Mistress Do Well: Extradition

Mistress Do Well: Extradition
by milesprower06

Four

December

AJ was spending her morning stacking hay bales the barn. She had just started on the third stack when Twilight came through the doors.

"Mornin' Twilight. What can I do for ya?"

"Well, I'm actually here on Fluttershy's behalf to discuss something with you."

"What does she want you to discuss?" Applejack said, taking a seat on the bale of hay she had just set down. Twilight did the same with a nearby bale.

"Well, she's wondering if she can convince you to take your relationship up a few notches. Specifically, making it more... Physical."

"What does she mean by that?"

"She said that so far, the only thing you've been doing is tying her up. She'd like more."

"I told her when we first got together that I would never hit her."

"I know, she told me. And she says if you really can't, she doesn't want to push you."

"Then why is she having you tell me this instead of doing it herself?"

"Because she thought it would make more sense coming from a dom or a switch."

"Huh?" Applejack asked, perplexed.

"A 'dom' obviously the one dominating, and a 'switch' plays both the dominating and submissive roles. Rainbow and I switch, but Fluttershy considers herself a sub all the time, so she thought it would sound better coming from somepony who shares the dominating point of view."

"So you're going to convince me to hit my marefriend?"

"No. I'm going to try and convince you to listen to what your marefriend wants."

"I told her I didn't want to come anywhere close to what it was like down there. Twilight, you wouldn't quite understand, you spent most of the time observing."

"You're right. I did. But I participated nonetheless. What I had to do, what Rainbow had to do, what Fluttershy had to do, and what she's trying to get you to do, is see the line, know where it is."

"I know where the line is, and I'm not about to cross it."

"No, I don't think you do, because you're so far left of the line that you're not being the dom Fluttershy wants you to be."

"So she wants me to break her? Make her mine?"

"Applejack, she is yours, from the moment you showed up at her door after the night at the bar. Bondage and submission isn't about breaking someone. It's about them letting you take control, then, at the end, giving it back to them. If she wants you to hit her, it's not abuse."

"You know how her and Rarity turned out."

"I know. You should have seen me, how much I was shaking, when I gave Rainbow my magic inhibitor. Of course you have to be careful. Both of you do, just like Rainbow and I do. Yes, she was in a very, very abusive relationship, but that doesn't mean she can't try again with you."

"How am I supposed to trust her to know where her limits are...?"

"Applejack... If you can't trust her, and help her find her limits... Why are you with her?"

That last question hammered the point home, and Applejack looked a bit shaken.

"I... I don't know if I can do that... I'm... I'm scared, Twilight."

"I was too. I was so afraid Rainbow would get out of my bed and storm out of the library when I first asked her. I'm sure she was scared when I found her collared and submissive after our bar night. But together, it's not so scary."

The light bulb in Twilight's head.

"Hey, there's an idea."

"What?"

"Together. What if... What if the four of us got together for some fun? If you're afraid of going past your limits when you're alone with her, then don't try it alone at first. Let's do it together, like... Like... Sweet Celestia, I can't believe I'm gonna say this..." She muttered. "Like it was down there. But we'll keep our heads this time. Consent. Safe words."

Applejack looked like she was staring at an oncoming train.

"So you want to give that a try? It would be quite the curve ball for Fluttershy and Rainbow."

"Are you sure about this, Twilight?" Rainbow asked as she trotted down the path to Fluttershy's cottage with her alicorn marefriend.

"Pretty sure, yeah. Fluttershy talked to me, then I talked to Applejack, then she talked to you, then you talked to me, then I talked to Applejack again to set things up. What's so confusing about that?"

"But how is this going to work? Fluttershy told me that AJ isn't going to feel comfortable putting her hooves on me, and I know you don't want to touch Fluttershy."

"I would've thought you'd know better than to question your mistress by now."

They turned the corner on the path to Fluttershy's cottage, and trotted up to her front door. Twilight gave a short knock, and the front door opened a few moments later.

"Well, howdy you two. Come on in." Applejack greeted, opening the door wider, revealing the spectacle on the center rug; Fluttershy trussed up on her back.

"Just getting our fuck toy ready for some fun."

Resting on the floor beside Fluttershy's head was a combination gag-dildo. The end that went into her mouth was an inflatable butterfly gag. When inserted and inflated, she wouldn't be capable of anything more than a muffled whimper. The other end was a fully erect and flared stallionhood. Applejack went back over to her pet, and went about getting the gag in her mouth, strapped around her head, and fastened securely.

"There we go. Be a good girl and stay put. Twi, can I see you in the kitchen?"

Twi magically reached into her saddlebags, got Rainbow's collar, and fastened it on.

"Sit next to Fluttershy, and I'll be back."

"Yes, Mistress." Rainbow replied, taking a seat next to Fluttershy, who merely glanced between her and the black silicone stallionhood that was protruding from her mouth, while the two mistresses went to the back of the kitchen to avoid being heard.

"So, just like we planned, right?" AJ asked, who was trying rather hard to hide her nervousness.

"Yep. Deep breaths, you'll be fine. I'll be here in case anything gets out of hand, and they'll have their safe words and actions."

Applejack's first deep breath came.

"Alright, in case I get Rainbow, what's her threshold?"

"Well, for the force I put behind my magic, usually thirty or thirty-five. Oh, and you'll get the best results if you take it slow. Let each blow sink in. But I can't account for your earth pony strength. But don't worry. You have to pay attention to more than the tears and the crying, AJ. That's just the natural bodily response to pain and punishment. But when you're dealing with someone who enjoys that to an extent, you have to factor in more. For either Rainbow or Fluttershy, look at her ears, her arousal levels, and whether or not she's cowering."

AJ took another deep breath.

"Alright, let's go."

They came out of the kitchen to find their pets right where they left them. Applejack reached into her saddlebag and procured another dildo gag, and another coil of rope, tossing them to Twilight, who caught it with her magic.

"There ya are, just let me know when your pet is ready to go."

"Lay back." Twilight commanded, and was immediately obeyed. Rainbow opened her mouth and accepted the incoming gag. She knew already to offer her hooves for a hog tie, and was simultaneously trussed up while the gag was fastened and inflated.

"Okay, she's all set. You ready?"

"Yep, let's get warmed up."

The two pets watched with anticipation as their mistresses straddled them above their necks, and gently caressed themselves with the dildos, getting themselves aroused. Fluttershy shivered as she witnessed Applejack's marehood start to slowly glisten. After ninety seconds, they were both ready, gave each other a nod, then took the cocks inside them, descending on their submissive's faces. They farmer and princess hummed with pleasure, as they slowly got faster, and began to facefuck their pets. They both found their muzzles become slowly coated with their mistress' arousal as it coated the dildo and dripped down to the base and down to their fur.

The two of them were going slowly enough to stay aroused, but not fast or forceful enough to achieve orgasm. This was obviously just the first course. Both Rainbow's and Fluttershy's wings struggled against the rope that held them down, yet Twilight's were already fully spread.

"Alright, alright, I think that's enough..." Applejack said, pulling up off of Fluttershy. Twilight did the same, a thread of arousal briefly connecting the tip of the dildo to her marehood.

Both gags were removed and set aside. Rainbow found herself magically picked up and carried halfway across the room to the other side of the rug, turned over onto her stomach, while Fluttershy, much more unceremoniously, was dragged across and placed next to her, likewise on her stomach. Both mistresses leaned down directly into their respective pet's ear.

"Good job so far, pet," Twilight began. "For this next activity, make me cum first, or I'll spank Fluttershy instead of you."

Rainbow nodded as much as she could, her chin resting on the floor.

Applejack had a similar message.

"I know what you've been hiding. If you make me cum first, I'll give your flanks what you've been secretly wanting. If not, well, then I just might have to give Rainbow that treatment and make you watch."

Fluttershy's eyes widened in anticipation. Going to Twilight had been the right choice, after all.

Twilight and Applejack got up and left their pets where they laid, and crossed the large area rug, and took revealing sitting positions on the other side of it, twenty feet away.

"Well, what are you two waiting for? Get over here and start licking!" Twilight commanded.

Both pegasi's attempt to stand was humorous, and they quickly deduced that they would need to wiggle and worm their way over to their mistress.

So the race was on.

Rainbow's method was to bend and worm her way across the rug to Twilight, and Fluttershy opted to wiggle herself to forward momentum. Both methods were desperate and evenly matched. Both Applejack and Twilight watched with expectant gazes as their pets drew slowly closer.

Rainbow saw her head pass the tips of Twilight's back hooves and started to lunge her body forward. She got herself tucked in between her mistress' legs, and inched forward one more time, bumping her muzzle into Twilight's slick marehood. She instantly began licking and sucking, a full five seconds before Fluttershy arrived at her destination. Applejack began to lean back, having a great view of her pet's efforts. She started slow and sensual; she was going to try and make slow and steady win the race. Applejack looked over to Twilight and Dash, who had taken the opposite approach and dove right in. Twilight stretched and flexed her wings to the best of her ability in her aroused state,so they wouldn't be sore in a few hours.

Since they had already warmed up with the dildos, this race was not going to take long. Especially since the licking and slurping sounds coming from in between the legs of the other dom was making them even hotter.

Both Dash's and Fluttershy's methods were proving effective; there was no clear advantage. If Applejack liked things slow and gentle, 'Shy was playing right into her hooves. Dash, on the other hand, was trying to figure out how to win this thing. Sloppy wasn't going to do it, but when she wasn't able to put any other body part other than her tongue to use in pleasing her mistress, that was proving tricky. Both Twi and Applejack were beginning to pant. It was a risk, but Rainbow wanted to take it. She didn't think she was prepared to sit and watch Fluttershy get punished.

Rainbow craned her neck up, drew her tongue to the top, and suckled hard on her mistress' clit.

"Ahhh!!!" Twilight cried, falling backwards, and the fruits of Rainbow's labor were seen squirting up from between her legs as she fell onto her back.

Applejack, as close as she was, saw Twilight's victory, and was forced to concede. It'd be easier to give Rainbow what was coming to her if she was pent up anyway. She reached down, and separated Fluttershy from her dripping marehood.

"S-Sorry, darlin'. Looks like you need a little more practice." She told her, getting a defeated whimper out of her in return.

The two pets were released from their ropes, and their wings immediately began to unfurl.

"Go sit over by my saddlebags." Applejack told Fluttershy, while Twilight handed AJ one of her wider leather straps.

"Alright, slave, since you did such a good job, AJ here is going to make sure you still know your place. I'm thinking... How does thirty sound, AJ?"

"Sounds good to me."

"And you, slave?"

"Y-Yes mistress. Thirty is good."

"Mm. Better make it forty then."

Rainbow visibly gulped as she presented towards AJ, and raised her tail. The farmer gently swung the strap around to get a feel for it. Then, she looked at the plot in front of her, and took aim.

"Remember to count."

She swung the strap down and connected with Rainbow's cyan flank.

"One!" Rainbow said almost immediately, gritting her teeth for the next one, but to her horror, Applejack was taking it nice and slow. She would wait until just after she stopped tensing up, then descend with another blow.

*CRACK!*

"Two!"

The blows continued to come, most when Rainbow least expected them. Some were delivered alone. A few were delivered in quick succession in chunks of two and three.

*CRACK! CRACK!*

"T-Ten! El-l-leven!"

Her voice was shaking by the teens, tears began to fall in the approach to twenty, and she was coming closer to full-on crying as they made their way up to thirty. AJ reared her arm back, and swung with such force that Rainbow heard the strap approach.

*CRACK!!!*

"Yaaahhhthirty!! Cloudsdale!" Rainbow yelled.

Applejack froze every muscle in her front hooves. That was the safe word. She looked to Twilight, who stepped up to check on Rainbow.

"You okay?" Twilight said, gently caressing Rainbow's neck.

Tears streamed down her cheeks, and she took a few shuddering breaths.

"Yeah... Yeah, just... Just give me a sec... Gotta catch my breath." Rainbow said, shuddering.

As she took a few deep breaths, Twilight walked around to check her backside. Her flanks were beginning to turn crimson, with red marks that contrasted sharply with her cyan coat, and there were a few welts, but no skin was broken. Applejack looked over at Fluttershy, obediently sitting off to the side, staring at Rainbow, and biting her lip, wings fully erect. She was certainly enjoying the show.

After ten seconds, Rainbow nodded to Twilight.

"Alright," she said, sniffling away some of the tears. "Go ahead and finish up."

"Are you sure?"

Rainbow nodded fervently, both pairs of her cheeks red. "Yes. I've got ten more." She was never one to back out early.

She looked back at Applejack.

"And don't go easy on me, Mistress." She quipped, adding just enough sass to the last word to make sure that going easy would be the last thing the farm pony did.

Applejack made note of Rainbow's mannerisms. "You have to pay attention to more than just the tears and the crying, AJ." Twilight had told her. She also had to pay attention to the body language. Rainbow's ears were perked, not folded, her wings were still fully erect, and she wasn't cowering. Lastly, she was nearly dripping from arousal.

Twilight gave her a nod.

"Alright. Brace yourself, Dash. These last ten are going to be nasty since you're starting to bruise up."

There was a crack, and Dash cried out the thirty-first strike. With every blow, Fluttershy felt her marehood pulse with desire. Euphoria and jealousy rushed through her mind like a tidal wave. However Twilight had talked to Applejack, whatever she told her, it evidently worked. Here was Rainbow, crying and bruising after thirty strikes, she had even given out the safe word for a chance to recuperate and catch her breath, and Applejack now had the heart to continue.

She just wished she had been the first. She would have to try harder next time...

"Ffffffforty!!!" Dash cried out, her knees about to collapse.

Twilight came around back again to check on the pegasus as she gasped for air, weeping, while Applejack came over to Fluttershy and stood her up, walking her over beside Rainbow.

"Present." Her mistress told her, and Fluttershy did as she was instructed, lowering her front half and raising her tail in invitation.

"How's she doing?" Applejack asked, looking over to Twilight, while gently rubbing Fluttershy's moist slit.

"She'll live." Twilight said, also beginning to rub Rainbow's winking marehood.

"Think these two deserve a reward for behaving today?"

Twilight levitated two ball gags to the front of Fluttershy and Rainbow, and they obediently opened their mouths and got them fastened. When they were gagged, they both knew the safe "word" was to tap the floor three times.

"I'm ready for dessert if you are."

Applejack licked her lips, and felt Fluttershy quiver.

"Bon appetit."

Simultaneously, the two mistresses began eating their pets up. Both of them tried their best not to squirm, and be good girls, but getting release after such a great build-up was making that difficult. Fluttershy whimpered through her gag as she resisted leaning into Applejack's face.

Over on Rainbow's side, the cyan pegasus wallowed in the euphoric pool of pleasure and pain. Twilight's hooves gently massaged her sore flanks while her tongue did the work of rewarding her for enduring the pain and taking her punishment like a good pet. The safe word really did make all the difference; the twenty-sixth through thirtieth strikes gave her flashbacks from the basement, and when she cried out the safe word, she was pulled out, and found herself in the hooves of her loving Mistress, her gentle, caring voice making sure she was okay. That feeling couldn't be put into words. A small part of her wished she wouldn't need the safe word, but she shoved that thought away every time. It was there for a reason, and a damned good one at that.

Her mind was such a chaotic mix, such a euphoric high, that she didn't recall the moment when she came into Twilight's waiting mouth, but when Twilight pulled away, her mind began to descend, things slowly came back into focus, and she felt incredibly weak at the knees. Immediately, the collar was removed and placed back into her saddlebags. She was led to the couch along with Fluttershy.

"There ya go," Twilight began, situating the two of them then wrapping them up in a couple of fleece blankets, while AJ came out with a tray containing four cups of hot cocoa. She had been adamant on having soothing aftercare. Safe words weren't enough. When everything was said and done, they'd relax and comfort the subs for a job well done. Together, on the couch, they cuddled each other, reflecting on the intense yet fun time they had just shared together.

Applejack snuggled a bit closer into Fluttershy, and realized that maybe going a bit deeper wasn't such a bad idea.

Two Hours Later

After nearly falling asleep on the couch, the four ponies were roused and went their separate ways. After Twilight and Dash departed, Fluttershy went up to bed while AJ took care of the dishes.

"Might as well check on her before I head home for the night." Applejack said to herself when the last cup was set on the drying rack. She trotted up the stairs. When she came to Fluttershy''s bedroom door, her concern rose exponentially when she heard crying.

"Fluttershy?" She asked, knocking, then opening the door. Her marefriend was curled up on her bed, facing away from her.

'Damn it all, I knew this was a bad idea...' AJ cursed herself as she approached Fluttershy's bed.

"Sweetheart, what's wrong? Did today not go how you wanted it to? I was ready to do it, but Rainbow won, and rules are rules, and-"

"No, Applejack," Fluttershy began, sniffling and rolling over to face her. "I loved today. I absolutely loved it, and even though it was aimed at Rainbow, I'm so happy that you're starting to open up and push a little harder. I can't wait to do it again. No... This is... Something's been bothering me, for a few week's actually, and... And I'm not sure I'm ready to tell you, because I'm scared to death of how you'll react."

Applejack wasn't sure how to feel. Fluttershy had always been a tad on the timid side, especially when it came to telling somepony something that might hurt or offend them. On the other hoof, she was her marefriend, and didn't want to be left in the dark if something was bothering one of the most important mares in her life.

AJ got up on the bed and took off her saddlebags.

"Sugarcube, listen. I don't want you goin' to bed with something you might need to get off your chest, so... You give me what I want and..."

Fluttershy felt the leather strap gently tap her flanks.

"And I'll give you what you want."

Fluttershy took a deep breath, her eyes widening. The lightbulb came on in her head, and she prayed AJ would accept it.

"Beat it out of me." She said hurriedly, getting up onto her hooves and presenting on the bed.

"Now I didn't mean it like that, I just-"

"No! Applejack, I'm too scared otherwise. You're my mistress, I'm your pet, now get it out of me!"

Applejack forced the butterflies in her stomach down, and knelt behind her trembling marefriend on the bed. All in the next second, she tried to settle her inner debate; Fluttershy's request was contradicting Twilight's advice today; right now, Fluttershy was cowering, but she wasn't afraid of the strap, she was afraid of telling her something she needed to get out.

*CRACK!*

"Sayin' nothin' is just as bad as lyin' Fluttershy. I won't tolerate a liar."

"Applejack, I-"

*CRACK!*

"Ah!"

"You're gonna tell me what I need to hear, or I'm gonna whip your flank 'til your nose bleeds."

*CRACK!*

"Ah! A-Applejack please I-"

*CRACK!*

No safe word said, nor safe taps on the bed.

"Now, Fluttershy."

"I... I..."

*CRACK!*

"The truth. NOW!"

*CRACK!*

"Ahh! I want to go see Rarity!!!"