Conversion Bureau: Unlucky Day

Fluttershy kept her eyes wide open, intensifying her Stare as she hovered towards the behemoth.

"We come here, trying to help you, and you repay us by slaughtering the mares and stallions that are risking their lives to bring peace!? I don't think so, mister!" she emphasized by jutting forward.

What happened next would have left those in Hell shocked, made monsters sick, and envy a perpetual nightmare.

Jason Voorhees retreated from the butter-yellow pegasus.

His steps were shaky and his hands were trembling in shock as his cold eyes gazed into the overwhelming abyss. It was a look unlike anything he had encountered before. This one felt as commanding as it did familiar, and it was that familiarity that made the killer falter. Only in his memories did a look barely reminiscent of this one echoed, haunting him. Scolding him. Judging him.

"We only wanted to help make your world better! You were all going to kill each other! And now you think you can get away with killing my friends!? Unacceptable!" Fluttershy emphasized with a stomp of her hoof.

The moment the hoof made contact with the ground, Jason tumbled backwards and started to crawl away from her, tears streaking down his faded mask.

Rarity and Applejack took the opportunity Fluttershy was providing to collect Twilight. The moment Rarity lifted Twilight from the asphalt, however, the alicorn passed out. Applejack braced herself as she carried the unconscious princess and began to trot away alongside Rarity. Both of them turned to see Fluttershy advancing on the monstrous Human.

Jason Voorhees continued to crawl backwards from the pegasus until his back hit a brick wall. Unable to summon enough strength to smash through it or the willpower to fight back, he watched in horror as Fluttershy advanced upon him. Seeing her rear back a front hoof, Jason braced for whatever was about to come his way.

What he did not expect, however, was for the pegasus to wrap its arm around his side in an attempt to hug him.

Fluttershy brought her other hoof up to wipe the tears off of Jason's mask as she smiled up to him.

"There there, it's going to be alright," she cooed.

The pegasus raised her hoof further up to pet Jason's head to calm him down.

"You were just unlucky in life. Nopony blames you for what happened. You're only Human."

The relenting authority that her Stare once had was gone, replaced by a tone far more familiar to Jason.

It was the voice of a mother.

"It's going to be okay now, I pro- HRGK!" Fluttershy choked out as a hand clamped onto her throat.

"Fluttershy!" Rarity cried out as she witnessed the Human strangle the pegasus.

Jason held her out as he stood back up, staring down into her eyes with his own fury.

No one could replace his true mother. He had been betrayed before, and he won't fall for it again.

Fluttershy tried to reassert herself through her stare, but all she saw was pure hatred and the inevitability of death.

Her will crushed by the glare of Jason, she put up no resistance to his actions. Without breaking eye contact, Jason shifted the pegasus in his grip so that either of his thumbs were beside her eye sockets.

"Fluttershy, get out of there!" Applejack screamed as both her and Rarity debated on helping her or running away.

Jason slowly dragged his thumbs across Fluttershy's eyes until they were centered in each of her pupils. Over the course of what felt like an eternity, he pushed inwards. Fluttershy shrieked in pain as Jason's thumbs ruptured through her eyes and dug deeper into her skull without resistance. She began to flail in his grip, only being held up by her skull as she wildly kicked with her hind legs, her wings flapping without any intended direction. After agonizing seconds, the grip on Fluttershy's skull began to intensify, feeling small bits of her head already starting to give way.

In a single motion, Jason ended her suffering.

Fluttershy's entire head, from her eye sockets to her temples, cracked and caved inwards as her entire body went stiff. Bits of her skull and greymatter dripped to the dirt below as her remains went limp.

Jason tossed her corpse to the ground without ceremony and began his advance on the remaining ponies.