Fluttershy and her pet Anon

Anon woke up. He was on his stomach flat on the ground. He had no freaking recollection of what had happened. Something about a basement, and stairs. He shook his head. It felt heavy, like there was way too much inertia. Was he drunk? He couldn’t read the labels here, did he accidentally drink pony pine sol again? He struggled to get up, but could only manage getting on his hands and knees. He gave up on regaining verticality for the moment, and looked around.

A court yard. Hard gray stuff in a circle. Concrete? Road? Building? … Cars?

…

Equestria doesn’t have cars. Does it? They had trains, maybe they had cars? He wandered somewhere with cars? He crawled forward, experimentally. Balance seemed okay. Actually felt semi-normal. No way he was gonna stand up though. He turned around behind him and saw a statue. A rearing up horse. Nothing out of the ordinary there. There was also a girl sitting, leaning back against the statue, staring at him. Not a filly, but a human, 2 legged, normal girl. With pink hair. Okay, mostly normal. Girls need to express themselves, who was he to judge? He spoke up.

“Are… are you real?”

The pink and yellow girl’s eyes went wide with shock. Anon smelled pee. Yup, he was pretty sure she peed herself a little.

“Taaaa… talking pony!” she cried.

Anon looked down. Fucking hooves. Weeeell shit. The girl looked around for witnesses. She had a feral look in her eyes. Anon might have peed a little at that. She fumbled in her bag and pulled out a collar and leash. Yup, he was definitely peeing now.

He had tried to run, but he was no match for the yellow one’s superior animal wrangling skills. She brought him home to her house. His cries for help had been muffled by a pair of what his surprisingly upgraded sense of taste told him were used underwear. His mind suddenly clicked, processed the incoming data, and recognized the taste. She sat him down in the living room. He spit out the underwear.

“Fluttershy?!”

The girl was startled. The magic pony could talk and he knew her name!

“Why the heck am I a pony, and why are you human? I swear, if this is some kind of weird kinky sex thing…” he trailed off for a second, then after his eyes widened with realization continued, “I am totally on board with it. As long as we fix it after.”

“What? How do you know my name? Am I the missing moon princess and you are going to give me magic powers in exchange for sex?”

Shit. Yup, definitely Fluttershy. He calmly explained how he was a human that had been trapped in a magical land called Equestria. He had apparently got magically drunk on cleaning solvent and somehow ended up here, where for weird magic polarity reasons he got turned into a pony. He also explained how he and that Fluttershy were very “close” and how she was the only one who could understand him.

Fluttershy looked disappointed. It hurt that he had to pop her dream bubble, but any Fluttershy in the multiverse deserved the truth from him. Even if she was a nympho pony with a nascent role-playing fetish.

“So you are only attracted to ponies then…” she said sadly.

Wait what.

“NOnnononoo, I like girls! Fluttershy was just really nice and…” he trailed off as he saw her perk up, get down on all fours, and crawl towards him. He felt his new horse cock twitch.

She crawled beside and nuzzled him. Making a kind of whinny noise she continued past and reached back to flip up her green skirt as her butt passed his head. His pony sense of smell went nuts. He spun around and buried his muzzle into her ass. Her panties proved insufficient defense against his newly prehensile tongue as he quickly pulled them down and out of the way. In Ponyville, he found his fetish was eating Fluttershy out while he listened to her try to talk about the town and her friends. Her voice had become his anchor in a sea of whinnies.

“Fluttershy, can you talk for me? Just say anything please, I want to hear your voice,” he begged, then buried himself in her familiar tasting plot.

The young woman panted and moaned as Anon ran his tongue up and down her slit, pausing only to suck on her clit. She tried her best to make small talk, jumping from the movie she and her friends watched the other day, to how she was pretty sure Rainbow Dash had tried to hit on her at the last Pinkie party. It was all music to his ears as he felt her tremble and her arms gave out. Mercilessly, he continued to suck and slurp, driving her orgasm on. Finally, he felt her relax and give a content sigh. Licking his pony lips, he gave her a short breather to bask in the afterglow.

Fluttershy rolled on to her back, smiling at him. He walked over her, leaving his cock dangling near her mouth. He had been slightly disappointed that his penis seemed to be the same size as before, though other Fluttershy had said he was about the same as the other stallions and not to worry because she loved it. Human Fluttershy leaned up and enthusiastically took him into her mouth. He forgot what he was thinking of as he felt her lips slide up and down his throbbing stallion hood. The lewd sound of her slurping and moaning filled his pony ears as he suddenly came all over the young girl.

She felt him stiffen and she pulled back just in time to be showered with his cum. She looked up at him and took an experimental lick from her hand. Her eyes lit up as she realized it tasted like gogurt. She greedily slurped it down, wiping it off her face and licking her fingers. She looked very pleased with herself.

“You couldn’t hold out for a little longer?” she teased sweetly, smiling.

He smiled and answered with another erection. Fluttershy stood up and took her soaked panties all the way off, throwing them across the room. She got down on all fours, flipped her skirt all the way forward, and wiggled her tail seductively.

“I’m ready for my pony ride, Mr. Anon.”

He enthusiastically mounted her, his horse cock butting up against her tight cunt. Pressing forward, it suddenly slipped in, the young girl giving an adorable sharp cry. With his new found pony muscles he pumped his dick in and out of the girl, as her pants and moans drove him to fuck her harder and harder. He had discovered pony stamina was not as good as what his human body was capable of. This might have been why Fluttershy was so enamored with his human cock. What he lacked in stamina here he made up with sheer mass, enthusiasm, and inertia. Human Fluttershy was in a daze as she shouted at him, her lewd comments driving him on.

“Ahhh, Anon, beat up my little human pussy with your giant horse cock!”

Anon came first. As he flooded her cunt with his horse semen, she came. He continued pumping into her, his horse balls apparently forgetting how to turn off. Finally, his cock slipped out with a pop, his seed spilling out of her abused cunt. Anon passed out. Fluttershy crawled up against him and slept too.

Fluttershy led the green pony back to the portal. She told him of Twilight’s visit, and how he could visit her whenever he wanted. She kissed him on the nose. Fluttershy was always sweet, pony or human.

“I wish we could get together as humans,” said Anon.

“I think I like it better this way,” she smiled mischievously, “and I bet *she* does too.”

Anon thought about it. He smiled at yellow girl. Yup, that sounded about right. He stepped through the portal. As his eyes opened, he found himself in Twilight’s basement. He was on two legs again. All around him were saddles, whips, riding crops, and various horse bondage related hardware spread along the walls. Oh shit, he remembered now. Purple horse looked at him, wearing a shiny black saddle, boots, and a pair of stirrups placed just a bit too far back for a normal riding position. He peed a little again. Mistress Sparkle smiled, her quarry returned.