Fluttershy and her pet Anon

“You are in my realm now, human! You will pay for the humiliation you caused us!”

Anon regarded the night mare.

“Your voice is lovely, Luna. I wish I could hear it all the time. Also, I have no idea what you are talking about.”

Nightmare Moon regarded back Anon carefully.

“I am Nightmare Moon in this form, not Luna! You will address me as such! You believe you can have your way with our royal person without taking responsibility?”

Rarity was confused. The human had sex with Luna? Why did that turn her on so much?

“Responsibility how? We had sex Luna. Pretty awesome sex, from the broken fragments I can remember. It’s not like you can get pregnant from me.”

“You were our first! How dare you shirk that?!” Nightmare Moon shook with rage. “None can challenge us in the land of dreams Anon!”

Nightmare Moon fired a gigantic energy blast at the human.

“No, that’s not true Luna. You’ve never been in my dreams, have you? I always nap during the day.”

Anon batted the laser away using a random wooden salad tosser with total disregard to physics.

"Luna, we are the makers of music,
and we are the dreamers of dark dreams.
Wandering by lone sea-breakers,
And sitting by desolate streams;—
World-losers and world-forsakers,
On whom the pale moon gleams"

“Anon, where did you get that thing? Is that my salad spoon?” shouted Rarity.

“No Rarity. You ponies have to realize there is no spoon.”

A multicolor glow surrounded Anon.

“This is what we call an ascended Super Sai…”

Anon looked back and realized he had grown wings and a horn, along with yellow highlights in his now long flowing hair.

“… whatever. KA ME HA MEEEEE HAAAAAAA!”

Rainbow colored laser beams shot from his hands as they surrounded Nightmare Moon. She writhed in agony as the dark cloud melted away, leaving a filly Luna.

“Oh Anon… I’ve been such a bad girl… punish me more!”

Anon and Rarity suddenly found themselves slightly uncomfortable. They stared into each other’s eyes for a long moment, looking for judgement. Finding none, they finally relaxed.

“Soooo, I think I’m gonna spank then fuck this pony now. Wanna help?”

Marshmallow pony smiled as a shadow spilled over her, washing her white coat in darkness. What emerged was a being every bit the equal of Luna’s alter ego, the Nightmare Rarity.

“Oh my, I did so miss having such a luxurious flowing mane!” She coughed. “I mean, you silly foals! I have returned to punish the one who dared to usurp my mantle! Resurp. Redosurp?”

Rarity shook her head and giggled. She so enjoyed this kind of play! A ball gag and paddle materialized out of nowhere.

“Oh no! We are so soww!” shouted Luna as the ball gag went on.

Anon shook his head and smiled. Freaking unicorns and their weird fetishes. He flexed and his clothes exploded from his body, only to be instantly replaced by a black leather speedo and steel ring bound leather chest straps. He approached the small princess and watched as she trembled. He nodded to Nightmare Rarity.

The paddle swung swiftly as it met her tender flank. The young alicorn let loose a muffled yelp as tears filled her eyes. Nightmare Rarity had no sympathy as she continued to swat the young pony repeatedly.

Anon kissed Rarity as she paddled night horse. Then leading her around to the front, he had her recline on the padded throne. He removed Luna’s ball gag as he shoved her face into Nightmarity’s sopping wet pussy.

Moving behind, he rubbed his dick up and down her pussy lips. Luna was wet. Tiny princess was loving this. She eagerly dug into Rarity’s plot.

“Hmmm, it seems my former host wants to get reacquainted!” gasped Nightmare Rarity. Her hooves pulled Luna’s head in tighter as Anon shoved his dick into the small horse.

Luna stared into Rarity’s slit pupils. She felt so small and insignificant as she felt herself drunk in by her dark counterpart’s gaze. The human pounded at her tender little slit with his human cock. She got off on being punished. It had been this way for the princess ever since she got zapped by the elements of harmony. It was hard for her to get off while trying to keep up the dignity of princess hood. Her eyes rolled back in her head as Anon and Rarity used her like a plaything.

Nightmare Rarity’s pussy erupted under Luna’s assault. Even as she found her muzzle flooded by Rarity’s juices the princess never let up, using her horn to telekinetically grind against gem horse’s G spot. Years of secretly using the ponies of Equestria to sate her ever growing sexual desires had taught her many little tricks regarding delicious mare anatomy.

Anon felt the filly convulse on his cock as he pounded her. Shit, she was really getting off on this. He sped up to try and catch up, he wasn’t close yet. He picked Luna’s rear end off the ground with one hand as he played with her fluffy wings with his left. Shit, still not enough. He stared into Rarity’s eyes as she got eaten by the princess. There we go. His balls let loose as he dove into her glazed half slit eyes as she came from the little horse eating her pony pussy.

Luna died as she felt Anon cum in her again. Due to her being so uptight, her orgy with Discord, Anon, and Celestia had actually been her first sexual experience in the real world. Her tight pony pussy welcomed his seed.

Luna, Rarity, and Anon collapsed into a pile. Anon found himself absentmindedly petting Luna.

“Holy shit that was fun.”

“Oh Anon, I hope you don’t think your work here is done.”

Nightmare Rarity floated Luna over the arm of the throne as she wiggled her dripping plot at Anon. Luna’s eyes went wide with tears as the ball gag was shoved back into her mouth and the paddle slapped against her still quivering flank.

Anon nodded at gem horse. He rolled her onto her back, rubbing her fluffy chest tuft. Anon had developed a weird missionary horse fetish in his short time in Equestria.

“Foolish human! You think you…” Rarity's role-play trailed off and gasped as Anon’s cock entered her. Dialogue was forgotten as she tried to maintain enough magical focus to continue spanking Luna’s blue flank an even darker purple.

Luna was lost as Rarity continued to spank her ass. She continued to orgasm as she watched Anon fuck her predecessor.

As he filled Nightmare stylish pony with semen, he felt her pussy spasm on his cock. He collapsed across her chest as crazy pony orgasms assaulted his penis. As he watched both ponies finally give up in a panting heap, he felt funny. He blinked. Then somehow his still open eyes blinked again. He found himself in an unfamiliar bedroom with a small white unicorn staring down at him. Sweetie Belle smiled as she put the smelling salts away.