Rarity's Desire

by El Hombre

Rating: mature
Tags: Human, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Second Person, Rarity, Romance, Sex
Length: 2185

A second person Human x Rarity Story where you get to know each other and have some fun time.

You and Rarity have been dating for a couple of weeks now and she's finally ready to make the next step in your relationship.

The cover was made by Skyline19 who uploaded it to DeviantArt LINK

Edited and corrected by Valen Machina

Published 2015-06-14 23:10:02 UTC
Last updated 2015-06-14 23:10:02 UTC

The next step

“Sooo…. are you sure you wanna do this?” you asked Rarity.

You two are sitting in the most romantic, and also most expensive, Restaurant in Ponyville. It took you nearly 2 weeks of persuading the manager to put you on top of the waiting list.

Rarity was so excited about this date.

The moment you told her that you had a reservation for a table in the most romantic restaurant in town you had the feeling she wanted to say something, but she kept quiet. You asked her what’s wrong, but she only replied, “Nothing my darling. Let’s talk after our dinner tomorrow.”

The next evening you meet Rarity in front of her boutique and you two walk, side by side, towards the restaurant opposite town hall.

The waiter guides you to your table and you two sit down. A look on the menu reminds you how badly you miss eating steak or any other meat. While you’re still looking for something acceptable to eat Rarity already made her choice.

“Can’t find something you like my darling?” she asked with a smirk on her lips.

“Oh, I’ll just take the same as you do,” you answered.

After a few minutes had passed, the waiter shows up and asks if you've already made your decision.

“As an appetizer I’d like a mixed salad, for the main course the daisy-sandwich, and the mousse au chocolate variations for dessert please.” Rarity ordered.

“Excellent choice. And for you mister?” the waiter asks you.

“I’ll take the same,” you said without turning your eyes from Rarity’s.

Whenever you look at her, you feel like losing yourself in those wonderful blue eyes. It’s been nearly a month now since you met Rarity.

You remember it like it happened yesterday.

You walked around town and asked a few ponies on the streets if there was a store where you can get your trousers sewed, because they had a big hole in a very inappropriate location. One of the mares told you to visit the boutique which was just a five minute walk to the north. As you enter the round house, it was empty and quiet.
“Is anypony here?” you shout in hope of getting recognized by somepony.

“I’m in the back, I’ll be there in a minute!” a sweet ladylike voice answered, dampened through the half closed door to your left.

“I wonder if she looks as good as her voice sounds,” you thought to yourself.

While you waited, you took a look around and noticed the mannequins that were spread out around the room. They were all wearing tailored dresses and suits. Each one perfectly and individually made for the mare or stallion who ordered them.

“Beautiful, aren’t they?” a voice asked behind you.

You nearly had a heart attack and turned around, “What the f…!”

Your heart stopped for another second when you saw the unicorn that was now in front of you. Her beautiful white fur that perfect purple mane, and those stunning blue eyes.

The same eyes that were looking right at you. “Is everything okay?” Rarity asked worriedly, snapping you out of your memories.

You tell her that everything is fine, and ask yourself how long you’ve been gazing at her.

During the dinner you two have nothing to say to each other and just enjoy each other’s presence. As the dessert arrives, you remember that Rarity wanted to tell you something, but you decide to wait until the two of you two are finished eating. After about fifteen minutes, that seemed like an eternity for you, you can’t think of anything else as a topic, except what she wants to talk with you about, Rarity looks at you and leans forward.

“You know…. Anon, I really like you and we have been dating for almost four weeks now, and… I don’t know how to say it,” her cheeks went from the clear white you know to a light pink. You encourage her to carry on but she kept silent and the pink grew a bit darker.

“I want to have sex with you,” she suddenly said.

Your mind switched to hyper mode and a million thoughts rushed through your brain,

“Is this for real? I didn’t expect this though I have wanted this since the second we met. A human and a pony?”

“So… what do you say?” Rarity asked after a while and nervously waits for an answer.

“I’d love that, my beautiful mare.”

Rarity grinned broadly at you, the color of her cheeks return to their natural white. She leans forward and you share a passionate kiss.

"So, you wanna go?" you say to Rarity with a very suggestive voice.

"Oh, not today darling. I think it will be more special if we wait until tomorrow and prepare ourselves for each other."

"Tomorrow evening then?" you ask her.

She agreed and told you to meet her at the boutique at 8 PM.

The next morning you wake up terribly tired. You couldn't get to sleep, the only thing you could think about was what was going to happen tonight. You get up, walk towards the kitchen and get some coffee. Internally, you hope it keeps you awake until your date with Rarity. This was the longest day that you ever experienced. The first thing you did to pass the time was getting your morning workout done. Normally it takes you an hour or so to finish your run around town, this time you finished in half the time. Time just didn't seem to pass fast enough.

Finally the time had come to get yourself ready. As you shave your beard your thoughts turn to the events that would happen in about 20 minutes, "Will she be nervous? Is this her first time? What will sex with a pony feels like?"

Ten minutes before 8 o'clock, you start your walk to the boutique. After arriving at your destination, you ring the doorbell and wait. A few seconds later Rarity opens the door. She looks absolutely breathtaking. Her mane isn't the same as what you are used to. It elegantly falls down on both sides of her head and as she moves it reflects the dampened light from inside the boutique. You step in and ask her if she’s ready. She nods and heads towards her bedroom, with you following behind her.

“Wine?” she asks, as she levitates a bottle accompanied by two glasses in front of you.

You accept the offer and grab one out of the purple magic-sphere. She pours a good amount of the dark red liquid into her glass and then yours. She seems a bit nervous, you notice as you look at her. You ask her if she’s ok, but instead of answering or taking a sip of her wine she does something unexpected.

Rarity drags you into a deep kiss. You feel her fur on your lips and her tongue in your mouth. While you just sit there with your eyes closed you touch her cheek. She moves her head into your palm, wanting to feel your skin on hers, never breaking your kiss. With the other hand, you begin to move downwards, you can feel a shiver run down Rarity’s body. As you reach the place between her legs you begin to trace your middle finger around her outer lips. She starts to moan lightly into the kiss. Like a reaction to her moaning your penis begins to grow. You two break the kiss you’re sharing and stare into each other’s eyes.

“I love you,” you tell her. She suddenly presses her lips against yours, pulling you into an even more passionate kiss than before. She starts to trace a hoof around your chest and quickly moves down to the growing bulge in your jeans. When she starts to press a bit firmer against your member, you quickly slide a finger inside her vagina. She again breaks the kiss and moans out loudly, “Ah!”

She gently pushes you down onto her bed. Rarity climbs on top of you and gives you a quick kiss before she slides herself down until her head is right above your trapped member. With her horn glowing, she opens the button and pulls down the zipper. After Rarity has managed to pull off your jeans she begins to nuzzle against your shaft which is still caught in your underwear. After a minute or so she magically pulls down your underwear too. Finally, your penis has the space to gain full size. Rarity’s eyes grew big as she sees your now fully erect cock. She begins to stroke a hoof up and down your member while she inspects it closely.

“I’ve never seen a human's... one before. It looks completely different compared to a stallions.” Rarity says.

She sticks her tongue out and begins to slowly lick upwards on the backside of your stiff cock. You brush your fingers through her mane and begin to fondle her ears. She lays her head sideways allowing you to reach her right ear more easily. You begin to feel the urge to release your load. You can’t think straight anymore.

Rarity realizes that you are close to your climax and stops licking your member. You get up and undress yourself completely. Lifting Rarity up and positioning her in the middle of the bed, you crawl up to her and begin to trace your tongue around her furry chest. She closes her eyes and starts to moan slightly. You slowly begin to move down towards her lower regions, just stopping here and there to place a kiss on her soft white fur. Reaching her vagina, you gently begin to suck on her clitoris.

She tilts her head back moaning out loudly, “Oh! Darling! That’s the spot!”

Her hot juices are beginning to flow out of her love hole. Quickly you move your tongue down to lick up her wetness before it reaches the bedding. She continues to moan while you eat her out. You start to push your tongue inside, causing her to moan even louder, “Ah! Yes! Fuck yes!”

She quickly blushes as she realizes what she just shouted. You feel Rarity nearing her climax, but you don’t want to finish her yet. You stop licking and crawl up beside her. After you two share a hot kiss Rarity climbs on top of you, positioning her winking sex over the tip of your cock.

“Ready?” she asks in a very aroused voice.

You quickly nod and see her grinning. She lowers her body. When your cock begins to spread her hole she opens her mouth and let her tongue hang out. Rarity turns her eyes upwards and slides down completely. You feel her inner walls move around you massaging your dick. You try to focus on not to cumming immediately. Her moaning and the feeling of her tail swishing on your legs nearly makes you lose your mind.

Rarity puts a hoof on your chest and begins to grind her hips against you. The feeling was just incredible. After a while you start to thrust into her. She lowers her upper body and presses it against yours. You hold her closely with both of your arms while you still thrust into her increasing in speed. Once more Rarity pulls you into a deep kiss and moans into your mouth while your tongues are passionately fighting against each other. You are coming close to your climax and you know she is too.

While you pound into her even harder she tilts her head backwards and begins to cry out loudly, “Ah! Ah! Ah! Anon, I’m cumming! Ah! Ah! Aaaaaaaahh!”

You feel her inner walls contract around your cock and her horn begins to glow brightly. Sparks begin to emit from the tip of her horn, while her whole body shivers. The look of her face, her aroused voice as she reaches her climax and the warm tight feeling around your cock are too much for you and you blow your load into her hole. You completely fill her up with your warm white seed.

Rarity collapses on top of you causing your dick to slip out of her. As she lays there, her body still twitching now and then. Tracing a hoof around your chest, she looks up to you, gazing into your eyes.

“I love you,” you both whisper at the same time.

You pull a blanket over both of your bodies and close your eyes. While your arms still hold her tightly you fall into a deep sleep, filled with dreams of Rarity and the fun you’re going to have in the future.

Author's Note

This is my first attempt on writing a story on my own and also my first clop-fiction so please don't judge me too hard. I hope you liked it and i would be pleased if you write your thoughts in the comments.

If you liked it please tell me and if you didn't like it please tell me what i can do better next time.