Lyra Thinks Bon Bon Is a Human

by Lyrafan38

Rating: everyone
Tags: Bon-Bon, Human, Sad, Lyra, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark
Length: 2125

Lyra thinks her roommate is one of the creatures from folklore. But is she?

Lyra thinks there's something wrong with Bon Bon.
Not in the caring housemate kind of wrong, but the "you are a human" wrong.
Lyra Heartstrings thinks that Bon Bon is a human and sets out to prove it.
------
Told first person from Bon Bon's P.O.V.

Published 2015-06-03 21:00:02 UTC
Last updated 2015-07-02 22:59:25 UTC

Investigation - Day 1 Part 1

You ever have those days where you feel that somepony is out to get you if you make one wrong move?

Thanks to Lyra, that has become my second nature. The unicorn refused to give up her mythical "hoo-mens" research on almost every pony in Equestria and had recently decided that she might have missed an easy target all along. Me.

I told her that she must be crazy. I've been an earth pony all my life. My name is Bon Bon.

And I think Lyra believes that I must be one of the mythical folkloric creatures who, according to her, once populated Equestria.

Much like she was right now.

"Seriously, have you ever thought about what humans are like, Bon Bon?" she asked, going off on another tangent of what they were supposed to be like. "Creatures that are real! With hands and everything!"

I rolled my eyes. "Listen, Lyra. How does this even relate to anything about me?"

"Oh, ye of little faith. It's because you must be a human, Bon Bon!"

My mouth dropped wide open. Was she serious? I usually had to drag her plot all the way out of the many embarrassing situations she got herself into, but this was somewhat new. "S-seriously, Lyra? You think I'm a creature from myths? Are you crazy? Have you taken your medication this morning?"

Lyra smiled smugly. "I know it's true. Now tell me. What was life on Earth like? Was it anything like I've read in the books? Or is it entirely different? Ooh, and who were you?" She started trotting towards me, firing off questions at a rate of about a thousand or so (give or take a few) a minute about my supposed life in a land from a storybook.

"LYRA!" I exclaimed, almost throwing the tray of desserts I had made into her face. "I am not a mythical creature. You know me. I'm Bon Bon. And I always will be. Not some fanciful creature that came out of somepony's mind to explain Equestrian history!"

She froze in her tracks. "Denying it, are we?"

"I'm not denying anything! I've been a pony all my life. We met when we were little fillies!"

"So......" Lyra let the word drag out from a very long and uncomfortable time.

"So I am not one of those creatures!" I finished for her.

It took nearly all my self control to not just reach out and slap her in the face until her normal senses came around. She had been advancing this theory on me for Celestia knows how long about a couple of times a day. And every time I denied it.

I was an earth pony that they called Bon Bon. I was born in Ponyville. Nothing could change those two facts no matter how much Lyra thought I just fabricated it out of thin air.

She believed that Bon Bon was a cover name for the 'true me' and got the mayor to falsify my own birth certificate out of nowhere.

And that was only just the tip of the iceberg.

Lately, she had even watched me very carefully (and yet always from the distance) doing my daily jobs around our house. She thinks that someday she'll see me slip up my 'pony masquerade' and revert back to my so-called 'human ways'.

Yeah, by this point I'm beginning to think that all this time I have been living with an insane unicorn known as Lyra Heartstrings. Celestia help me.

"Bon Bon......" Lyra deadpanned, inserting herself almost directly into my face. "I know you're truly a human....."

I set down the tray of desserts and raised a hoof to my forehead to massage the headache I was currently experiencing. "No, I'm not. You're getting silly, Lyra. I have never even been anywhere near this mythical creatures. So what makes you wholeheartedly believe that I must be one?"

"Scientific evidence!" she exclaimed in a voice that startled me and caused me to jump a few feet in the air. "I may not have it all together yet, but when I do, you won't be Bon Bon any longer. I'll see that you are a human!"

With that, she raced out the door (which she left wide open) on her way to the Golden Oaks Library. At least that's what I assumed. She probably was going to try to convince Twilight about me being an out-of-this-world creature from the far distant past.

With a sigh, I closed the door and slumped down into the nearest chair I could find. I needed a recap of what had just happened.

Lyra once again believed I was a mythical being summed it up pretty nicely.

I'll just keep telling her. My name is Bon Bon. We've known each other since fillyhood. I was born and raised in this town of Ponyville. And I had all the evidence I needed to prove my point. There's no way in Equestria that I am a.....human....... My thoughts began to wander viewing this from Lyra's perspective. Maybe I am..... What if I am a human? What if someday, she's going to be right in her theory?

I got up off the chair and trotted over towards the nearest mirror we had in our house. The same reflection looked back at me. One earth pony with a navy and pink mane and tail with my own special cutie mark that denoted my talent with candies. This reflection was not what Lyra kept saying that humans were like at all. This is the sight I had gotten used to all my life. I was nothing more than a simple earth pony. I couldn't stand up on my two hind hooves and walk around like Lyra set I could in my previous life.

What if.......What if......I am a human......?

Author's Note

This story is based on a dream I had. It went pretty similar to this in the sense that Lyra suspects her roommate Bon Bon of being one of the mythical creatures of Equestrian folklore and Bon Bon denied it. However, I woke up before I wanted to see if Bon Bon truly was a human.

Investigation - Day 1 Part 2

Why did Lyra have to say that? I thought to myself. I can't truly be a mythical creature.

I raised a hoof to my face as if to prove that fact. Surely, there was no truth in Lyra was saying. This was just another silly fantasy of hers.

At least, that's what I kept telling myself.

The truth is that Lyra's words had implanted themselves into my mind, making me question my existence. I silently cursed Celestia's name for giving them residency in my subconscious.

It's been roughly about an hour or two since Lyra rushed off to the library in order to 'make me remember my past' as one passing pony called it when I stepped outside for some fresh air to clear my head from her labeling me as a human.

I just don't understand it. Why, out of all the ponies in Equestria, would Lyra accuse me of being a creature from folklore? Has she run out of victims and accusations by this point?

I heard the door slam with such a force that I'm not ashamed to admit that caused me to jump a few feet in the air like a nervous cat. However, unlike the cat, my landing was not graceful by any standards. I landed with a small thud on the floor, knowing full well that would hurt tomorrow morning.

The door slam meant only one thing. Lyra was home with her so-called 'evidence.' Most likely she had bribed Twilight to create random shreds of things that were supposed to trigger flashbacks in ponies' minds. And no one was safe from these. I still remember Scootaloo almost bawling her eyes out when Lyra scared the living nightmare out of the filly.

"Bon Bon! I'm back!" Lyra exclaimed.

I nervously cast a glance behind me, somewhat afraid as to what she had supposedly found to recreate an event that never happened.

"Bon Bon? Are you okay?" she asked, a frown and a concerned look very evident on her face.

"I'm fine." I nervously answered, rubbing one of my forelegs with the other one. I must have not given that answer cheerily enough because Lyra trotted over to me in an attempt to make me feel better.

"It......It's just that what you said....." I mumbled into the air.

"You mean about you being a human?"

"Even though I'm not one of them.....yeah......" I sighed.

Lyra began to slightly give me a hug, although it was kind of tight since we both were currently standing up on all four hooves. "Look, why don't we do this a little bit at a time? Surely then it will help you remember it all."

I must have cast her a weird look because the next thing she did was distance herself away from me. "Calm down there, Bon Bon." she said, firing up her horn to remove her saddlebags. "Now, you're freaking me out."

"S....sorry."

Funny........Lyra kind of reminds me of my mom. Crazy one minute and caring the next. It's like when she used to hold me close when I was a little girl....foal.

I mentally did a double take. Did I just say girl? That wasn't even a term that I had heard of in the Equestrian language. Surely, I had just made that up. Yeah, that was it! It was just a word invented for the occasion.

Seriously, though. Has my mind gone flat out crazy?! Surely it has. I was born as a filly. Not that girl thing.

"You look like you need some sleep or something, Bon Bon." Lyra said. "I may have accidentally fired your brain into overdrive with what I was saying. You go take a nap and then we can work on recovering your memories to unveil the you that you were."

"I-I'm perfectly fine." I stammered.

The frown was back on her face. "Uh....no you're not."

"I need to go ask Twilight about this. Like now." I said, beginning to trot towards the door.

However, I ended up trotting into a wall of mint green. It took me a minute or two to recognize that I had just bumped into Lyra who must have been quicker than me to the door.

The next thing I knew was that I was being lifted off the ground in a golden magical aura of Lyra's doing. "This is going to be the best for you at the moment. We can't work with a scrambled brain at all. Totally inaccurate results could come flying out at you."

"Lyra.....I'm perfectly fine. I am no human and I don't need to go to bed."

I don't think she heard me as my eyelids grew somewhat heavy and I apparently fell asleep. The last thing I heard was her saying "Sweet dreams, Bon Bon."

When I awoke from sleep, I knew right off the bat that this wasn't our house. Not unless the house was a swirling mass of an endless void or something. Purple smoke was as far as I could see.

"Hello?" I called out, getting no answer. There didn't seem to be any other pony anyway in the near vicinity.

Somewhat unsteadily, I began trotting off into what I assumed was north. It was a little hard to tell since I wasn't the greatest at directions.

After a few minutes/hours/some measure of time, I began to realize that I was somehow exploring my dreams. Did Luna do this?

I kept looking around for her to explain this, but there was no sign of the alicorn anywhere in this dreamscape.

Soon, I found something else (I would say somepony, but the creature looked nothing like a pony. It looked like some horrendous creature that sauntered out of the Everfree.) and, out of curiosity, I trotted over to it.

This thing must have heard me coming becuase it suddenly came rushing out at me as fast as its legs would carry it. I attempted to turn around and gallop like my hooves were on fire, but for some odd reason, I was rooted to the spot.

That creature crossed the distance between us in a freakishly short amount of time and embraced me in a tight hug. It was so tight that I thought it was choking me.

Tears fell from this thing's eyes and landed on my fur as it slowly stroked my mane. I managed to hear one sentence being repeated over and over again. "Oh, my dear, sweet Brianna. How I missed you so."