A Night with Four Mares

by PaladinColt

Rating: mature
Tags: Lyra, Romance, Octavia, Bon-Bon, Sex, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, DJ P0N-3
Length: 3054

Lyra and Bonbon visit Octavia and Vinyl for a little get together. Things get sexy pretty fast.

Vinyl and Octavia invite their friends, Lyra and Bonbon over for a little get together. Things go well until Vinyl drinks a little too much and starts asking about the "personality" of the relationships her friends have with each other. After a little persuasive help from Lyra, the four begin to engage in one of the hottest nights of their lives.

Published 2015-06-14 16:20:02 UTC
Last updated 2015-06-14 16:20:02 UTC

Two Unicorns, Two Earth Ponies, Four Times the Fun

It was the middle of the night, and two mares, Lyra Heartstrings and Bonbon Sweetie Drops were on their way to their friends’, Vinyl Scratch and Octavia Melody’s house. The two had been invited by the Octavia for a night just to get together. Lyra wore a saddle bag which had some items that they were going to use for the evening.

The two mares finally arrived at their friends’ house, which had the appearance of half of it representing a classical music design while the other half had the appearance of a more modern musical design.

“I hope we’re not too late.” Said Bonbon as she and Lyra approached the door. The earth pony mare reached her hoof at the door bell and began to ring it, which played a tune that sounded like a mixture of a classical symphony mixed with some dubstep.

Soon, Octavia answered the door to find the two standing there, smiling.

“Lyra, Bonbon!” she greeted. “I’m glad you too finally made it; Vinyl has been waiting all night for your arrival.”

“Sorry, Octavia.” replied Bonbon. “But Lyra here said that she had to pack some ‘extra goods’ for tonight, whatever that means…”

“Hey, there’s no harm in bringing a little extra, Bonbon!” replied Lyra.

Bonbon just shook her head and turned to Octavia, who said,

“You two should come inside. Vinyl is in the living room.”

The two mares entered the house with Octavia. The grey-furred pony took the saddle bags from Lyra’s back and brought them to the living room. As they were going there, Octavia noticed how heavy the saddle bags were and asked Lyra,

“Lyra, what exactly are these ‘goods’ that you brought for tonight?”

“Just some things Vinyl asked me to bring for tonight.” replied Lyra.

“What kind of things?” asked Bonbon. “You didn’t even tell me when we left the house this evening.”

“You’ll find out soon enough, Bonbon.” replied the unicorn with a wink.

The three finally arrived at the living room. There, they saw Vinyl Scratch slouching on the couch, surrounded by a few empty bottles of hard cider courtesy of Sweet Apple Acres. Seeing the mess, Octavia said,

“Vinyl, I leave you for a few seconds to greet our guests and now you trash up the place!”

“Don’t sweat it, Tavi!” replied Vinyl, throwing a bottle to the side. “I’m sure our friends won’t mind the mess, right guys?”

“Well I don’t mind.” replied Lyra bashfully.

Octavia and Bonbon just rolled their eyes at their friends’ remarks and sighed.

“Well, despite the mess,” said Octavia. “Why don’t you two make yourselves at home?”

“Will do.” replied the two as they took their seats on the couch beside Vinyl, who began to sit up to give space for her friends.

Octavia hung Lyra’s saddle bags on a nearby coat hanger before taking her place on a sofa chair perpendicular to Vinyl’s couch. Vinyl used her magic to pass bottles of hard cider to their guests, saying,

“So, how has life been for you two?”

“Well, it’s been great, I guess.” replied Bonbon, taking a sip from one of the bottles of hard cider. “I mean, ever since that Bug-Bear attack, Lyra and I have began to share some more dark secrets with each other.”

“Dark secrets, huh?” said Vinyl, who was intrigued. “What like secret agencies or weird fetishes about hairless monkeys?”

Both Lyra and Bonbon scrunched their noses and looked away, neither confirming nor denying anything that their friend had said.

Octavia just sighed and took a bottle of cider for herself to drink. Normally, she would pour the drink into a glass and drink it from there, but the atmosphere that Vinyl had made in the living room had nullified Octavia’s gentlemare-like behavior. She also began to slouch and relax on her seat as they continued to chat with each other.

“Where are Derpy and Doctor?” asked Lyra as she took a few more sips from her hard cider.

“Oh, don’t you know, Lyra?” answered Octavia. “It’s their anniversary.”

“Really?” asked Bonbon.

“Yes, although the Doctor himself forgot about it, despite the fact that he’s crazy about time most of the time; Derpy told me that they had planned something special for tonight.”

“Why couldn’t they just party here with us?” said Vinyl.

“I think those two would rather celebrate their anniversary with each other alone rather than with friends.” replied Bonbon.

“I don’t see why they shouldn’t celebrate with their friends.” remarked the disk jockey. “I mean, I bet all they’re gonna do for tonight is get laid.”

The three mares who were listening began to suddenly spit out some cider at hearing Vinyl’s remark. They began to blush at the very idea of imagining how the Doctor and Derpy would like making love to each other.

“Vinyl!” shouted Octavia. “That is NOT how we talk about our friends!”

“What, I was just being honest!” replied Vinyl. “Besides, you and I would be doing the same if we were having our anniversary, and I wouldn’t mind if Lyra and Bonbon were here with us.”

Lyra and Bonbon’s face began to blush bright red at their friend’s words. Octavia just turned bright red, embarrassed at how openly Vinyl’s tongue had gone.

“Vinyl,” she said. “We do NOT talk about our ‘personal’ affairs with our friends!”

“Oh come on, Tavi!” said Vinyl as she sat up and reached her hoof around Lyra’s shoulder. “I bet they would do the same thing too.”

Bonbon’s eyes grew as she noticed Vinyl reach a hoof around Lyra’s shoulder. She thought that Vinyl had gone a bit drunk because of all the hard cider that she drank. Lyra just sat there, blushing and still drinking some cider herself as Vinyl continued to blabber about inappropriate things.

“Ummm, Octavia…” said Bonbon. “I think Vinyl’s drank a bit too much cider.”

“I can see that Bonbon.” replied Octavia. “I think we ALL have drunk a bit too much for tonight.”

“Aww come on, Tavi!” said Vinyl. “Don’t tell me you’re crashing this party now! We just got started!”

“You’re making our friends feel uncomfortable, Vinyl. I think we should resume this some other time when you’re not talking about sex-related stuff.”

“Actually,” added Lyra, cutting Octavia off. “I don’t mind if we talk about sex stuff…”

Bonbon and Octavia’s eyes grew wide while Vinyl made a smirk at Lyra’s remark.

“I mean,” Lyra continued. “it shouldn’t really be a surprise to us; Octavia and Vinyl are more-or-less a couple, and so are Bonbon and I. I’ll be honest, I really would not mind if Bonbon and I celebrated our anniversary with you guys, even if it means... making love in front of you guys.”

The room was silent for a moment with a few snickers from Vinyl’s smug face. Both earth ponies Bonbon and Octavia were speechless and blushing at Lyra’s words.

“Lyra…” Bonbon said, not knowing what else to say.

“I-I’m sorry Bonbon.” replied Lyra. “I-I just…”

Before she could continue talking, Vinyl placed her hoof at Lyra’s lips and said,

“Say no more, Lyra; I think we should reveal our real plan for tonight.”

Lyra stayed silent for a while, and then smiled with a blush. Still a bit confused, Octavia inquired,

“W-what do you mean, V-vinyl?”

“Well, I was hoping that you and Bonbon would be a little more drunk,” replied Vinyl. “but I think it would be better if we knew exactly what we were doing.”

“Doing?” said Bonbon. “Doing what?”

Lyra was about to explain when, suddenly Vinyl took Lyra’s face with her hoof and brought it to her face. The white unicorn then, unexpectedly kissed the green unicorn deep on the lips, her sunglasses dropping down her muzzle. Lyra was taken surprise, but soon began to accept the kiss as if she knew that this would happen.

Meanwhile, Bonbon and Octavia were dumbfounded at what they saw; their partners, friends, and what they could also considered their lovers were kissing each other.

“Vinyl!” exclaimed Octavia.

“Lyra!” so too did Bonbon.

The two unicorns broke the kiss and glanced at their surprised friends. They did not have any guilt for what they had just done, but instead smiled smirks at the two earth ponies.

“Are you thinking what I’m thinking, Lyra?” Vinyl said.

“Yes, I am Vinyl.” Lyra replied.

With that, Lyra stood up from her seat on the couch and waltzed toward Octavia while Vinyl scooted up from her side of the couch to sit beside Bonbon. Without warning, the two earth ponies were caught off guard when the two unicorns began to do the unpredictable; Vinyl began to kiss Bonbon while Lyra began to kiss Octavia.

Bonbon and Octavia began to squirm, but were held firm by the unicorns’ magic that were holding them down to their seats. They did not understand what was going on, or what their unicorn friends were doing, but slowly their resistance began to die down.

Feeling them starting to relax, the two unicorns broke the kiss and looked at the ponies that they had kiss in the eyes.

“W-what’s going on?” Octavia asked.

“Just a little something Vinyl and I planned.” replied Lyra.

“This is… I… Have you two gone mad?!” exclaimed Bonbon as she tried to get back to her senses.

“Aww come on, Bon!” chuckled Vinyl. “I bet you two are gonna love what we have planned for tonight.”

“This… this isn’t right, Vinyl!” exclaimed Octavia. “Are you suggesting that the four of us…”

“Get laid here tonight?” Lyra continued Octavia. “Well like Vinyl and I said, we don’t mind.”

“Yeah, and besides,” added Vinyl. “I’m sure you guys won’t regret it.”

The two earth ponies did not know what else to do; it had seemed that this night had been planned by their unicorn lovers, and there seemed to be no escape from it.

“Oh, what the heck?” said Bonbon, finally accepting the situation. “We’ll do it!”

“I suppose there’s no turning back from this.” sighed Octavia. “But this night better be worth something, you two!”

Hearing these, Lyra and Vinyl quietly rejoiced before engaging into another kiss with the two earth ponies. This time, Bonbon and Octavia were more accepting of the kiss than a while ago. But then, they began to feel their hooves sensually caressing their bodies. Soon, the kisses became sloppier and the four began to tongue wrestle.

A few moans escaped their lips as they felt each other’s hooves caressing against the sexy parts of their bodies. Vinyl and Lyra, in particular began to use their magic to help them pleasure Bonbon and Octavia. Soon, they began to caress the earth ponies’ marehoods, which caused them to blush and moan.

“Oooooh…” moaned Bonbon as she felt Vinyl caress her hoof on her marehood.

Octavia also moaned as she felt Lyra’s magic slowly caress the insides of her pussy while her hoof was caressing the outside. She bit her lip as she felt the unicorn lick her neck before giving her a kiss on the cheek.

Vinyl, on the other hoof stopped caressing her hoof on Bonbon’s marehood and began to move down, kissing Bonbon’s body downward until she reached her crotch. She took a sniff at the area and joked at Lyra, saying,

“Wow, Lyra, you were right; she does smell like candy down here.”

Bonbon just blushed and covered her face in embarrassment as Lyra giggled before continuing to pleasure Octavia. Vinyl then began to lick Bonbon’s pussy, flicking her tongue at her clit and caressing her hoof on the wet vagina.

“Ahh!” moaned Bonbon as she felt Vinyl lick her off. She ran her hood through Vinyl’s mane and began to press her closer to her crotch. “D-don’t stop Lyr- I mean Vinyl!”

Vinyl snickered at Bonbon’s slipped tongue, but continued to pleasure her Lyra’s lover. Lyra, meanwhile continued to caress Octavia’s vagina with her hoof and magic. She began to go faster, causing the musician to moan louder and louder, biting her lip to muffle the sounds of pleasure coming out of her mouth.

The two unicorns continued to pleasure the earth ponies until they began to feel a coming sensation.

“I-I’m g-gonna cum, Vinyl!” moaned Bonbon weakly as the disk jockey continued to lick her pussy.

“M-me too, L-lyra…” added Octavia as Lyra continued to hoof her vagina.

The two unicorns continued to pleasure their respective partners until they finally began to cum, moaning their names loud as they released their vaginal juices, with Bonbon squirting at Vinyl’s open tongue while Octavia came on Lyra’s hoof.

Vinyl accepted Bonbon’s love juices with an open tongue and began to lick off the excess while Lyra licked the love juices off her hoof. The two earth ponies began to pant, trying to recover from their release. As they recovered, Lyra and Vinyl stood up and walked toward the coat hanger where Octavia had put Lyra’s saddlebags. There, Lyra used her magic to pull out two strapon dildos from the bag.

“I got the goods, Vinyl.” said Lyra, showing Vinyl one of the strapons.

“Perfect!” replied Vinyl. “Now, let’s put them to use.”

The two unicorns then walked back to their lovers, who had just recovered from their afterglow. Showing them the strapons with their magic, the two said,

“Now we want you two to make us cum.”

Octavia and Bonbon looked at one another for a while. A devilish smirk came to both their faces as they looked back at Lyra and Vinyl.

“Sure.” they said as they took the strapons from the two unicorns.

The two began to put on the strapon dildos and began to mouth their respective lovers; Octavia mounted Vinyl while Bonbon mounted Lyra.

“We’re gonna make you two pay for getting us into this mess.” said Bonbon as she prodded the head of the dildo on Lyra’s pussy. Likewise, Octavia readied hers to enter Vinyl, saiying,

“We’ll show you what us earth ponies will do to you naughty unicorns.”

Without warning, the two suddenly began to thrust the strapons into the unicorns, causing a surprised moan from the both of them.

“Ahhh, Bonbon!” exclaimed Lyra.

“Damn, Tavi!” moaned Vinyl.

Octavia and Bonbon did not hold back; immediately, they began to thrust the strapon dildos into their respective lovers hard and fast, causing Vinyl and Lyra to moan louder than they did awhile ago. The two unicorns had their faces to the floor with their asses to the air as the earth ponies were pounding them from behind.

The strapons were also slightly pleasuring Octavia and Bonbon; each thrust they made caused a part of the dildo to thrust their own marehoods. But their main concern was to make sure their lovers would cum, which was pretty soon.

“I’m cumming!” moaned both Lyra and Vinyl as Octavia and Bonbon made one last thrust into their lovers, causing them to squirt out juices on the dildos and on the earth ponies’ bellies. Bonbon and Octavia pulled out after a few seconds, letting their lovers pant for breath in the afterglow.

While the unicorns were recharging, Bonbon and Octavia looked at each other’s cum-coated strapons and then looked at one another. A blush came to their faces before finally deciding to kiss each other on the lips. Vinyl and Lyra watched from the floor as their lovers began to kiss each other. Then the two both lied down on the ground and began to lick cum off of each other’s strapons, tasting the juices of each other’s lover.

Soon, the two took off their strapons and began licking each other’s pussies in a sixty-nine. Both mares enjoyed the moment, licking the marehood of another mare. The two moaned as they continued to caress one another’s vagina with either their tongues or hooves.

Vinyl and Lyra had just recovered from the strapon sex and found their lovers sixty-nining. Eager to get in on the action, the two exclaimed,

“We wanna join in!”

Hearing them, Octavia and Bonbon stopped and looked at their lover who looked like they were begging join in.

“Well don’t just stand there.” said Octavia, moving a bit to give space to the two unicorns.

“Come on in!” added Bonbon.

Vinyl and Lyra smiled greatly and lay down to join them. Now the sixty-nine became a daisy chain; Octavia was now licking Lyra’s pussy while Lyra was licking Vinyl’s. Vinyl was now licking Bonbon’s pussy while she began to lick at Octavia’s. The four then resumed their pleasurable acts, all of them moaning as they felt each other’s tongues caress against the sensitive parts of their marehoods. At times, the unicorns would use their magic while the earth ponies used their hooves to add to the pleasure.

Soon, however, they could not hold it in anymore. With one unison moan, the four of them came, with Lyra starting first, then Octavia, then Bonbon, and finally Vinyl. The four of them began to squirt their love juices at each other’s face, tasting the love that they all shared. Then, as soon as it had started, it was all over.

The four lay on the floor, catching their breaths, covered in each other’s cum. Then, after a few moments of afterglow, they began to huddle up together and cuddle, simply happy that they were together.

“That was awesome, you guys.” said Vinyl, breaking the silence.

“Indeed it was.” replied Octavia.

“I guess this wasn’t such a bad idea after all.” added Bonbon.

Lyra just lay there in the middle of them all and said to them,

“I love you guys so much!”

All four of them blushed, but smiled; indeed, the four of them felt that their friendship with one another had grown stronger after everything that they had done. The four of them then began to kiss one another on the cheeks and tightened their hugs.

“So,” Vinyl said. “When are we gonna bring the Doctor and Derpy into this?”

“Probably some other time, Vinyl.” replied Octavia, giggling. “We wouldn’t want to rush them into this.”

Author's Note

Please notify me in the comments for any grammatical or spelling errors. Once notified, I will edit it. Once edited, your comment will be deleted, but you will be thanked.