A gift from Applejack.

by The Frank

Rating: mature
Tags: Alternate Universe, Twilight Sparkle, Anthro, Applejack, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Mystery, Spike, Rarity, Romance, Sex
Length: 5448

Applejack wants to get.even with Elusive after his little "gift". Now he is planning something for Elusive. A surprice his coltfriend can’t even imagine...

Applejack doesn’t believe in holding grudges. Forgive and forget, that’s his motto, and there are few conflicts that can’t be solved over a mug of cider.

But he hates being played for a sucker, and after Elusive's "gift", he's just been waiting for a chance to pay back.

Elusive has no idea what awaits him.

A story about earth pony love and a nasty sense of humour. And stallions fucking the shit out of one another. Anthro, because the prequel was.

Cover by nolycs and used with permission of cource!

Published 2016-07-26 22:30:01 UTC
Last updated 2016-07-30 21:40:20 UTC

Act 1

Three hard knocks on the castle door. Barb knew only one pony who's definition of a friendly visit was light collateral damage, although she knew it wasn't on purpose. Nevertheless, if they wanted to keep the door, she had to run. Another three knocks, and the wood was almost crying from the assault when Barb finally got there and could open the door.

"Hi AJ!" The farmer was a giant compared to Barbara, so she always kept something to stand on when he came for a visit to be able to look him in the eye without streching her neck.
"Mornin' Barb. 'S Dusk up?"

Barb smiled. "He's awake, but not up. Trickster went to Baltimare earlier, and they spent most of the night saying goodbye, if you know what I mean."

Barb noticed with satisfaction that Applejack blushed. Even though some of the stuff he and Elusive done in the bedroom could be described as kinky, other ponies sex life was still something he prefered if they kept to themselves.

"Well, if he ain't presentable, ah'll just come back later..." He began to turn away, when he felt Barb's hand on his shoulder.
"Come on, AJ, it’s Dusk we're talking about. The only stallion alive that still sleep with pajamas, slipper and night cap. Just get in there, I'll bring some coffee."

"Ehm... well, Alright then. Mighty nice of ya, Barb."

" Just good hospitality, AJ."

Applejack made his way up to Dusk and Tricksters quarters. The bedroom door was slightly ajar, but he still knocked 'discretely' before he went in.

"What? Barbara? What is it? Is the castle on fire? Are the changelings attacking? Are..."
Dusk Shine sat up in his bed, with panic in his eyes and his hair in a mess. AJ assumed that apparently something had scared him while he was reading, because three open books were thrown on the floor. He quickly walked across the room so he could calm down his friend.

"Calm down Dusk, 's just me."

Dusk just stared at him first. "Apple...Jack? It’s just... you?" As Applejack nodded, Dusks eyes shrank to their normal size and his breath got steadier. "Well, it’s good to see you, but please try to knock a little softer next time."

"That's what ah did." Applejack looked confused.

Dusk stared at him, then he sighed. "Ok. So, Applejack, what can I do for you?"

"Well, um...it's kinda dumb but ah, well, ah need to do something, and it keeps nagging me, and ah know ah have to get this done if ah, um, would get some, eh, peace."

"Oookay... That sounds complicated. Is it something to do with the farm?"

"No, it's... Ah need help with Elusive."

"You need help with Elusive? Sorry for asking, but he told me what you did with ropes last time we had tea, so... I don't know if I can help you with that."

Applejack blushed hard. "N-no... It ain't about that. Well, sort of but... Not about sex directly, more..."

"Aha! I understand!"

"You do?" Applejack looked with surprice at Dusk, how could he know about this? Barb had promised to keep quiet.

"While the sex-change formula have to be slight altered, the procedure is basically the same. Have you decided who will carry the foal?"

Applejack blushed even harder. "What? No! Ah mean...ah will be the carrier... But it's not about that. We have to be married first!"

"So, is it about marriage? No, it can't be. You are already engaged."

"Dusk... It has nothing to do with... Ah need help to... get even with Elusive. "

Dusk blinked. "You mean... You mean like with a prank? Applejack nodded. "Oh, well I guess I... but, well sorry for asking, but wouldn't Rainbow be more of a help? He is the main prankster around here, as far as I know."

Applejack looked down at the floor and scratched his hooves. "Yeah, that’s the thing. Ah don’t wanna ask Rainbow."

"Why not? I thought he was your best friend?"

"Oh, he is. It ain't 'bout that. It's like this, if ah ask Rainbow for help, it will be something big and fancy and something that completely will piss Elusive off. And then he'll want to get even, and do something even bigger against me, and then ah have to do something to him and so on and so on for ever and ever! None of us Will give up, ah know Lucy! Damn it, ah wanna marry the stallion, not start a war with him."

Dusk blinked again. "But...Why do you have to get even with him then? If you just stop there won't be anything more."

Applejack looked at Dusk with a face that said 'did you just say that apples grew on squirrels'. "Of cource ah have to. No pony plays a member of the Apple family for a sucker and gets away with it."

Dusk stared at his friend, and he was dead serious. He sighed. He could try to reason with him, but that usually ended in talk about ' traditions'. Dusk realized that he never could talk AJ out of it so it was better to just tag along. " Okay. Then I guess asking Bubble is also out of the question? "

"Yep. To many bananas. Ah need something... Well not big but... Something he can’t one-up me on. Nothing cunning, or clear or childish. Ah need something smart, and yer the smartest pony ah know."

Dusk blushed. Applejack had to admit, as monogamous as he was, Dusk Shine was a cutie. "Well, Applejack... I am flattered but and I would love to help but, can’t you come up with something yourself?"

"Ah would but... Ahm not good at it. Ah don't like prankster, ah can do the switching of salt and sugar in someones coffee. But that's as far as ah'd go on my own. And He went further than that."

"What did he do? "

Applejack draw a deep breath and began his tale. He told Dusk about the breakfast, he mumbled his way through the description of the sex, and he became red in his face with anger as he told Dusk how he spent the whole afternoon shopping. "And he knows how much ah hate shopping. And so, when ah finally found a gift for him, he told me that it was all some punishment for me wearing his suit when ah fed the pigs. Mah pigs ain't filthy! And we could wash it!!! There was only a few stains on it, and those were gone after the wash! "

Dusk was lost for words. "Oh...uhm...well... that sounds like Elusive alright but... well...isn't it to much to prank him? I mean, you made up, he said he was sorry..."

"No, He didn't."

"What?"

"Dusk, this is Elusive. He never apologize. He said that I was myself to blame. If I didn’t feed the pigs..."

Dusk put his hand on his cheek. Elusive was known to be a bit to full of his own importance, and to put him down a nodge would be benifical for all. " Hmmm... I kind of see why this needs to be done. Alright, I'll help you. Just let me look in..."

"Dusk, if it is.'one thousand and one pranks', we have that one at home. A gift from Rainbow."

"Oh." Dusk slumped his shoulders. Then he began to think. Applejack could almost see the gears grind in his friends brain. He was silent for a while, and then he almost jumped out of the bed.

"I have it! It's perfect! I even think this is foulproof. There is no he can top THIS!"

***

Later the same day, Elusive was in his studio. The boutique was his main work space, but at times the familliar surroundings did nothing for his creativity and a quick change of surroundings usually did the trick. Plus, it was nice to steal a kiss at lunch. Today however, he had spent the day at the spa and had just went up to look things over.

He noticed it the moment he entered the room. Somepony had been there. The signs were small and subtle, but they were there. Some needles out of order, a chair one inch to much to the left... and a slight smell of dirt. Applejack. Elusive frowned. Why would Applejack go here? He never came up here on his own free will. Elusive shrugged his shoulders and went down for dinner.

After dinner, a simple meal of a cheese-, tomato and apple salad, Elusive looked at Applejack and asked: "Darling? Where you up in my studio today?"

Applejack read a newspaper and answered without looking up. "Nope".

Elusive frowned. Applejack HAD been there. Why didn’t he just admit it? "Darling, I believe you were. Some time after lunch."

Applejack seemed to think it over. "Hmmm... nope."

"Applejack... look at me."

"Yes, Lucy?"

"Don't call me that! Now I'm asking you for the last time. Why did you go up to my studio? I know you've been there. Don’t pretend something else."

"HMmm... oh yeah. Ah was up there looking for ya."

"Why were you looking for me? I was at the spa."

"Yeah, ah remembered when ah got there."

"Oh. Alright. "

They left the subject, but Elusive couldn't let go of the uneasy feeling. There was something... And later that evening, Elusive heard somepony open the door to the studio. He rushed to it, but there was no pony there. But the door had been opened, and from what he knew, only he and Applejack was inside the house...

It took some time to fall asleep that night.

***

The next day, after breakfast. Elusive had kissed Applejack goodbye and began his way to the boutique when he remembered that he forgot to bring the tie he was going to lend Dopey. So he went back to the house, and as he entered his room, he froze. Applejack was inside his wardrobe.

"Darling? What are you doing?"

Applejack quickly closed the door and smiled a demi-fake smile. "Oh, hi Lucy! Ah was just... out of briefs. And ah just wanted to see if yer had any."

"Applejack... First of all, that’s not the wardrobe where I keep my underwear, and you know that. I've told you, that one is for shirts, that one is for accessoaries, that one is for underwear. And besides, you hate wearing underwear when you work. "

"Well... ah wanted to surprice ya."

"Surprice me."

"Yes."

"By wearing underwear."

"Yeah."

"Look, Applejack. I don't know what your game is, but I suggest that you stop it. Now."

"Mah game? Lucy, ah ain't playin no games. Ah was just..."

"Ok. Ok. If that’s your way of handling this, forget it. See you tonight."

Elusive had trouble concentrating the whole day. No matter how much he tried, his mind came back to Applejack. His behaviour was suspicious, no matter what he said. But what was he doing? And why? Applejack was no prankster, and he was probably the least spontanious pony Elusive knew. Elusive tried to shake off his feelings. He needed to concentrate! This suit for Baritone demanded his best, and.

Suit. Applejack. That "gift".

Elusive almost dropped everything he held on the floor. The conclusion was instant. Applejack was going to get even for his little stunt. And he knew his coltfriend. The sweetest, yes, but stubborn as a mule and never letting go of things he got on his mind to do. Elusive stared blankly at the wall.

"Shit."

But a moment later, he calmed down. He had the upper hand here. Applejack didn't know he was found out. All he needed to do was to stay one step ahead and wait for a mistake. Elusive smiled a grim, cat-like smile, and finished the suit without further distractions.

***

But the following days were Tartarus. Elusive tried to act normal, but he didn't dare to leave Applejack alone in the house. That took a lot of him, as he had to follow Applejack whenever he went in came he decided to act. Then he realized he might have hired somepony to... The boutique! Then he bribed Soprano with theater tickets for him and Barb if they watched over the boutique and never left it unguarded. After three days, he never left the house. He checked his studio for traps and pranks once every hour. He checked his wardrobes twice an hour. He couldn't eat, and he didn't dare to sleep. Because one time, he woke up at night and found himself alone in bed... And he KNEW that Applejack had been in the studio. Even though he found him in the kitchen having a glass of water, he KNEW.

***

Now it had been five days since the realizetion. Elusive was pale, even more than normal. The Black rings under his eyes where thick like hoofprints, and his mane was laying flat against his head. And worst of all, he couldn't even have a cup of delicious tea since he caught Applejack with his hands in the can once.

It was now three o'clock at night. Applejack was out hunting fruitbats. SAID he... but Elusive knew. And he would catch him. He would catch him... He would...

"Lucy?"

"AAAAH! "

***

When Applejack was in caretaker mood, it was no use in fighting back. Elusive found himself in bed, with a cup of tea, his favourite silk pajama on and all the softest pillows. He reluctantly sipped his tea.

"Lucy, why in Solaris name are ya up at this hour? Ah told ya to go to bed. It could take all night if we were not of luck. So what were yer doin'? And why d'yer hair look like a mess?"

And then, Elusive had no resistance left. "I was trying to figure you out."

"Sorry?"

"I know everything, Applejack, I get it. You want to get back at me for...that thing at breakfast. And I thought I could outsmart you but... I checked everything, I have been one step ahead of you all the time! And I still! Don't! Get! It!
What are you planning? What is your game? Please, baby... I give up, I’m so tired... I'm sorry, okay? I'm sorry I played you that trick. Just tell me what you are going to do."

Elusive sank back on the pillows and looked at his coltfriend with tears in his eyes. Appeljack gave him a light kiss on his cheek. "Well, ah'm mighty thankful yer finally apologized. And because yer honest with me, ah'll be honest with yer. But yer got to understand, ah'm telling the truth. Nothing but the truth, ok? Or d'yer want me to Bubble promise?"

"No...no, I believe you. Just tell me."

"Alright then. The truth is... ah did nothing. Ah didn’t plan to do anything at all."

Author's Note

The reveal!

Act 2.

A few days earlier...

Applejack looked expactantly and a bit sceptic at Dusk. "So, what’s the plan?"

Dusk smiled. "Have you ever heard 'know your enemies and know yourself', Applejack?"

"Yeah, ain't it that Sun sea guy who said that? We read about him in agriculture school, when we talked about how to make good business."

"Sun Tzu. But still, excellent, Applejack! Then you will understand me. Now, what is your biggest weakness? "

Applejack began to move uncomfortably. "Now, ah know what yer after, and ah don’t like to call it a weakness... but ah guess yer talkin' 'bout me being a terribly liar. Blitz always nags me about that."

"Trust me Applejack, this time it will work. The thing about a prank is that it has to involve some kind of lie, some kind of decievement. What is Elusive's biggest weakness?"

Applejack thought about it for a while. "Mud on his clothes. "

"...ehm... yes... sorry, let me rephrase that. What is his worst trait?"

"Hmmm... oh, he always thinks he knows best."

"Exactly! So, if you should try and prank him, what would he do?"

"Ah wouldn’t prank him."

Dusk looked blankly at Applejack. "'Kay, ah'm goin' to do it NOW, but...it ain't the... ah haven’t done it before."

"Alright, but doesn’t Blitz rope you in on his schemes from time to time? And he has pranked Elusive a couple of times ?"

"Yeah, but he never does include me in those anymore. Because Lucy always get suspicious and always manage to make me spill the beans. What can ah say? Ah hate to lie."

"Well, then you are going to like this. You are going to fool Elusive with the absolute truth!"

Applejack stared at Dusk. "You can't fool anyone with the truth."

In that moment, Barbara arrived with the coffee. "Here you go... black and hot as usual. Milk for you and black for Dusk."

Dusk grabbed the cup with his magic and took a sip. "Thanks Barb. I needed that. And yes you can. Because he can only expose you if you try to hide something. But what you shall do is to just open his drawers, look through his stuff, walk in to his study... act suspicious, but that’s all you do. And so, when he asks what you're doing you can honestly say 'nothing'. You see? You'll decieve him with the absolute truth."

Applejack looked thoughtful. "Hmm... yeah, ah like the idea of that... and that’s something ah definitely can do. But ah dunno... will it work?"

Here, Barbara spoke. "Totally. It works on Dusk. Two weeks ago he asked me If I took ten bits from his wallet."

"Yes, and you said you didn’t. "

"And it was true. Because I didn’t take ten bits. I took twenty."

"Yes! So you see, Applejack! To lie with the truth will work perfectly! Because... wait a moment, BARBARA!"

But the young dragoness was already out the door. Dusk sighed, and shrugged his shoulders. "I'll deal with her later. Still, It will work. Because if you can make Elusive to believe that you are planning something..."

"...Yeah... He gets suspicious if ah so much as touched the door to his study... so if ah just go around and... He will go out of his mind! And ah don’t have to say one dishonest word!"

"Well, Maybe one or two. He knows you as a bad liar, so throw in one ore two small ones, that he will easily see through. "

"Ah, yeah! And then he will be so smug and full of his own smartness that he won't believe me when ah tell the honest truth. Dusk, this is..."

***

present

"...A masterpiece. It's brilliant. It has 'Dusk Shine' written all over it. 'I just read it in a book and followed the instructions'. And it worked. It worked..."

Elusive stared blankly at the teacup. He was angry at Applejack, yes. But to be honest... He had fooled himself the most. Sure, Applejack did set him up but... most of it was himself being so sure to outsmart his coltfriend. Perhaps Applejack was a simple soul at times, but he wasn't dumb. And the worst part..

"Sorry for doing this but... Now we're even."

...He was always the bigger pony. Always the first to apologize. Even if he had the right to get even... he still felt bad. And he still apologized. Because that was who he was. Honest. And the best pony anyone could find.

"Yes we are. Applejack? "

"Yeah?"

"Come here."

Applejack laid down on the bed next to his coltfriend, spooned him, and put his arms around him. Elusive sighed. He burrowed himself closer to Applejack and he felt his coltfriend burrying his muzzle in his mane.
The best part of a relationship. Cuddling.

"Applejack?"

"Uhu?"

" I'm sorry if I treat you like you’re dumb at times. You are smarter than ponies credit you for."

Applejack began to stroke Elusive mane. "Nah. Ah ain't smart. Not like yer and Dusk."

"But you are! Most ponies would have tried to do something themselves. They think they're better than they are. You? You recognized you limits and took help from a friend. That’s smart. I'm really lucky to have you." Elusive turned his head around and gave Applejack a kiss. A long kiss, where their tongues met and danced an intricate and sensualism dance. He felt Applejack pulling him closer. He felt every muscle in his coltfriends strong embrace. He was perfectly safe, and happy.

"Applejack?"

"Yeah?"

"I love you."

"Ah love yer to, babe."

"And you are sleeping on the couch tonight."

"...Horseapples."

Author's Note

No, this is not the end. But can you imagine Elusive being like, 'oh, you just made a fool out of me. Lets fuck!' ?

Me neither.

Act 3

Applejack was slightly dissapointed, but in all honesty he couldn't really blame Elusive. It was a rather nasty prank after all, and even though his intention was to make Elusive feel as bad as he did... He still felt ad about the outcome. And so, he started to make his way out of the bed, when he felt a hand on his thigh. He turned his head with a surpriced look. "Lucy?"

His coltfriend looked away, and said, with a very timid voice that was very un-elusive: "You don't have to rush down to bed, do you? Can't... you just stay here and keep me warm? Just for a while?"

Applejack yawned, but smiled. "Sure, Lucy. But yer might have to wake me up when yer think yer about to fall asleep so ah can go and sleep on the couch." Applejack began to lay down, but...

"Handsome? Can you please... you have to much clothes on. Take them off, will you?"

Applejack looked at Elusive, then shrugged his shoulders, and began to undress. Elusive's eyes never left him for a single moment. He didn't even blink. "Handsome? Can you... take off your pants a bit more... sexy? For me? Please?"

Applejack gave Elusive a warm smile. "Sure. Anything for yer pleasure, babe." He turned around, presenting his back to Elusive, and then he slowly unbottoned his pants, first in the front and then in the back over the tail-entrance. And then he slowly began to take them off, slowly and teasing. He even bent slightly over and raised his tail. Applejack was built as a brick house, Blitz used to say, but there was one place where the muscles did share their space with a healthy amount of flesh. He had, for a stallion, a rather large butt. It never caused him any troubles before, and normaly he didn't care about it, but there was one thing. Ever since he came out, other stallions obsessed over it. Elusive practically worshipped his ass sometimes, and he wasn't the only one. Vinyl Scratch, Bubbles brother Grindstone, Thorn Rose, Cherry Lee... Heck, even Blitz had been caught oglin' him a couple of times.

And of cource, Elusive. As the pants hit the floor, Applejack leaned forward with one knee slightly bent and one hand on his butt. He didn't turn around to look at Elusive. "Like my goods, Lucy? Wanna have a feel later?" Then he turned around, lay down on the bed and spooned Elusive. He lay his arms around him and took a little nibble on his ear. Elusive let out a gasp. "Comfortable enough to sleep, Lucy? Dream of me and what we will do tomorrow..." He whispered in his coltfriends ear. He wasn’t sure what Elusive wanted, but he'd never force himself on him. Besides, cuddling was nice to, and it was late. But perhaps Elusive wanted something more, at least it seemed so when he spoke.

"No..." Elusive mumbled. "Can't you... lay on top of me? I want you closer. I want to see your face."

Applejack let go of Elusive and rolled over so the later could lay down on his back. He also took of his pajama jacket. "Come here, handsome. I want to feel your fur against mine."

Applejack smiled, and lay down on him. He put his arms behind Elusive's head, as Elusive knitted his hands together behind Applejacks back. They looked each other in the eyes. Elusive's slightly teasing look he always wore was gone and the blue eyes were tired, but still filled with happiness. Applejack tried to look the same way, and then he closed his eyes, and kissed him.

For a long time, they didn’t move. Then Elusive slightly opened his mouth to let Applejacks tongue in. Applejack did the same. Then he began to play with Elusive's mane. Elusive's hands began to find their way down Applejacks back and down to his butt. One hand stayed on his buttcheeks, softly caressing his rear with the occacional groping, while the other was more adventurous and explored it’s way down his thighs, in between the cheeks dangerously close to his anus, once or twice letting it’s teasing fingers play around his tail base, even pulling it slighty at times.

Applejack felt his dick getting harder with every second, and he began to grind himself against Elusive. Dry humping was considered more of a teenage thing, but Applejack actually enjoyed it. Once or twice (and with a generous amount of lubricant ) he and Elusiveperformed a whole act of love making ending with orgasm in this way. There was no lube involved this time, and sweat didn’t do a good job as a replacement. But Elusives silk pajama pants did the trick instead. Soft, lean, warm and almost hugging his dick in a way Applejack hadn't felt before. He felt the tension build inside of him, and when Elusive finally put his daring finger inside his Asshole, Applejack was close to burst.

"AH!"

Elusive pulled his finger halfway out and said teasing: "What's wrong? Was I too fast?"

Applejack shook his head. "No, Babe. It's just... it's just...ahm close. It felt so damn good."

Elusive smirked. "So... Dryhumping my pants is what gets you off these days? Oh dear, and here I thought you only wanted me for my body when in fact it was my clothes you were after..."

Applejack blushed and began to stammer. "N-no... No, Lucy. Yer know ah love yer... y-yer know..."

Elusive silenced him with a kiss. "I know, handsome. I'm just kidding."

"Hmpf... well, yer almost killing the mood right noooh-oh-oow!"

Elusive put another finger into Applejacks ass and began to slide them in and out. "Really now? Is this a moodkiller to?" Applejack violently shook his head as he tried to think of hoofball, rainy Sundays and Grandpa's nasty smelling feet after a day on the field. Nothing worked. "Looks like you like it, handsome."

"Mhmmm..."

"Wanna cum?"

"...Yeah... but... well, Lucy...NNNNGGGHHH!"

Elusive smiled. "Then whats stopping you?" He pulled Applejacks head down and whispered in his ear. "Cum on me. I what your cum on my fur. And if your worried about my pants... I think some pony I know once said 'it’s only to wash them."

Then Elusive removed his hand from Applejacks butt, pushed it down his pants and grabbed Applejacks dick through the fabric. Applejack grunted. Elusive whispered once again. "Fuck me, Applejack. Fuck me like a real earth pony stallion takes his mate. Show me no mercy."

Applejack almost lost it at Elusives words, but he managed to regain focus. And then he began..He put all his strength behind every move, he thrusted so hard Elusive almost lost his grip a couple of times. Applejack was getting closer and closer. The fingers in his ass felt good. The fabric was so soft, Elusives hands was so warm and the grip was so tight...

It was impossible to hold back, as impossible as it was to stop a volcano from erupting. Elusive, however did nothing of that sort. Instead he began to jerk Applejacks cock, matching his hands movements with the final powerful thrusts from his coltfriend. And as a final act of pushing him over the edge, he grabbed Applejacks tail, and pulled. Applejack didn't say anything, it was only "hnngh" or "Ah!" or some other kind of grunt as he emptied his load in Elusives grip. He came so hard that Elusive could se his torso shale with every wave of pleasure shooting out from his dick. Most of it was caught by the fabric, but a few drops found their way to Elusives bare stomach. And even though the cum ceased to flow, Applejacks dick and lower body was still jerking from the orgasm. But as Applejack felt the last waves fade away, he slowly sank down over Elusive and uttered one single word. "Damn".

They lay there for a while, Applejack panting and Elusive stroking his back with soft motions. Once or twice he kissed him on his cheeks.

"I take it you enjoyed yourself, handsome."

"Lucy... babe, that was... incredible "

"It was. It was far more enjoyable than I expected. When you got it on for real there... You’re really hot when your turned on, handsome." Then he yawned.

"Tired"?

"Quite a bit, yes."

Then, something struck Applejack. "Lucy, did... did yer come yerself?" Elusive shook his head.

"Well... almost, handsome. Almost. If my right hand had been in my trousers as well, I probably would. But I prefered to pull your tail. More 'earthpony-wayish', don’t you think?"

"Oh. Oh yeah. Yeah. Sure. But... Now ah feel kinda bad."

Elusive lifted an eyebrow. "For me not cumming? Handsome... we agreed on this long time ago. It's ok. Besides..." He yawned again "I'm to tired to move a muscle. I'm even too tired to be upset over how messy the sheets are."

"Heh. But yer know what? Ah have an idea. Yer don't have do move a muscle." Elusive mentioning the 'earth - pony way' had given Applejack an idea. Sure, it was in the middle of the night, but Elusive had given him something special. Applejack wanted to do the same and this was and idea he had for a while. "Lucy. Yer just lay still, alright? Let me take them pants off."

Elusive did as he was told, curious of what Applejack had in mind. Applejack threw the pants in the wash in and climbed back on the bed, straddling Elusive in the reverse cowpony position. "Now, let me just..." He lifted up his tail and began to feel his way around his back, trying to get a hold on Elusives dick. When he found it, he apparently tried to steer it up against his asshole, and Elusive let out a protest. "Now, darling, I know the earth pony way means 'rough' but going up the butt without lube? Perhaps YOU like that feeling, but I don’t and especially not in that region. My foreskin is sensitive."

Applejack gave Elusive a reassuring smile. "Don't ya worry, Lucy. We ain't going that way. Ahm just going to. .. Applejack lifted himself slightly and spread his butt cheeks with his other hand. And then Elusive found his member stuck between the soft but still firm cheeks of Applejacks but. It was warm, and sweaty, and it felt strange. But not bad. No, not bad at all. Applejack looked at him over his shoulder.
"Ah hope yer ready, Lucy... cause this rodeo is about to get started."

And with those words, Applejack sank down and began to ride Elusive. The sensation was instant. And Elusive felt that... this was not going to last long. He was already close, thanks to the previous session, and the new sensation of his own member being squeezed between two tight buttocks... And tonaddbtobthat, seeing Applejacks butt go up and down, creating an off-beat pattern with his tail and mane... not to mention the slapping when skin met skin... Elusive came without any other warning to his lover but a "Ah! APPLEJACK! " And with three heavy shots, he soaked down Applejacks mane (and a bit of his tail and back) with his cum.

He wanted to say something, show some kind of reaction. But Elusive was exhausted, and the only thing he could pull off as he felt himself dozing of was a wide grin. His eyelids where so heavy it was impossible tonstay awake. He didn’t react when a blanket was pulled over him. He didn't react when a heavy, yellow-furred arm was put around him. And he didn't send Applejack down the stairs as he rightfully should sleep on the couch and be ashamed. Because he was already asleep.

Author's Note

But after every night comes morning...