Alone With Starlight Glimmer (You're mine... Forever)
Author's Note
Well guys. Here's Starlight. It's been a while since I posted a story for the "Alone With..." series. Sorry it took me so long for that, I really don't wanna talk about why. 
But, this one is a special one to me. And since that me and a friend worked on this. We really pulled this off. Al always, thanks to jesus6825 for editing this story.
Oh, and btw. I didn't actually try to make this relate to the episode when they go to that town, or something like that. And me and my friend were like "Why not." So, bare with me here.
I hope it goes well. As always, enjoy it.
*Deep breath* here goes nothing.
Alone With Starlight Glimmer (You're mine... Forever)
You begin to wake from your unconsciousness as you felt heat like sunlight hitting your skin, and you can see the sunlight through your eyelids. You slowly open them as you felt the sun hit your eyes.
“Ah, Jesus!” You said as you covered your eyes. You also feel pain all over your body. Your arms, your legs. They hurt so much. You’re also bleeding. Have you fallen through the tree branches? What happened?
You look at your left arm, and you noticed that it’s wounded. You need to find something to cover it up. Otherwise, you don’t want it to get infected. You just wish that you knew how to stitch them. But sadly, you don’t.
You begin to walk as you start to limp on your right leg. It hurts so bad. You winced a little bit as you felt that horrible pain on your leg, and your arms.
“Fuck, my leg.” You said to yourself.
You can’t remember how you got here, and you don’t know where you are, exactly. You can’t remember what you did before you passed out.
After walking for about several minutes, you can’t go any further. So you decide to rest at a tree, and start to feel your eyes get heavy.
But before you were able to fall asleep, you began to hear mumbling.
“Oh no, Angel. You can’t go out in the woods like that again. You could get yourself killed out here.” You hear a voice. It sounds like a female. You can hear it get closer and closer.
“You know I wouldn’t want you to get hurt out here in the forest.” Wait, is that… A horse? A horse with wings?
“Come on, Angel. Let’s get you ho-” She stops herself as soon as she sees you. You gulp nervously. She walks closer and closer to you, until she’s about ten feet away from you.
“Um, hello?” She said to you.
“Holy shit!” You yelled as you limped behind a tree. “Y-You can talk? How can you talk? Horses can’t talk!”
You said to the yellow creature who’s now flying with her wings. She doesn’t even look nervous or terrified as she sees you’re probably helpless, scared, and have no idea where you are.
“It’s okay.” She said as she gets behind the tree with you.
“Huh? No, get away from me, please!” You said as you crawled away. Not even caring if you felt pain on both your arms, or your legs. She can also see that you’re wounded badly.
“Oh my, you’re bleeding. You don’t want those cuts to get infected. Would you?” She said to you. You look at your arms, and your legs. You are pretty beat up, and your leg hurts really bad everytime you walk on it. Could it be broken? How can it be if you limped on it?
“It’s okay, I got a first aid kit back at my cottage. You need to get something for those. Or else, they can get worse.” She said to you as she gives out a smile to you.
You just don’t know how you can trust her. You’ve never seen anything like this before in your whole life. Can she be trusted? Will she ever hurt you? You just sat there, shivering, as you stared at her.
“It’s okay. Come with me, I’ll take you back to my cottage, and I can patch you up. Then you can stay with me.” She holds out a hoof in front of you. Just inches away from you. You take your left hand, and you grabbed her hoof as tight as you can. Since that you’re very, very sore from… You don’t know what happened.
“A-Are you sure?” She nods her head. “U-Um… Okay then.” You said as you tried to get up. But your leg is extremely sore.
“Can you walk?” She asks you.
“I dunno. My leg is… It hurts really bad. I don’t know if I broke it or not.”
“Hang on.” She said as she might have an idea. Out of nowhere, she puts you on her back, as she’s now carrying you back to… What she said was her cottage. “I’ve never seen a creature like you around here. I’m Fluttershy.”
“Hi, Fluttershy.” You said as you introduced yourself.
“What are you doing out here in the Everfree Forest?” She asked you.
“I… I don’t know. Frankly, I don’t even remember how I got here.” You said to her as you see her bunny who she calls “Angel” is hopping beside you both. “Oh god, so tired.” You said under your breath.
“Hold on, we’re almost there.” Fluttershy explains. After about a minute or so of walking out of the forest, you arrive inside of Fluttershy’s cottage. It smells like a wild life, that has a bunch of animals here and there. Fluttershy gently lays you down on her couch as you grunted in pain from your leg.
Angel hops on your chest as he looks at you with that weird look on his face.
“Now Angel. We wouldn’t want to be rude to our guest now, would we?” Fluttershy said to him. “I’ll be right back.” She said as you see her disappear into the other room, and it looks like she’s going upstairs.
Angel sits on your chest as it looks like he feels warm and snuggle from your shirt or something. You don’t know. You gently bring up your arms. They are very sore as you stroke Angel’s fur. He loves your touch, and he lays back on your chest as he takes in your touch.
This is a really cute rabbit.
About a minute later, Fluttershy comes back downstairs with a blanket. She also sees that you’re petting Angel in steady strokes, due to being hurt so bad, and that you’re bleeding. She also has some bandages, and some disinfectant that you use for stitching.
“I see that your left forehoof is wounded pretty bad. That’s going to need some stitching.” She tells you. You looked at your left arm, and back at her.
“Yeah. It’s actually called an arm, no offense. But, do you know how to suture it?” You ask her.
“I can do it on animals. But, I’ve never done it on a creature like you before. I can try.” She said as she got out the stitches. She was careful not to mess with your painful leg. You turn over the best you can after Fluttershy grabbed Angel who was sleeping, until he was disturbed. What a grumpy little rabbit now.
“Okay. Now I’m just going to pour this stuff on here, okay?” Fluttershy said as she gets herself prepared. You gulp nervously. This is the part that you hated the most.
She grabs a paper towel, and pours some disinfectant onto it. You take a deep breath to calm yourself as she begins get closer to it. As soon as she makes contact.
“AHHH!!!” You screamed. This burns like fire. Fluttershy’s heart drops as she heard you scream from the top of your lungs in pain.
As soon as she wiped the paper towel on your arm, it stung like hell. She lets you calm down for a little bit, and you let her know when you’re ready.
“Okay. Okay, I’m good.” You said in a shaky voice.
“Are you sure?” Fluttershy asks, just in case you’re still not ready.
“Y-Yeah, I’m positive.” You said, still shaking.
“Okay. I’m going to bring out the stitches now.” She said as she brings out the little needle, and threads.
‘Now the fun part.’ You think to yourself as you watch her take the little thread into the needle. You have your arm rested on the little table beside you. Fluttershy positions herself as she places the needle at the end of the wound.
“Okay. One… Two… Three.” She counted. As she began to sow, you start to scream in pain from how bad this actually hurts. You can even feel some drops of blood going down your arm.
After a few minutes. She sowed your wound shut, and wrapped a bandage around it. It was pretty painful, but she did a good job on it though. You can give her that.
She also wraps some bandages around all of your other cuts. But, careful not to touch your right leg.
“Thanks.” You said quietly.
“No problem. I don’t know about a broken leg, though. I might have to have a friend to, um, look at it.” Fluttershy tells you.
“A-Alright.” You said as you feel your eyes getting really heavy.
“The sun is about to set. I hate to leave you here by yourself, but, I promise. I’ll come back with somepony who can patch up your leg. I’ll be back.” Fluttershy said as she shuts the door.
“See you in a little bit.” You said as you drifted to sleep. Not even caring what’s going on.
***
“He’s in here” You hear Fluttershy’s voice coming from the front door.
“Oh my, Fluttershy. Where in Equestria did you find this thing?” You hear another voice.
“I found him in the Everfree Forest. Twilight, do you know anything about these creatures?” Fluttershy asked her friend. You still have your eyes closed.
“Not that I know of. You said that he has a broken leg?”
“Uh-huh.” Fluttershy said as she uncovers your legs. You’re still wearing your pants as she shows Twilight which leg could be broken.
“Is there a spell on healing broken bones?” Fluttershy asked.
“I should be able to find it in this book. There’s also a spell where you can tell if it’s broken or not.” Twilight looks through the book. Until. “Ah-ha, found it.” She said as she found what she was looking for. “Let’s see if it’s broken or not.”
Her horn begins to light up, and a dark purple aura around your leg. You winced a bit, as you slowly open your eyes to see Fluttershy’s friend who she calls “Twilight.”
“Tss, yeah, it’s broken, alright.” Twilight said as she has that look of ‘That must of hurt’ face on her. She looks at you, and noticed that you’re awake.
“Oh, glad to see that you’re awake, uh…” You introduce yourself to her. “Alright then. Yeah, your leg is broken. Do you know how this happened?”
“I don’t remember. I’m sorry.” You apologized.
“That’s okay. I know a spell that can heal this leg. In the meantime, you need to stay here until you fully recover. Fluttershy will take good care of you.” Twilight said as Fluttershy nods with that smile on her face.
“A… Spell?” You lifted an eyebrow at her.
“Yep. Just a spell, and your leg will be healed. But, it’s going to be sore for a while. When I do this, it won’t be pretty.”
What is she talking about? Is she saying that magic actually exist in this world? Twilight is now searching through her book to see what “spell” she was talking about.
“Okay, I found it.” She said in a quiet voice. She scans through it a few times before she lays the book down. She takes a deep breath. “Fluttershy, you may wanna cover your ears.” Twilight said to her.
Fluttershy nods, and did as she was told. She covered her ears with her hooves, and squeezed her eyes shut.
“Uh… What do you mean?” You ask Twilight.
“This is going to hurt for just a little bit.” This is making you nervous. You still have no idea what she’s talking about. Her horn starts to glow with her usual purple aura surrounding it. She’s got that scared look on her face.
That purple aura is now surrounding your leg. Huh, it doesn’t feel too bad.
“Uh, Twilight. I don’t feel anything. It doesn’t hu- FUUUUUUUCK!!!!” That was all you were able to say until you felt extreme pain run all over your broken leg. Tears begin to fill your eyes as how bad this really hurts. It feels like someone took a cannon, and shot your leg off.
Finally, after a minute of that, you can barely feel your leg.
“Okay…” Twilight pant. “I got it. It’s healed now. But, you have to stay off of it for a while though.”
You didn’t say anything. Your breathing is hollow, tears streaming down your face, and beads of sweat running down your face as well.
“Th-Th-Thanks.” You said the best you can.
“You’re welcome. I’m sorry if that was painful. It’s how the spell works.” Twilight said.
“It’s okay. If it’s how it works, it’s how it works. But, it. Was. Worse. Then I thought.” You said while you’re still shaking, and still in pain.
“I know. I guess my work here is done. Fluttershy, when he gets back on his hooves, or… whatever those things are. Can you bring him to the castle so I can study him more, and learn what he is?”
“Of course, Twilight. I would be happy to.” Said Fluttershy with a smile on your face.
“Great, I’ll see you both soon. I’ll stop by and visit to see how you’re doing.” Twilight said as she smiled at you and left. You both waved goodbye for now. Now, you have to stay with Fluttershy for a while, until you’re fully recovered, and ready to go again.
***
Three weeks have passed, as you’re finally on your feet again. Your cuts and your wounds have healed as well.
You got to know some of Fluttershy’s friends really well. But, some faces in Ponyville give you that really odd look of shock. Fluttershy’s friends already like you.
There’s Rarity, Applejack, Rainbow Dash, and Pinkie Pie. You also met the three fillies. There’s Applebloom, who is Applejack’s sister. Scootaloo, in which her idol is Rainbow Dash, and there’s Sweetie Belle, who is Rarity’s sister.
They would have a ton of questions that they would throw at you, and you try your very best to answer them. Their eyes would go wide in surprise as you tell them that you’re not from Equestria. You’re from where you’re originally from, Planet Earth.
You also got to meet Twilight’s dragon assistant named Spike. He’s really cool, and you two got to know each other really well.
As you’re standing outside to have some fresh air, you got called in by Spike.
“Twilight needs you for a minute.” He said to you.
“Okay, what is it? Is it something important?” You ask him.
“I guess so. Come on.” You followed him inside the castle, and there is a giant table in the center of the room in Twilight’s castle.
“Hey guys. What’s going on?” You said as you grabbed their attention.
“Oh good, you’re here.” Twilight said.
“Is that the map of Equestria?” You ask.
“It sure is, isn’t it neat?”
“It looks so cool.” You said as your eyes go wide in amazement. You also see something that’s floating on what looks like the edge of the map. It looks like all of their cutie marks. “What’s that?” You ask, pointing at the floating cutie marks.
“That? That shows us that there’s a town that’s a distance away from here, and that they need our help to spread friendship over there.” Twilight explains.
“Whoa.” You said as you still can’t believe that this amazement is happening right in front of you. “Is it like your job to do that, or is it something that you just started?”
“Well, it shouldn't be that hard for our first try.” Twilight said as she looked at her friends.
“Oh.” You said. “Do I have to journey along with you guys?”
“I don’t know. I think this could be dangerous for you.” Twilight said as she puts a hoof to her chin.
“Hey come on, I can be tough. I’m brave enough. Nothing can stop me.” You said as you try to show your strong muscles to them.
“Are you sure?” Twilight said as she’s got that worried look on her face.
“Oh come on, Twilight!” Rainbow Dash said, getting in the conversation. “You heard him!”
“Oh yes. I think it’s divine to have such a strong, handsome human to go along with us.” Said Rarity. “Even to protect little ol’ me.”
“Ah guess it won’t be too bad to have some company with us.” Applejack said with a smile.
“Yes, it’s gonna be super, super fun!” Pinkie Pie said jumping up and down in excitement.
“Alright.” Twilight said as she rolled her eyes. “But I warn you. What happen when Fluttershy found you in the Everfree forest a few weeks ago, let’s hope it won’t happen again, and don’t say I didn’t warn you.”
“Okay.” You shrugged as you all head off to the train station.
***
After riding on the train for about three hours now, you finally come to a stop at a small town. Or village. Let’s say it’s a village.
As you all left the train, you begin to wonder ‘What kind of village is this?’ you think to yourself.
“So, what are we doing here? Didn’t you say that there’s trouble here, Twilight?” You ask her.
“Not just any trouble.” She tells you. “We don’t know what it is yet. It could be that we need to spread friendship in this village, and it should be something that we can handle.”
“Alright.” You said as you look at her, and the rest of your friends. “But, should we walk around first to get to know some ponies here?”
“I think that’s a great idea.” She said as you all started walking. As you all walked around the village, you noticed that there’s no one here.
“Huh, where is everypony?” Said Twilight. You’re getting a little bit confused too. You look around, still nothing. It’s like a ghost town to you. With these apartment like buildings, and… who knows what.
You had your back turned for only a minute as you watch the train move out of the station.
“Uh, hello?” You hear Twilight’s voice. You turned around, and you noticed a group of ponies that have black coats with hoods over their heads. Also covering their bodies as well.
“Is there a leader of this town that we may speak with?” Twilight asks the group.
They start to walk a little bit closer, this is starting to make you a bit nervous on what’s going to happen.
“We’d like for you to join us.” One of them says. Their voice has a mix of both a robot, and a zombie. That’s just makes it creepy as hell.
“That’s enough.” You hear what sounds like a female voice coming from one of them. She takes off the hoodie and… She smiles at you, and your friends.
“Welcome.” She said to all of you. “I’m Starlight Glimmer, it is so nice to meet all of you. I’m the leader of this here village.”
“Hi, I’m Princess Twilight Sparkle. Our map has sent us here to help out whatever problem that you may have here. Why is everypony acting like this, and what’s wrong with them?”
“Oh, it’s just that we’re preparing for our little meeting tonight, that’s all. ” She said.
“Uh… Meeting?” You ask as you jumped right in.
“Indeed.” Starlight said. “Our little meeting on how to make this village as happy as can be.” You have no idea why, but, when she said “Meeting” you’re starting to feel something deep down inside you that something is not right about her. You just don’t know what it is.
“Well, since that you’re all here, why don’t we give you a quick tour.” She said. Your friends accept the tour, and you walked beside Fluttershy.
“Uh, Fluttershy?” You whisper.
“What is it?” She said as she whispered right back.
“I don’t think we can trust her. There’s just something not right about her.”
“What are you talking about? She seems really nice. She’s also offering us a tour while we’re here, how can you tell that something’s wrong with her?” Fluttershy asked.
“I just have a feeling that something just isn’t right here.” You tell her.
“Well, I think it’s a peaceful village. These other ponies that she’s with seem nice too. Come on, give it a chance.”
You can’t argue with Fluttershy. In fact, you don’t even want to. So you just let it be for now.
Some time passes as you all walked with Starlight on the tour of the town. But, what you didn’t noticed is that her guard like weirdos are now single file right behind you. This is making you suspicious every time you looked back.
Finally, the tour ends as you finally feel relief that it’s over. The ponies are still behind you in a perfect single file line. This is still making you uncomfortable.
“That was a great tour, Starlight.” Twilight said smiling at her. “But, is there a problem with this town? Because our map has summoned us towards you here.”
“Oh, there’s nothing wrong with our town here, Princess Twilight.” Starlight said smiling. “I think it must be a mistake, perhaps?”
Twilight doesn’t know what to say. She was actually confused.
‘Huh, that’s weird. If the map didn’t send us here because there isn’t trouble, why in the living hell would it send us here in the first place?’ You think to yourself.
As you were thinking, Twilight shrugged it off, but you’re hoping that she still has a doubt in her mind about this place.
“Very well then.” Twilight said. “Since that there was a mistake, maybe we should be heading back to Ponyville.”
“But, it’s getting dark.” Starlight said as she pointed at the sun that’s just setting over the horizon.
“So what, we can take the train at night. No big deal.” Rainbow Dash said.
“But, the train doesn’t come around here at night like they usually do in other places. It’s much dangerous if you travel at night by yourselves. I have a room for you all to stay in for tonight.”
Can she be right? You look back at the train station, and you did notice that there’s no train there, or coming from anywhere. Then again, you have to take it, no matter how much you hate every single minute of it.
“Thank you so much for the offer, Starlight.” Twilight said with a smile.
“You’re welcome. Come now, and I’ll lead you to your rooms.” She said as you all begin to follow her.
***
“Here we are.” Starlight said as she showed you your room. It seems big enough for all of you. “Sleep well, and I hope you all return to Ponyville tomorrow.”
“Thank you so much.” Twilight said.
“Anytime.” Starlight replied before she shut the door.
“I don’t like her one bit.” You said as you looked at the door with your arms crossed.
“Why not? She seems really nice.” Twilight said as she was getting prepared for bed.
“That’s what I told him earlier today.” Fluttershy replied.
“Ah dunno, ya’ll. Ah’m starting to take his side a little bit. Ah’m starting to get a funny feelin’ about it, too.” Applejack said as she gets in bed.
“Oh, what are you talking about?” Rarity gets in. “She seems like a nice mare. At least everypony can give her a small chance. She offered us a place to stay. Now how can you all deny such a request like that? Good night, dears.” She said as she put the blindfold over her eyes, turned off the lamp, and went to sleep.
“Are you coming to bed?” You hear Pinkie Pie as she gets in her own. You look around, everyone, except Rarity are looking at you. You shrugged.
“Yeah, I guess.” You said as you get in your own bed. At least it’s big enough for you. “Good night, guys.” You said as you drifted off to sleep.
***
You don’t know how much time has passed, you just can’t sleep. You can’t stop thinking about Starlight, and what’s going on with her. You look at your friends in the room. They’re all asleep, you can barely see them in the moonlight that’s shining through the window.
You just don’t know what to do right now. But, an idea pops into your head. Why not sneak out and see what’s up with her?
But what if one of your friends catch you? You’re not sure if it’s a really good idea, but you really want to know what’s going on with Starlight. So you decided to wait for a few more minutes.
Ten minutes have passed, and you’re now planning to sneak out. You want to know what’s going on with that mare. You slowly make your way out of the bed, and tip-toed to the door. You grabbed your socks and shoes, when you just slept with your clothes on. Well… you didn’t sleep actually.
You slowly turned the doorknob, and slightly opened it. It makes that stupid creaking sound that you hate so much. So you try your best to slowly open it, and fit through the gap the door made, and quickly shut it. But you did it quietly, so you won’t disturb them. Now’s the time to make your move.
You’re now outside sneaking around the village. No one’s awake, the buildings lights are out, and best of all, your friends are asleep.
As you’re sneaking around, you noticed that there’s two black coated ponies walking to a building.
“What the fuck?” You whispered. You decide to follow them, but stayed as quiet as possible. As you followed them to that strange building, one of them shuts the door behind them with their magic. Well, no way getting in now.
You start to look around on the front. Nothing.
You decide to look around the place, until you see a vent. Perfect. This vent should work, you hope.
You grab an old chair, and you climbed to it. It looks big enough for your size, you just hope that your skinny body will fit through this.
You try to open it, but, it’s screwed tight.
“Dammit.” You whispered. “How am I gonna get this fucker open?” You put your hands in your pocket, and you feel something. Yes, a coin was in your pocket. You remember when Rarity was washing your pants a few weeks ago while you were recovering, she found a coin that fell out of your pocket.
You lined it up with the screw, which fits a flathead screwdriver. It fits perfectly, and you begin twisting it.
After removing all the screws, you remove the vent very carefully so you don’t make any noise, and you climb up, and crawled in.
You’re just the perfect size for this vent. Now to see what’s up with Starlight.
No time passes when you kept crawling quietly. Until.
“Ugh, how were they able to find our town?!?” That sounds like Starlight’s voice. You’re just above their meeting room. You quietly crawled over there, looked down. There she is.
“Do you have any idea how they know?” She said to one of her black coated ponies. “Oh, that’s right, you can’t, you’ve been brainwashed by me!” She said as she laughs maniacally.
‘So that’s why they were acting weird.’ You think to yourself.
“Soon, you will all be powerful enough to take over Equestria after I’m done with you!”
‘Jesus Christ, what the hell is going on with this mare?’ You think to yourself. You couldn't believe what you were hearing. You have to tell the others about all of this. But they won’t believe you if you tried. But, Applejack might believe you, she can tell if you could be lying or not. Probably.
All of a sudden, you feel your nose begin to feel funny. Oh no, this can’t be good.
“Ah-choo!” You sneezed. Your body froze in panic.
“What was that?!?” Starlight screamed. As you tried to move, you felt the vent begin to loosen up.
‘Oh… no.’ You think to yourself. Until the vent began to bust, and you fall right through, landed in the middle of the table with a belly flop.
“F-F-Fuck.” You said in pain. “Fuck, my leg.” You said under your breath. It wasn’t bad when you didn’t break it again, it’s still sore from when you broke it a few weeks ago.
You feel hooves begin to straddle you.
“Hey, what the hell do you think you’re doing?!? Let me go!” You screamed as you’re squirming.
“Well, well, well.” Starlight said as she walked to you. “Looks like we have a visitor who just joined in.”
“You fucking monster! Just wait till I tell the others about all of this!” You roared as you kept squirming under the ponies that have a grab hold of you.
“Oh, I don’t think that’s going to happen.” She said as she begins to light her horn.
“You son of a bitch! I’m gonna-” You were interrupted by her knocking you out. Hitting you on the head either with her magic, or something else. You don’t know.
“You there!” Starlight said pointing to one of the black coated ponies. “Go and grab his friends, and bring them here, please. Also, mind telling them that something awful has happened?”
Her guard nod his head, and he raced off to go to your friend’s room and tell them something happened.
***
Meanwhile, back at the room.
All of your friends are still asleep. It wasn’t long until they hear a knock on the door, and then the door opens like a strong wind broke it open.
“Ugh, what’s all the fuss about?” Twilight said as her, and the others got woken up by one of Starlight’s guards.
“Yeah, I was having a good dream until somepony barged in like that!” Rainbow dash said as she rubbed her eyes.
“I know.” Said Applejack. “Why woul- Uh, where did he go?” Applejack now notices that you’re gone.
“Something terrible has happened!” The stallion said in the black coat. “Starlight needs to have a word with you all right away. I know it’s late, but, this is very, very bad!” He said in a panic like voice.
The others were a bit surprised, and a bit freaked out. So they hurried out of bed, and followed him.
No time has passed as they reached the building. The door shuts behind the stallion as soon as they entered.
“Okay, where’s Starlight?” Twilight asked, worried. The stallion points to a room, and they all charged in there. As soon as they walked in, they see you tied to a chair, with tape over your mouth.
“I’m glad you all could join us.” Starlight said. As soon as she said that, she takes the tape off of your mouth.
“Guys, run. It’s a trap, run!” You yelled.
“What’s going on here?” Twilight asked. Then, the door shuts behind them, and Starlight’s guards surround them.
“What are you doing to him?!?” Twilight yells.
“Oh, we caught him pointing his nose where he shouldn’t be pointing in.” Starlight said with a devious grin.
“I’m sorry guys.” You said. “I just thought that there was something with this place, I wanted to know. I’m really sorry!” You said as you lay your head back down.
“Ah also knew there was somethin’ weird to this place!” Applejack said.
“But darling.” Rarity said. “Why?”
“‘Cause I wanted to know what was going on.” You said quietly. “And it was stupid of me.”
“Hm,hm,hm,hm.” Starlight giggled as she rubbed your head with her hoof. “It’s alright now. There’s no need to apologize.”
“I swear, lay a hoof on him and I will destroy you!” Rarity shouts.
Starlight puts the tape back on your mouth. “Oh, that’s just a shame now, isn’t it.” She said. “I promise, I won’t kill him, he’s just too cute to be killed.”
“Hmm?” You said with the tape over your mouth. You have no idea what she’s gonna do to you.
“Mmm, mmmm! (Help me)” You shout over the tape.
“Oh, don’t worry.” Starlight said as she levitates something. “I’ll take good care of you.”
“Gmms, Mm- (Guys run)” That’s all you were able to say until Starlight hit you upside the head so hard, that it knocked you out. All of your friends watched in shock.
“Oh my goodness!” Fluttershy screamed.
“Take them away, and leave me alone with him.” Starlight said as she looked at your unconscious body.
“I swear, I will destroy you, when I get my hooves on you. JUST WAIT!” Rarity screams as they were taken away.
“Now, time for the special moment I’ve been waiting for ever since you got here.”
***
Your head hurts, like you have a headache. You slowly open your eyes, and you try to put a hand to your head. But, you can’t. They’re tied up. Same with your ankles.
You look down at yourself, and… You’re completely naked. You squirm around, trying to break free, but nothing works.
“Aww, trying to leave so soon?” You hear a voice that sounds like Starlight’s. You see her walk out of a little room. What you’re seeing is something both scary… And sexy at the same time.
“I see you’ve noticed my secret basement.” She giggles.
“Smmlmm? (Starlight)” You said as your mouth’s still covered with that tape. She’s wearing a black skirt, with her mane down. She’s also using the motion when she walks. Her hips swinging with each step she takes.
You also notice that she’s walking towards you, and she climbs on top of you. But still standing as she slowly removes the tape. But, before you could utter a word, she covers your mouth with her hoof.
“You know, I really didn’t wanna do this to you all. You all seemed friendly and not suspicious of me at all when you first arrived. I was actually going to let you all just leave after you guys woke up tomorrow morning. But, since that you had to be nosy, and poke your head in things you shouldn’t be poking in…”
She removes her hoof from your mouth, and finally you can speak.
“Wh-What?!” Was all you could say.
“Mmm, ever since I first laid my eyes on you, there was always something about you. I don’t know what it is, but I really love it. I was actually gonna go easy on you if you cooperated with me. But…” She leans in and whispers in your ear. “Looks like I’m gonna have to go hard on you now.” She giggles, and licks your ear. You begin to shudder, and a shiver goes up your spine as you felt her soft, wet tongue.
“Wh-What are you saying?” You said. You’re now scared on what she’s going to do.
Starlight giggles again. “I’m saying I like you, silly.” She traces a hoof on your chest, and begins to go in circles. “Mmm, your skin is so soft. You humans really do have something hiding from us ponies, don’t you? I’m interested in finding out myself.”
You gulp at her words. Scared out of your mind, you just wish that you can run out of here, free your friends wherever they may be, and get the hell out of here.
“What did you do to my friends?”
“Don’t worry. They’re locked up, and nopony will disturb us while we’re alone.” She giggles.
“What? What are yo-Mmph.” Was all you could say until she pressed her lips against yours. So passionately. You try to move your head back so you can break the kiss. But, it’s not working. Your head meets the pillow, and the pillow is just on the table bed thing with the rest of your body.
After about a minute of Starlight kissing you, she breaks the kiss and begins panting for breath. You do the same.
“Well *pant* that *pant* was very lovely *pant*”
Before you’re able to say anything else, she puts the tape back over your mouth.
“Mmm, mmmmm.” You mumbled as if you’re a sad Pinkie Pie who just wants more fun or something.
“Don’t worry, honey. I’ll take good care of you. I promise.” She said as she levitates a cart besides the both of you. She also looks down on your soft member.
She giggles a little bit as she looks at it. You blush and your eyes dart back and forth in embarrassment.
Starlight then looks up at your face, with that grin on her face. Then her horn lights up, and she brings a dildo in your view. Your eyes go wide, now that you know what she’s going to do to you. You squirm violently, and scream from the top of your lungs with the tape over your mouth.
“What, you think this little thing is for you?” Starlight giggled. You stop squirming, and you just look at her. “I didn’t bring this for you, sweetheart”
You raised an eyebrow as you don’t get what she’s saying.
“Still don’t get who’s it for? I’ll give you a little hint.” Starlight said as she turns around. She lifts her tail up just slightly, enough to reveal her tight anus, and her puffy labia.
Your eyes go wide at the sight in front of you. Starlight begins to lower her head, and levitates the dildo to her slit. She begins to tease herself as she slides it up and down on her folds.
“Mmm…” She purrs. You can already feel the blood slowly rushing down to your member as she makes that cute purring sound. “Oh my, you enjoying what you’re watching, honey?” She asked, giggling. You look away in response.
“Aw, not enjoying it? Don’t worry, It gets better.” She said as she slowly pushed the dildo inside of her with her magic. She begins to slowly cry out as she pushes it into her. As soon as almost all of it is inside her. She cries out in pleasure with that smile on her face.
You can’t bare the sexy sound that’s coming from her. Your member starts to rise slowly as she slides the dildo in and out of her. She makes cute little moans.
“Oh yes, this feels so good…” She pants. Her eyes looking back at you as she bites her bottom lip, and looks at you with half lidded eyes. She even sees that your member is still not hard enough.
“Aw, not turned on? I know just the thing that’ll get you pumped.”
“Mm-mm!” Mm-mm!” You nod your head as you kept your eyes closed, trying to ignore what you’re currently witnessing. You suddenly feel a warm wet sensation down below. You moan in surprise.
Starlight now has your soft member in her mouth as she bobs her head just a bit. Now, your member begins to rise quickly, until it stands up proud.
“Perfect.” Starlight whispers. She now takes the whole thing in your mouth as she masturbates with the dildo still inside her. She bobs her head up and down in a quick pace.
You moan out as the tape is still taped to your mouth. Now you can’t help but watch Starlight, it just feels too amazing.
You can hear Starlight moan as she bobs her head up and down on your cock, while she slides the dildo in and out of her in a fast pace.
You begin to feel a familiar sensation build up inside you. You moan out as loud as you can. Starlight spits you out as she’s still pleasuring herself.
“You gonna cum, aren’t you?” She said as she looks back at you. “Yeah, I want to taste it. I want to taste every last drop of it!” She now slides you back in her, and you cry out as loud as possible.
Starlight bobs her head up and down in a fast pace. Until you let out a long, and loud moan. You release into her mouth, and she swallows every single drop of your semen. She sucks on the head a little bit to make sure to get every last drop.
She takes you out of her mouth, and she begins panting.
“Oh Celestia, I’m cumming!” She cries as she lets out a cry, and gushes of fluids jet out of her like a rocket. You shut your eyes and look away to make sure that none of it gets in your eyes, or on your face.
But, instead, some of it landed on your face, and in your hair. You open your eyes slowly, and you look at Starlight. She’s now standing in front of you, and she’s panting.
“Oh *pant * my… That *pant* was *pant* amazing *pant* did you enjoy it?”
You didn’t say anything. You just stayed silent as she looks deep into your eyes.
“You know. You tasted really good. You taste really fruity, and you know, I still have enough energy for another round.”
“Mmmm! Mm-mm! Mm-mm!” You screamed and shook your head.
“What’s that? You really want more?”
“Mm-mm!”
Starlight ignores your response. Her horn lights up, and you feel something grab a hold of you. Except, that this one’s a gentle feel. You look down and see that your member is slowly rising from her magic.
“Hmm?” You mumbled.
“Yes, I can keep you like this for hours. You and I are gonna have so much fun together.” She said in a low tone voice. She leans her head down, and she begins to kiss your cheek over and over. Until she starts to lower herself, just enough to let her slit rest on the tip of your shaft.
You both yelp at the touch as Starlight slides it back and forth. You really want all of this to stop, and just leave. You want to break free, you want to cry. But, you’re just trap down here with her.
Welcome to hell.
Starlight is still kissing your cheek. She now lowers herself onto you, sliding you inside her. You start to moan out in pleasure as to how tight she is.
As soon as she quickly reaches the base, you let out a long moan. Starlight backs her head up and looks deep into your eyes. Her face just inches away from yours.
“Mm, I know you’re enjoying this. You don’t feel like you are, on the outside. But on the inside, I know you’re loving it.” She said as she wraps her hooves around your torso.
“Mmm, mmmm, mmm.” You mumbled.
“Yeah, you wanna keep going? I do.” Starlight said as her eyes never left yours.
“Hmmm.”
“I’ll take that as a yes.” Starlight begins to slowly lift herself up. Just as the head is just visible. She slams herself back down on you. You scream out in pleasure. She does it again, and again until she finds a good rhythm.
“Mmm, you feel really nice…” She pants. “Yeah, come on baby. I’m gonna show you the true meaning of love.”
She picks up the pace as she lets out cries of pleasure. You on the other hand are just taking it, since that there’s no way you can fight it.
It looks like you’re enjoying this. It’s very hard to ignore something this amazing. You start to feel that pressure build up inside you.
“Oh yes, oh yeah. I’m… I’m… I’m gonna cum. I want you to cum with me, pump it all inside me! I know you want to!” She screams. Your moaning is now increasing in volume.
You can feel it running, until it passes your head. Starlight tilts her head back as she begins to milk you dry when her fluids rush past your shaft like a race car.
“Yes! So amazing! Fill me up with whatever you have!” She screams. After a second of that, the both of you calmed down. Starlight rests her head on your chest, as she doesn’t stop hugging you. She kisses you on the cheek, a few times before she lays her head back down on your chest.
“Mm, that was really nice. I really enjoyed spending this time with you.”
“Mmm, mmmm.” You mumble. Starlight giggles.
“I know you really enjoyed it. You can stay with me, and together, we can rule Equestria once and for all.” She snuggles in your chest. You eyes go wide as you heard her say that. You shake your head in a frantic matter.
She whispers into your ear. “Mmm, don’t deny me now, sweetie. You’re mine… forever.” As she licks it playfully.
Your mind sends messages back and forth as you’re thinking about what she said.
‘Oh shit, I’m fucked. I hope my friends can come and save me from her. Oh my god, this is gonna be terrible.’ You think you yourself.
You’re definitely in hell now. Except that she’s Satan, and you’re being the tortured soul. Every time you call out to your friends, there’s probably no way that they will be able to hear you, perhaps maybe even rescue you. You’re doomed.
***
The Next Day.
All of you are now on a train to take you back home after Starlight has freed you all. You found your friends in a small little shed, and you were able to free them.
“Oh my goodness, I’m so glad that you’re okay, darling.” Rarity said to you as she hugged you tightly.
“Yeah, I’m glad too.” You said as you just stared out the window. Rarity just held onto you.
“What did she do to you?” Fluttershy asked. “did she hurt you?”
“Not really.” You said as your eyes still haven’t left the window when you’re looking outside.
“A-Are you alright?” Fluttershy asked again. “You don’t sound like… Yourself.”
“Yeah,” Twilight said getting in the conversation. “Is there anything wrong? If so, do you want to talk about it?”
“Ah think he doesn’t, whatever she did to him.” Applejack said as she looks at you when she’s sitting across the aisle from you in the passenger car.
“Well, she raped me.” You admitted, but, you don’t feel embarrassed about it. Not one bit.
“Did she, really?” Rarity asked as she now feels bad. You nod your head, still not keeping your eyes off the window. All of your friends came in and hugged you tightly.
“We’re so sorry that happened to you.” Twilight said.
“It’s okay.” You said quietly. “You guys did your best to protect me.”
Suddenly, the train stops. You’re now back in Ponyville.
“Finally, we’re home.” Rainbow Dash said as she flied out of the train car like lightning. You all walked out of the passenger car as you stayed quiet the whole time when you arrived at Twilight's castle.
“Home, sweet home!” Twilight said as she flops down onto her chair. Same with the others.
“I really don’t wanna leave Ponyville for something like that, ever again!” Pinkie Pie explains.
“Me neither. Now, I’ll have to talk to Princess Celestia about what we just been through at that strange town.” Twilight said. She sees that you’re sitting at the wall.
“And you,” Twilight said as she sat right beside you. “You probably should get some rest too. After what you’ve gone through back there.”
You nod your head as you look at the floor when you’re hugging your knees, and resting your chin on them.
“It’s alright, darling.” Rarity said as she walks to you, and puts a hoof to your head as she’s stroking your hair. “I’ll keep you company until you start to feel better.”
“Thanks Rarity.” You said with a smile.
“Anytime, dear.”
“Alright.” Twilight said. “Now everypony head on home, and get some rest. I know we had an exhausting two days, but, I’m sure that a good rest will help you guys out. Even you.” Twilight said as she puts you in a friendly hug. “Take care of him, Rarity.” Twilight said facing her.
“Don’t worry, Twilight. I’ll do my very best to comfort him. I’ll probably have Sweetie Belle cheer him up.”
“That’s a great idea.” Twilight said. “He might be in the mood after he gets his beauty rest.”
“Alright.” Rarity chuckled. Everypony else went home as you went with Rarity to the Carousel boutique.
As you hop in the bed, Rarity hops in with you. You both lay there for only a few minutes as Rarity tries to keep you company.
After about two hours of sleeping. You noticed that Rarity is sound asleep, you slowly sneak out of her bed, and you snuck out of the boutique.
You head to the train station, and ask for a ticket. After a long three hour train ride from Ponyville, you reached the familiar village. You meet the familiar mare at the station as soon as you got out of the passenger car.
“Well, well. I see you made it back.” She said with a smile on her face. You smile too, as your eyes start to glow green.
“Yes Starlight, I have.” You said as she stepped closer to you. She stands on her hind legs, and wraps her hooves around your neck, bringing you in for a hug and kissing you on the lips. “Now I’m yours… forever.”
“I know dear.”
“Princess Twilight is now headed to see Princess Celestia about this town. We better do something.” You said.
“Don’t worry, honey. We’ll find a better town to be in before they find us.” Starlight said as she puts a hoof on your chest, and goes in slow circles. “That’s why I love you.”
“I love you too, Starlight.” You said as your eyes glow green again.
“I knew you would say that to me, sweetheart.”
