were quite surprised to find the comfortable surface that had been placed behind you to sit was no longer there. You fell backwards onto the cold stone ground with a thud. In annoyance, you began to scan your room for signs of the prankster who dared remove your seat from under you. It took you a moment to fully realize that you were not in your house anymore.

No, the room you were in was not ‘homely’ at all. It wasn’t very friendly either. The grey stone floor and walls made the place seem more like a dark dungeon. The fact the rooms only light source was a few burning torches didn’t help its image either. You attempted to get off the ground and stand up, but are interrupted at the sight of another person just out of your light source.

“Well, you are certainly not what I was expecting.” The voice sounded female and just as annoyed at the situation as you. “The spell should have brought me someone… well, someone other than you, that’s for sure.”

Getting more annoyed to be rudely interrupted from your daily tasks only to be insulted, you stand up to face the mysterious woman and give her a piece of your mind. You never got the chance to, as a strange force wraps around your legs and lifts you off of the floor. Before you know it, you are carried towards the mysterious woman by this strange force. The fire of the torches began to burn brighter and change to the color of blue, illuminating the room better. You could now make out enough of the woman’s features to know that she is not human! Your mysterious woman was in fact a humanoid mare!

While your brain attempted to process this shocking information, the humanoid mare continued to scan you with her disapproving cyan colored eyes. “No, this will not do at all,” the humanoid mare mumbled to herself. Apparently, you were brought here completely by mistake. How comforting for you.

“Tartarus Sun!” the mare cursed as she turns away in frustration. You fall once again onto the cold floor as the force that held you up disappears. “All that time wasted! How did it go wrong? What did miss? I’m sure I followed everything that was written in that stupid book.” You watched as the mare returned to mumble to herself, most likely going over the actions she took that ended up bringing you to this room.  You attempted to stand up only to find the strange force once again lifting you off the floor. You were not enjoying being treated like a living yo-yo by this strange mare.

The mare gave you another look over before talking. “What are you, anyway?” she asked. You’d think that would have been the first thing she would have said to you if she didn’t know. You most likely would have asked her what she was. Just right after ‘how did you get into my house?’

You inform the mare that you are in fact a human. She gives you a look of both confusion and annoyance. “Human? I’ve never heard of your kind in Equestria. Are you one of those strange creatures that live in the Gryphon kingdom? Or do you live someplace beyond the Netherlands?”

Gryphons? There are Gryphons to deal with too? Don’t they eat people? As if this situation couldn’t get worst. You tell the mare that you’ve never even heard of any of those places before. The mare rolls her eyes in annoyance and you were pretty sure she was about to drop you on the floor again. Since you didn’t want to be dropped and picked up again, you yell at the creature to stop dropping you on the floor. That’s when you found the force that had been keeping you in the air start tightening its grip on you. You are lifted higher in the air to the face the mare at eye level, while the rest of you squirm helplessly in the air.

The mare gave you an angry glare. “Insolent creature. Do you know who are addressing?” she asked. The expression on your face was all the answer you felt you needed to say. You’ve already told her how you’ve never heard of any of these locations before. How would you know about its people? The mare continued on. “I am Nightmare Moon. I rule over all creatures that live in the night, be they dreamers or night walkers. I hold the power over the moon itself. I have powers of a god!”

‘Right.’ While she does seem to have powers, you really doubt they were really god tier powers. If she was that powerful, shouldn’t she have had the power to do the summoning spell correctly?

The angry look growing on Nightmare Moon’s face told you that you had accidentally said that last part out loud. Her eyes widen and began to glow white as her body began to shake in frustration. “You… You pathetic, brainless, worthless lump of horse apples! You dare to mock me?” A brilliant cyan light began to shine from Nightmare Moon’s head, allowing you to see her in more detail. The light seemed to glow around a horn on her head. She’s a unicorn? The Light brightens the room enough to make out her outstretched wings. A Pegasus too? You fell to the floor as her tail, the strange force that has been lifting you up, shrunk itself and lay at her side.

Nightmare Moon took a step closer towards you and pointed her finger at you. “You are in need of a lesson, worm. A lesson I will happily teach you.” The magical aura around her horn began to brighten even more, apparently powering up for some kind of attack. You felt fear overcome you, and all you could think to do was to back up until you could back up no more. The room began to hum from the buildup of the spell, and you cowered in your corner, unable to watch the doom that was approaching you.

Then the sound just faded away. You dared to peek at Nightmare Moon who simply stood there with a puzzled look on her face. She must have expected something different to happen That’s two times her magic had failed, you thought. And this time you made sure it stayed a thought!

“What… what did you do to me?” Nightmare Moon asked.

You took a moment to think of what you could have possibly done before giving your answer. You did absolutely nothing. Nightmare Moon focused her eyes on you with a stern glare. “If you’re lying to me…” You raise your hands over your head, hoping it would convince Nightmare Moon of your lack of magic altering abilities. The two of you simply stared at each other in silence, expecting the other to act.

The silence is broken as Nightmare Moon sighs in frustration. “Fine, follow me then.”

You watch Nightmare Moon turn around and light up the hallway with the magic from her horn. Slowly you get to your feet and begin to follow her down the hall. It wasn’t as if you were going to stay in this room after all. Whatever she did to bring you here, you were quite clueless on how to reverse. There also seemed to be no other exits to the room. Catching up to her, you ask Nightmare Moon where she was leading you.

“To my Castle,” she replied. “Whether you are telling the truth about not having a part to play in the disappearance of my magic or not, the answers I seek to rectify this situation will be there.”

And you are just to follow her into the heart of her domain? You asked.  You spot a new light source head of you shining down upon some stairs. Must be the way out of here.

“If you wish to return to your world again, then yes. Besides, you are already standing on my domain. So you might as well follow like a good human.”

You ask her what she means by that as the two of you approached the stairs.

Nightmare Moon turned around to address you. “I told you, I am Nightmare Moon. I hold power over the moon itself. There is no place on it that you can run or hide from me. And at the moment it would take a great deal of power to escape it at the moment. Power I doubt you have.” With that, she turns back to ascending the stairs to the top.

Wait. So is she saying you’re on the moon? But that can’t be true.

Climb the stairs to see if it is true.

Tell Nightmare Rarity about the summoning

You happily tell the beautiful Nightmare Rarity all about what has happened to you, about being summoned to the Moon by Nightmare Moon. In an instant, Nightmare Rarity’s expression turned from a warm smile into a cruel smirk. She let out a snarky laugh and shoved you back as she turned to face the angry Nightmare Moon. The entire thing took you by surprise as you fell to the floor.

“Oh Moony, you have fallen low.  To think you summoned that thing to help you? He barely looks capable of any real fighting. He’s as dumb as a sack of flours to be any use leading,” Nightmare Rarity took a glace back to look at you on the floor. “And he doesn’t appear to have the proper equipment needed to be any use as a stallion. If you’re into bestiality, as you appear to be for summoning this freaky thing, then there were so many other creatures in the animal kingdom that could have done any of those jobs better. And they’d smell better too.”

Those words hurt you. You felt the need to cover yourself up in shame, but you push those feelings aside in favor of the feeling of anger. Who was she to say such things to you? You were about to give Nightmare Rarity a piece of your mind when you spotted Nightmare Moon grab her by her mane and yank her.

“Hey, let go! You’re ruining my perfect mane!” Nightmare Rarity shouted.

Nightmare Moon pulled Nightmare Rarity closer to her. “You have wasted enough of my time, you little harlot. I’m only going to say this one last time: take that garbage you dare to call ‘decorations’ out of my castle and never come back!”

“You let go of my mane or you are going to be in trouble, you old hag!”

You saw Nightmare Moon’s eyes widen for a split second at hearing those words. “Well since you asked so nicely,” she said. With a show of amazing strength, Nightmare Moon let go of Nightmare Rarity’s mane and instead grabbed hold of her body to lifted Nightmare Rarity over her head. She then tossed Nightmare Rarity into a nearby room. You could hear the sounds of dishes and wooden furniture breaking as Nightmare Rarity went crashing into them.

In that moment, you couldn’t help but admire Nightmare Moon’s incredible show of strength. Her ‘amazon-like’ body was proving superior to the almost ‘twig-like’ shape of Nightmare Rarity. She was almost like your savoir.

That thought ended the moment she purposely stepped on your hand with her hoof. You quickly scrambled to your feet and rubbed your sore hand.

“Don’t think I didn’t forget about you.” Nightmare Moon commented cold. “I’m still throwing you into the dungeons.”

The sound of Nightmare Rarity’s screams of rage caused the two of you to look towards the room she was thrown into. Nightmare Rarity emerged from the room, her dress ripped and ruined, her teeth grinding, and her eyes glowing much like how Nightmare Moon does when she got angry.

Nightmare Moon’s eyes widen at the sight. “You… You’re the one who took my power!”

Nightmare Rarity let out a mocking laugh. “Did I forget to tell you that part, Moony? When they made me Queen, they gave me all the powers that came with it. You were too busy doing your little ‘thing’ out there to even notice yourself becoming weaker. And now…” Nightmare Rarity pointer her finger at Nightmare Moon as her horn lit up with a magical aura. “I’m going to teach you and your miserable pet there some respect for the crown!”

A familiar humming sound of magical build up filled the room.

Followed by a familiar fading of said magical hum.

Nightmare Rarity blinked. “That’s never happened before. GUARDS!”

The room began to quickly fill with the strange shadowy creatures you saw in the hall earlier. Nightmare Rarity picked on up by what appeared to be its ‘neck’ and addressed it at eye level. “Why does Nightmare Moon still have all her power? Wasn’t I supposed to get it all when I became your beloved queen?”

“The ritual should have worked, Mistress! You should have gotten all the power she had! Honest!”

“Well I don’t. She still has all her powers!”

“That’s impossible!” the small creature cried.

“What is this ritual?” Nightmare Moon demanded.

“Oh, why do you care Moony? It didn’t do anything.”

Nightmare Moon grabbed hold of Nightmare Rarity by her dress and pulled her face to face. The small creature Nightmare Rarity had in her hand fell to the floor and bounced like a ball. “Because thanks to you and your idiotic attempt to overthrow me and my ruling, we all are now too powerless to escape our prison ever again!”

“You mean you don’t have your powers and we are all trapped on this moon forever?” Nightmare Rarity asked in horror.  “But if you don’t have your powers, then where did they go?”

“Um...” came the voice of the creature. The two Nightmares stared down at the creature in anger. “Well, it’s just a theory, but… if former queen Nightmare Moon-“

“Current queen,” Nightmare Moon corrected. “The next fool to make that mistake will never live to correct it, this I swear.”

“If she was using a ritual herself to summon someone at the same time of us using our ritual, there is the chance that the two spells may have interfered with one another.”

“I knew I did it correctly!” Nightmare Moon seemed to beam with pride at this new knowledge. “But then, where did my powers go?”

The creature pointed what appeared to be its ‘tail’ at you. “In him.”

All eyes turned to face you.

“You mean that thing has my, I mean ‘our’, power?” Nightmare Rarity gasped.

You looked down at your hands. Did you really have all this power they talked about?

“N-n-n-now, now, now,” Nightmare Rarity began. “Don’t get any funny ideas there. You don’t know what kind of powers you’re messing with.”

“She’s right,” added Nightmare Moon. “Those powers were never meant for a mortal to use. You have no idea how to control it. For your own sake, don’t try and use it.”

Attempt to use the powers of Nightmare Moon.

Don’t use it.

Keep your mouth shut for Nightmare Moon.

If you were going to get back home, you were going to need the help of the person who got you stuck here to do it. So you might as well stay on her good side. Besides, there was something about Nightmare Moon that appealed to you. You choose to keep your lips sealed. You thought you saw Nightmare Moon crack a small smile at seeing your defiance of Nightmare Rarity.

Nightmare Rarity wasn’t beaten yet though. “Oooh, need more persuasion, do we? Don’t worry.” You felt the pressure of Nightmare Rarity’s hand shove you back against a nearby wall. Following that you felt the warmth of Nightmare Rarity’s chest force itself against you, as well as the feeling of her right leg grinding against your left. “I can up my game.”

You attempted to push her away, but Nightmare Rarity proved much stronger than she looked. All you could do was stare at Nightmare Moon with pleading ‘this is not my fault’ eyes and attempt hide any enjoyment you were getting from this.

Nightmare Moon grabbed a hold of Nightmare Rarity from behind and yanked her off of you. “I’ve had enough of your foolishness. You have wasted too much of my time, you little harlot. I want you out of my castle, now!”

“Not a chance, you old hag!” Nightmare Rarity’s tail snapped at Nightmare Moon’s arm like a whip, causing Nightmare Moon to let go of her. “I’m the new Queen of this kingdom, and soon I’ll be the Queen of Equestria. Decrepit old crones like you need to disappear into a retirement home and let us young and beautiful ponies run things.”

You saw Nightmare Moon’s eyes flash in anger. In a blink of an eye Nightmare Rarity went from standing beside her, to being lifted above her head. “Decrepit, am I?” shouted Nightmare Moon as she flung Nightmare Rarity into a nearby room. You could hear the sounds of dishes and wooden furniture breaking as Nightmare Rarity went crashing into them.

You stared at Nightmare Moon with your jaw open. Nightmare Moon turned to face you with a look of exhaustion and annoyance. “We’ve wasted too much time on this. My study is just beyond this hall. It’s there that we can find a way to-“

The sound of Nightmare Rarity’s screams of rage caused the two of you to look towards the room she was thrown into. Nightmare Rarity emerged from the room, her dress ripped and ruined, her teeth grinding, and her eyes glowing much like how Nightmare Moon does when she got angry.

Nightmare Moon’s eyes widen at the sight. “You… You’re the one who took my power!”

Nightmare Rarity let out a mocking laugh. “Did I forget to tell you that part, Moony? When they made me Queen, they gave me all the powers that came with it. You were too busy doing your little ‘thing’ out there to even notice yourself becoming weaker. And now…” Nightmare Rarity pointer her finger at Nightmare Moon as her horn lit up with a magical aura. “I’m going to teach you and your miserable pet there some respect for the crown!”

A familiar humming sound of magical build up filled the room.

Followed by a familiar fading of said magical hum.

Nightmare Rarity blinked. “That’s never happened before. GUARDS!”

The room began to quickly fill with the strange shadowy creatures you saw in the hall earlier. Nightmare Rarity picked on up by what appeared to be its ‘neck’ and addressed it at eye level. “Why does Nightmare Moon still have all her power? Wasn’t I supposed to get it all when I became your beloved queen?”

“The ritual should have worked, Mistress! You should have gotten all the power she had! Honest!”

“Well I don’t. She still has all her powers!”

“That’s impossible!” the small creature cried.

“What is this ritual?” Nightmare Moon demanded.

“Oh, why do you care Moony? It didn’t do anything.”

Nightmare Moon grabbed hold of Nightmare Rarity by her dress and pulled her face to face. The small creature Nightmare Rarity had in her hand fell to the floor and bounced like a ball. “Because thanks to you and your idiotic attempt to overthrow me and my ruling, we all are now too powerless to escape our prison ever again!”

“You mean you don’t have your powers and we are all trapped on this moon forever?” Nightmare Rarity asked in horror.  “But if you don’t have your powers, then where did they go?”

“Um...” came the voice of the creature. The two Nightmares stared down at the creature in anger. “Well, it’s just a theory, but… if former queen Nightmare Moon-“

“Current queen,” Nightmare Moon corrected. “The next fool to make that mistake will never live to correct it, this I swear.”

“If she was using a ritual herself to summon someone at the same time of us using our ritual, there is the chance that the two spells may have interfered with one another.”

“I knew I did it correctly!” Nightmare Moon seemed to beam with pride at this new knowledge. “But then, where did my powers go?”

The creature pointed what appeared to be its ‘tail’ at you. “In him.”

All eyes turned to face you.

“You mean that thing has my, I mean ‘our’, power?” Nightmare Rarity gasped.

You looked down at your hands. Did you really have all this power they talked about?

“N-n-n-now, now, now,” Nightmare Rarity began. “Don’t get any funny ideas there. You don’t know what kind of powers you’re messing with.”

“She’s right,” added Nightmare Moon. “Those powers were never meant for a mortal to use. You have no idea how to control it. For your own sake, don’t try and use it.”

Attempt to use the powers of Nightmare Moon.

Don’t use it.

Don’t use it.

You decide that perhaps playing with forces beyond your understanding is not the wisest idea. So what are you going to do now? You ask them what they are planning to do now that they know what happened. You weren’t about to do anything that might harm yourself just to give these mares back their powers.

“Should be easy enough to fix,” the shadow smoke creature replied. “Your body was not made to contain our beloved queen’s powers, so it would be just a matter of willingly giving up the power.”

“Right, you heard him,” Nightmare Moon said. “Just give me back my power and I’ll deal with this fake harlot queen. Once she’s out of the way, I can send you back home.”

“Hang on a moment!” Nightmare Rarity objected. “Why should he give you the power?”

Nightmare Moon rolled her eyes. “Because it’s my power, obviously. Plus, I’m the only person who can send him back home.”

“That’s not true! If he gives me the power, I can send him home.”

“You? You don’t even know where his home is!”

“And you do?”

“I know enough. Besides, between the two of us I am the only one he could possibly trust with that power. You’d just backstab him like the treacherous whore that you are.”

Nightmare Rarity gasped at Nightmare Moon’s words. She then placed her hand on her chest and took a defiant posture towards Nightmare Moon. “I would never do such a thing! I only behaved a bit… ill-mannered, because I thought that you two were…”

Nightmare Moon raised an eyebrow. “Were what?”

“Well, you know what they say needing ‘help’ around the lonely castle. Something about ‘cleaning the cobwebs’ and all that?”

“From him?” Nightmare Moon narrowed her eyes at Nightmare Rarity. “He’s a mistake. One that I promise will fix should he return my powers. But I am growing impatient on waiting.” She then fixed her gaze upon you. “Give me back my power, now!”

As a reaction to Nightmare Moon’s yelling, you took a step back. However, you found that Nightmare Rarity had moved from beside Nightmare Moon to beside you while you were looking at Nightmare Moon. “You see what she thinks of you? ‘A Mistake’. Something that needs ‘fixing’. Does this sound like the words from someone who thinks much of you? Someone who would keep their word to you? Once she has her powers back, she’ll toss you into the dungeon and forget about you. But I can return you home. I have no need to keep you here, should you wish to leave. I am as generous as I am beautiful. Ask any of my subjects. Subjects, that I might add, who choose me over her.”

“Stop filling his head with nonsense!” Nightmare Moon demanded.

Nightmare Rarity pressed her warm chest against your back and caressed the side of your cheek from behind with her hand. “I’m only letting him take his time in seeing the whole picture. Why are you in such a rush, Moony? Are you afraid he’ll realize the truth? That you’re the backstabbing harpy who can’t be trusted with any sort of power?”

Nightmare Moon and Nightmare Rarity continued to argue with one another between you. It was quite clear it would be a difficult choice to choose which of them to trust with the power. But you didn’t have time to get to know both of them well enough to make a decision. Only one answer came to your mind: you were going to have to hold a contest.

“A contest?” Nightmare Moon asked.

Nightmare Rarity clapped her hands together. “What a wonderful idea!” She then began to pace back and forth around the throne room muttering how magnificent she would look beating Nightmare Moon in front of all her faithful subjects. Her pacing stopped when a realization came to her. “Just what kind of contest did you have in mind?”

Nightmare Moon gave a suspicious look towards you. “Yes, tell us. What did you have in mind?”

A Bikini Contest.

A Bikini Contest.

“… A Bikini Contest.” Nightmare Moon repeated with a surprisingly calm look on her face. It changed to a face of anger as she grabs you by your shirt and pulls you closer to your face. “A BIKINI CONTEST? You would dare to mock me, Nightmare Moon, with such a demeaning competition? I am not your play thing! I am not some desperate lonely school filly to be used by your perverted whim and ogled at for your pleasure! I am a queen, not some courtesan!”

You heard Nightmare Rarity say your name and comment that the idea was ‘pretty bad’. “I mean, you have to at least come up with a contest that Moony has even the smallest chance of winning. This one just isn’t fair to her.”

You felt Nightmare Moon grip on you slowly give away as a look of shock began to spread across her face. “What do you mean by that?” she asked without turning around.

“Come on Moony, it should be pretty obvious even to you. I mean even if you weren’t going up against moi, you still don’t have a chance to win. You’re like, what, one hundred years old? A thousand? How can you compete in such a contest when you’re so old? You also don’t have the body for it, darling. All those ‘moon pies’, or whatever you ate before I came along, just didn’t keep you in good shape. Plus I haven’t even touched on how absolutely unappealing a person you are. Why, you wouldn’t know how to have a good time if it bit you, so obviously you wouldn’t know the first thing about winning such a contest. You don’t have the ‘hot’ personality to wear such an outfit with any real style. Who in their right mind would ever let someone like you win such a contest about beauty? Going up against you in such a contest would be so easy; it would take away all the joy of beating you. We should move on to something that would prove to be a real challenge.”

You watched Nightmare Moon slowly become angrier and angrier as Nightmare Rarity listed off each reason she believed that Nightmare Moon couldn’t possibly win such a contest. Finally, Nightmare Moon marched over to Nightmare Rarity, who was too busy listing other contests Nightmare Moon might have a slight better chance at winning to notice. Standing side by side, you noticed that Nightmare Moon was slightly taller than Nightmare Rarity. When Nightmare Rarity finally took noticed of the angry Nightmare Moon, her reaction caused her to appear to shrink in the towering presence of Nightmare Moon.

Nightmare Rarity flinched as Nightmare Moon closed the distance between the two of them and gave a death glare at her opponent. “It. Is. ON!” Nightmare Moon said with a spiteful voice.

Regaining her composure, Nightmare Rarity smiled and pushed her chest forward, shoving Nightmare Moon back with her perky breasts. “You sure about this, Moony? No one is going to fault you for picking something you actually good at.”

Nightmare Moon regained her balance and decided to fight Nightmare Rarity at her own game. Nightmare Moon pushed her breasts together with her hands and pressed her breasts against Nightmare Rarity’s, causing Nightmare Rarity to attempt to keep balance. “I’m positive about this. I am still queen after all. I don’t need to flaunt my beauty like some common cheap slut to make myself seem ‘more beautiful’. And I must admit I will enjoy the look on your face when you realize you aren’t as beautiful as you think you are. It will be a better punishment than anything I could bring upon you.”

The two mares simply stood there, glaring at each other with wicked smiles on their faces as their lush breasts rubbed against each other with each breath they took. The sight was pretty titillating for you, even with all the clothing in the way. After what seemed like a glorious eternity of silence, Nightmare Rarity backed away from Nightmare Moon to clap her hands together, summoning her shadow smoke servants to her side. “Build us a stage worthy of our stature. Tomorrow, we shall see who is rightfully queen.” Neither one of them broke eye contact the entire time, but their wicked smiles grew to wicked grins.

You were given a room to rest until the time of the contest. This would have been a good time to plan on what your next move would be, but your mind was racing with the perverted anticipation of seeing those two lovely mares in a bikini. It seems as though luck was on your side, so you were confident you’d be able to handle any issues that showed up tomorrow the same way. You relaxed in your room and drifted off to sleep.

The following day began with one of the servants serves you a rather strange meal. It looked like moon rocks that had someone been watered down to be mushy. Then again, what were you expecting them to serve on the moon? The meal itself tasted quite bland, but wasn’t unappealing.

You were then shown to stage that was built outside the castle. Your judge seat was place directly at the center of the stage facing it. You sat down and waited for the contestants to arrive.

Nightmare Moon was the first you saw, walking up on stage with a less than amused look on her face. You couldn’t help but grin in delight at the sight of her. She wore string bikini, which color matched the pair of marking she had on both sides of her flank. The top had multiple strings between the two triangle fabrics, as if to claim that Nightmare Moon’s breasts could not be simply contained with just a single piece. Two large pair of straps held the rest of the bikini top on Nightmare Moon, one pair going around her sides to her back, the other above her shoulders. Her bikini bottoms were held up by a single pair of string, tided up at the sides of her hips like a bow, giving an appearance as if she was a present just waiting to be unwrapped.

Nightmare Moon looked like she was about to say something, most likely dealing with how you were staring at her if you were to guess, but ended up changing her mind and closing her mouth. It was quite clear she didn’t like all this attention you were giving her. Or at least, she did not want to show you she liked it. For a brief moment, you could have sworn Nightmare Moon was blushing with a smile. But it must have been your imagination.

“Where’s that hot aired bimbo?” Nightmare Moon asked, apparently wanting to change things up so you wouldn’t simply stare at her all day. “If she has backed out of this already, she could have simply said something to not waste my time. Then again, what more could you expect from someone who is all talk.”

“Perfection is something that takes time, Moony. Not that you’ve ever known anything like that,” came the voice of Nightmare Rarity as she appeared behind the stage and walked on from the other side. Your mouth dropped once more at her appearance.

Nightmare Rarity had chosen to go for a pretzelkini style of bikini! The white straps wrapped around her neck with a criss-cross before wrapping around her ample bosoms, covering up her perky nipples before leading behind her midriff. The straps attached themselves to another pair of straps, which held up her white g-string micro thong. The entire bikini left Nightmare Rarity showing off as much skin as she could, while covering up only what she needed ‘necessary’, leaving very little imagination needed to picture what she would look like naked.

Nightmare Moon was furious at the sight. “That’s not a bikini!” She yelled out.

“Of course it is, Moony,” Nightmare Rarity answered without even bothering to look at Nightmare Moon. Her gaze was fixed on you and your reaction to her. “It just happens to be a more modern style. It’s not surprising that you don’t recognize it as such. What with you being so out of touch with society and people. You spend too much time locked away in your little moon tower and….” Nightmare Rarity paused to think for a moment. “What is it that you even do again?”

Nightmare Moon entire body seemed to shake with rage at Nightmare Rarity’s words. But she soon calmed herself down and replied with a grin. “Fine. I will just show off how to be as radiant as the moon itself. You can continue to show off how you are a just a cheap attention whore.”

“Hey!” Nightmare Rarity yelled, finally turning to face Nightmare Moon. “I am not cheap! This outfit is quite expensive. A price fit for a queen, I’ll have you know.”

“So you admit to the rest it then?”

Nightmare Rarity smiled at Nightmare Moon. “I’ll be whatever I have to. I’m here to win, Moony. Not just for me, mind you. But for all my loyal subjects!” A small crowd of shadow servants cheered at Nightmare Rarity’s words from behind you. You had not noticed them gathering until now, what with being distracted by the display in front of you. “For the good of –my- kingdom, I would sacrifice anything, even my modesty.”

“I’m here to win as well. To reclaim my kingdom and power from you, I’ll take on any task.”

“Then you’d best start realising who you’re up against, Moony. Because when I say I’d do anything for my beloved subjects, I do mean….” Nightmare Rarity turned to face you as she let her hands slide up from her firm flanks towards her rounded breasts. She pushed her thumbs under the straps, pushing them slightly forward, taunting you with the thought of pushing the straps to the side and giving her entire breasts some freedom. As she looked you in the eyes with a smile, she finished off her sentence with a seductive voice. “Anything.”

Nightmare Moon attempted to keep her smile lasting as she spoke. “Whatever the task is, not only will I take it, I will do a better job than you.”

This caused Nightmare Rarity to let out a laugh. “We shall see.”

The two mares stared down at you. “So ‘judge’…” began Nightmare Rarity.

“… What is the task of this contest?” Nightmare Moon finished.

That’s a good question. What will you have them do to judge them properly?

Judge them by having them ‘show off their stuff’ on stage.

Judge them on a walk across a Runway.

Judge them by having them pose like they were at the beach.

Climb the stairs to see if it is true.

Holy crap, you are on the moon!

Well, not the same moon that rotates around the Earth. But it is a moon!

You scan your surroundings, unable to focus on one direction. This was fantastic! There was a colorful planet hovering among the stars above you. How breathtaking! The surrounding landscape looked much like what you would expect a moon surface to look like, and yet also felt like looking at an alien barren world. Exciting! You never felt so alive in-

Your excited thoughts were interrupted as Nightmare Moon called for you in the distance to hurry up and get moving. You run towards the temperamental mare. Out here in the open with the light of the sky, you finally can get a good look at her.

Nightmare Moon was about the same height as you.  She was wearing a bright blue helmet on her head that matched in color with with her dress. A strange aura floated around her head, matching that of her ‘tail’. You had to assume it was her mane.

Not wanting the entire trip to be completely in silence, you asked Nightmare Moon how far her castle was. “You should be able to see it soon, human. I made sure the ritual would take place in a location quite close.”

Your head buzzed with questions as your eyes took notice of the fine blue dress Nightmare Moon was wearing in greater detail. Before, you had glanced over the dress, believing it to be a typical dress worn by someone attempting to look like ‘royalty’. A fitting image for what little you knew of Nightmare Moon. But now you notice there was something more to it. The V neck style, the open back, the elegant design, these spoke to you as if Nightmare Moon was trying to make a different impression on her summoned guest.

You asked why she needed to be away from the castle to cast her ritual.  “So I could be left in silence, of course. My loyal subjects mean well, but at times they can be quite a nuisance. That’s why I needed someone to-“Nightmare Moon stopped in her tracks, as if to contemplate continuing the sentence. You stopped behind her and waited to see what her next action would be. She gave a depressed sigh and turned to face you. “Someone to help me keep them all in line. I can’t deal with their childish bumbling and prepare for a war at the same time.”

Wait, a war?

Nightmare Moon rolled her eyes at the sight of your reaction. “Oh, there is nothing for you to be worried about human. There’s no fighting yet.”

You asked her who she is planning on fighting then. Nightmare Moon narrows her eyes, though she does not glare directly at you this time. She seems to be staring off into the distance behind you.

“She’s someone similar to me, and she is my completely opposite. She has power over the sun and the rules over the daytime. She thinks she’s so perfect! And worst of all is the fact that everyone seems to agree with her!” Nightmare Moon clenched her fists as she began to rant about this ‘sun ruler’. With her attention distracted off of you, you felt more confident about looking at her in more detail.

And after taking a good look at her, you had reached a conclusion: Nightmare Moon was quite the alien knockout! Her curvy humanoid form, her long toned legs, her gorgeous eyes. Heck, even some of her ‘horse like’ appearance wasn’t all that off putting either. Her small muzzle, her scratch-able ears, her magical mane and tail, all were quite appealing to you. Even her wings, which before had a frightening look to them back in the place you were summoned from, looked like they’ve be quite comfortable in a hug. And her horn… well actually, that part of her still filled you with a bit of worry, but the rest of her was amazing!

Deep down you felt a small part of yourself die at the thought of finding something not human so attractive. Truly, you have betrayed humanity with such thought. However, another part of you felt quite strongly that it would be an even bigger betrayal of humanity to pass up a chance to get it on with a hot alien woman like this (if such a chance was offered in the first place, of course).

Nightmare Moons voice, as she continued her rant, returned your thoughts to your current situation. “…And it’s not like there’s anything a pony can’t do during the night time that can be done in the day! In fact, everything is better done at nighttime! My stars are far prettier than any sun rise! In fact, we don’t even really need the sun! It hasn’t done anything good for us at all!”

“What about growing plants?” you asked. Deep down, you knew this was going to be a bad idea, but you just had to ask.

“What about them?” Nightmare Moon asked, glaring at you.

“You have those, right? Farmers would need the sun to grow food. Trees need the sun to live. Taking the sun away would hurt them.”

“Fool. We would just use our magic to make them feed on moonlight instead of sunlight. It would be better for them in the long run. Moonlight would make the food taste far better than sunlight.”

“You know, moonlight is really-“you managed to shut yourself up before adding the ‘made up of mostly sunlight part’. You really need to think before you spoke!

“Is really, what?” Nightmare Moon asked in an annoyed tone.

“Is really…”you desperately try and think of a way out of your predicament. “Really…. Romantic? Moonlight is far too romantic for any farmers to get any work done. Why, one gaze up at the beautiful moon and they’ll stop working to write poetry about it and gaze up with their love ones.” You could feel yourself begin to sweat under Nightmare Moon’s disapproving stare. Even without her ‘god like’ power, the mare gave a look that told you she could break every bone in your body if she saw a reason to. You continued your attempt to talk your way out of this. “Meanwhile, the sun itself is an eyesore! No one goes sun gazing, after all. That’s why they spend all their time work on things facing away from the sun, like farms.”

You stood there as Nightmare Moon began to consider the answer you gave her. Slowly her emotions changed on her face from a scowl to a slight smile. “The moon is a thing of beauty. One that could make my subject’s forget their job while staring up in awe at its splendour. And you are right, human. The sun is quite the ‘eyesore’.”

You tell Nightmare Moon your name, in hopes of keeping her from calling you ‘human’ for however long you’ll be here.

“If you insist. Personally, I don’t think it’s a very good name. Heck, ‘human’ sounds better than that.”

You were about to say something back to her about insulting your name, but Nightmare Moon began to walk away and continue her rant about how great the moon is and how terrible the sun is. She wasn’t paying much attention to you anymore, and interrupting her would most likely make you to end up in the same dangerous place you were before. So you decided to let it drop, follow Nightmare Moon in silence, and admire her from behind.

Or rather, admire her behind! Her dress certainly complimented her curves just right. You couldn’t pry your eyes away from those swaying hips. With every step she took, her flanks seemed to beckon you. You felt a great desire to reach out your hand and caress every inch of her round rump. But you knew how angry she would react to that. So instead you simply watched it. You continued to watch, mesmerize by it with each step that she-

“And just what are you staring at now?”

Nightmare Moon’s voice caused you to look up into her perplexed stare. Quickly, your mind raced to find an answer to give. “I was just taking in the scenery of…”

“-My beautiful moon?” Nightmare moon finished off your sentence as she looked around the landscape.

“Um, yeah,” was all you were able to say as you cached your breath again. You were making way too many close calls today. It was almost like you had a death wish or something.

“It is quite lovely to take in, isn’t it?” Nightmare Moon asked, turning to face you again.

“It… it sure is,” you carefully answered back.

“But tell me,” Nightmare Moon took a step closer towards you and said your name in a rising angered tone that make her seem to tower over you. “Just which of my ‘lovely moon’s’ were you ‘taking in’? Is it my kingdom you find impressive? Or have you been ogling my chest and backside?”

Your words were failing you under Nightmare Moon’s unhappy gaze. Nightmare Moon continued without waiting for you to find your voice again. “I’m not even the same species as you, you know? Are all humans such perverts, or did I simply have the misfortune of being stuck with the only exception?” Just as you were finding your voice again, Nightmare Moon let out a laugh that caused you to lose it once more. She looked back down upon you with a wicked grin. “And just what went through your perverted little mind, human? That I would allow you touch me? That your unworthy greasy peasant hands could caress the prefect hide of royalty? That your brutish strength could somehow overpower me? Force me to the ground like some helpless filly and have your way with me?”

Your mind once again raced for an answer out of this situation, but this time nothing was coming up. Nightmare Moon stared down in annoyance of your silence. “Well, don’t you have anything to say for yourself?”

Almost by instinct, your voice found its way out in the words of “I’m sorry.”

Nightmare Moon closed her eyes and sighed. “You’re sick and pathetic.” She then took a step to the side motioned to the path behind her. Off in the distance you could make out the structure of a castle. “You’re walking in front of me the rest of the way now.”

The castle looked like it was carved from giant crystal, rather than built. The ceiling was built high, allowing your footsteps to echo in the halls. The floors were polished enough to show your reflection on. The walls were adorned with banners filled with pictures of crystals and gems that seem glow with magic, lighting the room up. The entire place was breathtaking.

“What is all this junk?” came the voice of Nightmare Moon.

You looked back to see Nightmare Moon stare at room with a disgust. “Who dares to ruin my home while I was away?”

The sound of a metal bucket dropping causes the two of your to turn your attention to a small creature shrouded in some kind of obscuring dark mist. You couldn’t make out much of the creatures figure other than the glowing eyes that stared at the two of you, the shape of its terrified mouth, and a small yellow sponge it held.

The creature attempted to flee from the sight of the two of you, but Nightmare Moon turned out to be quite faster than it. In a blind of an eye, her magical aura that was her tail and mane enveloped her body and slithered like a snake with amazing speed, seemingly teleporting Nightmare Moon before the creature, trapping its escape. She then swiftly grabbed the creature and held it in the air before you. “What is the meaning of this?” she demanded.

The creature shook in fear as it stared at Nightmare Moon “The new mistress of the moon wanted the castle cleaned up, and for all the junk of the old ruler to be removed.”

“The new mistress of the moon? THE NEW MISTRESS OF THE MOON? Someone dares to take my rightful place from me? Why didn’t you fools tell me? Why didn’t you do anything to stop her?”

“Um, because we invited her here?” the creature answered.

Damn, looks like someone is challenging you for ‘dumbest things to say’ today.

With a scream of anger, Nightmare Moon tossed the little creature down a hallway.

“’Beloved by all your nighttime subjects’ huh?” You know that was a dumb thing to say, but you couldn’t help yourself.

“Quiet!” Nightmare Moon screamed at you with such a force that it made you fall backwards on your ass.  Apparently, she was hold back before when she was yelling at you. “I don’t have time for your foolishness! I need to find the soon-to-be-dead mare who dares to take my kingdom from me!”

Nightmare Moon began to storm down one of the hallways, which you assumed leads to her throne room. You followed behind, because what else were you going to do? One right turn later and you see a large double door at the end of the hall. Nightmare Moon opened the doors with enough force, one could mistake it being forced opened by an angry rushing bull. You peeked around Nightmare Moon to get a glance of the mare trying to overthrow Nightmare Moon. Your jaw need hit the floor at the sight of her.

This dark blue violet unicorn mare laid across the throne chair, her legs across one arm and her back on the other. He head lay upside down against the side of the throne chair, allowing her multi-mulberry colored mane to flow down to the floor like a magical mist. She stared at the two of you with her pale cold blue eyes in what looked like boredom. She wore a black open chest dress with multiple necklaces filled with precious gems across it. From you could tell at a distance, she was every bit as beautifully shaped as Nightmare Moon.

“Oh, it’s you, Moony.” The mare asked in a bored tone. “I thought you had died or something.”

“Get off my throne!” Nightmare Moon demanded.

The mare began to check her nails, barely paying any attention to Nightmare Moon. “It’s not your throne anymore. I’m your new replacement.”

“Like tartarus you are! I don’t need a replacement!”

“Oh, but you did! You were doing such a poor job that someone had to cleanup your mess.”

Continuing on your path of ‘not knowing when to shut up’, you snickered at the comment. “Guess you’re as good at ruling as you are at magic. No wonder you wanted to find some help.”

Nightmare Moon gave you a quick death stare glace but didn’t have the chance to say anything. The mare on the throne sat straight up at the sound of your voice. “Now, who have you brought?” she asked.

“No one of importance,” Nightmare Moon replied, returning her gaze back at the mare. “Now, leave my kingdom or-“

The mare leaped out from her chair and made her way towards you at surprising speed. “No, no, no, no, no! You do not bring a guest to my castle and not properly introduce them! Where are your manners, Moony?”

“Introduce him? I don’t even know who the hay you are! And this is my castle!”

The mare stopped between you and Nightmare Moon and gave a short mocking laughed as she looked her in the eyes. “Right, I forget how out of touch you are with the times.”

You thought to yourself how that line didn’t make a lick of sense but were interrupted when the mare turned and leaned towards you, getting quite close to your face with a smile. “Hi, I’m Nightmare Rarity. Although some of my faithful subjects call me ‘Queen’, or ‘Mistress’. You can feel free to call me that if you so desire. And what is your name?”

You attempted to say your name, but ended up trailing off as you got a closer look at Nightmare Rarity. Being this close to her made you start to believe she might be even more beautiful than Nightmare Moon. While Nightmare Moon had more of the build of a slim athlete, Nightmare Rarity looked more like a super model. Her blue eyes seemed much more inviting than the piercing gaze of Nightmare Moon’s. Her smile seemed to warm your very soul. And even her breasts were larger! While Nightmare Moon’s chest size was impressive, being in the heavy end of the C cup barely making it to D cup size, Nightmare Rarity’s were definitely D sized breasts. Possibility even reaching DD cup size status!

“Like what you see?” Nightmare Rarity asked as she noticed you staring at her chest. You jumped at the sound of her voice and began to think of your best excuse to get you out of the coming situation. Noticing your reaction, Nightmare Rarity continued before you got a word out. “Oh, there is no problem with that. Beauty is nothing if no one is around to appreciate it. And my beauty surpasses all, so it would be an utter crime to make you avert your eyes. So please, stare as long as you like.” Nightmare Rarity said that last line in a sultry tone that made your mouth dry up like a desert and your face beam like a sun. You gulped to try and get some moisture and attempted to put on your best smile.

“You both sicken me,” said Nightmare Moon.

“So, cutie, why are you traveling with Moony here?” Nightmare Rarity asked while fluttering her eyelashes at you.

Nightmare Moon gave you an angry stare from behind Nightmare Rarity. “Answer her and I will leave you to rot in the dungeons.” It was quite clear she was not only upset with Nightmare Rarity, but upset with how you were acting around here.

You felt Nightmare Rarity place on one of her fingers on your chest and circled it around as she stared deeply into your eyes. “I’m the one who is in charge of this castle, not her. Her threats are meaningless to you. So you can tell what you are doing with her…”

Tell Nightmare Rarity about the summoning.

Keep your mouth shut for Nightmare Moon.

Attempt to use the powers of Nightmare Moon.

You close your eyes tight and concentrate. You could feel something deep inside you. It was faint, so faint you could not notice it unless you were looking for it. But now that you focused on it you could feel it growing inside you. It felt like grabbing hold of an emotion. A feeling of being completely forsaken by everyone you ever knew wrapped up with a burning desire to make them all pay.

You opened your eyes to see dark magical smoke rise from your hands. Nightmare Moon and Nightmare Rarity looked quite frighten at your actions. After all those two have put you through, you were going to show them what it is like to be on the receiving end. You give them a cruel smile of your own, point your hands at the both of them, and repeat the same lines they used on you.

And then you blasted them both with a magical beam, knocking them against the wall.

Unfortunately for you, you were caught unprepared for the kind of force the beam had, as it propelled you down the hall, out a window, and into space.

Thanks to the powers of Nightmare Moon, you seemed to be able to breath in space. Unfortunately for you, you didn’t seem able to control the direction you were heading or the ability to stop. Right now you were heading directly to the sun.

You tried to command your powers to somehow prevent you from hitting the sun. Being that this was the powers of Nightmare Moon, the moon itself came to your aid. Unfortunately, the moon is not known for being soft.

Splat.

Your body impacted with the moon’s surface. Eventually, Nightmare Moon and Nightmare Rarity will recover from the blast you gave them to fight over your corpse to reclaim their power. It was a pretty painful way to go, but at least it was an exciting change to your boring Life!

The End.