Fluttershy and her pet Anon

Anon’s Perspective

It had been 2 weeks since he got trapped with these crazy candy horses and was forced to be the pet for the yellow one.

He was seriously starting to lose it. The language barrier seemed insurmountable. They just made whinny noises. The petting was nice, as was the ability to basically act like a dumb animal with no consequences, but the lack of voices was starting to echo in his mind.

He looked over. The yellow one seemed to be trying to get the lid off a jar. The question of how horses invented glass jars haunted him every day. He rolled off the couch, grabbed the jar of what appeared to be strawberry jam, easily took the lid off and handed it back. She smiled. Or she was challenging him. It was tough to tell with these magic horses.

She flew over to a bean bag chair and leaned back. She looked at Anon and made what might have been meant to be soothing whinny noises while waving her hoof to beckon him. He then watched with shock as she spread a little bit of the strawberry jam on her magic horse vagina.

It had been about 2 weeks since he last came. The blue that best described his balls would be a nice deep Oxford Blue he thought. His mind always seemed to go to strange places these days. These horses never gave him any privacy. It was a big part of why he was losing it. Looking at yellow quiet, rubbing the strawberry jam on herself, he knew he had to ask himself one question: could he fuck this tiny horse?

"Fuck it. I'm game." Anon shouted to no one in particular.

The yellow horse jumped a little, but then settled down when she saw Anon get down on all fours and crawl toward her. As he got closer he took a moment to smell her. Yellow always smelled like what an herbal essence commercial looked like, wild grasses, exotic fruit, and just a generally nice girly smell. Looking up into the yellow one's eyes, he quickly leaned forward and took a big long slurp of her little horse pussy. He made sure to run his tongue all the way from the bottom to the top. Anon was not a trained animal doctor and knew very little about horse physiology. He hoped it was similar enough to take his human dick.

The tiny magic horse made the most obscenely lewd whinny he could have ever imagined. It was like a moaning girl voice somehow got put through some kind of horse auto-tuner. Dick was now diamonds. Anon slurped and thumbed her throbbing pussy. The strawberry jam jar had rolled off somewhere. Neither of them would need it.

Furiously licking and slurping at what he hoped to god was her clit, he experimentally took a finger and started to work it into her pussy. He let his tongue take a break as he looked up to see how she was reacting to it.

“Holy fuck, I think this horse loves me,” he said out loud.

He got back in and continued to flick her clit with his tongue as he pumped his fingers in and out of her tight horse cunt. There was no question now on whether there would be compatibility issues. He stopped licking and pulled his fingers out. The yellow one looked confused as Anon lifted her up to his chest, spun around, and sat down on the bean bag chair himself.

His pants lost between the kitchen and the chair, yellow quiet found her soaking wet pussy rubbing up against engorged cock. He took her flank in her hands and rubbed her up and down the bottom of his shaft, watching her tremble and neigh softly. Then, he stopped, moved his arms back onto the bag, smiled, and left the softly panting pony to think about what she wanted.

With a sad little whinny, she moved her hips back and forth rubbing on Anon’s cock. But it wasn’t enough to satisfy the magic pony. With an irritated neigh, she flew up, through some mysterious ability took his cock in her hoof, and slid the head into her drooling pussy. With a quiet neigh of triumph, she slowly lowered herself back down. Anon swears the horse is smiling at him as she rocks her hips forward and back, her slippery cunt taking in his cock greedily while not letting it go without a fight.

“Holy crap, this horse is gonna suck my cock dry,” Anon realized with a shock.

He was ruined. No pussy could ever possibly compare to the one on this tiny horse. With a small tear forming in his eye he reached up, grabbing the horse by her flanks. With his powerful hands he massaged her haunches as he forced his dick deeper into what he realized truly was a magic horse vagina. He stared into her eyes with hunger as he used his hands to pull his dick out while her pussy fought to keep it inside. The horse’s eyes glazed over in bliss as Anon pounded his cock in and out. Her soft neighs seemed to take on more character as he heard her panting. Finally, with a sudden burst of speed he pushed the yellow one over the edge, her pussy clamping down and releasing on his battered cock. Too much to bear, his balls tightened as he filled the tiny horse with his semen. He pushed his cock as deep as it could go, not wanting to miss the crazy contractions going on inside the pony’s pussy.

“Was it good for you?” he asked, somewhat ironically.
“Oh yes, that was wonderful,” the tiny yellow horse cooed, as she nuzzled up against his chest.

Fluttershy’s Perspective

It had been 2 weeks since she adopted the human. She knew it was mean, but she enjoyed always flying into the room whenever he tried to touch himself. Maybe he’d use those big strong “hands” of his to take out all his frustration on her, she thought with a giggle. Perhaps just a bit more teasing was in order…

Fluttershy flew into the kitchen and searched for something Anon might like. Discovering a jar of strawberry preserves, she struggled to get the lid off. Anon saw her, and being the little sweetheart he was, easily opened the jar and handed it back to her. Sudden inspiration hit her. She giggled to herself as she flew over and plopped herself down on her bean bag chair. She made a seductive beckoning motion to him as she rubbed just a little strawberry on her cute little pussy. She hoped he would get the hint.

“Fuck it, I’m game.”

She nearly dropped the whinny act as he slurped at her pussy, only hitting the strawberries as collateral damage. Her moan was only barely caught through sheer force of will. The jar rolled out of her hoof, totally forgotten. Oh god, those fingers she thought, as he probed the outer folds of her mare-hood with his wonderful thumb. He licked and suckled at her clit, making her eyes foggy with lust. She gasped as he used those amazing fingers to probe deeper into her tight pussy. She looked him in the eyes with naked desire as he pumped his fingers in and out of her. As she felt herself get closer and closer to an orgasm, he suddenly stopped. She made a confused gasp as he lifted her up in his big strong arms, spun around, then sat back down on the bag. He used his hands to move her entire lower body, grinding her pussy up against his cock. She remembered this time to whinny normally, but in a supportive way, but then he stopped. She looked at his smug face as he leaned back into the chair, waiting to see how bad she wanted it!

She wiggled, experimentally, to see if he would get the hint and put it in, but he just sat there with that dumb smirk. Finally, with what she hoped came across as an assertive, angry whinny, she used her wings to lift up and hover, grabbed his warm cock with her hoof, and slowly slid his human-hood into her hot waiting pony pussy.

Feeling super assertive now, Fluttershy smiled as she stared Anon in the eye as she forced his cock in and out of her. Her hips rocked back and forth at a medium pace as she could feel him struggling to control himself. She was dripping wet, the soft sounds of Anon’s penis struggling in and out of her tiny little pony-hole turning her on even more.

As she wondered just how much he was gonna take before he came, Anon grabbed her by her flanks. His strong hands massaged her as they sought to gain control over her pussy. As he forced his cock deeper into her pussy, Fluttershy melted. Then, finally having assumed direct control, he pounded his cock in and out of her with abandon. She stared at Anon, eyes filled with dumb love as he pounded her cunt like it had never been pounded before. With a final burst of speed, Fluttershy finally lost all sense of control as she began to cum all over Anon’s magical penis.

“Ahh, ahhhh, AHHHHHHHH!” Fluttershy cried as her cunt went insane with convulsions, no longer caring about keeping up the act.

She could feel Anon grip her tighter just as he started to shoot his load into her. Her pussy continued to spasm as it greedily tried to drink it up, not knowing it wasn’t horse butter. As they both faded into a nice afterglow, small aftershocks still coursing through them, Anon turned to her with a stupid grin and asked a question.

“Was it good for you?”

She smiled and nuzzled up against his broad chest.

“Oh yes, that was wonderful!”