Shifting Melodies - The Lost Stanzas

“Okay!” Amy giggled. “Sugar! Right forehoof on red! And you have to moan somepony’s name while doing it!”

“Oh my,” Sugar said as she did her best to obey the given command. Moondancer had ended up under her, and Chrysalis and her had ended up intertwined. Fritter had ended up under Moondancer as well, and now all Sugar had to do was reaaaach…

Oh, that was interesting. She’d ended up grinding against her wife while doing so. Mmm...Still, she’d made her choice as to whose name she was going to moan. “Ooohh, Fritter,” she said, making it sound just like they were on the bed instead. “It feels so good having you both under me~”

“You know it~” the Earth mare winked and made sure she was watching as she trailed her tongue along Moondancer’s neck, causing the mare to shudder and moan lightly.

“That works!” Amy chirped before spinning the dials again. “Okay, contestant number four, Chryssy! Left hindhoof on...yellow! And you have to...lick somepony in the process!”

“Oh really~?” Chrysalis purred as she reached past Sugar’s thigh, brushing past it as she did. “Well, best go all in hmm?” that was when Sugar felt a tongue against her lower lips.

“Oooh,” she moaned. “That’s not unwelcome, but how long do you intend to do that?”

“Oh, I have my tricks, but I guess you miss out this time,” Chrysalis purred as she pulled back and licked her lips.

“That works too!” Amy giggled. “All righty then, number one, Fritter! Left forehoof on green...And you have to grind against somepony!”

“Ah… how?” Fritter asked, pinned under all the ponies. She reached out, just barely reaching a green square, but was unable to bend her body in a way to fulfill the second part of that.

“Oh, too bad. Hmm, let’s see...penalties, penalties...aha! ‘If a player is unable to complete the pervy action, then the player closest to them gets a free pervy action to perform on them.’” The pink nymph nodded and spun the dial again.

“So that means me?” Moondancer asked. She chuckled as her horn flared and Fritter felt like she was getting felt up all over.

“Kyaa~!” Fritter resisted the urge to flinch.

“Naughty Moondancer! You were supposed to wait for the dial! ‘If a player acts out a pervy action out of turn, they get one performed on them from the closest player.’ I think this one can go to either Sugar or Chryssie, whoever has access to more fun bits.” Finally the dial stopped, and the pink nymph nodded. “It says she gets a licking!”

“I believe I’m closest,” Chrysalis replied and looked at Sugar. “Though, I like my chitin in one piece.”

“Oh, it’s all part of the game, dear,” Sugar said with a smile. “I think we can allow you this~”

Chrysalis chuckled, almost bordering on a mad cackle as she leaned down. Moondancer raised an eyebrow, wondering what the crazy nymph had planned. Then as Chrysalis pressed her mouth against her, there was a small, green flash and Moondancer’s eyes went as wide as saucers as she shrieked!

“Interesting choice,” Sugar said. “I’ll have to try that one later. Whatever it was.”

Chrysalis pulled back as she slurped three long tentacles back into her mouth and reverted back to normal. Moondancer was just quivering and panting loudly.

“All right Moony!” Amy chuckled as she spun both dials again. “Right forehoof on red! And...you get to lick somepony yourself!”

“I...I can’t…” she panted as she leaned out and gave a lazy lick along Sugar’s chest.

“Bzzt!” Amy said. “‘If a player fails to move in accordance with the dials, then they get a perverted action done to them by the nearest player.’ Chryssy did the last one, so Sugar…” The dial spun again and Amy grinned. “Sugar gets to...Oooh, hooves on!”

Sugar grinned and picked up her right forehoof from the circle it had been in before slowly tracing it down her wife’s form, just touching her.

“Oh come on…” Moondancer moaned from the touch, still sensitive from her climax thanks to Chrysalis.

A pair of pink hooves draped around Amy as a pair of baby blue eyes stared into her pink ones.

“Heya!” Pinkie giggled. “Having fun in here?”

“Yup!” Amy said as Sugar’s hoof travelled south and teased her wife’s lips lightly. “They made me the rule master! And I’m loving the show!”

“What’s this rule?” Pinkie asked as she pointed at the book. “One about tagging out for a partner if you want?”

“Eh, we’d need more ponies to do that one,” Amy said with a shrug. Sugar flicked Moondancer’s clit once before returning her hoof to the circle it’d been on. The unicorn moaned again as she twitched.

“Ohh, seems you have been having fun in here,” Pinkie giggled and looked at Moondancer. “You okay over there?”

“Ah, I’ll haaah, Um…”

“Yeah, she’s fine,” Pinkie giggled.

“Oh my,” Fluttershy said, having come in with Pinkie. “That’s… um… okay?”

“And now we’re back to Sugar!” Amy cheered. “Right hind hoof on...green! And you have to...feel somepony up!”

“Easy enough,” the nymph boasted as she picked up her hind hoof and started moving it in the right position...which coincidentally led to it trailing up Chrysalis’ thigh as she shifted it around.

“Mmm, not bad,” Chrysalis replied in a deeper tone as Sugar’s hoof brushed against something that wasn’t female.

“Oh dear me,” Sugar said. “Somepony’s feeling frisky~”

“You have no idea~” Meta purred.

“Um, is...is that…?” Fluttershy turned a deep crimson and looked away.

“Yup, Chryssy can grow one when she feel like it!” Amy chirped before spinning the dial again. “All right Chryssie, left hind hoof on...blue, and...grind on somepony!”

“Easy enough,” Meta said as he moved a hoof back and then dragged his member along Sugar’s lower lips, grinding against her. Even in this form, he was still very much a Noble~

“Oh my,” Sugar purred. “Somepony is making a very good case for me not to pursue the other Noble of Las Pegasus…”

“That so?” Meta purred into her ear. “Sorry love, only two get this little gift~”

“Fritter’s turn!” Amy cheered. “Hmm...right hind hoof on red and...oh, sorry Fritter. ‘Hump somepony.’”

“Uh, so, like this?” she asked as one of her hooves reached out, just as Ace opened the door and she shrieked in surprise, flinching and causing everypony to fall over. “Aw horseapples.”

“Acey~” Amy whined. “You ruined the game~”

“Huh?” he looked around and scratched his head. “What the heck kind of game is this?”

“A fun kind,” Pinkie giggled. “Ohh, we do have another guy to play now Creamy. Maybe he could fill in the penalty round~?”

“I think they all deserve a break,” Amy chirped. “Maybe we can start a new game with you ponies, me, and Acey?”

“That sounds fun~” Pinkie giggled. “Wanna play Shyshy?”

“Um, no… that’s okay,” the pegasus still blushed a deep red. “I don’t think I—”

“I can’t shift, so you’d only have to worry about Acey, and he’ll likely be more interested in Pinkie or me,” Amy said. “I dunno what it is with him and pink ponies, but I like it~”

“Oh...oh my,” Fluttershy blushed again and moved over to the bed to sit. “Um, no… I think I’ll be alright…”

“Well then in that case, you can spin the dials, and Acey and Pinkie and I can play,” Amy said as she helped the mass of ponies off the mat. Fluttershy could at least do that, and she already noticed Sugar dividing her attention between Meta and herself.

“Um, okay, first pony. Right forehoof on red… and, oh my!”

“It’s okay Flutters,” Amy said as she filled that role nicely. “The rules say you don’t spin the second dial until everypony’s in place. So after round one.”

“Oh, okay,” Fluttershy nodded. “Second pony, left back hoof on yellow.”

“On iiiit~” Pinkie giggled as she did.

“So then Mr. Ace? Put your left paw on blue please, um, if that’s okay with you?”

“Of course my dear,” Ace bowed his neck and did so, nipping at Amy’s ear as he did.

“And now the fun starts up again,” Amy said. “Both dials this time Flutters!”

“I don’t know if I can…” Fluttershy said softly.

“Mmm,” Sugar said as she walked over and gave the pegasus a kiss on the head. One filled with more than a little extra lust, to help her get over her inhibitions. “And now?”

“W-Well,” she blushed and spun the wheel. “Miss Amy, left front hoof on red, and… ohmy, sayyourgreatestkink!’ she said quickly.

“Oh that’s easy,” Amy said as she put her hoof in the indicated spot, showing off more than a little to Acey as she did. “I enjoy being dominated by those who know how to take control. It just sorta happened with Acey, and Chryssy does it so well as well...”

“Naturally,” Chrysalis said, having turned back to normal.

“Ohmy,” Fluttershy whispered as she spun the wheel again. “Okay, Pinkie, right hoof on red. And… um, seduce the closest one?”

“Ooh, how… vague,” Pinkie giggled as she reached over, effectively lying on her side as she looked at Amy and gave her a come-hither stare. “Hello there beautiful, wanna come back to my place for a little Pie~?”

“I would, but only if I get to bring Acey as well,” Amy replied. “I don’t want to come unequipped to give you everything, after all~”

Fluttershy wondered how she was still conscious at this point. “Okay Mr. Ace, left talon on green and… describe a sexual act you haven’t done yet.”

“Hmm,” Ace mused as he leaned over, now standing over Amy. “I have never lay with another Griffon before.”

“That’s it, dear,” Sugar said as she sat behind the yellow pegasus. “You’re among friends here. No need to be embarrassed...no need to keep yourself so bottled up and reserved...you can let it all out if you want to…” At the end of her reassurance, she softly stroked the mare before giving her another kiss with another small dose of lust.

“Oh my,” she hummed again and closed her eyes, when she opened them, they seemed to have a red tint to them as she licked her lips. “Alright then, Little Amy, right hoof on green.” Her voice suddenly took a husky tone, one that if the most erotic literature suddenly found a voice, it would sound like that. “And then suck off the closest pony for thirty seconds~”

“Holy moley!” Pinkie gasped. “What the heck was that!?”

“I dunno, but I like it!” Amy said as she maneuvered herself to more fully stand under Ace. She licked at a portion of him that was only just waking up, managing to get him hard before thirty seconds were up and pulling off. “Sorry Acey, but you heard the mare, that’s all you get for right now~”

“Hrrrm, maybe I should drop the game and make you keep going,” he growled and nipped at the back of her neck. “Luckily, I am a patient griffon.”

“Mmhmm, I think you’ll like some of the actions on there Acey~” Amy said. “Alright, next up is Pinkie, Flutters. What’s she doing?”

“She’s going to place both front hooves on red and then present herself for all the other players to do as they like for a minute~’ Fluttershy replied, still keeping that audio erotica tone.

“I can go for that,” Amy replied.

Pinkie gulped and nodded as she did, stretching out with her front hooves like a cat as she raised her hind legs and flagged her tail.

“This… is a little embarrassing,” she blushed. Sugar was then standing in front of her and kissing her as well, giving her just a little extra lust in an attempt to make Pinkie enjoy what was likely about to happen.

Amy lifted up a forehoof from its place and merely stroked and played along Pinkie’s lips, whereas Ace raised his free talon, taking a clawful of that plump rump and squeezing it, before he smirked and pressed a few places around her cutie mark, causing Pinkie to moan and soak Amy’s hoof.

“Now, doesn’t that feel good?” Sugar asked the pink mare.

“Oh sweet cupcakes,” Pinkie drooled. “What was that!?”

“That…” Chrysalis smirked. “Is just a taste of what that griffon can do. He can have you cumming for hours, just by touching you.”

“What next dear Fluttershy?” Sugar asked the no-longer shy mare. Fluttershy nodded and spun the wheel.

“Ohh, Mr. Ace?”

“Yees?” Ace said and waggled his eyebrows.

Fluttershy giggled and tapped the board. “You’re allowed to position yourself however you like, save for one limb, and then tease everypony else in reach for thirty seconds each.”

Ace chuckled and turned to his marefriend. “Seems I have neglected you my dear,” he purred as he lifted her free leg as the tips of his claws traced around her leg holes. Amy moaned at the touch and did her best to stay standing on the board like she should. She would just have to hold out for thirty seconds!

And that was when his claws moved up her leg and found their way under the shell on her back, pressing and teasing at the sensitive skin underneath. Amy let out a louder moan and wobbled a little. Surely...surely he would have to stop soon, right?

Ten seconds left, his claw moved down her rump, giving it a squeeze and as he counted down, his claws kneaded at her folds, cupping it and squeezing. And on the last second, just as he pulled away, he flicked one claw out against her clit.

Amy screamed and drenched the retreating claw with her fluids as she came and managed to stay standing somehow. Probably by sheer willpower. “Haaah...don’t think...you’ve ever gotten me off...that fast before,” she panted.

“I endeavour to improve,” Ace nodded as Pinkie licked her lips at the show. That had been… wow~!

Fluttershy idly rubbed her lower belly with a hoof as she spun the wheel again. “Pinkie? Left rear hoof on green and then ‘return the favour’.”

“Favour huh?” Pinkie giggled as she did so, before she turned and dragged the still tired nymph into a kiss filled with unbridled happiness and even a little lust. Amy was revitalized in an instant, moaning happily at so much being given so freely.

“There we go,” Sugar said happily. “Now it’s a party~”

“Not yet,” Fluttershy said, before flittering over to Sugar and placing a chaste kiss on the mare’s cheek before blushing and hovering back.

“Sugar likes~” the violet nymph purred. “So what will Amy be doing now, Fluttershy?”

“Amy will…” Fluttershy spun the wheel. “Place her hooves on red and say aloud, who she would like to sleep with the most that isn’t in a relationship with her. And what she’d do with them.”

“Oooh, another easy one?” Amy said as she did her best to follow the directions, once again showing off for the griffon behind both of the mares. “That’s easy, it’d be Pinkie here! And if I didn’t have a foal in me, I’d show her everything I can do. As it is, Cherry can’t come out to play until I have my foal.”

“Me? Really?” Pinkie asked. “Why’s that?”

“Cause you’re so much like me,” Amy replied. “Plus...that would mean Acey could have a turn with you as well, and I know he likes Pink ponies~”

“You are determined to make me like Midnight aren’t you?” Ace chuckled. “Or Ledger. I fear he and I are going to have more in common if you got your way.”

“Are you saying you don’t want to do Pinkie here?” Amy asked.

“I’d at least like to get to know her first,” Ace said. “While Chrysalis was a rather spur of the moment thing, one that I don’t regret mind you. I prefer to wine and dine a mare or stallion before bedding them.”

“A stallion?” Pinkie and Fluttershy echoed.

“Who do you think I took Cherry out to play with when we were just getting to know one another?” Amy asked.

“Gender does not matter with me,” Ace nodded. “It’s what’s in your heart that truly matters.” He thumped his chest to make his point, but the sudden movement, mixed with the alcohol in his system, caused him to stumble and trip onto the two mares under him.

Pinkie and Amy suddenly had a very large griffon on their backs, and Amy did everything she could to help her fellow Pink pony hold him up.

“Whoops,” Ace chuckled.

“H-heavy,” Pinkie groaned and then cranked her tail like a chariot jack as she raised them up. “There we go~”

Amy almost thought about asking, but she knew better. Instead, she just hoped this was enough to get Ace back on his feet. While she was used to his weight, they usually had a bed underneath to help take most of it off…

“I think I’m still a little tipsy,” Ace chuckled as he rolled off of them and onto the floor. “Sorry ladies.”

“Well, since Amy moved the least, she wins this round,” Fluttershy said. “And is free to do as she likes to the others~”

“Hmm,” Amy said as her horn lit up, lifting Pinkie up and placing her on a certain feathery chest. “Including this?”

“The rules state,” Fluttershy cleared her throat. “The winner is Queen or King. And gets to do whatever they want. The others must follow any orders, well, within reason of course.”

“So if I tell Acey to show Pinkie here a good time,” Amy posed, waiting to see what would happen.

“I’d say you have to be a little more specific,” Ace mused as he played ‘pattycake’ with the giggling mare.

“Okay then,” Amy purred. “Why don’t you show her your magic touch?”

“That, I can do,” Ace nodded as he traced his claws along the mare’s spine and sides, leaving her gripping him and moaning at his touch. Sugar could sense her desire build up, reaching tipping point before he brought her back down. Then rinse and repeat as Pinkie panted and moaned, begging for release.

“Oh, stop being so cruel to the poor mare,” Amy said before kissing the top of his feathery head.

“Ah, but you said to show her,” Ace said. “You never said to allow her a finish,” he just chuckled as he kept up his relentless and pleasureable torture.

“Then I hereby command you to let her cum,” Amy said before beeping his beak with a hoof.

“As you wish,” Ace shrugged and tapped a few points before gripping her cutie marks. Pinkie let out a loud screaming moan and came hard!

“There we go,” Sugar purred as she went back to cuddling Fluttershy. “Wasn’t that fun?”

“I just watched one of my best friends do something like that,” Fluttershy blushed. “I don’t know what to feel.”

“I think the correct answer is aroused, dear,” Sugar said as she went back to comforting the shy mare. “Like I said earlier, you’re among friends here. We won’t judge you. It’s fine to have feelings about things~”

“I...I wouldn’t have done that… if I didn’t mind,” Pinkie panted and rolled off of Ace, before making her way over to Fluttershy and hugging her. “Still, if you don’t want to, we can forget this happened and go back to our room.”

“I don’t know,” Fluttershy said. “And… I’m worried about Dashie. She still seemed kinda mad…”

“It’s cause she likes you,” Pinkie said and kissed her cheek. “And… well, I kinda like you too.”

Fluttershy turned a deep crimson. Mind, Pinkie liked all her friends. But, she had no idea that Rainbow felt like that.

“Ah, young love,” Sugar purred. “I rather think you should think about whether you like your friends like that, miss Fluttershy, then think about if you want to do this with them.”

Fluttershy thought about it and then she got an idea. “Miss Sugar? Could you help me with Rainbow?”

“That depends,” the Violet nymph purred. “How do you mean?”

“Well, I think she might be mad at me for coming here… and, I don’t handle confrontation very well… and Dashie is kind of…” Fluttershy trailed off and looked away.

“So, maybe we can go back to your room,” Sugar said. “And we’ll see what happens there~”

“Um, that’s… only if Miss Moondancer doesn’t mind…”

“I don’t think she will, as long as I come back,” Sugar said with a smile.

“Hey, I finally get some peace and quiet,” Moondancer said as she opened a book. “‘Bout time.”

“See? She’s fine with it,” Sugar said, giving Fluttershy a normal kiss. “So let’s go see miss Dash then, and see what occurs.”

“Y-Yes,” Fluttershy nodded and the two left the room.