First Time
I took Fluttershy home. Avoiding Rainbow Dash was the goal, or at least, one of them.
Me and Fluttershy had spent some of the afternoon near the forest, enjoying a peaceful picnic, but honestly, the whole time I was thinking of things that were much less innocent. She had no idea what, until the very end when I’d pushed her back on the blanket, our lips locked and tongues flickering in and out of each other’s mouths. It was then when we were so rudely interrupted by Rainbow that we decided to take our “picnic” home.
Although Fluttershy had seemed open to the idea of sexuality when she finally understood what was about to happen, I still couldn’t help but notice the minute uncertainty in her actions and words. Like she wanted to, but was unsure if she was ready. And it turns out that I was right.
When we got to her cabin, we stuck all the picnic stuff, including our saddlebags, in the kitchen. After a few exchanged words, I convinced her to head upstairs with me, without ever actually saying what we were about to do, though I’m positive she knew, as the expression of nervousness on her face conveyed.
The romance of the moment was not lost, and her nervousness only made me feel more confident, so I felt obligated to be in control. However, I hadn’t told her yet that we had more in common than she probably thought.
You see, what I hadn't told her was that she wasn’t the only virgin, and I suspected she'd be quite surprised when I told her. Also, I shared with her the anxiety that she was clearly experiencing.
We walked into the bedroom, her first, and I closed the door behind us. Angel was downstairs, and I didn’t want him walking in on anything. I turned to Fluttershy, who’d hopped up on the bed, sitting on the edge near her pillow, glancing around uneasily, her eyes darting back and forth. She was acting the way I’d expected, and I had a plan to counter it, but I was unsure as to whether it would help.
I went over and sat beside her, taking her hoof in mine and smiling benignly. “You know, you’re not the only one nervous as hell right now. I mean, I can say the same thing about myself.”
She seemed to perk up a bit, subtle, but just enough for me to have noticed. “Really?”
I nodded, placing her hoof on my chest, over my heart. My heart was racing a hundred miles an hour, and feeling her hoof on my chest made it nearly pound its way out.
She looked over at me, into my eyes. I saw the concern replaced with amusement and relief. “Oh…my. You are nervous…” She took a deep breath. “Are you sure you want to do this…? I mean, w-we don’t have to…not saying I don’t want to, but I’m just…afraid to mess up…I’ve never done this before.”
I turned my body toward her, resting a hoof on her thigh and the other on her forearm. “Flutters, I’m a virgin too. You and I are both new to this.”
She didn’t seem to mind me putting my hoof where I’d placed it, but she definitely looked down at it. Her gaze returned to my face, and she was trying hard to smile. “Wow…I had no idea…” She kept her eyes locked with mine, and I felt an overwhelming sense of attraction, I could not hold back any further. I leaned forward, placing my lips on hers.
At first, she did not react, but soon she was tenderly kissing me back. We fell back, with me on top, and she seemed to grow a little more comfortable with this whole situation. I let my hooves run up and down the soft coat of her sides, then I ran them through the feathers of her wings, caressing them. She let out a low-pitched moan and I pulled back to see her face.
“W-why’d you stop?” She stammered.
I scratched the back of my head. “I-I thought I hurt you. But I guess that wasn’t the case…”
Surprisingly, she pulled me back down, and we resumed. I deepened the kiss, and her response was promising. She’d wrapped her hind legs around me. I feel the warmth of her body, and it was more than I could bear…
I broke off the kiss, running my lips down her cheek and onto her neck. I nibbled at her gently, and heard her moan again, but this time it was a deeper, more provocative noise. It sent a chill up my spine and I thought to myself, this is really about to happen…I can’t believe that this is really about to happen…
She placed a hoof on the back of my neck, applying a gentle pressure that encouraged my nibbling, which I hesitantly moved further down her body, now on her chest. Her body writhed slightly, and I assumed that I was doing well.
After I gave her face a quick glance, seeing her eyes were shut tight, a slight smile on her face, I continued my teasing, moving down to her abdomen. She placed her other hoof on my head, letting out another groan. I was really getting turned on now, and I could feel myself growing harder with each of her deep, sighing breaths.
I ran my lips down even further, just inches from her warm inviting marehood. The grip she had on my neck had tightened, and I assumed this meant she knew what I was about to do next. I was hesitant, not sure if I could bring myself to do something I’d never done before, something I’d never been given the opportunity to do before. After I considered this, I told myself that I shouldn’t pass up an opportunity that I may never get again.
I allowed myself to venture down south one last time, my lips making contact with her warm, wet slit.
A gasp escaped her lips and she tensed up. I anticipated this, and continued. She tasted sweet, nothing like I imagined. I placed a hoof on each of her legs and pushed them apart to get a better access. I moved down, so my lower body was off the bed, my legs on the floor, and my upper body leaning over her crotch. She was writhing with pleasure as I pushed my tongue inside her, feeling her insides…
I found her bud, and rolled my tongue over it in circles, causing her to tense up even more so. I felt resistance from her legs, like she was trying to close them. I was concerned that I might be doing something wrong, so I stopped. "Are you okay? " I asked, worried.
She kept her eyes closed and gave me a very slight nod.
Seeing her nod, I continued. I felt myself hard as rock, throbbing. I wanted her, but I wanted to finish this first, and so I chose to keep up with my oral action.
She moaned louder, and it sounded like my name was embedded within that moan, only enticing me to continue my pleasuring of her sweet spot. I kept at it, going faster and faster, feeling her squirm, listening to her cries and groans. Finally, she climaxed, and the bed was suddenly much wetter.
I climbed back up onto her, my face inches from hers. She had her eyes still closed, panting rapidly. Moments later, they were open, and she was grinning amorously up at me.
“T-that was…incredible…I n-never knew that this…felt s-so good…” she barely whispered. I could see the lust growing in her eyes, which actually surprised me. She was getting into this, and so was I. I no longer had any doubts or worries. My confidence was built up just because of the look in her eyes.
I leaned down and whispered erotically in her ear, “Then let’s move on to the next part…”
She knew exactly what I meant as I lifted my waist a little to find my way in. She must have had something else in mind, as I felt her hoof touch me, and she soon began running it up and down my length.
“Oh, god Fluttershy…”
She smiled mischievously and wrapped her hoof around it now, rubbing harder, faster. I let out a gasp and lowered my head to kiss her. I made out with her while she jerked me off. I was fighting the imminent orgasm, but it was futile. Within moments, I blew my load all over her stomach, yelling out her name several times as I felt the waves of ecstasy ripple through my body.
She kissed me passionately, her tongue rolling over mine. She pulled away and asked, “Did I do it right?”
I laughed quietly. “Yeah…you did.” I leaned down and pecked her lips. “But we aren’t done.”
Her coquettish smile and twinkle in her eye said that she agreed.
I once again lifted my lower body, but this time, Fluttershy guided me inside her. As I lowered myself, I felt my hardness slip inside her. She was tight, tight enough that I almost couldn’t fit in. She moaned as inch after inch found its way into her sweet wetness. I kept my eyes locked on hers, and she with mine. Her mouth opened as I took her virginity and she let out an almost silent, “Ouch…”
“It's okay, sweetie. Are you okay? Do you want me to stop?" I asked soothingly. I knew what had just happened, and I also knew that sometimes it hurt, so I wanted to be sure we could keep going, and that she was alright.
Her eyes never left mine, the expression of pain fading away as she smiled up at me. "I'm f-fine..."
I went on, and I couldn’t help but groan with pleasure. She was tight, but wet enough from earlier that I could make it in. “Guess what? We aren’t virgins anymore…” I whispered huskily in her ear. She didn’t say a word, just smiled up at me.
I lifted my rump up a little, pushing myself deeper into her opening and lifting again, and she once again closed her eyes, overcome with pleasure. I lowered myself, and listened to her whimper. I could not believe we were actually doing this. Knowing how shy and timid she was, seeing her like this, doing this with her didn’t seem real. But it was.
She put her hooves on my shoulders, gripping them tightly as I pumped away inside her, her whimpering growing to full out moaning. “…Emerald…oh…” I established a rhythm and kept to it, but as her cries filled my ears, I wanted more.
I increased pace, listening to her get louder, feeling the sweat building on my body. “Yeah, girl…” I purred, closing my eyes for second to take in what was happening. Her hooves moved to my sides, where she then let them fall to her own, unable to hold them up anymore.
Feeling her around my cock was pushing me to the limit. I fought hard not to cum inside her so soon, but seeing her with her mouth agape, hearing her moaning my name, and feeling her silky insides rubbing against my pole was too much. She climaxed the same time I did, heightening the euphoria that we were both feeling. Her tunnel squeezed and pulsed as I emptied myself into her, and we called out each other’s names.
I finally glanced down to see her half-lidded gaze watching me. She had the most enticing grin on her face, one that I never pictured her wearing. She was gasping for breath, and so was I. I could feel her hot breath on my face, and I kissed her gently, with more passion than I ever knew existed before.
This girl rocked my world.
“I…I really liked this…” She murmured, still out of breath.
I fell on my side beside her, wrapping my hooves around her, feeling her chest rise and fall in sync with my own. “Yeah…I loved this…it was…amazing…”
Her eyes searched mine, trying to see if I was being honest. I guess she believed me, because she then joined me in a tight embrace that felt different than the ones we’d had before this. This one felt more emotional. It felt like she was more attached to me than ever. All I could think was, I’m never gonna leave her…
I felt the wetness from our love-making all over the bed and on our bodies, so I rolled off the bed, picking her up and cradling her like a baby, while she threw her arms around my neck, and after a quick kiss and an “I love you”, I took her to the bathroom to clean up.
