Cheese Pie

by Flutterbat276

Rating: everyone
Tags: Alternate Universe, Romance
Length: 1070

Lovestruck party ponies :3

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2015-06-16 05:39:44 UTC

Love at Second Sight

Hello...I'm Cheese Sandwich. I'm a party pony who throws parties across Equestria! (Cheesy, enough of that introduction stuff and get on with the story already!) Alright alright! Jeez calm down Pinkie!

You have to excuse her. We only have one room where we can record this. Anyways, this is our story as a couple!

I decided to come back to Ponyville and visit my friends there, and my soon to be wife, partner, girlfriend, etcetera. I found that the library was blown to bits. I saw a castle not to far away, and I seemed drawn to it. I could sense a party in there. Ponies all around looked at me as I trotted along in my sombrero and rug-like jacket. Boneless two hopped and bounced about on my back. One pony, Ditzy Doo I believe, stopped me.

"Excuse me mister, but I really enjoyed yours and Pinkie's party for Rainbow Dash! I really liked the part where, um, uh..,where you..." She stopped talking tapped her muzzle trying to remember. A stallion, I suppose her boy friend, came in. The accent was a bit familiar then I remembered it was British. So sophisticated sounding, and with my more Mexican approach, we had quite a multicultural thing going.

(Ow Pinkie! Jeez! Don't punch me!)

(Sorry your just getting boring!)

(Alright)

Anyways, the three of us held a small conversation in the street and after what seemed like ten or fifteen minutes, we parted ways. The stallion, who I had found out to be named Doctor, had asked if I could throw a surprise party for Ditzy. I nodded and waved goodbye. As I kept trotting towards the castle I said to myself, "What a nice couple. They seem pretty happy!"

I made it to the castle and I was a bit hesitant to enter. I knocked and heard a familiar voice say, "Come in!"

I opened the large crystal door and entered. The pony who had told me to come in was Twilight.

"Oh, hello Cheese. What brings you here?" she asked, levitating a book and quill. I was still looking around, taking in the scene around me when she repeated herself.

"Oh, yes. I just wanted to say hi. Where's the other girls?" Just then I heard a familiar sounding explosion come from the other room, followed by a rain of a few streamers and confetti. "Nevermind. I think I found one."

I trotted into the newly confettied room and was greeted by none other than Pinkie Pie herself. She was surprised to see me and we chatted for a bit. Rainbow came in a few moments later saying, "Hey Cheese. I loved the party you guys threw for me a while back! Best birthaversary I've ever had!"

Pinkie and I said, "Thanks!" in perfect unison.

It was this moment where I looked into her eyes, her heartwarming smiling filling me with a new feeling that I had never felt before in my life! I felt like I was happier than I'd ever been just sitting next to her. I didn't know how else to describe it but love! That's it, I was in love! The way she smiled, her confetti filled mane, her sea blue eyes, and her adorable laugh all made my heart soar away.

Rainbow stared at me and so did Pinkie. They looked at me funny, then I realized I was staring. I felt embarrassed at that moment. I knew one thing for certain, though. I knew that no matter what, I'll do my best to make her happy!

Familiar New Surroundings

I had began to consider moving to Ponyville. I had the bits to make the move. After a few weeks of debate, I packed my things and bought a new house in Ponyville. It was relatively close to the castle, so I could visit Pinkie whenever I liked. It was nice being so close to her, in case she needed me. I settled in, made acquaintances with my neighbors, and got to know my way around town. I was trotting along one day and found that grey mare again with the stallion. I trotted over and said hello. Derpy and Doc were headed to Sugar Cube Cornor for a bit and I decided to go with them, since that was my destination anyways. We chatted as we walked, and Doc had pulled me over to the side and asked about the party for Derpy.

"Oh right, I got ya covered! It'll be here at Sugar Cube Cornor. I was actually coming here for that reason. Pinkie and I were gonna discuss what to do for the party. Say, why are you so interested in throwing this mare a party anyways, since you two have, quite nervously and suspiciously, told me you two were not a thing?" I asked, nearly joking with him. He looked like he was frustrated, yet nervous at the same time.

"N-no reason. I just wanted to-" I stopped him mid sentence.

"I know exactly how you feel. I'm going through the same thing with Pinkie Pie. I know it's hard, but..." I stopped as well, noticing Pinkie and Derpy holding a conversation. For some reason, seeing her in her little pink apron made my heart fly! Doc was staring at Derpy, and I quickly nudged him, nearly scaring him.

"Good Gallifrey! You nearly gave me a double heart attack!"

I tilted my head in confusion. Maybe it was a British pony thing or something. I shrugged it off and asked him, "You like her don't ya?"

He sighed and nodded. "More than all the universes combined. She's all that I can think of, and with us living together in my house, it's gotten harder not to tell her. I've kept myself at bay, but...it is hard to not let go of your feelings for others. You understand what I'm saying?"

I nodded and continued about how I felt about Pinkie. It felt good to let it all out of my systems to somepony. Boneless isn't much of a talker, and I didn't have anypony else to chat to about this. "I guess all I can say to you now is good luck with your Ditzy Doo."

"Thank you, and good luck with Pinkie Pie, Cheese. Thanks for the chat, it helps knowing I'm not alone in this struggle."

We extanged grins and trotted inside.