"Mmh, thank you, Sugar Bell! Your muffins are delicious as always!" Twilight forced herself not to grimace as she swallowed a chunk of the awful, cardboard-tasting muffins. The remainder of the mane six were following suit. Rarity had the hardest time feigning her excitement for the awful pastry.
"Y-Yes, simply... divine! May we come inside and have some more?"
Sugar Bell nodded eagerly and smiled the broadest she could. "Of course! Anything for my new friends!" She opened the door let all of the Ponyville residents inside her humble home. Once the last was inside, she caught the eye of Starlight Glimmer. With a weak smile, Sugar nodded slowly.
"I really wish she would get some better lights in here." Rainbow Dash squinted her eyes to see anything in the dark and damp basement. "It's not like there are any windows anyway."
Applejack slowly paced back and forth, her eyes planted on the floor. "We really have to come up with somethin' this time. We need to help them here ponies." All the other girls mumbled their agreements. Silence fell over the room. Twilight looked around, trying to see anything in the dark corners. She knew there was nothing there, yet this basement made her feel uneasy.
"Sugar Bell should have been here by now... What's taking her so long up there?"
Pinkie put her hoof around Twilight's neck and giggled happily. "I'm sure she's just making sure the others are here as well. Don't worry, Twilight!"
Twilight smiled at her friend. She was so very happy to have Pinkie and the others here with her. Seeing this ponies robbed of their cutie marks and individuality wasn't easy. With good friends at her side, however, Twilight knew she could endure and find a way to help them. The tender moment was broken by the sound of hoofsteps from upstairs.
"Finally", Rainbow Dash sighed. Her brow was furrowed and her face scrunched up. All the busywork and lack of proper sleep hadn't been good to her. Let's not even mention the lack of ponies complimenting her on her flying abilities.
"All right, girls, let's focus. We NEED to find a way to restore the cutie ma- What?!" The girls, who had been looking at Twilight turned as they saw her eyes widen. The very moment they did, they reacted in much the same way. Sugar Bell was slowly walking down the stairs. However, she wasn't alone. In front of her was the ever so 'charismatic' Starlight Glimmer, and behind her a mix of stallions and mares of the town.
"Hello, girls", Starlight said, her voice thick with scorn.
"What is SHE doing here?!" Rainbow called out.
Sugar Bell didn't even look Rainbow in the eyes as she replied. "It's for your own good... You'll be happier this way..."
With fury burning in her veins, Applejack stomped her hoof into the floor. "Ya ratted us out?! Why, I oughta -"
"Silence!" Starlight called out.
Despite emotions running high in the six pony friends, they all kept their tongues. Starlight slowly looked them all over, from head to hoof. "Sugar Bell told me everything. She told me how YOU forced her to co-operate with your schemes, your plans to ruin the friendship of this village. Everything." Behind Starlight was a a crowd of angry expressions staring right at the six girls in the dark basement.
"OUR schemes? SHE was the one who wanted her cutie mark back!" Rainbow flew right up in front of Starlight, only to find herself thrown to the floor and pinned by the unicorn's magic.
"Not only do you lie through you teeth, you also try to slander our villagers? You truly know nothing of friendship!" While Starlight was focused on Rainbow, Twilight fired up her own magic, ready to even out the encounter. As her horn lit up, however, she felt a surge of pain shoot through her body, causing her to lose focus and stop the spell prematurely.
"W-What is this?!" the princess cried out. Once more she attempted to cast a spell, only to be met with the same treatment. "How can you -"
"Limit your magic?" Starlight scoffed. "You're not the only one who studied magic for years. And you're not the one with true friendship in your heart, either." Twilight felt herself get pinned to the floor, and looking around, she saw all of her friends in the same predicament. Applejack and Dash fought against their restraints, while Fluttershy simply whimpered under the confinement. Pinkie and Rarity seemed to frightened or confused to even try to fight.
"You stroll into our town and think you're so much better than us, don't you? You think that you're special. You think this brings you friendship. You're wrong. You need to be more like us. Equal. Friendship isn't what you think it is. You haven't seen anything yet."
Twilight waited patiently. Though she wanted nothing more than to engage this battle of words head on, she knew it to be unwise. Her mind was racing at record speed, recalling all the spells and magic she had read and learned about over the years. There had to be something to get her, and her friends, out of this.
"Look at you. Even your bodies aren't what they could be."
A sudden roadblock hit the speeding mind of the princess. "Our bodies?"
"Yeah, jus' what the hay are y'all talkin' 'bout?"
"Don't you dare lay a hoof on me, you... You skank!"
Starlight chuckled heartily. "You don't think I would hurt fellow ponies, now, do you? I merely wish to make you equal. You'll be happier that way."
"What do you mean, 'equal'?! Are you saying I'm not already a hundred times better th-" Rainbow abruptly stopped talking, and her eyes went wide. Twilight looked at her friend's eyes and then to where they were pointed. Sugar Bell. Or, more specifically, underneath Sugar Bell.
"IS THAT A PENIS?" The first one to speak a word was Pinkie Pie. "But that doesn't many ANY sense! You're a mare! Mares don't have that! If they did, they wouldn't even be mares! That'd be like being a baker but selling- Mmph! Mmh!"
Starlight sighed deeply as she watched Pinkie's mouth being forced shut by magic force. "Don't you get it yet? We are equal! There are no mares or stallion in this village, there are only ponies who are friends!"
Twilight gulped as she looked around from her low vantage point. They were all truly equal. The ideas of stallionhood and marehood were completely gone in the face of what she was seeing. "This isn't right..." she whispered to herself.
"And it looks like you -" Starlight smirked at Twilight "- all need to be made equal."
"MMMH! MM-MMH!" Muffled, indistinguishable cries flooded the room. Every one of the girls had had the same treatment as Pinkie. Every one aside from Twilight. Each of them were clawing and scratching at the floor in desperation. It was no use.
The purple alicorn hadn't even noticed Starlight walking up to her, but there she was. Towering above her stood the cruel, propaganda-spouting pony. Yet Twilight's eyes were fixed on what that pony was packing.
"I'll make sure you are made especially equal, princess."
"You can't do this", Twilight said quietly.
"Oh, but I can. Now, open up."
Twilight felt her mouth forcing itself open. Her jaw was strained, but she couldn't stop it.
"You may begin, my dear friends." Starlight's voice was sugary sweet. The kind you'd expect from a caring, loving mother. The mere sound of it sickened Twilight to her core.
"You won't get- MPPH!" She knew it was coming, but she wasn't ready in the slightest. The large cock slid into her mouth, prodding against her throat. More than anything in the world, she wanted to pull back. Starlight's magic wasn't giving her a single inch, not even the slightest glimmer of hope of escape. She was, however, receiving more than enough inches from Starlight's rod. Tears flooded Twilight's eyes, and she coughed onto the cock in her mouth.
"My, my, the little princess isn't used to this? Such a shame." Starlight placed a hoof on Twilight's head and used it as leverage. With a wide smile on her face, she slowly started thrusting herself into Twilight's mouth, ignoring the gagging and muffled cries of the pony beneath her. Through her eyes blurred by tears, Twilight saw her friends, though she wish she hadn't. Her stomach churned as she saw them all fighting their hardest to avoid the ponies above them. Avoid the cocks being shoved into every orifice of their body. For just a second, Twilight forgot about her own predicament. She let Starlight's dick slide into her throat, causing the cruel pony to moan quietly with pleasure.
"Oh ho, maybe the princess HAS had her share of fun at the big castle after all." As Starlight spoke, Twilight's eyes closed. She let her head rest on the floor as Starlight continued to thrust her large member into her throat with ease. The initial resistance in the princess' throat had completely disappeared. Starlight was able to bury her entire length inside Twilight's mouth, only triggering an occasional gag and cough.
"This won't do..."
Seeing the defeated pony underneath her made the fire within her flare up. This wasn't like she had imagined it. Looking around, she saw the rest of these outsiders fight and scream to the best of their abilities as they were penetrated deeply. Yet Twilight was just laying there, completely still. A wicked smile spread on Starlight's face. She slid her cock out of Twilight's mouth, causing an audible "pop". Leaning down, Starlight stuck out her tongue and licked the inside of Twilight's ear. Much to her enjoyment, this caused the princess to whimper and shed a tear. Starlight chuckled quietly and gently bit her ear.
"Look at your so-called 'friends'. They are being made equal. They WILL become like the rest of us", she whispered. "And it's time for you to follow suit."
"Please..."
The sound of Twilight's whimpering voice made the fire between Starlight's legs intensify. She bit the princess' ear harder and snarled. "Please what? Please ravage you? Use you? Make you equal? I certainly will."
Starlight walked around the pinned alicorn and placed a hoof on her rump. It was small, but very firm; clearly one that hadn't been used the way Starlight intended to. Smiling to herself, Starlight opted instead to lay down on top of Twilight's back. She positioned her muzzle right next to Twilight's ear and once again put it between her teeth. With great anticipation of the coming moments, Starlight lined the head of her horsecock up with the most sacred entrance of the princess' body. As the head hit the folds, Starlight's eyes rolled into the back of her skull for just a moment. She rubbed herself against Twilight's cunt, slowly lubricating herself with natural juices.
"I don't care about making you equal." Starlight didn't even bother consider the risks of what she was saying. "I don't care about friendship, or about anyone in this village. I'm going to take your cutie mark, and I'm going to use you every single night."
Adrenaline rushed through her body as she whispered to the princess. She pushed herself forward, making the tip of her cock slip inside. In all her years in this village, Starlight had never experienced a feeling so tight. "I'm gonna make you watch your 'friends' get used until they can't even walk. You're going to be my. Little. Slut." With those words, Starlight slammed her stallionhood into Twilight's tight pussy.
Starlight's body shivered as she penetrated the mare underneath her. Twilight cried out as she was filled to the brim with the magically created cock.
"NO! STOP!"
Giggling to herself, Starlight bit the ear in her mouth harder. "That's all I wanted to hear."
Without any further warning, she started thrusting rapidly into Twilight. Each time she sheathed herself fully inside the cunt, she bit the ear harder and moaned directly into it. Her body was flooded with a surge of excitement and tingling. The tight walls clamping down on her impressive girth set her mind on fire and made her loins leak onto the floor underneath her. Despite Twilight's protests, Starlight felt her getting increasingly wet with each thrust, until her pussy was flowing with juices.
"STOP IT, PLEASE! LET ME GO!"
"You know you, ugh, want to be made equal! You want this! Mmh! Don't lie to me!"
Starlight sped up her thrusting, slamming her hips into Twilight's rump at a rapid pace. The princess screamed loudly into the basement, but all she was met with was laughter from the remaining villagers. Even Sugar Bell had been unable to contain herself and was now buried balls deep inside Fluttershy. She no longer seemed to care about the loss of her cutie mark, or feel remorse for her betrayal. Her face was one of pure bliss as she used the crying, whimpering yellow pegasus.
"Just give up! You are nothing! You are mine to, mmh, enjoy! And nothing more!"
Starlight could barely see. The incredible feeling of Twilight's tightness was taking away her capacity to focus on anything but keeping her spells up. Her body was burning with exhaustion from thrusting at such a quick pace, yet she couldn't stop going faster by the second. Waves of hotness rolled over Starlight's body, and her breath turned to nothing more than repeated panting. Placing her right hoof on Twilight's head, she pushed it onto the floor and kept it down.
"You'll t-take all of it and enjoy it!"
Other ponies in the room had already blown their loads inside Twilight's friends. Pinkie Pie was a complete mess; she was more white than pink.Tears rolled down Twilight's cheeks as she saw the state of her friends. But more than anything else, she hated that she could do nothing to help them. And now, now it was her turn. Above her, Starlight growled into her ear, biting down on it so hard it drew a drop of blood. Twilight winced, not because of the pain that briefly shot through her, but because of the torrents of seed being pumped deep inside of her. Starlight trembled heavily before exhaling deeply and letting her body slump on top of Twilight's. The hoof in her hair slowly began petting her, and Starlight chuckled no louder than a whisper.
Even if the spell on her had been lifted, Twilight had not the willpower to get up. Though Starlight had finished, she was still subjugated to watch her friends. Everything was a blur at this point. She didn't know any of the ponies here, nor did she care. All she knew was that this village was going to be her new home. There was no reason to fight it.
"I'm sure you and I will become very good friends." Starlight's voice was as sugary sweet as the first time Twilight had heard it.
She didn't respond.
There were a thousand words in her heads, and she didn't know which ones to pick. For a while, that was all that happened. Starlight continued petting Twilight as she basked in the afterglow, and Twilight watched her friends being used. She thought of Ponyville, and how much she would give to be at Sugarcube Corner, eating too many sweets. This town was like a nightmare of reality in comparison.
As she watched Fluttershy finally give out and stop struggling, simply laying there on the floor and taking whatever was thrust upon her, Twilight found clarity in her mind. With a surprisingly calm voice, Twilight asked just one question.
"Why?"
Starlight chuckled quietly to herself before lowering her head to look directly into Twilight's eyes. With a sickeningly sweet smile, Starlight answered the one, singular question.
"Because I'm better than you, and because I can. Welcome to the village, and enjoy your stay."
